Italy And Austria's Changing Loyalties: Wwi Vs Wwii

Italy has a unique distinction in both World Wars: it switched sides. In World War I, Italy was initially a Central Power allied with Germany and Austria-Hungary, but in 1915, it entered the war as an Allied Power, fighting against Austria. Almost thirty years later, Italy was in a similar situation. Once again, Italy was an ally of Germany and Austria (which had been annexed by Germany) but in 1943, it switched sides again to join the Allies.

Italy's switch in WWI was influenced by the Treaty of London, which promised Italian-speaking territories from Austria-Hungary

The Treaty of London promised Italy the following Italian-speaking territories:

• Trieste
• Southern Tyrol
• Northern Dalmatia
• Trentino
• South Tyrol
• Istria
• Zadar
• Šibenik
• The Julian March
• The city of Vlorë
• The Dodecanese Islands

In May 1915, Italy declared war on Austria-Hungary, fulfilling the first part of the agreement. However, Italy delayed declaring war on Germany for a year, leading to resentment from France and the UK.

At the Paris Peace Conference after the war, the territorial promises made to Italy in the Treaty of London were not fully kept. Italy did receive some Italian-speaking territories, such as Trentino-Alto Adige/Südtirol, the Julian March, and Istria. However, Italy also received territories with significant non-Italian populations, such as Dalmatia, which became a source of resentment and contributed to the rise of Italian nationalism and fascism.

Italy was a member of the Triple Alliance with Germany and Austria-Hungary in WWI

Italy was a member of the Triple Alliance with Germany and Austria-Hungary during World War I. The Triple Alliance was a defensive military pact formed on May 20, 1882, and renewed periodically until it expired in 1915. Each member promised mutual support in the event of an attack by any other great power.

Italy's primary motive for joining the Triple Alliance was to gain support against France, with whom it had rival colonial ambitions in North Africa. The treaty stipulated that Germany and Austria-Hungary would assist Italy if it was attacked by France without provocation, and Italy, in turn, would assist Germany if France attacked.

However, when World War I broke out in July 1914, Italy declared neutrality, considering Austria-Hungary the aggressor. Italy eventually sided with the Triple Entente and declared war on Austria-Hungary in May 1915. This shift in allegiance was influenced by Italy's goal of annexing territories along the frontier with Austria-Hungary to unite Italian-speaking populations with their cultural homeland.

During the interwar period, Italy's relations with Germany and Austria-Hungary evolved differently. Italy's alignment with Germany strengthened, and they signed the Pact of Steel in 1939, formalizing their military alliance. However, Italy and Austria-Hungary did not maintain their alliance after World War I, and they found themselves on opposing sides during World War II.

Italy's switch in WWII was influenced by secret negotiations with the Allies

Italy's switch in allegiance during World War II was influenced by secret negotiations with the Allies.

Italy, led by Benito Mussolini, joined the war as one of the Axis Powers in 1940, with a plan to concentrate Italian forces on a major offensive against the British Empire in Africa and the Middle East. However, Italy's military actions were often heavily influenced by external factors, and its imperial ambitions were only partially met by late 1942, with significant German assistance.

Italy's military campaigns were characterised by a series of disasters, with Italian conscripts fighting far from home for causes they did not believe in. Poor leadership, inadequate equipment, and low morale all contributed to Italy's failures. The Italian military lacked tanks, anti-tank guns, clothing, food, vehicles, and fuel. Italian factories could not produce weapons due to a lack of raw materials, and production was limited due to heavy Allied bombing.

In July 1943, following the Allied invasion of Sicily, Mussolini was deposed and arrested by order of King Victor Emmanuel III. Although the new Italian government, led by General Pietro Badoglio, initially declared it would continue fighting alongside Germany, it secretly negotiated with the Allies to switch sides. On September 3, 1943, Italy signed a secret armistice with the Allies, which was publicly announced on September 8.

The switch in allegiance was influenced by Italy's desire to end a series of military disasters and the growing anti-Fascist sentiment in the country. The Allied invasion of Sicily and Mussolini's arrest had diminished popular support for the war. Additionally, the Italian military was suffering from heavy losses, and Italy's imperial conquests were being contested by insurgencies and Allied military forces.

The secret negotiations with the Allies allowed Italy to officially join the Allied Powers on October 13, 1943, and declare war on its former Axis partner, Germany. Italy's switch in allegiance during World War II was a significant development, influencing the course of the war and contributing to the eventual defeat of the Axis Powers.

Italy's wartime fortunes began to wane after the opening of the Eastern Front

Italy's participation on the Eastern Front began in mid-July 1941, with the arrival of the Italian Expeditionary Corps in Russia (Corpo di Spedizione Italiano in Russia, CSIR). The CSIR, consisting of three divisions, was initially integrated into the 11th German Army and later into the 1st Panzer Army. It participated in the campaign until April 1942, when two additional Italian corps were sent to the front, merging with the CSIR to form the 8th Italian Army, or the Italian Army in Russia (Armata Italiana in Russia, ARMIR).

The 8th Italian Army was deployed to the southern sector of the Eastern Front, in the Don river region. Together with the 2nd Hungarian Army and the 3rd Romanian Army, they were tasked with covering the left flank of the German forces advancing towards Stalingrad. However, rapid reversals at the front changed the course of the battle. After the encirclement of German forces in Stalingrad, a subsequent Soviet offensive overwhelmed the Italian forces, leading to a hasty retreat.

The Italian forces suffered heavy losses during their retreat, with tens of thousands of men falling victim to the harsh winter conditions and Soviet attacks. The Italian 2nd and 35th Army Corps, which were part of the southern deployment of the 8th Army, were forced to withdraw, and six Italian divisions, along with German and Romanian forces, were defeated. The Alpini troops, poorly equipped and lacking supplies, were also overwhelmed by a major Soviet offensive in January 1943, which resulted in their retreat.

The Italian military operations in the Soviet Union officially ended in March 1943, marking a significant blow to Mussolini's power and popularity. The disastrous outcome of the Italian campaign in Russia further weakened Italy's position in the war, contributing to the country's eventual surrender and armistice with the Allies in September 1943.

Italy surrendered to the Allies in September 1943

Italy's surrender to the Allies in September 1943 was the culmination of a series of events that began with the Allied invasion of Sicily in July 1943, which led to the ousting of Benito Mussolini and the fall of the Fascist government. King Victor Emmanuel III appointed Marshal Pietro Badoglio as the new Prime Minister, and he began negotiating Italy's surrender with General Eisenhower.

On September 3, 1943, the Armistice of Cassibile was signed between Italy and the Allies, marking Italy's official surrender. The agreement was kept secret for five days and was made public on September 8. The surrender allowed the Allies to land in southern Italy and begin their advance up the peninsula.

However, the Germans were quick to react, launching Operation Axis to occupy Italy and prevent the Allies from gaining a foothold. As German troops entered Rome, King Victor Emmanuel III, Badoglio, and the royal family fled to southeastern Italy to establish a new anti-fascist government. Italian troops either surrendered or were slaughtered by their former German allies.

The Italian Navy also faced a precarious situation, with the danger of some ships falling into German hands. The battleship Roma, which headed for an Allied-controlled port, was sunk by German bombers, resulting in the loss of over 1,500 crew members.

The surrender of Italy did not signal the end of the war for the country. The Italian Social Republic, led by Mussolini, was established in northern Italy with German support. Italian troops outside Italy, in the occupied Balkans and Greek islands, continued to resist for several weeks but ultimately succumbed to German forces without determined Allied support.

The Allies failed to fully capitalize on Italy's surrender, facing stiff resistance from German troops. The Italian Royal Army and Air Force disintegrated following the announcement of the armistice, and the Allies had to work to gain control of the Italian Navy.

The surrender and its aftermath marked a chaotic and violent period in Italy's history, with the country becoming a battleground between the Allies and German forces. The complex dynamics and shifting allegiances during World War II shaped Italy's role and ultimately contributed to its defeat and occupation.

Frequently asked questions