The Impact Of Globalization On Afghanistan: A Complex Web Of Influences

Afghanistan has had a complex relationship with globalization. On the one hand, the country has been affected by some of the negative forces of globalization, including the influence of transnational extremists, terrorists, and drug traffickers. Additionally, the country's governance has been impacted by a substantial amount of corruption, with leaders and warlords benefiting from the illicit opium trade. On the other hand, globalization has also brought about some positive changes in Afghanistan, such as increased connectivity and the introduction of new technologies like cell phones and the internet in larger cities. The impact of globalization on Afghanistan's economy has been mixed, with some arguing that it has led to economic interdependence and market connectivity, while others claim that it has resulted in a disconnect from the global economy.

The economy: Globalisation has brought economic interdependence through global financial markets

Globalisation has brought about economic interdependence through global financial markets, and Afghanistan's economy has been significantly impacted by this.

Afghanistan's economy is the 155th largest in the world in terms of nominal gross domestic product (GDP) and 137th in terms of purchasing power parity (PPP). The country's GDP is projected to fall to $5.79 billion for the 2025 financial year, with a GDP per capita of $142. The country's unemployment rate is over 23%, and about half of its population lives below the poverty line.

Afghanistan has long sought foreign investment to improve its economy, and globalisation has brought about both opportunities and challenges in this regard. On the one hand, globalisation has led to increased economic openness, foreign direct investment, and the transfer of technologies, all of which offer potential opportunities for economic growth. Afghanistan's economy has improved due to the influx of expats, the establishment of more trade routes, and the expansion of the agriculture, energy, and mining sectors.

However, the country also faces challenges due to its integration into the global economy. Afghanistan's economy is heavily dependent on foreign assistance, and when donor governments cut off aid, it can have devastating consequences. For example, after the Taliban took control of the country in 2021, donor governments led by the US instructed the World Bank to cut off about $2 billion in outside international assistance, leading to a massive drop in purchasing power and contributing to the country's humanitarian crisis.

Additionally, Afghanistan's economy is heavily reliant on agriculture, which accounts for 94% of total exports. However, this sector faces challenges such as insufficient irrigation, drought, and lack of market access, which hinder its potential to contribute more significantly to the country's economic growth.

The country also has a significant informal economy, with the Taliban controlling the opiate trading routes that form the bulk of Afghanistan's domestic exports. This has contributed to a fragile economic situation, with elements of corruption and a lack of transparency.

Overall, globalisation has brought both benefits and challenges to Afghanistan's economy. While it has opened up opportunities for trade and investment, it has also led to increased economic interdependence and vulnerability to external shocks, such as the withdrawal of foreign aid.

Foreign influence: International bodies providing aid, relief and security has meant a continuous rise in political influence by foreign nations

Afghanistan has long been a battleground for conflicts over regional influence, with its strategic location making it a key player in the pushback against terrorism. The country's economic development has been heavily reliant on foreign aid, which has primarily come from the US and the World Bank. This aid has been used to fund education, healthcare, governance reforms, and infrastructure projects.

The influx of foreign aid has led to a continuous rise in political influence by foreign nations. The US, in particular, has had a significant impact on Afghanistan's economy and political landscape. Following the 2021 Taliban takeover, the US frozen Afghan government reserves held in US bank accounts, crippling the country's economy and banking system. This action, along with the suspension of infrastructure projects and other forms of aid, has contributed to a worsening humanitarian crisis in Afghanistan.

Other countries, such as Pakistan, India, China, and Russia, have also exerted influence in Afghanistan. Pakistan, for instance, supported the Taliban government in 1996, seeing it as a strategic ally in its conflict with India. China has also sought to strengthen its ties with Afghanistan, becoming the first country to formally name a new ambassador in 2023, although it still does not formally recognize the Taliban.

The competition for influence in Afghanistan among regional powers and major world powers has resulted in proxy wars and political interference. As Afghanistan navigates its political and economic challenges, it is crucial for the country to reclaim its sovereignty and oppose foreign interference in its internal affairs.

Social impact: Globalisation has influenced the import of cultural and social identities and appreciation of various political voices

The impact of globalisation on Afghanistan has been varied. While it has brought about positive change, it has also resulted in a loss of sovereignty and an increase in inequality.

Afghanistan has a rich history, once housing rulers who invaded the rich plains of India. However, it has also been marred by conflict, with its society affected by a continuous struggle for power. The country has also been impacted by economic woes, rigid social norms and values, and a lack of infrastructure.

Before 2001, Afghanistan had poor communication infrastructure, largely due to poverty and strict control by the Taliban. However, since then, there has been a significant increase in international aid and military deployment, leading to improved connectivity and knowledge. The content produced by the BBC, for example, has played a significant role in changing Afghan society.

Globalisation has influenced the import of cultural and social identities and the appreciation of various political voices in Afghanistan. The country has a strong sense of personal honour and community, with hospitality, loyalty and modesty being highly valued. However, Afghan culture and daily life have been significantly impacted by constant conflict, resulting in resilience becoming an essential trait.

Afghanistan is a multi-ethnic society, with diverse ethnic, linguistic and tribal groups. While the official religion is Islam, there are also small populations of Hindus, Sikhs, Parsis and Jews. The country's national game is Buzkashi, also known as goat grabbing, and poetry has been an important part of Afghan culture for over 1000 years.

Despite these unifying factors, Afghanistan tends to hold a stronger sense of loyalty for kin, tribe or ethnicity than for its national identity. This is partly due to the country's history of conflict and political turmoil, which has resulted in a prevailing attitude that favours independence from controlling bodies. Additionally, the Pashtun, the largest ethnic group in Afghanistan, are widely regarded as the most politically influential and dominant group, with successive governments formed through their political expansion. This has led to feelings of exclusion among minority ethnic groups, who argue that the national identity and civil service exclude non-Pashtuns.

Globalisation has brought about increased connectivity and cooperation, and it has had a significant influence on the coordination and control of discourse directed at prominent political figures. It has also resulted in the manipulation of various discourses by big technological companies, which has impacted both state and non-state actors.

In conclusion, while globalisation has had both positive and negative effects on Afghanistan, it has undoubtedly influenced the import of cultural and social identities and the appreciation of various political voices in the country.

Infrastructure: The Afghan economy has been affected by structural deficiencies in the private sector

Afghanistan's economy has been impacted by a variety of factors, including globalization, conflict, and the drug trade. However, one of the key issues affecting the country's economic development has been the lack of infrastructure, particularly in the private sector.

The country's infrastructure was devastated during the Soviet invasion and the civil conflicts that followed, with virtually no development in this sector for over three decades. This has left Afghanistan with a substantial infrastructural deficit, which has hindered economic growth and development. The lack of roads, reliable energy supplies, and other basic infrastructure has made it difficult for businesses to operate and has limited their access to domestic and international markets. It has also made it challenging for the government to provide basic services to its citizens, including education and healthcare.

Recognizing the critical importance of infrastructure development, the Afghan government, with the support of international donors, has initiated various infrastructure projects in recent years. These include the National Rail Network, electrical systems, National Road Networks, dams, and airfields. The first section of the national rail network, connecting Mazar-e-Sharif to Hairatan and Central Asia, was completed with funding from the Asian Development Bank (ADB). Additionally, the reconstruction of Afghanistan's 2,700 km 'Ring Road' has been completed, with significant funding from the World Bank and ADB.

However, despite these efforts, Afghanistan's infrastructure remains inadequate, and the country continues to face significant challenges. The private sector, in particular, lacks the necessary infrastructure to thrive, with poor transport links and limited access to energy supplies. This has hindered the development of a robust private sector-led economy, which is crucial for the country's long-term growth and poverty reduction.

To address these issues, Afghanistan needs to continue investing in infrastructure development, particularly in the transport and energy sectors. This includes completing the remaining sections of the Ring Road, which is vital for trade and travel, as well as improving provincial roads, which are often unpaved and in poor condition. Additionally, the government needs to address skills shortages and stimulate private sector investment in infrastructure development, as well as seek sustainable infrastructure financing.

The development of Afghanistan's infrastructure is a long-term process, and it will likely take decades for the country to establish the kind of infrastructural framework enjoyed by its neighbors. However, with continued support from the international community and a coordinated approach to infrastructure development, Afghanistan can make significant progress in addressing its infrastructural deficiencies and improving its economic prospects.

Governance: Globalisation has impacted the political spectrum of Afghanistan, with international institutions and states aiming to impart a Western form of governance

Afghanistan's political landscape has been influenced by globalisation, with international institutions and nations attempting to impose a Western style of governance. The nation's integration into the global political spectrum was accelerated by America's declaration of war on terror following 9/11. The invasion of Afghanistan by US-led coalition forces was motivated by the desire to eliminate terrorist strongholds and prevent future attacks on Western nations. Another key objective was to establish a national government backed by foreign aid and led by representatives of the Afghan people.

Prior to the US intervention, Afghanistan had been relatively insulated from the effects of globalisation. Religious and social norms, as well as a sense of alienation, shielded Afghans from external influences. However, economic and social insecurities drove Afghan communities to cluster together, reducing their exposure to globalisation. The post-9/11 era significantly altered Afghanistan's social, political, and economic landscape. Foreign intervention sought to transform the conservative Afghan society and introduce it to global financial markets.

The influx of international aid and the deployment of US military forces led to a communication boom in Afghanistan. The growth of media outlets exposed Afghans to new discourses and perspectives, challenging traditional societal norms and values. This influx of foreign influence in Afghanistan's governance structure has resulted in a sense of ""loss of sovereignty" among Afghans, as they perceive the increasing role of international institutions and foreign states as a threat to their independence.

Despite efforts to impose a Western-style government, Afghanistan's continued resistance to globalisation and new forms of governance has hindered progress. The current government, backed by NATO forces, struggles to gain credibility and acceptance from the Afghan people. The Afghan conflict remains largely unresolved, and the influence of organisations like the Taliban persists due to their acceptance among the general population.

The challenges faced by Afghanistan in the context of globalisation are complex and multifaceted. While foreign intervention has brought about some changes, Afghanistan continues to grapple with issues of inequality, influence of non-state actors, and a sense of loss of sovereignty. The future of Afghanistan's political spectrum remains uncertain as the country navigates the tensions between traditional values and Western ideals.

Frequently asked questions