The Veiled Reality Of Afghanistan: Unveiling The Truth About An Informed Populace

Afghanistan has been unstable for decades, with frequent coups, civil wars, and violent transfers of power. The country has been governed by various systems, including a monarchy, republic, theocracy, dictatorship, and a pro-communist state. The Taliban, a fundamentalist Islamic nationalist movement, took control of the country in 2021 and established a totalitarian emirate within an Islamic theocracy.

The Taliban's rule has been marked by a lack of democratic norms and civil rights, with all political activities forbidden and most oppositional leaders fleeing the country. The current government is not recognized internationally and is neither democratic nor willing to promote Western democracy.

However, the Taliban has taken steps to improve domestic security, stability, and the fight against corruption. They have also allowed elementary schools for girls to remain open and have not enforced strict dress codes for women, marking a departure from their previous time in power.

While the Taliban has expressed interest in moderating its image, the movement's leadership remains committed to its interpretation of Sharia law and views democracy as incompatible with Islam. The country's future trajectory remains uncertain, with enormous uncertainty looming over how the Taliban will navigate the inherited structures of the fallen republic.

The role of education in creating an informed populace

Afghanistan has been unstable for decades, with frequent coups, civil wars, and violent transfers of power. The country has been governed by various systems, including a monarchy, republic, theocracy, dictatorship, and a pro-communist state. The current government is a totalitarian emirate within an Islamic theocracy, with the Taliban Movement holding a monopoly on power.

The Taliban's rule has been marked by restrictions on women's rights, particularly in the areas of education and employment. Girls have been prohibited from pursuing secondary and higher education, and women have faced limitations on their ability to work, including a ban on participation in sports. These measures have had a significant impact on the level of education and opportunities available to Afghan women and girls.

Despite these challenges, education plays a crucial role in creating an informed populace in Afghanistan. An educated citizenry is essential for a well-functioning democracy, as people need to be informed and encouraged to think critically to participate meaningfully in a political society. This is especially important in a young country like Afghanistan, where two-thirds of the population is under 25 years of age.

Improving access to quality education has been a key priority, and one of the major achievements of the post-Taliban era. Many schools that were closed under Taliban rule have been reopened, and girls have been offered access to education once again. This has been met with enthusiasm by Afghan citizens, who have shown a strong desire to invest in the future of their country by sending their children to school. As a result, school enrollment has skyrocketed, with almost 3 million more girls attending school despite continued threats and attacks against them.

However, there are still significant challenges to be addressed. Literacy rates remain low, especially in rural areas, where three-quarters of the population resides. Around 90% of women and 63% of men in these areas are illiterate. Ensuring equal access to quality education and protecting regions where Taliban groups continue to burn school buildings and threaten those who seek education are crucial steps towards creating an informed populace.

Additionally, civil society must be allowed to thrive, with freedom of expression, association, and assembly protected. The media should also be allowed to operate without censorship, as these channels are essential for citizens to learn about and engage with their government.

While Afghanistan faces significant obstacles, a focus on education and the protection of civil rights can play a crucial role in creating an informed populace and fostering democratic values in the country.

The importance of access to information and justice

Access to information and justice is essential for a well-functioning democracy. An informed citizenry is crucial for meaningful political participation and ensuring that the government is accountable to its people. However, the situation in Afghanistan presents a complex picture, with a history of foreign occupation, a weak central government, and a lack of democratic institutions.

The country's political landscape has been shaped by decades of conflict, frequent coups, civil wars, and violent transfers of power. The most recent example is the Taliban's seizure of power in 2021, which overthrew the Western-backed Islamic Republic and imposed a strict interpretation of Sharia law. This event highlighted the fragile nature of Afghanistan's democracy and the challenges it faces in ensuring access to information and justice for its citizens.

During the Taliban's rule, dissent was not permitted, and politics was largely limited to internal policy debates and power struggles within the movement. The country currently operates without a clear constitution or a defined rule of law, with the Taliban ruling by decree and interpreting Sharia law to suit their needs. This lack of a formal legal framework makes it difficult for citizens to know their rights and understand how the law will be applied, hindering their access to justice.

Additionally, the Taliban's restrictive policies on media and non-governmental organizations further limit the flow of information. The media plays a crucial role in informing citizens and holding the government accountable, but under the current regime, journalists face censorship and the threat of repercussions for criticizing the government. This situation undermines freedom of expression and makes it difficult for Afghans to access unbiased information, which is essential for a healthy democracy.

Moreover, Afghanistan's history of weak central governments and reliance on foreign subsidies has contributed to the challenges in establishing effective rule of law. The country has a history of powerful local influencers and power brokers who hold significant autonomy and are not easily controlled by the central government. This dynamic has further fragmented authority across the country and made it difficult to establish a uniform justice system.

Despite these challenges, there are glimmers of hope. For example, traditional community councils (shūrās) and tribal assemblies (jirgas) have continued to function and provide a degree of local justice, even during periods of political upheaval. These informal institutions are deeply rooted in Afghan society and provide a sense of social norms and order when central authority is weak.

In conclusion, access to information and justice is of paramount importance for any society striving for democracy. However, Afghanistan faces significant challenges due to its political instability, weak central government, and lack of democratic institutions. The country's history of foreign occupation and internal power struggles have hindered the development of a robust justice system and free flow of information, which are essential pillars of a healthy democratic society.

The impact of the Taliban on the education system

The Taliban's takeover of Afghanistan has had a detrimental impact on the country's education system. The group has banned girls from attending secondary school and prohibited women from pursuing higher education, causing international outrage. However, the Taliban's harmful policies extend beyond these widely publicised restrictions.

The Taliban has prohibited women from teaching in schools, causing thousands of female teachers to lose their jobs. Boys who were previously taught by women now have unqualified male teachers or no teachers at all. The curriculum has also been altered to remove important subjects such as art, sports, English, and civics, and to promote discrimination. Corporal punishment has become increasingly common, and students are beaten, slapped, and whipped for infractions such as having a mobile phone or failing to comply with rigid rules on hairstyles and clothing.

The quality of boys' education has declined, and attendance rates have dropped as families struggle to meet basic needs. Boys are increasingly anxious about attending school and have lost hope for the future. The Taliban's policies are causing irreversible damage to the Afghan education system and risk creating a lost generation.

The Taliban's educational policies are undermining access to education for all children and young adults, violating Afghanistan's obligations under international law. The group's systemic discrimination against women and girls is also having harmful effects on boys, including teaching them harmful gender norms and putting pressure on them to be the sole financial providers for their families.

The influence of international aid on the education system

Afghanistan's education system has been devastated by over three decades of sustained conflict. The country has one of the youngest populations in the world, and equal access to quality education is critical to boosting economic growth and democratic development. International aid has played a significant role in rebuilding and improving the education system in Afghanistan, especially after the overthrow of the Taliban government in 2001. Here is an overview of the influence of international aid on the education system in Afghanistan:

Post-Taliban Education Reforms

After the Taliban government was deposed in 2001, the Karzai administration received substantial international aid to restore the education system. Around 7,000 schools were operating in 20 out of 32 provinces by the end of 2003, with 27,000 teachers educating 4.2 million children, including 1.2 million girls. The literacy rate increased significantly, rising from 8% in 2001 to 43% in 2021.

International Aid Efforts

Various international organisations have contributed to improving education in Afghanistan:

• UNESCO: UNESCO has been supporting education in Afghanistan for many years and has witnessed significant gains. They have developed the Multi-Country Preparedness and Response Plan (MCPRP) to address immediate and medium-term education needs, focusing on protecting the right to education for all Afghans, especially girls and women.
• USAID: Since 2008, USAID has helped increase access to education for three million Afghan girls. They have improved school infrastructure, rehabilitated existing schools, and strengthened community-based education. They have also provided scholarships to increase the number of female teachers and extended learning opportunities to girls in rural areas.
• World Bank: The World Bank, in coordination with the international community and donors, has provided over $1.7 billion in support, including funding for humanitarian health, education, and livelihood needs through the Afghanistan Resilience Trust Fund (ARTF).
• UNICEF: UNICEF has worked with the Afghan government and partners to increase school enrolment, particularly for vulnerable children and girls. They support community-based education and establish community-based schools and accelerated learning centres to improve access to education.

Challenges and Barriers

Despite the progress, the education system in Afghanistan continues to face challenges:

• Lack of Infrastructure: Afghanistan requires more schools and teachers. As of 2021, there were nearly 10 million students and 220,000 teachers, but many schools lack proper buildings and facilities.
• Gender Inequality: Girls' enrolment is hindered by insecurity, traditional societal norms, and a lack of female teachers, especially in rural areas. The Taliban's ban on girls' education since 2021 has further exacerbated this issue.
• Economic Factors: Poverty and the lack of skilled and educated workers impact enrolment rates. The recent economic contraction in Afghanistan has reduced aid, affecting aggregate demand and public services, including education.
• Safety Concerns: Violence and sexual abuse against students and educators have been prevalent, preventing millions of children from attending school.
• Curriculum Development: There is a lack of standardised curriculum and adequate textbooks, particularly for secondary and high school levels.

The relationship between democracy and education

The Impact of Education on Democracy

Several scholars have argued that increases in education levels positively impact democracy. Education fosters democratic values such as liberty, equality, justice, and cooperation, making it more effective, meaningful, and relevant. It empowers citizens to understand their rights and responsibilities, encouraging active political participation. Educated citizens are more likely to be active participants in democratic processes, hold leaders accountable, and promote social justice.

However, the relationship between education and democracy is not always linear. Some scholars, like Acemoglu et al. (2005), challenge the notion that education necessarily leads to improved democracy. They argue that increases in education within countries may not significantly impact democracy levels, and that other factors, such as economic development, play a more significant role.

The Role of Education in Afghanistan

Afghanistan's political landscape has been tumultuous, with frequent power shifts and a lack of stable governance. The country's current regime, led by the Taliban, does not adhere to democratic principles and has been criticised for human rights violations and restrictions on civil liberties.

The Taliban's interpretation of Sharia law has resulted in the denial of basic rights and freedoms, particularly for women and girls. They have banned girls from secondary and higher education, restricted women's employment, and imposed strict dress codes. These actions have limited opportunities for women and hindered their ability to participate in democratic processes.

Despite these setbacks, there have been some efforts to promote education and encourage democratic values in Afghanistan. The previous government, led by Ashraf Ghani, made strides in reopening schools and improving access to education, particularly for girls. However, with the Taliban's return to power, these gains are now at risk.

Frequently asked questions