The Economic Enigma Of Afghanistan: Unraveling Revenue Streams And Opportunities

Afghanistan's economy is ranked 155th in the world in terms of nominal gross domestic product (GDP) and 137th in terms of purchasing power parity (PPP). The country's GDP stands at $6.81 billion as of 2024, with an annual export value exceeding $1 billion. Agriculture, minerals, and textiles are the main drivers of Afghanistan's economy, contributing to 94% of total exports. The country has a largely agricultural-based economy, with 60-80% of its population working in this sector.

Afghanistan's economy has faced significant challenges due to political instability, foreign intervention, and internal strife. The continuous war in the country has deterred business investors, and the lack of infrastructure development has hindered economic growth. However, the country's economy has shown signs of improvement due to several factors, including the influx of expats, the establishment of new trade routes, and the expansion of agriculture, energy, and mining sectors.

Afghanistan's official currency is the Afghani (AFN), and the country has a central bank called Da Afghanistan Bank (DAB). The country's economic development is closely linked to its natural resources, including extensive deposits of minerals and natural gas. The stability of the Afghan economy is crucial for the well-being of its citizens, and there are ongoing efforts to improve financial stability and governance.

Agriculture and livestock

Agriculture and animal husbandry are the most important elements of Afghanistan's GDP, accounting for nearly half of its total value. Afghanistan is essentially a pastoral country.

Agriculture remains Afghanistan's most important source of employment, with 60-80% of the population working in this sector. However, it accounts for less than a third of GDP due to insufficient irrigation, drought, lack of market access, and other structural impediments. Most Afghan farmers are primarily subsistence farmers.

In 2018, Afghanistan produced 3.6 million tons of wheat, 984 thousand tons of grapes, 615 thousand tons of potatoes, 591 thousand tons of vegetables, 381 thousand tons of watermelons, 352 thousand tons of rice, 329 thousand tons of melons, 217 thousand tons of apples, 150 thousand tons of onions, 106 thousand tons of maize, 56 thousand tons of barley, and 47 thousand tons of peaches.

Afghanistan produces around 1.5 million tons of fresh fruits annually, including pomegranates, grapes, sweet melons, and mulberries. The country is also known for cultivating pistachios, almonds, and walnuts.

Animal husbandry is another important component of Afghanistan's economy, with livestock contributing about 15% of agricultural GDP. Livestock includes cattle, sheep, goats, donkeys, horses, camels, buffalo, and mules. About two-thirds of the annual milk production is from cows, with the rest coming from sheep and goats.

The country has many lakes, ponds, reservoirs, rivers, springs, and streams, making it suitable for fish farming. Consumption of fish has increased due to the establishment of many fish farms, with over 2,600 across the country.

With the right mix of policies and investments, the agriculture sector can drive down poverty and boost sustained growth in Afghanistan through job creation, improved productivity, and inclusiveness.

Natural resources

Afghanistan is believed to be sitting on one of the richest troves of minerals in the world, with an estimated value of $1-3 trillion. The country has vast reserves of gold, platinum, silver, copper, iron, chromite, lithium, uranium, and aluminium. It also has high-quality emeralds, rubies, sapphires, turquoise, and lapis lazuli, which have long been sought after in the gemstone market.

The United States Geological Survey (USGS) has conducted extensive scientific research on Afghanistan's minerals and concluded that the country may hold:

• 60 million metric tons of copper
• 2.2 billion tons of iron ore
• 1.4 million tons of rare earth elements (REEs) such as lanthanum, cerium, and neodymium
• Veins of aluminium, gold, silver, zinc, mercury, and lithium

Afghanistan's mineral resources are not only valuable in terms of their monetary value but also their strategic importance. Rare earth elements (REEs), for example, are essential in modern technology, such as cell phones, computers, lasers, and batteries. They are also critical to national security, playing a key role in the production of tank navigation systems, missile guidance systems, missile defense components, and military communications systems.

Recognizing the importance of REEs, the Trump administration amended the Defense Production Act of 1950 to authorize the domestic production and processing of light REEs. Additionally, the Energy Resource Governance Initiative (ERGI) was launched to promote the mining of high-demand minerals, and Afghanistan could potentially be included in this initiative to boost its economy and ensure a long-term strategic partnership with the United States.

However, there are challenges to exploiting Afghanistan's mineral wealth. Poor security, weak legislation, and corruption have hindered the development of the mining sector. Deficient infrastructure makes transport and export difficult, and high royalties and taxes imposed by the Afghan government have discouraged potential investors. The lack of a proper legal framework and organizational capacity has further hindered progress.

Illegal mining is also rampant in Afghanistan, with more than 2,000 sites raising money for warlords and insurgents. The Taliban and other armed groups have benefited from this, with estimates suggesting they earn millions of dollars annually from mining talc alone.

Despite these challenges, Afghanistan's mineral resources present a significant opportunity for economic growth and a path towards stability and peace.

Customs duties

The Taliban's ability to effectively collect taxes has led to impressive revenue totals. In 2021, the Afghan government collected around $400 million in total revenue from September to December, with customs duties making up a significant portion of this. Customs receipts held up better than expected despite the sharp decline in imports and economic activity, suggesting substantial improvements at the borders and a reduction in corruption.

The Taliban's tax system has been described as a form of racketeering enterprise or extortion rather than a normal taxation system. They have also imposed separate trade levies, which have been abolished since they retook power.

In 2022, the Afghan Finance Ministry spokesman Rafiullah Tabeh stated that the previous government generated an estimated £66.5 million in revenue through customs until May. However, as the Taliban gained control of more key border crossings, government revenues declined, with revenues in June plummeting to £41.5 million. Official figures showed that over £1.46 billion in trade passed through three Afghan border crossings with Iran in 2021, but this figure is likely to be higher when informal trade is included.

The Taliban's control of border crossings and customs allows them to oversee the flow of massive wealth and has been identified as one of their main sources of income.

Foreign aid

The influx of foreign aid to Afghanistan has had a significant impact on the country's economy. It has contributed to the improvement of various sectors, including agriculture, energy, mining, and infrastructure development. However, the distribution and utilisation of this aid have also faced challenges due to concerns about corruption and the lack of effective governance structures.

Following the Taliban's return to power in 2021, there were significant changes in the flow of foreign aid to Afghanistan. The US and its allies froze billions of dollars in Afghan government reserves and halted development aid to the country. This had a crippling effect on the Afghan economy, exacerbating the existing humanitarian crisis.

Despite these challenges, some donors have continued to provide humanitarian assistance to Afghanistan. The United Nations, through its various agencies, has played a crucial role in coordinating and delivering aid to the country. The European Union (EU) has also been a significant donor, providing over €1.7 billion in humanitarian funding since 1994.

The distribution of foreign aid in Afghanistan has been a complex issue. While donors aim to provide essential support to the Afghan people, there are concerns about ensuring that the funds do not inadvertently support the Taliban regime. This has led to discussions and negotiations between the US and the Taliban regarding the conditions for releasing frozen Afghan central bank funds.

Overall, foreign aid has played a critical role in Afghanistan's economy, but it has also been a source of political and ethical debates among donors. As Afghanistan continues to face economic and humanitarian challenges, the role of foreign aid will remain essential in supporting the country's development and addressing the needs of its people.

Taxation

The Taliban imposes a range of taxes on the people and businesses in areas under its control. These include a 10% tax on every link in the drug production chain, a 10% "Ushur" Islamic tax on a farmer's harvest, and a 2.5% "Zakat" wealth tax. They also tax mining operations, media, telecommunications, and development projects funded by international aid. Drivers are charged for using highways in Taliban-controlled regions, and shopkeepers pay the Taliban for the right to do business.

The Taliban's taxation practices have been likened to extortion, with one source stating that "what we really mean is extortion... This is not a normal taxation system - it is much more like racketeering enterprise."

The Taliban's tax revenue is estimated to bring in around $160 million annually, according to Mullah Yaqoob, the son of the late Taliban spiritual leader Mullah Mohammad Omar. However, this figure may be optimistic given the economic contraction Afghanistan is currently facing.

The Taliban has also imposed state monopolies and high taxes to raise money during previous regimes. Under the rule of Emir Abdur Rahman Khan (1880-1901) and his son Habibullah Khan (1901-1919), these practices slowed the long-term development of Afghanistan.

To improve the business environment and attract foreign investment, Afghanistan has introduced a new law on private investment that provides tax holidays and exemptions from export tariffs and duties.

Frequently asked questions