Belarus' Future: Surviving Without Russian Financial Support?

Belarus has long been dependent on Russia for financial support, with Moscow propping up its Soviet-era economy through discounted energy exports, loans, and preferential market access. However, the relationship has become strained due to Belarus's support for Russia's war against Ukraine, and the subsequent sanctions imposed on Belarus by the EU, UK, US, and Canada. While Russia has not cut off all assistance, it has also not been generous in its aid, and Belarus is now more dependent on its eastern neighbor. The question of whether Belarus can survive without Russian subsidies is a complex one, and it remains to be seen if the country can wean itself off Russian support and chart an independent path forward.

The impact of Belarus's dependence on the Russian market

Belarus' dependence on the Russian market has had a significant impact on the country's economy and political landscape. The country has been described as having a "Soviet-era economy," with a strong state-owned industrial and agricultural sector inherited from the USSR. This has resulted in a low poverty rate of less than 1% between 2000 and 2013, compared to a European average of 14%.

However, this economic model is outdated and inefficient, with stagnant economic growth. Belarus' economy is highly dependent on Russian energy subsidies, preferential market access, and cheap loans. More than 46% of Belarusian goods are exported to Russia, which is also its main import partner. Russia holds almost 38% of Belarus' national debt and has offered to bolster security to quell public anger during protests.

The energy sector is a key aspect of this relationship, with Belarus importing Russian crude oil and gas at below-market prices for refinement and resale. Russia has used this energy subsidy as a bargaining chip, phasing it out slowly to force Belarus into a deeper political and economic union. The loss of these subsidies would be a significant blow to Belarus, impacting its annual oil export revenues by $13 billion.

Russia has also provided cheap loans to Belarus, such as a $10 billion loan for the construction of a nuclear power plant in 2011. Additionally, certain sectors of the Belarusian economy, particularly food and engineering, enjoy preferential treatment in the Russian market, which has guaranteed their survival.

The impact of this dependence goes beyond economics. Belarus' support for Russia's war against Ukraine has resulted in tougher sanctions, affecting about 70% of its exports to the EU. Belarus has also faced challenges in maintaining a multi-vector foreign policy, as its dependence on Russia has limited its ability to normalize and deepen relations with the West.

The growing trade between Minsk and Moscow has alleviated Belarus' short-term economic difficulties but has also made it more dependent on Russia in the long term, ceding its economic sovereignty. Belarus' exports to Russia grew by 40% in 2022, but this was likely due to high prices rather than increased trade volumes.

In summary, Belarus' dependence on the Russian market has had a significant impact on its economy, with Russia providing energy subsidies, cheap loans, and preferential market access. This dependence has also influenced Belarus' foreign policy and made it vulnerable to Russia's geopolitical goals, ultimately impacting its sovereignty.

The role of energy subsidies

Belarus has a diversified industrial profile and has achieved solid economic growth through manufacturing and exports. However, it has a modest natural resource base and relies on imports from Russia to meet most of its energy needs. The country is one of the world's least energy-sufficient countries and is very dependent on its neighbour.

The energy sector in Belarus is dominated by state-owned companies, with the government believing that having control over the entire sector will guarantee a secure and stable energy supply. The country's energy policy focuses on providing reliable energy while reducing import dependence, particularly on natural gas from a single supplier.

To achieve this, the government is considering investment measures and fuel diversification to reduce natural gas consumption and include more coal and renewables in the country's energy mix. Belarus is also developing local energy sources and introducing nuclear power.

At the same time, Belarus is phasing out subsidies for electricity, heat, and gas, which is expected to make the energy sector more market-focused and attractive for private investment. According to the World Bank, the country's economy is set to contract due to the temporary oil blockade and the coronavirus pandemic.

Russia has supported Belarus for decades, and the two countries have a lopsided relationship. Russia has been subsidising its neighbour for years, and this support has kept the Belarusian economy afloat. The most obvious subsidy occurs within Belarus' energy sector, which receives cheap Russian gas and has tariffs waived on oil destined for its refineries.

Russia has also granted Belarus special access to its market, with certain sectors of the Belarusian economy enjoying preferential treatment. Cross-border smuggling has also played a role in supporting the Belarusian economy, with certain EU goods being relabelled and smuggled into Russia to evade sanctions.

In summary, the role of energy subsidies in Belarus has been significant, with Russian support keeping the country's economy going. However, Belarus is now facing the challenge of reducing its dependence on Russian energy and subsidies while also trying to attract more private investment in the energy sector.

The effect of sanctions on Belarus's economy

In 2021, the European Union, the United Kingdom, the United States, and Canada imposed severe financial and trade sanctions on Belarus. These sanctions, along with the country's political crisis, have had a significant impact on the Belarusian economy, which is heavily dependent on Russia.

Belarus has been described as having the last Soviet-era economy, with a strong state-owned industrial and agriculture sector inherited from the USSR. This economic model has kept income inequality low but has led to slow economic growth due to archaic state-run industries. The country's biggest political crisis in 2020 further threatened its economic stability.

The sanctions have targeted key sectors of the Belarusian economy, including its energy sector, which receives cheap Russian gas and oil. Russia has also been a major market for Belarusian exports, accounting for about half of its trade. The loss of this market due to sanctions has dealt a severe blow to Belarus, as it has had to find alternative markets for its goods and services.

The Belarusian economy has also been affected by the country's increased isolation from the West. The opposition has called for Belarus to withdraw from the Eurasian Economic Union, a single market with Russia and other ex-Soviet states, which the Minsk government insists would lead to economic calamity. The dynamic tech sector in the capital, Minsk, has also been impacted, with many startups choosing to relocate to more favourable locations.

The sanctions have also disrupted the country's financial system, with the Belarusian rouble falling significantly against major currencies. There are concerns about financial turmoil as deposits have been flowing out of the country, and long-term walkouts from large factories could be detrimental to the economy.

To cope with the sanctions, Belarus has turned to Russia for support. Moscow has provided loans, agreed on low gas prices, and deferred debt payments. However, this assistance has come at a cost, with Belarus becoming more dependent on Russia and ceding its economic sovereignty. The growing trade between the two countries has alleviated Belarus's current economic difficulties but has increased its long-term dependence on its eastern neighbour.

Overall, the sanctions have had a significant negative impact on the Belarusian economy, disrupting its key sectors, markets, and financial system. The country has turned to Russia for support, but this has led to increased economic dependence and a loss of economic sovereignty.

The importance of import substitution

One of the main advantages of import substitution is the protection and incubation of domestic industries, particularly in emerging economies. By restricting imports, there is increased demand for local products, which generates investment opportunities within domestic boundaries. This leads to the formation and growth of new industries, potentially reducing unemployment and improving livelihoods. In the case of Belarus, import substitution could be a way to reduce dependence on Russian imports and develop self-sufficiency.

Additionally, import substitution can help countries like Belarus protect infant industries from competing with well-established international companies. This incubation period allows local industries to grow and become more competitive in the international market, reducing the risk of collapse. It also reduces the cost of transportation by focusing on developing local products.

However, there are also potential disadvantages to import substitution. Lack of external competition can affect the efficiency of domestic industries, leading to reduced total output and growth rates. It may also lead to the development of black markets and financial leakages, reducing government revenue. Trade protectionism may result in overvalued exchange rates, causing a rise in domestic prices and inflation.

In the case of Belarus, the loss of Russian subsidies and preferential access to the Russian market due to the war in Ukraine has had a significant impact on its economy. Industries such as oil refineries, fertilizers, and gas have lost vital rents and incomes, and the country now faces challenges in accessing the Russian market due to its independent status.

Overall, while import substitution can be a mechanism to reduce Belarus's dependence on Russia, it also carries risks that could further destabilize its economy. The country's leadership will need to carefully navigate these challenges to ensure the survival and long-term economic growth of the nation.

The potential consequences of Belarus's support for Russia's war against Ukraine

Belarus's support for Russia's war against Ukraine has had significant consequences for the country, impacting its economy, political relations, and domestic stability. Here are some key potential consequences:

• Economic Fallout: Belarus has long relied on Russian energy subsidies, preferential market access, and financial support. However, its involvement in the war has led to sanctions from Western countries, including the EU, US, UK, Canada, and Japan. These sanctions have targeted Belarusian banks, central bank ties, and exports, dealing a significant blow to the country's economy.
• Deterioration of Ukraine-Belarus Relations: Ukraine has divested from strategically important Belarusian imports, particularly petroleum products. As a result, bilateral trade between the two countries has plummeted, highlighting the collapse of economic cooperation. Political relations have also degraded to their lowest point, with minimal communication and the recall of ambassadors.
• Domestic Political Challenges: The war has exacerbated domestic political tensions in Belarus. Protests against the government's involvement in the conflict have taken place across the country, and opposition figures have condemned President Alexander Lukashenko for his role in the invasion. There is growing discontent and ambivalence among Belarusians about their country's deepening relationship with Russia.
• Loss of Independence: Belarus's dependence on Russia has increased due to the war. The country has become a crucial supplier of military hardware and components to Russia and has allowed the stationing of Russian nuclear weapons on its territory. This loss of independence has left Belarus vulnerable to further Russian influence and potential annexation.
• Security Threats: Belarus has become a target of Ukrainian countermeasures due to its support for Russia. Ukraine has closed border checkpoints, and there have been reports of Ukrainian attacks on Belarusian settlements and military installations. Belarus's involvement in the war has also led to the presence of Russian soldiers and weaponry on its territory, creating security concerns for its citizens.
• Humanitarian Concerns: There are reports of Belarusian involvement in forced transfers of Ukrainian children to Belarus, with the UN estimating that at least 2,100 Ukrainian children have been deported and held in recreational camps. This has raised concerns about potential re-education efforts and violations of international humanitarian law.

Frequently asked questions