China's Complex Relationship With Afghanistan: A Delicate Balancing Act

China's primary concern with Afghanistan is security and stability. Beijing does not want Afghanistan to become a safe haven for Uyghur militants and other terrorist groups that could direct attacks at China. China also worries that instability in Afghanistan could spill over into neighbouring countries, particularly Pakistan.

China has long sought to reach agreements with the Taliban, particularly regarding their ties with Uyghur groups. Beijing has been pragmatic about the power realities in Afghanistan, but it has always been uncomfortable with the Taliban's ideological agenda. China wants to see the Taliban hemmed in by compromises with other political forces in the country, rather than resurgent after a military victory.

China's other interests in Afghanistan include economic and commercial interests, such as the Aynak copper mine and the Amu Darya energy projects. There have also been discussions about Afghanistan's involvement in the Belt and Road Initiative, but Beijing's view has been that stability must precede serious new economic commitments.

China's primary concern is national security and preventing terrorism from destabilising the region

China's primary concern in Afghanistan is national security and preventing terrorism from destabilising the region. The country has a long history of involvement in Afghanistan, dating back to the 18th century when trade relations were established during the reign of Ahmad Shah Durrani in Afghanistan and Qianlong in China.

China's overarching goal in Afghanistan is to prevent terrorism and violent extremism from destabilising the region. Specifically, China is concerned about the potential spillover of Islamic extremism from Afghanistan into Western China and the Xinjiang Autonomous Region. China also worries that a destabilised Afghanistan could provide a base for terrorist groups such as the East Turkistan Islamic Movement (ETIM), which seeks to liberate Xinjiang Province and impose an Islamic form of government.

To address these security concerns, China has taken several steps:

• China wants to ensure that Afghanistan has a functioning government that can maintain stability and prevent cross-border spillovers of violence.
• China aims to secure its border with Afghanistan to prevent violent extremists from entering its territory. It relies on the Taliban, as well as the security provisions of neighbouring countries such as Tajikistan and Pakistan.
• China seeks to ensure that the Taliban eliminates Uyghur militant groups operating within Afghanistan. While China has exaggerated the threat posed by Uyghurs, it considers their suppression a crucial aspect of its domestic policy.
• China aims to protect its citizens and investments in Afghanistan. However, it recognises that this requires a stable government and security guarantees from the Taliban.

China's approach to Afghanistan is shaped by its desire to manage threats and maintain stability. While China has economic interests in the region, its primary focus is on preventing terrorism and extremism from spilling over into its territory. China's efforts to engage with the Taliban and other regional powers reflect its commitment to addressing security concerns and preventing Afghanistan from becoming a safe haven for militant groups.

China's secondary concern is economic investment and development in Afghanistan

China certainly has substantial commercial and economic interests in the wider region, but they are minimal in Afghanistan itself. Its major investments there, the Aynak copper mine and the Amu Darya energy projects, have been in stasis for many years. There have been numerous discussions about Afghanistan's involvement in the Belt and Road Initiative, including connections to the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor, but Beijing's view has been that, in Afghanistan, stability has to precede serious new economic commitments.

Beijing has also chosen not to build any cross-border infrastructure through the Wakhan Corridor, despite Afghan government requests, effectively leaving a physical buffer with its neighbour. If there is a permissive security and political environment in the country, then China would certainly take on a significant investment role – but it will be extremely cautious. Right now, it is very worried about recent attacks on Chinese nationals working on projects in Pakistan, not thinking about hair-raisingly risky new ventures in Afghanistan.

China's closest partner in the region, Pakistan, has been the Taliban's chief host and backer, which gives them an additional avenue of influence, even if it's not one they've always been willing or able to use effectively. In the coming period, though, Beijing will be tightly focused on securing their bilateral interests in Afghanistan and channelling their diplomatic energies in the region to deal with the fallout from current events.

China's relationship with the Taliban is pragmatic, focused on security and economic interests

China's primary interest in Afghanistan is stability. Chaos in Afghanistan, from Beijing's perspective, stokes Islamic fundamentalism that threatens domestic security in China, particularly in Xinjiang. China's overarching goal in Afghanistan is to prevent terrorism and violent extremism from destabilizing the region.

China has been in talks with the Taliban to ensure that its border with Afghanistan is secure to prevent violent extremists from entering its territory. China is also relying on security provisions of Tajikistan and Pakistan. It has also been working with Russia and the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), which operates a military base in southern Tajikistan, to provide support.

China has been actively engaging with the Taliban, but this should not be mistaken for support. China has been dangling economic incentives in front of the Taliban to extract security guarantees while seeking to ameliorate development challenges in Afghanistan for fear that poverty may drive instability. China is keen on luring the Taliban into cooperation with promises of economic development but understands that it clearly has the upper hand when it comes to this relationship.

China has also been concerned about the Taliban's connections to East Turkistan terrorist organizations. Chinese security concerns have increased, and it has feared that chaos in Afghanistan could spill across the countries' border. China has been pushing the Taliban to crack down on extremist groups.

China has been investing in Afghanistan, but those projects have been plagued by problems and have mostly been on hold for years. The Taliban has been keen to re-engage projects, but China understands that restarting them will require security. China has been Afghanistan's largest trading partner and has given millions of dollars in aid throughout the war.

China has been willing to play a more active role in Afghanistan, but it has been cautious and has not taken on a leadership role in the country. China has been treading a careful line between Kabul and the Taliban, supporting political inclusiveness and reconciliation between the two sides. China has been pragmatic about the power realities in Afghanistan.

China has been enhancing its relations with the Taliban and will most likely continue to do so in the future. It has been pleased to see plans for a U.S. troop withdrawal from Afghanistan but remains skeptical that Washington will go through with it.

China's approach to Afghanistan is multilateral, seeking to avoid unilateral intervention

China's primary concern with Afghanistan lies in its security situation and in instability and radicalization spilling over into China. China has consistently supported political inclusiveness and reconciliation between the Taliban and the Afghan government. Beijing has consistently issued visas to Taliban representatives to visit China for meetings, enabling it to play a facilitatory role between the Taliban and Kabul.

China has also been testing the waters with the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, a regional organization dedicated to security issues, stepping up its role in Afghanistan. Beijing has examined how the organization could play a counter-terrorism and counter-narcotics role. Eventually, if Afghanistan stabilizes, China will support the incorporation of Afghanistan into the organization's security mechanisms and framework.

China has also been clear that it will not recognize the Taliban government without agreement from Pakistan, Russia, and Iran. China has urged the international community to maintain its dialogue with Afghanistan and encourage the country to put in place an inclusive political framework, adopt moderate policies, combat terrorism, and develop friendly external relations.

China has been seeking to reach agreements with the Taliban, largely focused on the question of their ties with Uyghur groups. Beijing is also concerned about the risks of entanglement in Afghanistan, which is seen as a strategic trap that has diminished other great powers. There are endless references to the "graveyard of empires" in Chinese analysis.

China's overall view of the U.S. presence in Afghanistan is a mixture of conflicting factors. On the negative side, China saw the invasion as the United States establishing a foothold in the heart of the Eurasian continent that could then be used to contain China. From the Chinese perspective, 9/11 and the ensuing war in Afghanistan fostered the radicalization of Muslims in the region and directly contributed to the unrest in China's northwest Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region. However, on the positive side, the Chinese have viewed America's wars since 9/11 as a "window of strategic opportunity" that gave Beijing a decade to build its strength while Washington was distracted.

China's approach to Afghanistan is cautious and flexible. It sees its role in Afghan security as marginal in the sense that it is not a primary party to the conflict; indispensable in the sense that China is a great power and a neighboring country that cannot be ignored; and central in the sense that Chinese investment will be critical for the country's future post-conflict reconstruction and economic development.

China's policy towards Afghanistan is cautious and flexible, adapting to events as they unfold

China's overarching goal in Afghanistan is to prevent terrorism and violent extremism from destabilizing the region. Specifically, it is worried about the potential spillover of Islamic extremism from Afghanistan into Western China and the Xinjiang Autonomous Region. China also worries that a destabilized Afghanistan will provide a base for the East Turkistan Islamic Movement (ETIM) or other groups that wish to use Afghanistan as a launchpad for attacks.

China's policy towards Afghanistan has evolved over time. Initially, China opposed the 2001 US-led invasion of Afghanistan and backed UN Security Council resolutions that endorsed international efforts to oust the Taliban. However, China grew to see the US presence as the lesser of two evils, as it helped curtail the growth and spread of anti-China terrorist groups. Despite this, China wants the US to withdraw its troops from Afghanistan, but only when the withdrawal is responsible and does not leave a chaotic power vacuum.

China's relationship with Afghanistan is complex and multifaceted. While China has economic interests in Afghanistan, particularly in the mining and energy sectors, its investments have been minimal due to security concerns. China has also provided humanitarian assistance to Afghanistan, such as in the aftermath of the 2022 earthquake that killed over 1,150 people.

China's approach to Afghanistan is also shaped by its broader geopolitical interests. China seeks to counter US influence in the region and solidify its dominance in what it considers its backyard. Additionally, China wants to prevent Uyghur separatists from using Afghanistan as a base for separatist activities in Xinjiang.

In summary, China's policy towards Afghanistan is cautious and flexible, adapting to the evolving security, political, and economic dynamics in the country. China seeks to manage threats, maintain stability, and protect its interests in the region.

Frequently asked questions