Foreign Aid In Afghanistan: A Lifeline For A Nation In Turmoil

Foreign aid to Afghanistan has had a mixed impact on the country. On the one hand, it has helped to improve access to education and healthcare, construct infrastructure, and promote governance reforms. For example, foreign aid contributed to a significant increase in school enrolment, with the number of students rising from 900,000 in 2001 to over 9.5 million in 2020, and the construction of thousands of miles of roads and other infrastructure projects. It also helped to increase access to healthcare and raise life expectancy. Additionally, foreign aid supported governance reforms, including the adoption of a new constitution and the holding of elections.

However, there have also been drawbacks and criticisms of foreign aid in Afghanistan. One major issue is the mismanagement of aid and systemic corruption, with concerns that aid money has been misappropriated by corrupt officials, warlords, criminals, and insurgents. The centralised governance system in Afghanistan has been criticised for giving the president too much power over planning, budgeting, and taxation, without sufficient checks and balances. This has contributed to the ineffective use of aid funds and a lack of accountability. There are also concerns that foreign aid has created a culture of dependency, with the Afghan economy heavily reliant on aid, and local industries and agriculture suffering as a result.

Foreign aid has helped enrol far more students in school, including girls

The number of female students in Afghanistan has also increased significantly. There were no female college students in 2001, but there were 54,861 in 2019. The share of girls among all students reached 39% in 2020, up from an estimated 5,000 in 2001.

Foreign aid has also helped improve access to education for girls and women in Afghanistan. For example, the Partnership for Advancing Community-Based Education (PACE-A) is a $31 million program that has helped expand access to primary education classes for more than 84,000 children, over 63% of whom are girls. The program involves four prominent international NGOs—CARE International, Catholic Relief Services, International Rescue Committee, and the Aga Khan Foundation—who have experience providing education in areas not served by the Ministry of Education.

However, it is important to note that the progress made in education through foreign aid is at risk due to the Taliban's restrictions on girls' education. For instance, despite requests from the Ministry of Education for a longer extension, USAID is granting a no-cost, 3-month extension for the PACE-A program. Turning this program over to the Ministry of Education prematurely could end access to education for many students, particularly girls, and jeopardize the relationships built in these communities with village mullahs that defied the Taliban to allow their girls to attend school.

It has contributed to the construction of thousands of miles of roads and streets

Foreign aid to Afghanistan has contributed to the construction of thousands of miles of roads and streets. Billions of dollars in aid have been spent on infrastructure projects, including the construction and rehabilitation of roads and streets. This has helped to improve transportation and connectivity within the country.

The United States, in particular, has provided significant support for infrastructure development in Afghanistan. The Afghanistan Security Forces Fund (ASFF) and the Train and Equip Fund, managed by the U.S. Department of Defense, have provided funding for facility and infrastructure repair, renovation, and construction. This includes the construction of roads and streets to improve transportation and connectivity for security forces and the local population.

Other international donors, such as Germany, the United Kingdom, and other NATO allies, have also contributed to infrastructure development in Afghanistan. Their aid has supported various construction projects, including roads and streets, to enhance transportation networks and connectivity within the country.

The impact of these infrastructure projects has been significant. They have improved mobility and accessibility for Afghans, facilitating trade, commerce, and the movement of people. These road and street construction projects have connected previously isolated communities, promoting economic development and social cohesion.

However, there have also been challenges and limitations. The construction of roads and streets in Afghanistan has faced issues related to security, terrain, and the capacity of local contractors. The ongoing conflict and instability in the country have hindered construction efforts, and the difficult terrain has posed technical challenges. Additionally, there have been concerns about the capacity and oversight of local contractors involved in road and street construction projects.

Despite these challenges, the construction of thousands of miles of roads and streets through foreign aid has had a positive impact on Afghanistan's transportation network and connectivity. It has facilitated the movement of people and goods, supported economic activities, and connected previously isolated communities.

Foreign aid has helped increase access to healthcare for most of the population

The number of students enrolled in schools increased from 900,000 in 2001 to over 9.5 million in 2020, with the number of universities also increasing. There were no female college students in 2001, but there were 54,861 in 2019. The share of girls among all students reached 39% in 2020, compared to an estimated 5,000 in 2001.

Foreign aid has also helped to construct and pave thousands of miles of roads and streets, as well as other infrastructure projects such as hydroelectric dams and solar power plants to generate electricity, bridges, and irrigation and drinking water projects.

In the area of healthcare, life expectancy in Afghanistan rose by about a decade between 2001 and 2019, to 64.8 years. The Basic Package of Health Services (BPHS), established in 2003, has helped to unify the country's health system, improve coordination between the Afghan government, donors, and NGOs, and increase the percentage of the population with access to primary healthcare. National coverage rates have risen from an estimated 9% in 2003 to 85% in 2008, and under-5 mortality rates have dropped by 26% since 2002.

However, it is important to note that there are also drawbacks to foreign aid. Afghanistan's highly centralised governance system gave its president unconstrained political, fiscal, and administrative power, without any way for the legislature or the public to hold the executive branch to account. This lack of checks and balances contributed to systemic corruption, with one interviewee estimating that 40% of US aid to Afghanistan since 2001 ended up in the pockets of corrupt officials, warlords, criminals, and insurgents.

It has supported governance reforms, including the adoption of a new constitution

Foreign aid has supported governance reforms in Afghanistan, including the adoption of a new constitution. Here is a detailed overview of how foreign aid has supported governance reforms in Afghanistan:

The New Constitution

The constitution of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan, approved on January 4, 2004, establishes a nation that pledges to be both Islamic and democratic. It creates a presidential system that roughly follows the US model, dividing government power among executive, legislative, and judicial branches. The constitution does not include an explicit reference to Sharia or Islamic law, but it states that no Afghan law can contradict the beliefs and provisions of Islam.

Governance Reforms

The new constitution established a framework for liberal democratic governance and the protection of human rights. It held four presidential and provincial council elections and three parliamentary elections. Afghanistan also adopted hundreds of new laws and regulations regarding education, health, insurance, budgeting, mining, women's rights, and land titling.

The Role of Foreign Aid

Foreign aid has played a crucial role in supporting governance reforms in Afghanistan. Between 2001 and 2020, Afghanistan received approximately US$150 billion in non-military aid from the US alone, in addition to billions more from its allies and international organizations. This aid has been instrumental in funding education, healthcare, governance reforms, and infrastructure development.

Challenges and Shortcomings

While foreign aid has made significant contributions, there have also been challenges and shortcomings. One major issue has been the centralized governance system, which gave the president unconstrained political, fiscal, and administrative power without adequate checks and balances. This lack of accountability contributed to systemic corruption, with aid money often ending up in the pockets of corrupt officials, warlords, criminals, and insurgents.

Additionally, foreign aid programs aimed at improving governance often failed to address the underlying political issues and instead focused on technical solutions. They also tended to emphasize skills relevant to being a good aid recipient rather than navigating the complex local political landscape.

Moving Forward

To address these challenges, it is crucial to incorporate lessons learned and adopt a more nuanced approach to foreign aid. This includes recognizing the limitations of foreign intervention, focusing on sustainable solutions, and empowering local communities. By addressing these issues, foreign aid can play a more effective role in supporting governance reforms and promoting long-term stability in Afghanistan.

Foreign aid has contributed to the construction of hydroelectric dams and solar power plants

This aid was used to fund education, healthcare, governance reforms, and infrastructure projects. In terms of infrastructure, foreign aid helped construct and pave thousands of miles of roads and streets, as well as hydroelectric dams and solar power plants to generate electricity.

The construction of hydroelectric dams and solar power plants in Afghanistan was made possible through the financial support and expertise provided by foreign aid. These projects have helped to improve access to electricity in the country and contributed to the overall development of Afghanistan's infrastructure.

The US, in particular, played a significant role in providing military and economic aid to Afghanistan over the years. The US devoted substantial financial resources to reconstruction activities and strengthening the Afghan National Defence and Security Forces (ANDSF). The Afghanistan Security Forces Fund (ASFF), created by the US Congress, provided the ANDSF with equipment, supplies, services, training, funding for salaries, and facility and infrastructure repair, renovation, and construction.

While the exact breakdown of how much aid was allocated specifically for the construction of hydroelectric dams and solar power plants is not publicly available, it is clear that foreign aid played a crucial role in these infrastructure developments in Afghanistan.

Frequently asked questions