The Soviet-Afghan War: A Different Outcome?

The Soviet-Afghan War was a conflict between the Soviet Union and the Mujahideen, a group of Afghan resistance fighters, that lasted from 1979 to 1989. The Soviets ultimately withdrew from Afghanistan, but some have speculated that the outcome could have been different if certain conditions had been met. One suggestion is that the Soviets would have needed to commit genocide and significantly reduce Afghanistan's population to win. Others argue that the Soviet Union's initial atrocities cost them popular support, making it impossible to win the war despite their military victories. The Soviet Union's internal political instability, with four presidents during the war, and lack of clear rationale for the war also contributed to their inability to achieve victory. The support provided by the US to the Mujahideen, including stinger missiles, is also seen by some as a crucial factor in the Soviet defeat.

The role of the US in the Soviet-Afghan War

The Soviet-Afghan War was viewed by the United States as an integral Cold War struggle. In July 1979, President Jimmy Carter initiated a covert program through the CIA to financially support the Afghan mujahideen rebels. After the Soviet invasion in December 1979, the CIA expanded the program, code-named Operation Cyclone, and began providing weapons and money to the mujahideen through the Pakistani intelligence services.

Operation Cyclone was one of the longest and most expensive covert CIA operations ever undertaken. More than $20 billion in U.S. funds was funnelled into the country to train and arm Afghan resistance groups. The U.S.-built Stinger antiaircraft missile, supplied to the mujahideen in very large numbers beginning in 1986, struck a decisive blow to the Soviets. The mujahideen were eventually able to neutralise Soviet air power through the use of these shoulder-fired antiaircraft missiles.

The war in Afghanistan became a quagmire for the Soviet Union. Despite having failed to implement a sympathetic regime in Afghanistan, in 1988 the Soviet Union signed an accord with the United States, Pakistan, and Afghanistan and agreed to withdraw its troops. The Soviet withdrawal was completed on February 15, 1989, and Afghanistan returned to non-aligned status.

The impact of Osama Bin Laden's following during the Russian invasion

Osama Bin Laden's following during the Russian invasion of Afghanistan played a significant role in shaping the course of events and had a lasting impact on the region. Here are some key points highlighting the impact of his following during this period:

• Bin Laden's Financial and Logistical Support: Bin Laden provided significant financial and logistical support to the Afghan resistance, also known as the Mujahideen, who were battling the Soviets. He raised funds and provided logistical aid, including weapons and supplies, to the Mujahideen fighters. This support boosted the morale and capabilities of the resistance forces.
• Formation of Al-Qaeda: During the Soviet-Afghan War, Bin Laden established a network of foreign Mujahideen fighters, which later became the foundation for Al-Qaeda. In 1988, after the Soviet withdrawal, Bin Laden founded Al-Qaeda ("the Base") to continue the jihad through violence and aggression. Al-Qaeda began setting up training camps and carrying out attacks worldwide to further its violent agenda.
• Bin Laden's Charismatic Leadership: Bin Laden's charismatic leadership and reputation for piety and bravery in combat attracted a loyal following. He was seen as a war hero by many due to his role in opposing the Soviet occupation. This following enhanced his stature and influence in the region.
• Anti-American Sentiment: Bin Laden's opposition to the US presence in Saudi Arabia and Somalia during the Gulf War fueled anti-American sentiment among his followers. He sought to drive US forces out of these regions and issued fatwas declaring a holy war against the United States. This anti-American stance gained traction among his supporters and contributed to increasing hostility towards the US.
• Impact on US-Soviet Relations: Bin Laden's activities and the rise of Al-Qaeda during the Soviet-Afghan War had broader geopolitical implications. The US supported the Mujahideen and Bin Laden's network during the war, which later backfired as Al-Qaeda turned against the US. This dynamic added complexity to US-Soviet relations and influenced the broader Cold War dynamics.
• Bin Laden's Escape and Continued Threat: Despite the Soviet withdrawal, Bin Laden's influence and activities persisted. He escaped to Pakistan and continued to plot and carry out attacks. This included the 1993 World Trade Center bombing and other terrorist acts, which heightened concerns about his growing network and capabilities.

The possibility of Al-Qaeda forming without US involvement

The formation of Al-Qaeda was a direct response to the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in 1979. Osama bin Laden, a Saudi Arabian, provided the Mujahideen with money, weapons, and fighters. Along with Abdullah Azzam, a Palestinian Sunni Islamic scholar, bin Laden grew a large financial network. When the Soviets withdrew from Afghanistan in 1989, Al-Qaeda was created to take on future holy wars.

Bin Laden was exiled by the Saudi regime and later stripped of his citizenship in 1994. He set up operations in Sudan, with the United States as his primary target. Al-Qaeda was responsible for the attack on the World Trade Center in 1993, and a car bombing in 1995 that destroyed a U.S.-leased military building in Saudi Arabia. In 1996, bin Laden was expelled from Sudan and returned to Afghanistan under the protection of the Taliban, where he provided military training to thousands of Muslim insurgents.

Al-Qaeda's violent opposition to the United States stemmed from its support of "infidel" governments, including those of Israel, Saudi Arabia, and Egypt, along with the United Nations. Additionally, they opposed America's involvement in the 1991 Persian Gulf War and in Somalia's '92-'93 Operation Restore Hope mission.

Al-Qaeda's formation was a direct response to the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan and was further fueled by the United States' presence in the region. Without U.S. involvement in Afghanistan, it is possible that Al-Qaeda would not have formed or would have lacked the anti-American sentiment that characterized the group. However, it is important to note that the roots of Al-Qaeda's ideology extend beyond U.S. involvement in Afghanistan, and the group's targets included other countries and entities beyond the United States.

The impact of the Soviet victory on Islamic fundamentalism

A Soviet victory in Afghanistan would have had a significant impact on Islamic fundamentalism. Firstly, it is important to note that the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in 1979 and the subsequent war with the Mujahideen, who were supported by the US, bolstered Islamic fundamentalism in the region. The conflict galvanised thousands of Muslims worldwide to send aid and, in some cases, travel to Afghanistan to fight for their faith. This pan-Islamic effort was led by Palestinian scholar Abdullah Yusuf Azzam. The eventual withdrawal of Soviet forces in 1989 was seen as a triumph of Islamic faith over superior military power, which could be replicated elsewhere.

A Soviet victory in Afghanistan would have likely had the opposite effect, diminishing the appeal of Islamic fundamentalism. Without a military victory over a superpower, Islamic fundamentalist groups would have struggled to gain legitimacy and prestige within the militant community and among ordinary Muslims. This could have resulted in a decline in the popularity of Islamic fundamentalism and a shift in the dynamics between conservative and fundamentalist Islam.

Furthermore, a Soviet victory would have prevented the emergence of the Taliban and Al-Qaeda, both of which played a significant role in the spread of Islamic fundamentalism. The Taliban, which emerged during the Afghan Civil War that followed the Soviet withdrawal, governed Afghanistan from 1996 to 2001 and imposed a strict interpretation of Islamic law. Al-Qaeda, founded by Osama bin Laden, who fought in the war against the Soviets, carried out numerous terrorist attacks in the name of Islamic fundamentalism, including the 9/11 attacks.

It is worth noting that even with a Soviet victory, Islamic fundamentalism may have still spread due to other factors. For instance, the Iranian Revolution of 1979, which overthrew the pro-Western monarchy, was a significant event that galvanised Islamic fundamentalists worldwide. Additionally, the funding of Islamic revivalist movements and leaders by Saudi Arabia through its oil wealth contributed to the spread of Wahhabism, a conservative branch of Sunni Islam.

The potential for a Soviet victory without US aid to the Mujahideen

The Soviet-Afghan War was a protracted armed conflict fought in the Soviet-controlled Democratic Republic of Afghanistan (DRA) from 1979 to 1989. The war was a significant conflict of the Cold War, with extensive fighting between the DRA, the Soviet Union, and their allied paramilitary groups against the Afghan Mujahideen and their foreign allies. The Mujahideen were backed by various countries, but most of their support came from Pakistan, the United States, the United Kingdom, China, Iran, and the Arab states of the Persian Gulf. The involvement of these foreign powers made the war a proxy conflict between the United States and the Soviet Union.

The Soviet Union's invasion of Afghanistan aimed to support the local pro-Soviet government. However, they faced fierce resistance from Afghan guerrillas and operational challenges due to the country's rugged mountainous terrain. The war resulted in significant casualties and displacement, with approximately 3,000,000 Afghans killed and millions fleeing the country as refugees.

Now, let's explore the potential outcome of the Soviet-Afghan War if the United States had not provided aid to the Mujahideen:

The United States played a crucial role in aiding the Mujahideen during the Soviet-Afghan War. They provided military assistance, particularly in the form of shoulder-fired Stinger missiles, which proved effective in countering Soviet helicopter gunships and inflicting damage on occupying Soviet forces. The absence of this American support would have significantly impacted the Mujahideen's capabilities and altered the dynamics of the conflict.

Without US aid, the Mujahideen would have faced greater challenges in acquiring advanced weaponry and coordinating their efforts effectively. The Stinger missiles were instrumental in levelling the playing field against Soviet airpower, and their absence would have given the Soviets a significant advantage. It is likely that the Mujahideen's ability to inflict casualties and damage on Soviet forces would have diminished without access to these advanced weapons.

Additionally, the United States provided crucial financial and logistical support to the Mujahideen through Operation Cyclone. This support included funding, training, and the supply of non-military equipment such as medical supplies and radio transmitters. Without this backing, the Mujahideen may have struggled to sustain their resistance over an extended period, potentially leading to a decline in their morale and combat effectiveness.

Moreover, the United States played a pivotal role in rallying international support for the Mujahideen. They worked closely with Pakistan, coordinating efforts to assist the Mujahideen and exert pressure on the Soviet Union. Without US involvement, the dynamics of the conflict would have shifted, and the Mujahideen may have found themselves at a disadvantage in terms of resources and international backing.

However, it is essential to consider that the Mujahideen also received support from other sources, including Pakistan, China, Iran, and several Arab states. While the loss of US aid would have been a significant blow, these other backers could have potentially stepped up their assistance to fill at least part of the gap.

In conclusion, while the absence of US aid would have undoubtedly impacted the Mujahideen's capabilities, it is challenging to determine the exact outcome of the Soviet-Afghan War in this scenario. The conflict was complex, with multiple actors and variables at play. However, it is reasonable to assume that the Mujahideen would have faced greater challenges and that the Soviet Union may have been able to exert more control over Afghanistan's cities and key strategic areas.

Frequently asked questions