Austria-Switzerland: A History Of Conflict And Peace

Austria and Switzerland have a long history of conflict, with the two countries fighting on opposite sides in several wars. One of the earliest recorded instances of conflict between the two nations was the Battle of Sempach in 1386, which saw Swiss confederate forces defeat an Austrian army led by Habsburg duke Leopold III of Tirol. During the First and Second World Wars, Switzerland maintained armed neutrality, but its territory was violated by both Axis and Allied aircraft. Switzerland also served as a refuge for prisoners of war, revolutionaries, and politicians from both sides of the conflict.

Swiss neutrality in World War I

Switzerland has the oldest policy of military neutrality in the world. It has not participated in a foreign war since its neutrality was established by the Treaty of Paris in 1815. However, during World War I, Switzerland shared land borders with two of the Central Powers (Germany and Austria-Hungary) and two of the Entente Powers (France and Italy). This made maintaining neutrality difficult.

Under the Schlieffen Plan, the German General Staff considered the possibility of outflanking the French fortifications by marching through Switzerland, which would have violated its neutrality. However, Helmuth von Moltke the Younger, the plan's eventual executor, chose Belgium instead due to Switzerland's mountainous topography and the disorganized state of the Belgian Armed Forces. Switzerland's powerful defense and mountainous landscape also deterred Germany from invading.

Switzerland's neutrality was further tested by the internal division between its German-speaking majority, who generally favored the Central Powers, and the French- and Italian-speaking populations, who sided with the Entente Powers. This caused internal conflict in 1918. Despite these challenges, Switzerland maintained its neutrality throughout World War I. It served as a "protecting power" for both sides, playing a special role in helping prisoners of war and facilitating diplomacy, espionage, and commerce. Switzerland's central location, neutrality, and lack of damage from the war also made it a haven for approximately 300,000 refugees, as well as politicians, artists, pacifists, and thinkers.

Swiss neutrality in World War II

Switzerland's neutrality during World War II has been the subject of much debate and controversy. While the country managed to avoid direct involvement in the conflict, its actions during the war have been scrutinised and criticised by many.

Switzerland's neutrality can be understood in the context of its topography and strategic location. Surrounded by the Central Powers (Germany and Austria-Hungary) and the Entente Powers (France and Italy), maintaining neutrality was a challenging task. Switzerland's mountainous landscape, however, made it less appealing for invasion, and the country was able to build a strong defence.

One of Switzerland's notable actions during World War II was its role as a "protecting power". It served as a neutral intermediary for the warring parties, facilitating diplomacy, espionage, and commerce. Switzerland also provided refuge for approximately 300,000 people, including politicians, artists, pacifists, and thinkers. This included notable figures like Vladimir Lenin, who led the Bolshevik movement from Switzerland during the war.

However, Switzerland's neutrality has been questioned due to its economic dealings with Nazi Germany. Swiss banks accepted deposits from Nazi leaders and facilitated the laundering of hundreds of millions of dollars in stolen assets, including gold looted from occupied countries and dental gold extracted from victims. Switzerland also traded with Germany, exchanging precision machine tools, watches, jewel bearings, electricity, and dairy products for coal.

Switzerland's border policies during the war have also been a subject of controversy. While the country did provide refuge for some, it also vigorously blocked the entry of Jewish refugees, often turning them away or delivering them into the hands of the Nazis or Vichy officials. The suggestion to stamp Jewish passports with a "J" originated from the Swiss Chief of Police, and the phrase "the lifeboat is full" was coined by a Swiss official, reflecting the country's reluctance to accept more refugees.

In conclusion, Switzerland's neutrality during World War II is a complex and contentious issue. While the country managed to avoid direct involvement in the war and provided refuge for some, its economic dealings with Nazi Germany, trade relations, and border policies have raised questions about the integrity of its neutrality.

Swiss Confederation vs Austrian Habsburgs

The Swiss Confederation and the Austrian Habsburgs fought several times during the late medieval and early modern periods. The Swiss Confederation began as an alliance between communities in the Central Alps, which were part of the Holy Roman Empire. The Habsburgs sought to extend their influence over this region and bring it under their rule. This led to a conflict between the two powers, with the Swiss Confederation trying to defend its privileged status as a reichsfrei region.

The Swiss Confederation was formed by the cantons of Uri, Schwyz, and Unterwalden, which were joined in the early 14th century by the city-states of Lucerne, Zurich, and Bern. They managed to defeat the Habsburg armies on several occasions and profited from the fact that the emperors of the Holy Roman Empire during most of the 14th century came from the House of Luxembourg, regarding them as potential allies against the rival Habsburgs.

The Swiss chronicles of the Burgundy Wars period (1470s) refer to a rebellion against the local bailiffs, with a coordinated destruction of their forts or castles, known as the Burgenbruch. The earliest reference to this is the White Book of Sarnen (1470), which records that "wherever there were hostile forts (towers), they broke (slighted) them and first began in Uri to break these buildings".

The Swiss Confederation's refusal to join the Swabian League in 1488 CE and its rejection of the legislation passed at the Diet of Worms in 1495 CE triggered the short but ferocious Swabian War in 1499 CE. The Swiss won six major victories in rapid succession: Hard (February 1499), Bruderholz (March 1499), Schwaderloh (April 1499), Frastanz (April 1499), Calven (May 1499), and Dornach (July 1499). The war culminated in the Battle of Dornach, where Emperor Maximilian I had no choice but to agree to a peace treaty signed on September 22, 1499, in Basel. The treaty granted the Swiss Confederation far-reaching independence from the empire, effectively acknowledging it as a separate political entity.

The Swiss Confederation and the Austrian Habsburgs clashed again in 1515 during the Battle of Marignano in the Italian Wars. The Swiss mercenaries, renowned as the best soldiers in Europe, suffered a heavy defeat at the hands of the French, which put an end to their military territorial interventions. However, Swiss mercenaries from individual cantons continued to participate in the Italian Wars beyond the middle of the 16th century, serving various parties.

Swiss neutrality in Napoleonic Wars

Switzerland's neutrality was established by the Treaty of Paris in 1815, and the country has not participated in a foreign war since. However, the roots of Swiss neutrality can be traced back to the early 16th century, when the Swiss Confederacy suffered a devastating loss to the French at the Battle of Marignano in 1515. Following this defeat, the Confederacy abandoned its expansionist policies and sought to avoid future conflict.

The Swiss neutrality was truly sealed during the Napoleonic Wars. In 1798, Switzerland was invaded by France and renamed the Helvetic Republic. The country became a battlefield during the French Revolutionary Wars, culminating in the Battles of Zurich in 1799. During this period, the Swiss constitution and the Treaty of Paris's Act on the Neutrality of Switzerland affirmed Swiss neutrality.

In 1803, Napoleon's Act of Mediation reestablished the Swiss Confederation, partially restoring the sovereignty of the cantons. The Congress of Vienna of 1815 fully re-established Swiss independence, and the European powers agreed to permanently recognize Swiss neutrality. The territory of Switzerland was increased for the last time with the addition of the new cantons of Valais, Neuchâtel, and Geneva.

During World War I, Switzerland maintained its neutrality despite sharing land borders with both the Central Powers and the Allied Powers. The country mobilized its army and accepted refugees but refused to take sides militarily. Switzerland's neutrality was questioned during World War I by the Grimm-Hoffmann Affair, in which a Swiss socialist politician attempted to negotiate a separate peace agreement between Russia and Germany.

In conclusion, the Napoleonic Wars played a crucial role in shaping Swiss neutrality. The country's invasion by France, its establishment as the Helvetic Republic, and the affirmation of its neutrality during the Congress of Vienna all contributed to Switzerland's long-standing commitment to impartiality in global affairs.

Swiss neutrality in modern times

Swiss neutrality has a long history, but the concept has evolved over time. The country has not participated in a foreign war since its neutrality was established by the Treaty of Paris in 1815. However, the country did have a civil war in 1847.

The roots of Swiss neutrality can be traced back to the defeat of the Old Swiss Confederacy at the Battle of Marignano in 1515 or the peace treaty signed with France in 1516. Prior to this, the Swiss Confederacy had an expansionist foreign policy. The Peace of Westphalia in 1648 was another important step, as other countries were disallowed from passing through Swiss territory, and the Confederation became legally independent from the Holy Roman Empire.

During World War I, Switzerland maintained its neutrality despite sharing land borders with two Central Powers (Germany and Austria-Hungary) and two Allied Powers (France and Italy). The country managed to avoid conflict, although there were internal tensions as the German-speaking majority generally favoured the Central Powers, while the French- and Italian-speaking populations sided with the Allies.

Switzerland also remained neutral during World War II, surrounded by Axis powers and Axis-controlled territory. The country made preparations for a potential invasion by Nazi Germany and mobilized up to 850,000 soldiers. While there were skirmishes in the air, resulting in heavy losses for the Luftwaffe, it never escalated to a full-scale war.

In modern times, Swiss neutrality continues to be a key aspect of the country's foreign policy. Switzerland has not joined military alliances such as NATO and pursues an active policy of non-alignment. However, the country has participated in peace missions and joined the United Nations in 2002.

Switzerland's neutrality was called into question following the Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2022. The country imposed economic sanctions on Russia and froze Russian assets, which some described as a "sharp deviation from traditional neutrality." Switzerland also adopted EU sanctions against Russia, including the freezing of Russian bank accounts. These actions sparked debate within Switzerland and led to proposals to amend the constitution to include "integral neutrality."

While Swiss neutrality has evolved and faced challenges over time, it remains a core principle of the country's foreign policy, with a 2018 survey finding that 95% of Swiss citizens supported maintaining neutrality.

Frequently asked questions