The Afghanistan And Vietnam Wars: A Study In Historical Parallels And Strategic Lessons

The Vietnam War and the War in Afghanistan are two of the longest wars in American history. Despite their differences, there are some similarities between the two conflicts, and experts have drawn comparisons between them. Both wars involved the United States waging a counterinsurgency campaign and supporting a local government. In both wars, American forces teamed up with local troops, but often did not trust them. The enemy in both wars could disappear quickly and did not wear uniforms, making them hard to distinguish from the local population. Additionally, both wars involved fighting in underground structures, and the rapid outdatedness of maps. However, it is important to recognise the differences between the two wars as well, including the unique geopolitical contexts, operational environments, and ideological motivations.

The Vietnam and Afghanistan wars were America's longest wars

The Vietnam War (1955–1975) and the War in Afghanistan (2001–2021) were two of America's longest wars. The Vietnam War was a conflict in Vietnam, Laos, and Cambodia, which was also a part of the Cold War. It was fought between North Vietnam, backed by the Soviet Union and China, and South Vietnam, supported by the United States and other anti-communist allies. The war resulted in more than 3 million deaths, including over 58,000 Americans, and a significant number of refugees and wounded civilians.

The War in Afghanistan was a response to the September 11 attacks, led by the United States, and aimed to address the threat posed by the Taliban and its allies. The conflict ended with the Taliban's return to power in 2021. This war also had a significant impact, with 2.6 million Afghans becoming refugees and 4 million being internally displaced.

Both wars had far-reaching consequences and were marked by complex ideological and strategic environments. The Vietnam War was a civil war between two rival nationalist visions, while the War in Afghanistan was an international counterterrorism operation mixed up in a tribal civil war. Despite their differences, there are some parallels that can be drawn between the two conflicts. In both cases, the United States intervened in an ongoing civil war due to concerns related to American security interests. Additionally, the United States supported the weaker protagonist in each conflict, such as the South Vietnamese government in Vietnam and the anti-Taliban resistance forces in Afghanistan.

The Vietnam War and the War in Afghanistan are among the longest and most significant conflicts in American history, with lasting impacts on the regions and the world. The similarities and differences between the two wars offer important lessons and insights into the complexities of international relations and warfare.

Both wars were fought in different strategic environments

While there are some similarities between the Afghanistan and Vietnam wars, the two conflicts were fought in notably different strategic environments.

The Vietnam War was a proxy war between two superpowers—the United States and the Soviet Union—overlaid on top of a national liberation movement. The North Vietnamese had the resources and public support of the Soviet Union and China, and the risk of escalation was very real. In contrast, the conflict in Afghanistan was an international counterterrorism operation mixed up in a tribal civil war. The US intervention in Vietnam was unilateral and lacked broad international legitimacy.

In terms of scale, the Afghanistan War was a minor conflict compared to Vietnam. Taliban fighters numbered in the tens of thousands, while the US military deployment was only one-fifth the size of the deployment in Vietnam. About 3,500 coalition troops perished in Afghanistan, a relatively small figure compared to other major wars in US history. From December 2014 until the evacuation from Kabul, just seventy-nine US service members were killed in action; fewer troops were lost over the final six-and-a-half years in Afghanistan than in Vietnam in 1968 alone.

The security environment in Afghanistan is also notably different from that of Vietnam. While urban areas in Afghanistan remain secure, the security situation in rural areas is deteriorating, with a growing Taliban threat. The political situation at the national level is poor but relatively stable, although pervasive corruption in governmental institutions continues to impact the regime's effectiveness and legitimacy. Economic conditions are challenging, with growth rates contracting due to reduced foreign troop levels, and are unlikely to improve substantially or rapidly.

The Vietnam War, on the other hand, involved a different set of strategic considerations. The US employed a strategy that aimed to drive peasants into the cities, depriving the National Liberation Front of a population and food base, and safe jungle havens. This process was labelled "forced-draft urbanization" and resulted in massive destruction and environmental damage.

Both wars were fought in different ideological environments

The Vietnam War and the War in Afghanistan were fought in different ideological environments. The Vietnam War was a civil war between two rival nationalist visions (a communist version and a nationalist version), both seeking unity and independence. The North Vietnamese fought with the fervor of a people seeking unity and independence. Both claims were marred by autocracy. The communists' claim was also marred by their brutality, while the South Vietnamese’s claim was marred by their corruption.

On the other hand, the Taliban was a minority sect that was unpopular and scarcely perceived as legitimate, even when it governed Afghanistan, due to the group's extremism and incompetence. It advocated Deobandi Islamism—which differs from the Hanafi school of Islam prevalent across Afghanistan—persecuted and excluded all non-Pashtun ethnic groups, and presided over the complete collapse of most state institutions. The various anti-Taliban factions, parties, and militias included almost all of Afghanistan’s major ethnic, religious, and regional groups, including Pashtuns and political Islamist groups. The government in Kabul had a much stronger claim to legitimacy and broad-based representation than did the military government in Saigon.

The Vietnam War was fought between two monolithic enemies, whereas the War in Afghanistan was fought between a complex network of networks. In Vietnam, the enemy was monolithic; the United States fought against the North Vietnamese Army (NVA) and the Viet Cong (VC), who were fighting for Vietnam. However, the United States obtusely insisted on casting the war as a fight against the spread of communism. In Afghanistan, the enemy was a complex network of networks, and the United States misread the fundamental narrative of the enemy they were fighting, determined to wage a secular campaign against an enemy who was fighting a religious war.

Both wars were fought in different tactical environments

The Vietnam War and the Afghanistan War were fought in different tactical environments.

Vietnam War

The Vietnam War was fought between 1955 and 1975. The conflict was between the communist North Vietnam, backed by the Soviet Union and China, and South Vietnam, backed by the United States. The war was a proxy war between the two superpowers, the United States and the Soviet Union, and was part of the Cold War.

The Vietnam War was a guerrilla war, with the Viet Cong, the military branch of the National Liberation Front, using guerrilla tactics such as ambushes and surprise attacks. The Viet Cong were highly mobile and used the Ho Chi Minh Trail to keep their forces supplied. They also had a hidden system of tunnels stretching over 200 miles, which could hide thousands of Viet Cong.

The Viet Cong were supported by the North Vietnamese Army (NVA), which was a conventional army with tanks, artillery, and air power. The NVA would sometimes fight directly with their opponents, using conventional tactics.

Afghanistan War

The Afghanistan War was fought between 2001 and 2021. The conflict was between the Taliban, an Islamic fundamentalist political movement and military organisation, and the United States, backed by NATO. The war was part of the War on Terror, which was the US response to the 9/11 terrorist attacks.

The Afghanistan War was a counterinsurgency, with the Taliban using guerrilla tactics such as ambushes and surprise attacks. The Taliban were highly mobile and used the mountainous terrain to their advantage. They also had a decentralised command structure, with local Taliban commanders having a lot of autonomy.

The US and NATO forces had air superiority and used a combination of conventional warfare and counterinsurgency tactics. They also had superior technology, such as drones and night-vision goggles.

Both wars had different impacts on US society, culture and politics

The Vietnam War and the War in Afghanistan had vastly different impacts on US society, culture, and politics.

US Politics

The Vietnam War had a profound impact on US politics, polarising the country and weakening the Democratic Party. The war also undermined liberal reform and made Americans deeply suspicious of the government. It inspired Congress to attack the "imperial" presidency through the War Powers Act, restricting a president's ability to send American forces into combat without explicit Congressional approval.

The War in Afghanistan, on the other hand, did not have a significant impact on the Democratic Party or liberal reform. However, it did contribute to a sense of malaise throughout the country, with America appearing to lack confidence and a moral centre. The war also strained US relations with Pakistan, with the US accusing Pakistan of supporting and providing safe havens for the Taliban.

US Society

The Vietnam War exposed deep cleavages within American society, with protests and counterculture movements gaining momentum. The war also resulted in a loss of confidence in American military abilities, as the US was unable to defeat the Viet Cong.

The War in Afghanistan, meanwhile, led to the displacement of millions of Afghans, with 2.6 million remaining refugees by 2021. The war also resulted in increased tribalism and factionalism in Afghanistan, with the Taliban imposing their fundamentalist interpretation of Islam.

US Culture

The Vietnam War had a significant impact on US culture, with Americans becoming more cynical and less trusting of authority. The war also changed how the media covered conflicts, with greater government censorship and more investigative journalism.

The War in Afghanistan, on the other hand, did not have a significant impact on US culture. However, it did result in increased awareness of the issues facing veterans, with organisations like the Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction (SIGAR) working to improve the treatment of veterans.

Frequently asked questions