Exploring Border Control: Italy-Austria Border's Unique Scenario

The Austria-Italy border is a 404km (251 mi) land border along the Alps between the Republic of Italy and the Republic of Austria. In recent years, the border has been a point of contention between the two countries due to Austria's concerns about migration from Italy. In 2016, Austria announced its intention to introduce border checks at the Brenner Pass, the busiest route through the Alps, in response to the expected arrival of hundreds of thousands of migrants in Italy. This led to condemnation from Rome and expressions of concern from the European Commission. The border has also been the subject of cooperation between the two countries, with a cross-border programme aiming to increase economic competitiveness and address inequalities. The border is unique as the first mobile border in the world, recognised as such by the 1994 border treaty signed in Vienna, which states that it can move as a result of environmental changes.

Border checks at Brenner Pass

The Brenner Pass is a mountain pass over the Alps that forms the border between Italy and Austria. The pass is a busy route through the Alps, accommodating motorway traffic, railway tracks, and pedestrians.

In 1995, the Schengen Agreement came into force in Austria, and Italy ratified the treaty later that year. As a result, border checks were abolished, and the border barrier between Italy and Austria at Brenner was officially abolished. However, Austria reintroduced border checks in 2015 in response to the European migrant crisis. In 2016, Austria announced it would build a 370-metre-long fence at the pass, clarifying that it would be used to "channel" people rather than acting as a barrier.

In 2018, Austria and Italy carried out random checks at the border, including at the motorway and train station at Brenner. Officers slowed vehicles to a maximum speed of 30 kilometres per hour on the highway and 10 kilometres per hour in the town centre, rarely stopping cars, and usually only small trucks or vans. These checks were reportedly to ensure the security of EU interior ministers in Innsbruck, but they were probably a test run for finding migrants.

In 2024, Austria planned to introduce temporary border controls at selected crossings on the border with Germany and Italy in July and September. These measures were scheduled much earlier to improve security during the Austrian presidency of the Council of the EU.

Austria-Italy border treaty

The Austria-Italy border treaty, known as the Treaty of Saint-Germain-en-Laye, was signed in 1919 and established the border between the two countries. The border is a 404km (251mi) land border along the Alps, with the current demarcation in place since 1919. The border begins in the west at the 'Dreilanderpunkt' tripoint, where the borders of Austria, Italy, and Switzerland meet, and follows the ridgeline of the Carnic Alps mountain range. The border also plays a role in water allocation between the Inn and Adige rivers.

The history of this border is quite fascinating. While a border between Austria and Italy has existed since 1861, the current iteration only came into being in 1920 after the peace treaty between the Kingdom of Italy and the Austrian Republic. This treaty resulted in a significant change to the border, with South Tyrol becoming a part of Italy instead of Austria. The border has undergone minor changes since, with the last modification occurring in 1947. Since 1995, it has been an EU internal border.

The Austria-Italy border is also notable for being the world's first recognised 'mobile border', as stipulated in the 1994 border treaty signed in Vienna. This means that the border can shift due to environmental changes, but only after a diplomatic agreement between the two countries.

In recent years, the border has been the subject of discussion regarding potential border checks. In 2016, Austria considered introducing border checks at the Brenner Pass, the busiest route through the Alps, due to concerns about the northward flow of migrants. These checks could have impacted the local economy, particularly the tourism and trucking industries. However, it is unclear what the current status of these potential border checks is.

Border controls and migration

The Austria-Italy border is a 404km (251-mile) land border along the Alps between the Republic of Italy and the Republic of Austria. The border has existed since 1861, but the current demarcation has been in place since 1919 and the Treaty of Saint-Germain-en-Laye. The border was last changed in 1947 when South Tyrol was made part of Italy instead of Austria.

In recent years, the issue of border controls and migration has become a contentious topic between the two countries. In 2017, Austria threatened to send troops to the border to stop migrants from entering, causing outrage in Italy. However, Austria has since sought to de-escalate the situation, stating that there is "no need to employ temporary border controls" with Italy.

Despite this, the issue of migration continues to be a challenge for both countries. With Italy bearing the brunt of migrant arrivals from across the Mediterranean, the country has pleaded for help from other European Union nations, stating that it is struggling to cope. In 2024, Austria announced that it would begin conducting checks at the border with Italy, specifically at the Brenner Pass, a busy route through the Alps. These checks are in response to the expected arrival of hundreds of thousands of migrants in Italy from Africa.

The potential impact of border controls on the local economy, particularly tourism and trade, has been a significant concern for the region. However, Austria has pledged to keep disruptions to a minimum, and some believe that the measures may not have severe consequences. The situation highlights the complexities of managing migration and border controls within the European Union, and the need for a common European solution to the ongoing migrant crisis.

Border demarcation

The Austria-Italy border is a 404km (251mi) land border along the Alps between the Republic of Italy and the Republic of Austria. The border begins in the west at the 'Dreilanderpunkt' tripoint, where the borders of Austria, Italy, and Switzerland meet. From there, the demarcation of the border follows the ridgeline of the Carnic Alps mountain range, marking the water allocation between the Inn and Adige watercourses. The border ends at Monte Forno, the summit marking the tripoint between Austria, Italy, and Slovenia.

The border has existed since 1861, but its current demarcation has only been in place since 1919, following the Treaty of Saint-Germain-en-Laye, with a large change in 1920 when South Tyrol was made part of Italy instead of Austria. The border was last changed in 1947.

The Austria-Italy border is unique as it is the world's first recognised "mobile border," according to the border treaty signed in Vienna in 1994. This means that the border may shift due to environmental changes, but any shifts must be confirmed through diplomatic agreements between the two countries.

Cross-border cooperation

The Austria–Italy border is a 404 km (251 mi) land border along the Alps between the Republic of Italy and the Republic of Austria. The border has existed since 1861, but the current demarcation has been in place only since 1920, when the peace treaty between the Kingdom of Italy and the Austrian Republic was signed. The border was last changed in 1947 when South Tyrol was made part of Italy instead of Austria.

The border between Italy and Austria is of significant economic importance to the region. Located in northern Italy, the level of employment in this area is 10% higher compared to the rest of Italy. In contrast, the employment rate is slightly lower in this region compared to the rest of Austria.

The objectives of the cross-border cooperation programme between the two countries (2007-2013) aimed to increase economic competitiveness while addressing the growth of existing inequalities on both sides of the border. This involved the diversification of activities and innovation, allowing cross-border workers to increase their capacity for adaptation.

The territory also owes its attractiveness to its biodiversity and pleasant environment. The Interreg programme supports hazard prevention and the development of renewable energy in the region. Furthermore, it recommends reducing administrative obstacles to increase exchanges within this region, which is already united by its landscape.

The Austrian province of Tyrol and the Italian province of Bolzano/Bozen (or 'South Tyrol' in English) are involved in more advanced cooperation. Despite the natural obstacles, they maintain numerous exchanges in the artistic and cultural fields, notably within the Tyrol–South Tyrol–Trentino Euroregion.

In recent years, there have been tensions between Italy and Austria regarding border controls and the movement of migrants. In 2017, Austria threatened to send troops to the border to stop migrants from entering, causing outrage in Rome. More recently, in 2024, Austria announced it would conduct border checks at the Brenner Pass, the busiest route through the Alps, in response to the expected arrival of hundreds of thousands of migrants crossing the Mediterranean to Italy from Africa. These developments have highlighted the sensitive nature of the border issue between the two countries and the ongoing challenges in managing migration flows.

Frequently asked questions