The Complex Reality Of Afghanistan's Human Development Index

Afghanistan has a low Human Development Index (HDI) ranking. The HDI is a composite indicator that measures education, longevity, and economic performance. Afghanistan's HDI ranking in 2007 was 174 out of 178 countries, and in 2019, it was 169 out of 187 countries. The country's social and economic indicators are comparable to or lower than the indicators for sub-Saharan Africa. Afghanistan's challenges include widespread corruption, a breakdown in the rule of law, a paralysed judiciary, and increased poverty. The country also faces issues with food security, access to education, health services, and environmental degradation.

Afghanistan's HDI ranking

The low HDI ranking of Afghanistan can be attributed to several factors, including conflict, insecurity, political transitions, a small economy, illiteracy, unemployment, and a lack of investment in agriculture. Afghanistan has experienced conflict and political transitions since the Soviet invasion in 1979, which has led to insecurity and economic shocks. The country's economy is too small to absorb the growing labor force, and many workers are illiterate and looking for low-skilled jobs, which are scarce.

The agriculture sector, which employs most Afghans, has been hurt by low investment and natural disasters. There is a lack of natural resources necessary for successful agriculture, such as farmable land and water for irrigation. Additionally, the country has faced multiple droughts since 1999. The small-scale farmers, herders, landless people, and women-headed households in rural areas bear the largest burden of poverty.

The inequality between the rich and poor in Afghanistan has been widening, with the poor experiencing a decline in household consumption and continued lack of access to jobs and basic services. International aid has helped grow the economy, but it has not benefited all sectors equally, particularly the agriculture sector. To reduce poverty, Afghanistan must focus on strengthening the agriculture sector, investing in human development, and managing and mitigating risks that increase the vulnerability of the poor.

The impact of conflict

Afghanistan has been in a state of conflict since the Soviet Union invaded in 1979. The conflict has had a devastating impact on the country's human development, with Afghanistan ranking among the most destitute, war-weary countries in the world. The impact of the conflict on human development in Afghanistan is evident in several key areas.

Economic Impact

The conflict has led to a severe economic crisis in Afghanistan, with the country's economy on the verge of collapse. The Taliban takeover in 2021 disrupted economic activities and led to the isolation of the country from the international community. Sanctions and the termination of significant development aid have crippled the Afghan economy. The revocation of the country's central bank's credentials halted all basic banking transactions and restricted cash flow, affecting Afghan families' daily market activities. The economy's dependence on the primary commodities market and heavy reliance on imports have made it vulnerable to external factors such as the Russia-Ukraine war. Inflation has soared, with a more than 50% increase in the price of goods from July 2021 to June 2022.

Humanitarian Crisis

The conflict has resulted in a deepening humanitarian crisis in Afghanistan, with acute food insecurity and malnutrition affecting a significant portion of the population. By March 2022, 95% of Afghan households did not have enough to eat, and more than 3.5 million children required nutrition support. The healthcare system has collapsed, with limited access to healthcare and food, leading to an increased risk of malnutrition and disease. The situation has been exacerbated by consecutive years of drought and natural disasters such as earthquakes and floods.

Human Rights Violations

The conflict and the Taliban's restrictive policies have led to severe human rights abuses, particularly against women and girls. The Taliban has imposed restrictions on women's education, employment, and freedom of movement, with reports of women being barred from appearing in public without a male chaperone and the closure of beauty salons affecting women-owned businesses. There has also been a rise in child and forced marriages, gender-based violence, and femicide. The Taliban has further restricted freedom of expression, with journalists and critics of the regime facing harassment, arbitrary arrests, and unlawful detention.

Displacement and Refugees

The conflict has resulted in a large population of internally displaced people and refugees. More than 1.4 million Afghan refugees in Pakistan were at risk of forced return, with the Pakistani government having deported hundreds of thousands by December 2023. Afghanistan also faces the influx of refugees returning due to the improved security situation and the lack of opportunities in host countries. This has placed additional strain on the country's limited resources and infrastructure.

Access to Education

The conflict and the Taliban's policies have severely impacted access to education, particularly for girls and women. Afghanistan is the only country in the world that prohibits girls' education at the secondary level, doubling the number of girls out of school. The ban on women working with the UN and other restrictions on female employment have also impacted the delivery of humanitarian assistance and affected the education sector, which relies heavily on female teachers and aid workers.

Overall, the conflict in Afghanistan has had a devastating impact on the country's human development, leading to economic collapse, a humanitarian crisis, human rights abuses, displacement, and limited access to education. The situation has been exacerbated by natural disasters, drought, and the country's fragile economy, with limited diversification and dependence on external factors.

The role of international aid

Afghanistan has received approximately $35 billion in international aid between 2002 and 2009. However, much of this aid has not helped ease poverty or improve economic and living conditions. The country currently ranks 172nd in the Human Development Index (HDI) and is heavily reliant on foreign aid, with aid accounting for more than 90% of the national budget.

Addressing Basic Needs and Humanitarian Crises: International aid has played a crucial role in addressing the basic needs of the Afghan people, especially in times of humanitarian crises. For example, after the Taliban takeover in August 2021, there was a sharp deterioration in economic conditions and basic services. International humanitarian aid helped to alleviate some of these issues, providing emergency food, nutrition, healthcare, and protection to vulnerable populations. The World Food Program, for instance, provides life-saving nutrition support to children and pregnant and breastfeeding women.

Supporting Health and Education: International aid has contributed significantly to improvements in health and education in Afghanistan. For instance, the World Bank's Approach 2.0 provided critical health, education, food security, and water services to the Afghan people. Additionally, international spending has helped improve human development outcomes, with youth literacy improving by 8% and primary school enrolment growing by 6%.

Economic Growth and Infrastructure: International aid has supported Afghanistan's economic growth and infrastructure development. For example, the World Bank's Afghanistan Resilience Trust Fund (ARTF) has provided funds for humanitarian gap financing and basic service delivery. However, it's important to note that strong economic growth during the pre-transition period of 2007-2012 did not reduce poverty and instead contributed to widening inequality.

Challenges and Limitations: There have been challenges and limitations to the effectiveness of international aid in Afghanistan. One issue is the suspension of non-humanitarian funding by international donors after the Taliban takeover, which has had a significant impact on the economy and the government's ability to provide services. Additionally, there are concerns about "phantom aid," where aid is looted or misused by corrupt officials, warlords, or criminals. The complex security situation and the presence of the Taliban have also obstructed aid operations and limited the access of women and girls to humanitarian assistance.

Coordination and Conditionality: The coordination of international aid in Afghanistan is crucial, and there have been efforts to unify donor positions and ensure principled assistance. The European Union (EU), for instance, has been a major donor, providing close to €1.7 billion in humanitarian funding since 1994. However, there are also challenges in ensuring that aid is used effectively and aligns with the priorities and needs of the Afghan people.

In conclusion, international aid has played a vital role in Afghanistan, providing essential support in health, education, humanitarian assistance, and economic development. However, there have also been challenges and limitations, including issues with aid effectiveness, suspension of funding, and the complex political and security situation. As Afghanistan continues to face humanitarian crises and economic instability, the role of international aid remains critical, but it must be coupled with efforts to strengthen the country's resilience and long-term development.

The state of human development

Afghanistan has a low human development ranking, with a score of 0.478 points in 2021, according to the Human Development Index (HDI). The HDI is a composite measure of life expectancy, educational attainment, and income level. Afghanistan's HDI score is significantly lower than the world average of 0.724 points in 2021.

Low Life Expectancy and High Mortality Rates: Afghanistan has one of the lowest life expectancies in the world, with an average life expectancy of about 40 years. The mortality rate for children under five is alarmingly high at 26%, and the country has a high maternal mortality rate as well.

Lack of Access to Basic Services: Only 13% of the population has access to improved water sources, and the country struggles with insufficient infrastructure, sanitation, and electricity.

Poverty and Income Inequality: Despite economic growth, poverty rates in Afghanistan remain high, with nearly all Afghans living in poverty or just above the poverty line. The gap between the rich and poor has widened, and income inequality is prevalent.

Limited Educational Opportunities: Afghanistan has a high illiteracy rate, and less than one-third of children were enrolled in schools in 1999. The country is the only one in the world that prohibits girls from attending school.

Food Insecurity: Around 6.6 million Afghans do not meet their minimum food requirements, and malnutrition is a significant issue.

Gender Inequality: Afghanistan ranks low on gender equality indices, and women face increased inequalities in access to education, healthcare, and employment. They also face discrimination and are excluded from many social and economic opportunities due to patriarchal norms.

Economic Challenges: The economy is largely dependent on the agricultural sector, which is vulnerable to natural disasters and lacks investment. The country also faces challenges such as a large informal economy, inefficient revenue collection, and a lack of economic diversification.

Security and Political Issues: Decades of conflict, insecurity, and political transitions have disrupted the country's progress. The Taliban's restrictions on women's rights and education further hinder human development.

Healthcare Concerns: The healthcare system is overburdened, and the country struggles with issues such as drug addiction, disability, and the impact of prolonged conflicts on the physical and mental health of its citizens.

Environmental Degradation: Afghanistan faces issues such as soil degradation, air and water pollution, and drought, with limited efforts to address these ecological concerns.

Overall, the state of human development in Afghanistan is dire, and the country faces significant challenges in improving the well-being and opportunities available to its citizens. Efforts to address these issues are necessary to enhance human development and provide a better future for Afghans.

The future of the economy

Afghanistan's economy is in a state of crisis, with the country facing multiple challenges. The economy has been heavily reliant on international aid, which accounted for around 75% of total government spending and nearly 40% of GDP before the Taliban takeover. However, foreign donors largely suspended aid after the transition, causing a sharp contraction in the economy. The country also lost access to the international banking system and offshore foreign exchange reserves, leading to disruptions in investment and a brain drain as skilled Afghans fled the country.

The Taliban's policies and practices, including restrictions on women's education, employment, and mobility, have further hindered economic growth and exacerbated the humanitarian crisis. The banking sector is dysfunctional due to constraints on international transfers and liquidity issues. Unemployment remains high, and food insecurity is expected to increase.

To improve the economic situation, Afghanistan needs to address several key issues:

• Diversification: The economy is heavily dependent on agriculture, which has been affected by natural disasters, lack of investment, and insufficient infrastructure. Afghanistan should focus on developing other sectors, such as the extractive industry, to reduce reliance on agriculture.
• Education and Gender Equality: With high illiteracy rates and gender inequality, Afghanistan needs to invest in education, particularly for girls and women, to improve human capital and increase economic opportunities.
• Private Sector Development: Encouraging private sector growth and investment can help create jobs and stimulate the economy. The Taliban should continue to engage with the private sector and address issues such as high taxes and business regulations.
• Infrastructure Development: Afghanistan needs to invest in infrastructure, particularly irrigation systems and roads, to support agriculture and facilitate trade.
• Good Governance: Addressing corruption, improving revenue collection, and ensuring equitable access to opportunities and services are crucial for economic growth.
• International Support: While Afghanistan should reduce its dependence on foreign aid, coordinated and effective international support is still needed to address the humanitarian crisis and promote sustainable development.

The future of Afghanistan's economy depends on the country's ability to address these challenges and promote inclusive, sustainable growth. It is crucial to prioritize human development, reduce inequality, and build a resilient economic system that can provide opportunities for all Afghans, especially women and children, who have been disproportionately affected by the country's economic woes.

Frequently asked questions