The Human Impact Of Samangan's Mines: Weighing The Benefits And Costs For Local Communities

Afghanistan is known for its rich deposits of minerals such as copper, iron ore, gold, rare earths, and lapis lazuli. The country's mineral wealth is estimated to be worth trillions of dollars. While the development of mines in Samangan, Afghanistan, has the potential to bring economic benefits to the country and create job opportunities, there are also concerns about the impact of mining on the local community, especially when it comes to child labour, unsafe working conditions, and environmental contamination.

Samangan is one of Afghanistan's largest coal seams, with over 500 coal mines in the Dara-e Suf district alone. Child labour is prevalent in these mines, with more than 1,000 out of 5,000 workers being underage. The work is dangerous and accidents are common due to the lack of safety standards. The local environment has also been contaminated, with many residents suffering from respiratory issues and asthma.

To ensure that the development of mines benefits the people of Samangan, it is crucial to address issues such as labour laws, safety regulations, and environmental sustainability. It remains to be seen whether the recent mining contracts signed by the Afghan government will bring about positive change and improve the lives of those in Samangan and other mining regions.

The potential economic benefits of mining in Afghanistan

Afghanistan is one of the world's most resource-rich nations, with over 1,200 mineral fields. The country's mineral wealth is estimated to be worth up to $3 trillion and includes resources such as gold, chromite, copper, iron, lead, zinc, coal, natural gas, petroleum, precious stones, lithium, talc, and various rare earth elements.

Job Creation and Employment Opportunities

Foreign direct investment (FDI) in the mining sector could provide much-needed employment opportunities for Afghans, directly in the mines and indirectly in ancillary sectors like transport, services, and manufacturing. It is estimated that mining-related activities could create over 50,000 jobs in various fields, including geology, engineering, machine operation, transportation, and security.

Technological Transfer and Skills Development

Partnerships with foreign companies experienced in advanced mining techniques could result in a significant transfer of technology and skills to Afghanistan. This would enhance the country's technical capabilities and industrial know-how, potentially kickstarting industrialization and leading to inclusive economic growth.

Economic Diversification and Revenue Generation

Afghanistan's economy heavily relies on agriculture, making it vulnerable to climate change, market fluctuations, and economic shocks. Mining investments could contribute to economic diversification, reducing the country's vulnerability to various risks. Additionally, the Afghan government retains a significant percentage of shares in the mining projects, ranging from 12% to 56%, and will levy relevant taxes, creating a substantial revenue stream for the state.

Infrastructure Development and Improved Energy Security

Some mining projects, such as the lead and zinc project in Ghor, are linked to the development of power interconnection infrastructure, which will improve energy security and supply electricity to industrial parks, extending their operational hours. Increased power supply could also benefit the agricultural sector by facilitating mechanization.

Currency Stabilization and Foreign Investment

The mining projects are expected to attract foreign investment and boost the influx of foreign currency into the country, contributing to the stabilization of the Afghani currency. European and Asian partners associated with the seven recently signed mining agreements are well-equipped to facilitate the export of processed materials to international markets.

Community Development and Poverty Alleviation

Mining companies are obligated to invest in community development initiatives as part of their contracts, creating additional employment opportunities in healthcare, education, and other sectors. These initiatives have the potential to alleviate poverty and elevate living standards, particularly in underserved provinces.

The challenges of resource exploitation

Afghanistan is a country with a wealth of natural resources, including copper, iron, lithium, and gold. However, the challenges of resource exploitation in the country are significant and present a complex situation. Here are some key challenges:

• Security and Stability: The presence of insurgent groups such as the Taliban and criminal networks poses a significant challenge to the safe operation of mines. Looting and occupation of mines by these groups affect the stability of the industry and deter potential investors.
• Governance and Corruption: Weak governance, corruption, and political influence have hindered the development of the mining sector. There is a lack of proper legal frameworks and organisational capacity, and transparency in the industry. Revenue losses due to corruption are substantial, with hundreds of millions of dollars lost annually.
• Environmental and Social Impact: Mining activities can have detrimental effects on the environment and local communities. There are concerns about water scarcity, air and land pollution, and the preservation of cultural heritage sites. Ensuring equitable distribution of profits among Afghan citizens is also a challenge.
• Infrastructure: Afghanistan lacks the necessary infrastructure, including good-quality roadways, railways, and electricity, which are essential for transporting ore and refined minerals to foreign markets.
• Community Resistance: Local communities sometimes resist formalisation and government control of mines, especially when they perceive corruption or a lack of benefit from mining activities. This can lead to conflicts and violence, with communities seeking protection from insurgent groups.
• Child Labour and Worker Safety: Child labour is prevalent in Afghan coal mines, and worker safety standards are often inadequate, leading to frequent accidents and injuries.
• Foreign Investment Challenges: Attracting foreign investment is challenging due to security concerns and the involvement of insurgent groups. There is a risk of handing over disproportionate power and influence to foreign corporations, potentially compromising Afghanistan's self-determination and long-term wellbeing.
• Timeframe for Development: Large-scale mining projects typically require a significant amount of time for exploration, construction, and establishing operational standards. The anticipated economic benefits may not be achieved in the short term.
• Illicit Activities: Illegal mining and smuggling activities deprive the government of revenue and contribute to the financing of insurgent groups.
• Geopolitical Dynamics: Afghanistan's mineral resources are of great interest to various countries, including the US, China, India, and Pakistan, leading to geopolitical struggles and potential conflicts over access to these resources.

These challenges highlight the complexities of resource exploitation in Afghanistan and the need for careful navigation to ensure that economic development does not come at the expense of the country's sovereignty, environment, and the wellbeing of its citizens.

Child labour in Afghan coal mines

Afghanistan's coal mines have long relied on child labour. In the Dara-e Suf district of Samangan province, one of Afghanistan's largest coal seams, child labour is rife in the more than 500 coal mines. According to Khair Mohammad Akhtarzada, the deputy governor of Samangan, more than 1,000 of the 5,000 people working in these mines are underage.

Children as young as 12 years old spend all day working in the pitch darkness of these coal mines, loading donkeys with coal to be transported to the surface. The work is dangerous, and the money is good—400 Afghanis (approximately six US dollars) a day, well above the average wage in Afghanistan. Many children need the wages to support their families.

The government only controls four out of the hundreds of mines currently operational in the region. The others are unlicensed and do not maintain minimal safety standards, so accidents are common and often fatal. The deputy governor of Samangan has written hundreds of letters to the ministry of mines and industries on the subject, but no action has been taken. The government lacks the resources to monitor such a large number of collieries.

The use of children in heavy or forced labour is against all accepted international conventions on children's rights, and Afghanistan, as a signatory to the international convention on children's rights, should uphold its commitments. Afghan law also clearly precludes the use of children or young teenagers for hard physical tasks.

The impact of mining on local communities

Mining can have a significant impact on local communities, and these effects can be both positive and negative.

On the positive side, mining can bring much-needed economic development to local communities, particularly in terms of employment opportunities and technological transfer. For instance, in the case of Afghanistan, foreign investment in mining could provide direct employment in the mines and jobs in ancillary sectors like transport, services, and manufacturing. It can also contribute to technological transfer, with foreign companies bringing in advanced mining techniques, thereby raising the country's technical capabilities and industrial know-how.

However, there are also negative consequences that need to be considered. Large-scale resource extraction can lead to a disproportionate amount of power and influence for foreign corporations, sometimes compromising local communities and governance structures. It can also result in environmental degradation, with mining activities exacerbating water scarcity and contaminating water resources, which can have devastating effects on communities that rely on these resources for their livelihoods.

Additionally, labour exploitation and unsafe working conditions are also concerns, particularly when mining sectors are monopolised by high-ranking officials. Child labour is another issue, as seen in the case of coal mines in Samangan, Afghanistan, where more than 1,000 out of 5,000 workers were found to be underage.

Furthermore, the distribution of profits from mining activities may not always benefit the broader population, and social issues such as income inequality, housing pressures, and infrastructure strain may arise.

Overall, while mining can bring economic benefits to local communities, it is essential to carefully navigate the complexities and potential negative consequences to ensure that the pursuit of prosperity does not come at the expense of the wellbeing of local communities and their environment.

The role of foreign investment in the Afghan mining sector

Foreign investment in the Afghan mining sector has been a topic of interest for many countries, including the US, China, India, Germany, and Turkey, which have signed various trade and investment agreements with Afghanistan. The country has an abundance of natural resources, including copper, iron ore, gold, rare earths, and lapis lazuli, with an estimated worth of $1 trillion.

However, there are challenges and risks associated with foreign investment in the Afghan mining sector. The country faces issues such as poor security, lack of proper legal framework and organisational capacity, and corruption, which have hindered the sector's development. Large-scale resource extraction can also lead to power imbalances, favouring foreign corporations over local communities.

To ensure equitable distribution of profits and minimise negative impacts, it is essential to have strong regulatory frameworks, transparency, and community engagement. The Afghan government has taken steps towards reform, but effective implementation and international support are crucial for the sector's success.

Overall, foreign investment in the Afghan mining sector has the potential to bring economic growth and improve the lives of Afghans. However, addressing the challenges and ensuring responsible and sustainable practices are vital to avoid the "resource curse" and ensure that the benefits reach the local communities.

Frequently asked questions