A World Apart: Contrasting Realities In Afghanistan And Australia

Life in Afghanistan is vastly different from life in Australia. From a socioeconomic perspective, Afghanistan has a lower GDP per capita, higher unemployment rates, lower internet access, and lower life expectancy compared to Australia. The political situation in Afghanistan is also less stable, with the country facing substantial humanitarian and economic challenges, including the marginalization of women and the persecution of minorities. In contrast, Australia is a stable, democratic, and culturally diverse nation with a strong economy. Afghans migrating to Australia often face challenges in adjusting to a new culture, language, and way of life. Despite these differences, both countries share a history of migration and asylum-seeking, with Afghanistan experiencing ongoing political turmoil and Australia providing humanitarian assistance.

Life expectancy: In Afghanistan, it's 54 years, while in Australia, it's 83 years

Life expectancy is a crucial indicator of a population's overall health, and the differences between Afghanistan and Australia in this regard are stark. As of 2022, the average life expectancy in Afghanistan is 54 years, with men expected to live 52 years and women 55 years. In contrast, Australians have a life expectancy of 83 years, with men expected to live 81 years and women 85 years. This disparity of 29 years highlights the significant gap in health outcomes between the two countries.

Several factors contribute to the lower life expectancy in Afghanistan. Firstly, the country has a high maternal mortality rate, with approximately 638 maternal deaths per 100,000 births as of 2017. Additionally, the infant mortality rate is high, with around 104.9 infant deaths per 1,000 live births in 2022. Furthermore, access to quality healthcare and medical technology is limited for many Afghans, and the country faces challenges such as food insecurity and inadequate access to potable water.

On the other hand, Australia's high life expectancy can be attributed to improved medical knowledge, better healthcare availability, enhanced living conditions, and an overall improved quality of life. Australia also has a lower infant mortality rate, with only 3 infant deaths per 1,000 live births in 2022. The country has made significant strides in reducing infectious diseases, which now account for less than 2% of deaths.

The gap in life expectancy between Afghanistan and Australia underscores the disparities in health and well-being between the two nations. Efforts to improve healthcare infrastructure, address food insecurity, and enhance overall living conditions in Afghanistan could help narrow this gap and improve the health outcomes for Afghans.

Internet access: 18% of Afghans have it, compared to 90% of Australians

Internet access is a significant differentiator between life in Afghanistan and Australia. While 90% of Australians had internet access as of 2020, only 18% of Afghans had it during the same period. This disparity has likely widened further since the Taliban's takeover of Afghanistan in 2021, which restricted women's access to education, healthcare information, and other fundamental human rights.

The low internet penetration in Afghanistan is due to various factors, including the lack of reliable electricity and IT infrastructure, social norms that limit women's access, and political turmoil. The Taliban's frequent suspension of connectivity in Kabul and other areas to curb opposition has also hindered internet access.

On the other hand, Australia has a highly developed internet infrastructure, with the National Broadband Network (NBN) providing fast broadband access to most of the country. As of January 2023, Australia had 25.31 million internet users, with an internet penetration rate of 96.2%. This high level of connectivity has become an essential part of daily life for Australians, who use it for email, web browsing, banking, video streaming, and shopping.

The disparity in internet access between Afghanistan and Australia has significant implications for the populations of both countries. For Afghans, limited internet access means reduced access to information, education, and economic opportunities. In contrast, Australians can take advantage of the convenience and opportunities provided by widespread internet connectivity.

Economic opportunities: Afghanistan's GDP per capita is $2,000, while Australia's is $48,700

Afghanistan and Australia are vastly different when it comes to economic opportunities. Afghanistan's GDP per capita is estimated to be $200 in 2024, while Australia's is $48,700 in 2020. This huge disparity is due to several factors, including war, political instability, and a lack of foreign investment in Afghanistan.

Afghanistan has been embroiled in decades of conflict, which has deterred business investors and hindered economic development. The country also has a high unemployment rate of over 23%, with about half of its population living below the poverty line. On the other hand, Australia has a stable and resilient economy, ranked 14th in the world by nominal GDP in 2023.

Afghanistan's economy is primarily based on agriculture, with 60-80% of its population working in this sector. However, it accounts for less than a third of the country's GDP due to insufficient irrigation, drought, and lack of market access. In contrast, Australia's economy is dominated by its service sector, which comprises a significant portion of its GDP and employs a large percentage of its workforce.

Afghanistan has a vast wealth of natural resources, including minerals, natural gas, and petroleum. However, the country has struggled to attract foreign investment and develop its economy due to political instability and the Taliban's restrictive policies towards women and girls.

Australia, on the other hand, has a highly developed and diversified economy, with strong manufacturing, mining, and service sectors. The country has a strong track record of economic growth and has remained resilient during global financial crises.

The significant gap in GDP per capita between Afghanistan and Australia highlights the economic disparities between the two countries, with Australians having far greater economic opportunities and a higher standard of living.

Education: Afghanistan spends 3.2% of GDP on it, Australia 5.1%

Afghanistan and Australia differ in many ways, one of which is their spending on education. As of 2019, Afghanistan spent 3.2% of its GDP on education, while Australia spent 5.1% in 2018.

Afghanistan has faced substantial economic challenges, which have been compounded by natural disasters such as earthquakes. The country's long-term growth prospects rely on a shift from reliance on international aid and consumption-driven growth to a more resilient, private sector-led economy. Education is key to this, and the World Bank has provided over $1.7 billion in support to the Afghan people since August 2021. This includes funding for basic services such as health, education, food security, and water services.

Despite this support, Afghanistan's economic outlook remains uncertain, with the threat of stagnation looming until at least 2025. Structural deficiencies in the private sector, coupled with waning international support for essential services, are expected to impede economic progress. This stagnation will deepen poverty and unemployment, and job opportunities are expected to decrease.

In contrast, Australia has a strong and stable economy. It is committed to supporting the Afghan people, including through its humanitarian program and advocacy on important issues such as human rights. Australia has provided over $1.6 billion in development and humanitarian assistance to Afghanistan since 2001, with a focus on improving women's education, health, and participation, and preventing violence against women.

While Australia's spending on education as a percentage of GDP has increased over time, from 5.1% in 2000 to 5.9% in 2015, it is worth noting that the increase has been driven primarily by private sources of funding rather than government funds. This indicates an increasing willingness of individuals to invest in their own or their children's education.

Australia's government spends a relatively large proportion of its budget on education compared to other OECD countries. In total, government spending on education is 13.5%, ranking Australia ninth out of 39 countries in the OECD. This spending includes funding for primary schools, secondary schools, and higher education, as well as early childhood education, preschool, and vocational training.

The differences in spending on education between Afghanistan and Australia reflect the distinct economic and social realities of the two countries. Afghanistan is facing economic challenges and is working towards building a more resilient economy, while Australia has a strong economy and can allocate more resources towards education.

Culture: Afghans tend to know everyone in their community, while Australians live in an individualistic culture

Afghans tend to have a collectivist society, with a strong sense of personal honour and a strong awareness of their community's opinion of them. They are loyal to their kin, tribe, or ethnicity, and are generally hard-working. Afghans tend to know everyone in their community and socialise with their neighbours daily.

In contrast, Australians live in an individualistic culture. They are more likely to be informal and egalitarian, with a strong belief in a 'fair go' and a 'fair chance' for all. They are also more likely to be modest about their accomplishments and self-deprecating. Australians tend to be more independent, with a stronger sense of loyalty to their family than their community.

Frequently asked questions