Ending Afghanistan's Endless War: Strategies For A Lasting Peace

The war in Afghanistan has been ongoing since 2001, when US and allied forces invaded the country and overthrew the Taliban regime. Since then, the conflict has resulted in enormous casualties and displacement for Afghans, and thousands of deaths and injuries for US and NATO troops. The war has also come at a staggering financial cost to the American taxpayer, estimated at over $2 trillion.

Despite the signing of a peace deal between the US and the Taliban in 2020, the conflict has continued, with the Taliban making significant territorial gains and imposing strict laws that restrict the rights of women and girls. The humanitarian situation in Afghanistan has also deteriorated, with Afghans suffering from food shortages, economic collapse, and a lack of international aid.

So, how can we stop the war in Afghanistan? One approach is to negotiate with the Taliban, although this may require making concessions that are unpopular with the American public and Congress. Another option is for the US to withdraw completely from Afghanistan, although this could result in further loss of life and freedoms for Afghans. Ultimately, a combination of humility, local expertise, and political will may be needed to bring an end to this decades-long conflict.

Negotiate with the Taliban

Negotiating with the Taliban has been a strategy considered by the US and its allies since at least 2009. However, the Taliban has refused to negotiate with the Afghan government, instead referring to it as a "puppet regime" of the West. Despite this, the Taliban has met with Afghan leaders since 2017, although only unofficially.

In 2020, the US and the Taliban signed a peace deal, known as the Doha Agreement, which set a timeline for the withdrawal of US troops from Afghanistan. Under the agreement, the US pledged to reduce its troops to approximately 8,500 within 135 days and to complete a full withdrawal within 14 months. In return, the Taliban pledged to prevent territory under its control from being used by terrorist groups and to enter negotiations with the Afghan government.

However, the Taliban quickly resumed attacks on Afghan security forces and civilians after a brief reduction in violence. Direct talks between the Afghan government and the Taliban began months after the agreed-upon start of March 2020, but the negotiations faced multiple delays and ultimately made little progress. Violence across Afghanistan continued in 2020 and 2021 as the US increased airstrikes and raids targeting the Taliban. The Taliban, in turn, attacked Afghan government and security forces targets and made significant territorial gains.

In April 2021, US President Joe Biden announced that US military forces would leave Afghanistan by September 2021. The Taliban ramped up attacks on security bases and outposts and rapidly seized more territory. By the end of July 2021, the US had completed nearly 95% of its withdrawal, leaving just 650 troops to protect the US embassy in Kabul.

On August 15, 2021, Taliban fighters entered Kabul, and Afghan President Ashraf Ghani fled the country. Later that day, the Taliban announced they had taken control of the presidential palace and were establishing checkpoints to maintain security. The speed of the Taliban's territorial gains and the collapse of the Afghan government surprised US officials and allies.

Following the US withdrawal, the Taliban rolled back women's rights, reintroduced public flogging and executions, and cracked down on opium production. The group has also made it more difficult for aid agencies to operate in Afghanistan, contributing to the country's worsening humanitarian crisis.

While some have argued that the US should cut its losses and fully withdraw from Afghanistan, others have suggested that negotiating with the Taliban is the only alternative to outright defeat. Any viable settlement will require serious political work in Washington as well as in Kabul, and it will be essential to lay the political groundwork and build congressional support for a potentially controversial deal.

A settlement that the US could live with would require the Taliban to renounce violence, break with Al-Qaeda, disarm, and accept something along the lines of the Afghan constitution. In exchange, the Taliban would receive legal status as a political party, set-asides of offices or parliamentary seats, and the withdrawal of any remaining foreign forces from Afghanistan. The Afghan government, meanwhile, would have to accept a role for the Taliban in a coalition government.

While such a deal would be far from ideal, it could preserve the US's two most vital national interests in Afghanistan: preventing the country from becoming a base for militants to attack the West, and securing the rights of women and girls.

Withdraw US troops

The withdrawal of US troops from Afghanistan was completed on August 30, 2021, marking the end of the 2001–2021 war. The evacuation efforts from Kabul's airport effectively ended America's longest war.

The US-Taliban deal, signed in February 2020, was the first critical event that triggered the collapse of the Afghan National Security Forces (ANSF). The deal stipulated fighting restrictions for both the US and the Taliban and provided for the withdrawal of all NATO forces from Afghanistan in return for the Taliban's counter-terrorism commitments.

The second critical event was the Biden administration's final decision in April 2021 to pull out all US troops by September 2021 without leaving a residual force. This decision, along with the US-Taliban deal, triggered the start of the collapse of the ANSF.

The US-Taliban deal included a schedule for the withdrawal of US and NATO forces from Afghanistan. In return, the Taliban pledged not to associate with al-Qaeda, ISIS, or other militant groups and not allow them to use Afghan territory to plan, organize, and launch attacks against the US or its allies.

The ability of the US to maintain some forces in Afghanistan was a major sticking point throughout the talks. Washington argued that a small number of American troops were required to counter future terrorist threats, while the Taliban insisted that all foreign forces had to depart.

The deal also called for the Taliban to begin direct negotiations with the Afghan government to craft a political roadmap for the country's future. This was critical for achieving a long-term settlement, and Afghan President Ashraf Ghani was concerned that his government was not directly involved in the initial negotiations.

The overall political settlement between the Taliban and the Afghan government remained problematic. Ghani argued that Afghanistan must continue to be a democracy and show respect for women's rights. However, experts believe that the Taliban intends to create an emirate guided by religious leaders and has shown no interest in providing women's rights in the areas under their control.

The withdrawal of US troops from Afghanistan was a controversial decision that received both criticism and praise. Some critics argued that the withdrawal undermined the fragile security situation in the region and hampered ongoing peace talks between the Taliban and the Afghan government. There were also concerns that the withdrawal would lead to a resurgence of the Taliban and a loss of the gains made in securing women's rights and education.

On the other hand, a majority of US adults (54%) supported the decision to withdraw troops, according to a Pew Research Center survey. They believed that the US had mostly failed to achieve its goals in Afghanistan, and that the situation in Afghanistan posed a security threat to the US.

The withdrawal of US troops from Afghanistan ended America's longest war and marked a new chapter in the US effort to keep pressure on terrorist groups such as Islamic State and al-Qaeda.

Reduce US aid

Reducing US aid to Afghanistan is a complex issue that requires careful consideration of various factors. Here are some key points to discuss this topic:

Impact on Humanitarian Crisis

US aid has played a significant role in addressing the humanitarian crisis in Afghanistan. Since mid-August 2021, the US has provided nearly $2 billion in humanitarian assistance, with USAID contributing over $1.46 billion. This aid has been crucial in providing food, nutrition, healthcare, and protection for vulnerable Afghans, especially women and children. The reduction in US aid could leave millions of Afghans without access to basic necessities and essential services, exacerbating the already dire humanitarian situation in the country.

Economic Consequences

The US has been a major source of economic assistance to Afghanistan, providing billions of dollars in aid over the years. The reduction or cessation of this aid could have severe economic consequences for the country. Afghanistan's economy is heavily reliant on foreign aid, and the loss of US economic support could lead to a further collapse of the economy, increased poverty, and macroeconomic instability. This could result in even higher food insecurity, unemployment, and a deterioration of basic services such as healthcare and education.

Impact on Governance and Development

US aid has also been directed towards supporting governance and development initiatives in Afghanistan. However, there have been criticisms that much of this aid was wasted or stolen due to corruption within the Afghan government and ineffective management by US agencies. Reducing US aid could provide an opportunity to restructure and improve the efficiency of these initiatives. However, it could also lead to a complete halt in progress or even a regression in the country's development, especially if the Taliban fails to organize an effective governance system.

Geopolitical Implications

The reduction of US aid could have significant geopolitical implications. Afghanistan's stability is crucial for the region, and a complete withdrawal of US support could create a power vacuum that neighboring countries such as Russia, China, Iran, and Pakistan may seek to fill. This could lead to increased competition and tension among these regional powers, potentially destabilizing the region further. Additionally, the reduction in US aid could weaken the US's influence in Afghanistan and its ability to promote its interests and values, such as protecting human rights and preventing Afghanistan from becoming a safe haven for terrorism.

Alternative Approaches

While reducing US aid may be an option, it is essential to explore alternative approaches that could be more effective in addressing the complex challenges in Afghanistan. These approaches could include encouraging a neutral state or international consortium to lead aid efforts, conditionality in aid allocation to promote good governance and reduce corruption, and strengthening diplomatic efforts for a peaceful and stable Afghanistan. A combination of reduced US aid and alternative strategies may be the most realistic approach to achieving sustainable progress in the country.

In conclusion, reducing US aid to Afghanistan could have significant consequences, both positive and negative. It is essential to carefully consider the impact on the humanitarian crisis, economic stability, governance, and the geopolitical landscape. Exploring alternative approaches and working collaboratively with regional powers and international organizations may be key to achieving a peaceful and prosperous Afghanistan.

Improve Afghan governance

To improve Afghan governance, several measures can be taken:

Firstly, it is imperative to address the deep-rooted corruption within the Afghan government. The current system is marred by corruption and exclusionary practices, which have only worsened over time. This has led to a lack of trust in the government and provided an opportunity for the Taliban to gain support by positioning themselves as an "incorruptible" alternative. To counter this, donors must condition their aid contributions on the Afghan government's implementation of significant reforms. By withholding assistance when necessary, international donors can exert pressure on the government to bring about meaningful change and improve its credibility among the Afghan people.

Secondly, the Afghan government must be encouraged and supported in its efforts to become more inclusive. This includes ensuring the protection and advancement of the rights of women and minorities, which are currently under threat. The Taliban's strict interpretation of Islamic law has resulted in the reversal of gains made in women's rights, with girls being barred from secondary schools and women facing restrictions on travel and public life. The Afghan government must actively promote and safeguard these rights, ensuring that any negotiations with the Taliban do not come at the expense of the freedoms and opportunities of its citizens.

Thirdly, the Afghan government should focus on improving its relationship with Pakistan. Pakistan has long been accused of supporting the Taliban and providing safe havens for their leaders. By addressing this complex dynamic and working towards a stable border, the Afghan government can reduce external interference and strengthen its position. Additionally, the Afghan government should continue to engage in negotiations with the Taliban. While these talks are challenging and complex, involving multiple factions and stakeholders, they are necessary for a long-term settlement. However, the Afghan government must approach these negotiations with caution, ensuring that any agreements do not compromise their core interests or lead to a complete takeover by the Taliban.

Finally, the international community, particularly the United States, must remain committed to providing the necessary resources and support to Afghanistan. This includes financial aid, military assistance, and diplomatic efforts. The US withdrawal from Afghanistan has had a significant impact, and a sustained commitment is required to help the Afghan government address the various challenges it faces. This includes supporting the Afghan National Defense and Security Forces (ANDSF) in their efforts to maintain security and stability within the country.

Provide economic assistance

Providing economic assistance to Afghanistan is a complex issue that requires careful consideration of various factors. Here are some key points to consider:

• Addressing Basic Needs: The first priority should be ensuring that basic needs are met for the Afghan people. This includes providing food, shelter, and medical supplies to prevent humanitarian catastrophes. This was especially crucial during the winter months when distribution of aid becomes more challenging.
• Coordination with the Afghan Government: It is essential to work closely with the Afghan government and seek their input on how economic assistance can be utilized effectively. This includes involving them in decision-making processes and ensuring that aid reaches those who need it the most.
• Long-term Development: While meeting immediate needs is crucial, it is also important to invest in long-term development projects that will help Afghanistan rebuild its infrastructure, economy, and social services. This includes supporting education, healthcare, agriculture, and other sectors that will improve living conditions and provide economic opportunities for Afghans.
• Accountability and Transparency: To ensure that economic assistance is used effectively and reaches the intended beneficiaries, strong accountability measures and transparent processes are necessary. This includes monitoring and evaluating the use of funds to prevent corruption and misuse of resources.
• Involving Local Communities: Economic assistance should aim to empower local communities and build their capacity to manage their own resources. This includes providing support for local businesses, farmers, and entrepreneurs to create sustainable economic opportunities.
• International Cooperation: Working with international organizations and other countries can help coordinate aid efforts and ensure a comprehensive approach to supporting Afghanistan. This includes organizations like the UN, World Bank, and other international aid agencies.
• Security and Stability: Providing economic assistance should go hand in hand with efforts to establish security and stability in Afghanistan. This includes supporting the Afghan security forces and working towards a peaceful resolution to the conflict.
• Addressing Gender Inequality: Economic assistance programs should specifically address the needs of women and girls, who often face greater obstacles in accessing resources and opportunities. This includes promoting women's empowerment and ensuring their rights to education, healthcare, and economic participation.
• Sustainability: It is crucial that economic assistance programs are designed with long-term sustainability in mind. This means building the capacity of Afghan institutions to manage and maintain the projects and infrastructure developed with international aid.
• Private Sector Development: Encouraging private sector investment and entrepreneurship can help stimulate Afghanistan's economy and reduce aid dependency over time. This includes creating an enabling environment for businesses to operate and attracting foreign investment.

Frequently asked questions