Music, Mountains, And More: Austria's Cultural Depiction

The Sound of Music is a 1965 Hollywood blockbuster starring Julie Andrews and Christopher Plummer, which was set and filmed in Salzburg, Austria. The movie is based on the true story of Maria Kutschera, who moved in with the Trapp family as a governess and later married the widower father. The family choir they founded went on to achieve international success after their emigration to the United States in 1939. While the film romanticises Austrian culture with its depiction of lederhosen-clad men and dirndl-wearing women, it also touches on the country's complex history with Nazism. Despite its global popularity, The Sound of Music has never been well-received in Austria, with many Austrians resenting the historical inaccuracies and reinforcement of stereotypes.

Reinforcement of Austrian stereotypes

The 1965 film The Sound of Music is based on the true story of Maria Kutschera, who moved in with the Trapp family as a governess and later married the widower father. The family choir they founded became internationally successful after their emigration to the United States in 1939. However, the film has been criticised for reinforcing Austrian stereotypes.

The film has been accused of perpetuating the stereotype of Austrians as "Lederhosen-clad men and dirndl-wearing women". The costume choices in the film contribute to this stereotype by dressing the characters in traditional Austrian clothing, such as Lederhosen and Dirndls. This has led to many tourists flocking to Salzburg, expecting to see locals dressed in these outfits and experience the "magic" of the film.

In addition to the clothing, the film also reinforces the stereotype of Austrians as yodellers and singers. The character of Maria, in particular, is often shown singing and teaching the children to sing, which has led to some people believing that Austrians are always singing. This belief is further reinforced by the film's musical nature and the success of its soundtrack, which has become well-known and loved by many, especially those who grew up with the film as a Christmas tradition.

The Sound of Music has also been criticised for its historical inaccuracies, such as the portrayal of Maria as a nun and the escape route of the Trapp family. These inaccuracies contribute to a distorted view of Austrian history and culture, reinforcing stereotypes that Austrians may wish to distance themselves from.

Furthermore, the film's portrayal of the von Trapp family as anti-Nazi can be seen as a reinforcement of Austrian stereotypes. The hero of the film, Captain von Trapp, is explicitly opposed to Nazism, but his concern is primarily the threat to Austrian independence rather than the ideology's inherent problems, such as antisemitism, militarism, and authoritarianism. This portrayal aligns with the stereotype of Austrians as hyper-conservative and nationalist, which was particularly prevalent in the context of post-World War I Austria, a landlocked, German-speaking republic created against the wishes of many of its citizens.

In conclusion, while The Sound of Music has brought international attention to Salzburg and Austria, it has also contributed to the reinforcement of Austrian stereotypes, from clothing choices to musical abilities and political ideologies.

Historical inaccuracies

The Sound of Music, a 1965 musical film set and filmed in Salzburg, Austria, is "historically inaccurate" when compared to the real-life von Trapp family and Maria von Trapp. Here are some of the historical inaccuracies in the film:

Number of Children:

In the film, the von Trapp family is depicted as having seven children. However, in reality, the family had ten children. Three children born to Captain Georg von Trapp and Maria were omitted from the film due to the altered timeframe.

Maria's Role:

Maria von Trapp was hired to tutor one von Trapp child, who was ill and could not attend school, rather than being a governess to all the children as shown in the film.

Maria and Georg's Relationship:

The film depicts Maria and Georg's relationship as a blossoming love story. However, the real-life Maria revealed that she did not love Georg when they married. She stated, "I really and truly was not in love. I liked him, but didn't love him. However, I loved the children, so in a way I really married the children." Additionally, they were married for eleven years before the Nazis took over Austria, not when the Nazis were taking control as shown in the film.

Georg's Character:

The film portrays Georg von Trapp as a detached disciplinarian and a harsh, aggressive sea captain. However, his children described him as a "warm and loving" father, and Maria von Trapp noted that he was a kind and gentle man.

Escape from the Nazis:

In the film's climactic scene, the von Trapps are shown fleeing Salzburg, Austria, by hiking across the mountains to Switzerland. However, in reality, they simply walked out of their villa and crossed the railroad tracks behind it to board a train to Italy, where they had citizenship. If they had attempted to cross the mountains as shown in the film, they would have ended up in Nazi Germany, not Switzerland.

Music in the von Trapp House:

The film depicts Georg von Trapp as disapproving of music, with Maria bringing music and song into the house. However, in reality, Georg and his first wife introduced music and taught their children to play instruments.

These inaccuracies in The Sound of Music have led to resentment among Austrians, who feel that the film reinforces stereotypes and inaccurately depicts their heritage.

The real Maria Von Trapp

In 1926, Maria was sent from the convent to tutor Maria Franziska von Trapp, one of seven children born to widowed naval commander Georg von Trapp. His first wife, Agathe Whitehead, had died of scarlet fever in 1922. Maria eventually began to care for all of the children: Rupert, Agathe, Werner, Hedwig, Johanna, and Martina. Captain von Trapp proposed to Maria, although he was 25 years her senior. Initially frightened, she accepted after seeking guidance from the mother abbess. They married in 1927 and had three children together: Rosmarie, Eleonore, and Johannes.

The von Trapps enjoyed hiking and singing together, and their musical career began when the Archbishop of Salzburg sent Father Franz Wasner to stay with them as their chaplain. Soprano Lotte Lehmann heard the family sing and suggested they perform at concerts. They soon became a popular touring act, performing across Europe. However, their lives became increasingly difficult under Nazi rule, and they fled Austria for Italy by train in 1938, later travelling to England and then the United States. Initially calling themselves the "Trapp Family Choir", they began to perform in the US and Canada, eventually settling in Stowe, Vermont in the 1940s.

Maria von Trapp's autobiography, 'The Story of the Trapp Family Singers', was published in 1949 and inspired the 1956 film 'The Trapp Family' and the 1959 Broadway musical 'The Sound of Music'. While the film and musical were not entirely accurate in their portrayal of the family, they brought the story of the von Trapps to a global audience.

The 'real' Salzburg

Salzburg is a city steeped in history and culture, but it is often overshadowed by its association with the film "The Sound of Music". While the movie has brought international attention to the city, it also means that many visitors come with certain expectations that may not reflect the reality of life in Salzburg.

The "Sound of Music" trail attracts over 300,000 visitors to the city each year, all keen to experience the magic of the movie for themselves. However, this focus on the film means that many visitors miss out on the opportunity to explore the 'real' Salzburg and all that it has to offer beyond the world of Maria von Trapp and the von Trapp family.

Salzburg is, in fact, a cultural hub with numerous attractions that have no connection to "The Sound of Music". For example, the Museum of Modern Art offers a rich artistic experience, and there are also several secret sites to discover. The city is also home to a thriving football club, FC Red Bull Salzburg, which competes in the Austrian Bundesliga and has a passionate fanbase.

In addition, Salzburg has a rich musical heritage that extends far beyond the von Trapp family. Mozart, for instance, is celebrated as one of the city's most famous sons, and his compositions continue to be performed and enjoyed by locals and visitors alike.

So, while "The Sound of Music" has brought worldwide fame to Salzburg, it is important to remember that the city has a diverse range of attractions and a unique cultural identity that extends far beyond the world of the film. Visitors who take the time to explore beyond the "Sound of Music" trail will be rewarded with a deeper understanding of the rich tapestry that is the real Salzburg.

The Sound of Music's impact on tourism

The Sound of Music has had a significant impact on tourism in Austria, particularly in Salzburg, where the movie was filmed and where the real-life Trapp family once lived. The city attracts over 300,000 visitors annually due to the film, with 650,000 overnight stays booked in the region per year. The popularity of the movie has led to the development of themed tours, such as guided bike tours and bus tours, that take fans to filming locations and landmarks related to the Trapp family.

However, it is important to note that the movie's impact on tourism in Austria has also been met with some criticism. Austrians themselves have a complex relationship with the film, and many have rarely watched it or are even unaware of its existence. They view the movie as perpetuating stereotypes and reinforcing historical inaccuracies about their culture and history. The film's portrayal of Austrians in lederhosen and dirndls, for example, is considered a caricature by many locals.

Additionally, the movie's depiction of the von Trapp family's escape from Nazi-occupied Salzburg and Captain von Trapp's opposition to Nazism is seen as simplistic and offensive to some Austrians, who believe it ignores more complex political dynamics at play during that time. Austrians also take issue with the fact that the movie was not a box-office success in their country when it premiered in 1965 and that it reinforces stereotypes about their culture and history.

Despite these criticisms, The Sound of Music continues to be a major driver of tourism in Austria, with visitors flocking to Salzburg to experience the magic of the movie and walk in the footsteps of Maria von Trapp and Julie Andrews.

Frequently asked questions