Austria's Pope: Power Or Puppet?

The Revolutions of 1848 in the Austrian Empire were a series of nationalist uprisings that took place across the multi-ethnic empire, ruled from Vienna. The Pope at the time, Pius IX, was initially considered liberal, but his refusal to go to war with Austria during this period of unrest caused a shift in public opinion. The Pope's power was further diminished by the assassination of his prime minister, Pellegrino Rossi, which forced him to flee Rome.

Pope Pius IX's refusal to declare war on Austria

In the context of the revolutionary fervour sweeping across Europe in 1848, Pius IX's stance was a bold move that ultimately contributed to a shift in his public image. Initially, as a self-proclaimed liberal, he granted a general amnesty to political prisoners, but this backfired as the freed revolutionaries resumed their activities with renewed vigour. Patriotic Italian groups, emboldened by the Pope's initial concessions, began to demand more, including a war of liberation against Catholic Austria, which controlled several northern Italian provinces.

Pius IX, claiming to be above national interests, refused to go to war with Austria, and this decision had a profound impact on his popularity in his native Italy. It was a stark reversal from his earlier liberal reforms, and it complicated his situation further as he faced strong opposition within the Vatican and the Papal States. The Austrian Emperor, too, rejected the Pope's appeal to voluntarily cede the Italian provinces, and this rejection in Vienna added to the mounting tensions.

The appointment of Pellegrino Rossi, a liberal, as the Pope's chief minister for the Papal States, further inflamed the situation. Rossi's subsequent assassination on November 15, 1848, left the Pope a virtual prisoner in the Quirinal Palace, forcing him to concede to a lay ministry that included individuals hostile to the Holy See. Public disorder escalated, with repeated riots, and Pius IX ultimately fled Rome in disguise as a regular priest, escaping to Gaeta in the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies on November 24, 1848.

The Pope's refusal to declare war on Austria thus set in motion a series of events that culminated in his exile and the declaration of the Roman Republic in February 1849. The Roman Republic was openly hostile to the Catholic Church, and the Pope responded by excommunicating all active participants. This period witnessed a breakdown of law and order, with widespread looting, violence, and desecration of religious sites.

Pius IX's refusal to wage war against Austria, therefore, had profound implications, not only for his own position but also for the stability and religious character of the Papal States. It marked a turning point after which the Pope's policies took on a more conservative tone, and it underscored the complex dynamics between the Papacy, revolutionary forces, and the broader European context of the time.

The Pope's escape from Rome

In 1848, Pope Pius IX was faced with a wave of revolutionary movements across Western Europe, including in his native Italy. The Pope, who claimed to be above national interests, refused to go to war with Austria, which was unpopular with his Italian base. This was especially true as Austrian Emperor Ferdinand I rejected the Pope's appeal to voluntarily cede the Italian provinces. The Pope's situation was further complicated by strong opposition to his policies within the Vatican and the Papal States, originating from forces loyal to his opponent in the papal election two years earlier.

On November 15, 1848, the Pope's chief minister, Pellegrino Rossi, was assassinated in a calculated move. In the following days, the Swiss Guards were disarmed, leaving the Pope a prisoner in his Quirinal residence. Pius IX was forced to concede a lay ministry with persons hostile to the Holy See, and a constitution. However, public disorder grew, with repeated riots, and the Pope fled Rome in disguise as a regular priest on November 24, escaping to Gaeta in the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies.

A Roman Republic was declared in February 1849, and the Pope responded by excommunicating all active participants from his exile. The Republic was openly hostile to the Catholic Church, desecrating Saint Peter's Basilica on Easter Sunday with a secular Republican victory celebration. The public finances were spent liberally, leading to an early financial disaster, and palaces, convents, and churches were plundered for valuables and artwork. In addition to the official pillaging, private gangs roamed through the city and the countryside, murdering, raping, stealing, and spreading fear among the citizens of the Papal States.

The Roman Republic

Secret societies in Rome stirred up the common people, demanding a secular, constitutional government for the Papal States. The Pope's chief minister, Pellegrino Rossi, was assassinated on November 15, 1848, and the Pope himself became a prisoner in the Quirinal Palace. He eventually escaped in disguise and fled to Gaeta, where the King of the Two Sicilies offered him refuge.

In February 1849, the Roman Republic was proclaimed, with the aim of establishing an independent Italian nation. It attempted to improve the economic situation of the underserved by giving some of the Church's large landholdings to poor peasants, and it also made prison and asylum reforms and provided for secular education. However, the many reforms, combined with lower taxes, led to monetary problems, and the economy was further strained by the need to send troops to defend Piedmont from Austrian forces.

The Pope's loss of power

The loss of power began with the Revolutions of 1848, which took place across Europe, including the Italian states and the Austrian Empire. These revolutions were driven by nationalist, liberal, and socialist sentiments, seeking to overthrow conservative monarchies and establish independent and unified nation-states.

In the context of the Papal States, the Revolutions of 1848 had a significant impact on the Pope's power. Pope Pius IX, who had initially been considered liberal due to his support for reforms and modernization, faced a backlash from revolutionaries when he refused to go to war with Austria, which claimed northern Italian provinces as its own. This refusal led to a decline in his popularity, especially among Italian patriots who sought to unify Italy and liberate it from foreign rule.

The situation escalated with the assassination of Pellegrino Rossi, Pius IX's prime minister, on November 15, 1848. Rossi, a Liberal who supported constitutional monarchy, was hated by radical liberal republicans. His assassination sparked further unrest, with the Pope becoming a virtual prisoner in his palace, the Quirinal. Pius IX was forced to appoint a Liberal ministry and eventually fled Rome in disguise on November 24, 1848, seeking refuge in Gaeta under the protection of the King of the Two Sicilies.

During this period, a short-lived Roman Republic was proclaimed, which was openly hostile to the Catholic Church. It was suppressed by the French army in 1849, and Pius IX returned to Rome, but his policies became increasingly conservative. He moved his residence from the Quirinal Palace to the Vatican, where popes have lived since.

Despite regaining control of the Papal States, Pius IX's temporal power continued to erode over the following decades. In 1860, Victor Emmanuel II of Sardinia, who had taken the title of King of Italy, seized most of the Papal territories except Latium with Rome. Finally, in 1870, the Kingdom of Italy seized the remaining areas of the Papal States, including Rome, marking the definitive end of the Pope's temporal power.

The Law of Guarantees, instituted by Italy in 1871, granted the Pope the use of the Vatican but denied him sovereignty over this territory. Pius IX officially rejected this offer, refusing to recognize the new Italian kingdom and excommunicating its leaders. This stand-off between the Papacy and the Italian state was only legally resolved in 1929 with the Lateran Treaty, which established the Vatican City State as the sovereign territory of the Holy See.

The Pope's relationship with Austria post-1848

The Revolutions of 1848 in the Austrian Empire were a series of uprisings that took place from March 1848 to November 1849. These revolutions were driven by nationalist, liberal, and socialist sentiments resisting the Empire's longstanding conservatism. The Pope at this time, Pius IX, initially held liberal views and enacted liberal policies, such as opening up the Jewish ghetto in Rome and granting amnesty to political prisoners. However, his refusal to go to war with Austria and his pro-Austrian stance led to a decline in his popularity in his native Italy.

In November 1848, the Pope's prime minister, Pellegrino Rossi, was assassinated, and the Pope himself became a prisoner in his palace. He eventually escaped Rome in disguise and took refuge in Gaeta, under the protection of King Ferdinand II of the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies. A Roman Republic was declared in February 1849, and the Pope responded by excommunicating all participants. The Roman Republic was openly hostile to the Catholic Church, celebrating Good Friday with fireworks and desecrating St. Peter's Basilica on Easter Sunday.

The Roman Republic was suppressed by the French army in 1849, and Pius IX returned to Rome, where he appointed a conservative government of three cardinals known as the Red Triumvirate to administer the Papal States. He also moved his residence from the Quirinal Palace inside Rome to the Vatican, where popes have lived ever since.

The relationship between the Pope and Austria continued to be influenced by nationalist sentiments and the ongoing unification of Italy. In 1859, the Kingdom of Sardinia, led by Victor Emmanuel II, invaded the Papal States and took all the territories except Latium with Rome. In 1866, Austria was defeated by Prussia in the Austro-Prussian War, which further weakened its influence in Italy. Finally, in 1870, the newly unified Kingdom of Italy seized the remaining Papal States, marking the end of the Pope's temporal power.

In summary, the Pope's relationship with Austria post-1848 was complex and shaped by the broader political and social changes occurring in Europe. The Pope's initial liberal policies and refusal to go to war with Austria led to a decline in his popularity and the establishment of the short-lived Roman Republic. The subsequent suppression of the Roman Republic and the ongoing unification of Italy further strained the relationship between the Pope and Austria, ultimately leading to the end of the Pope's temporal power in 1870.

Frequently asked questions