Understanding The Taliban's Insurgency In Afghanistan: A Complex Dynamic

The Taliban is a predominantly Pashtun, Islamic fundamentalist group that returned to power in Afghanistan in 2021 after waging a twenty-year insurgency. The Taliban insurgency began after the group's fall from power during the 2001 War in Afghanistan. The Taliban forces fought against the Afghan government, led by President Hamid Karzai, and later by President Ashraf Ghani, and against a US-led coalition of forces that included all members of NATO.

The Taliban's first rule in Afghanistan lasted from 1996 until October 2001, when they were routed from power by the US-led campaign against al-Qa'ida. The Taliban provided a safe haven for al-Qa'ida, which was responsible for the 9/11 attacks in the United States. The Taliban's harsh rule in Afghanistan has been marked by a crackdown on women's rights and a neglect of basic services. The group has also been criticised for its close ties with al-Qaeda and other terrorist organisations, raising concerns that Afghanistan could once again become a safe haven for terrorists.

The Taliban's relationship with al-Qaeda

The Taliban and al-Qaeda have a long history of cooperation. The Taliban, a predominantly Pashtun Islamic fundamentalist group, first rose to power in Afghanistan in the 1990s, and al-Qaeda, led by Osama bin Laden, was headquartered in the country during this time. The two groups were closely aligned, with bin Laden swearing a religious oath of allegiance to the leader of the Taliban, Mullah Omar, and the Taliban providing protection to al-Qaeda.

After the Taliban was overthrown by US-led forces in 2001, the group continued its insurgency against the US-backed government in Kabul, and al-Qaeda continued to operate in the region, often with the support of the Taliban. In 2020, the Taliban signed a peace deal with the US, agreeing to prevent al-Qaeda and other terrorist groups from operating in Afghanistan. However, there are concerns that the Taliban has not upheld this agreement and that the two groups remain closely linked.

The Taliban and al-Qaeda have historical, ideological, and personal ties that make their relationship resilient. Many analysts believe that the Taliban has not truly distanced itself from al-Qaeda and that the groups continue to collaborate. The Taliban has provided protection and resources to al-Qaeda, and al-Qaeda has publicly pledged loyalty to the Taliban. The two groups have also intermarried over the years, creating familial bonds that further strengthen their alliance.

Despite the Taliban's assurances to the US and the international community, experts worry that Afghanistan could once again become a safe haven for al-Qaeda and other terrorist groups. The Taliban's return to power in 2021 has raised concerns that the country could be used as a base for launching international terrorist attacks. The killing of al-Qaeda leader Ayman al-Zawahiri in Kabul in 2022 by a US drone strike further underscores the ongoing relationship between the Taliban and al-Qaeda.

The Taliban's resurgence after 2005

The Taliban insurgency began after the group's fall from power during the 2001 War in Afghanistan. The Taliban regrouped and re-escalated their insurgency campaign in 2006, with the support of Pakistan, Iran, China, and Russia.

In 2005, the Taliban began to reassert their presence with new tactics modelled on those used by insurgents in Iraq. They adopted the use of suicide bombings and buried bombs, which caused heavy casualties. In 2006, Afghanistan began facing a wave of attacks by improvised explosives and suicide bombers, particularly after NATO took command of the fight against insurgents in spring 2006.

The Taliban's resurgence was also aided by the group's ability to raise funds through opium revenues, taxation, and mineral sales. In 2009, Richard Holbrooke, the United States special envoy for Afghanistan and Pakistan, said that money transfers from Western Europe and the Gulf States exceeded the drug trade earnings, and a new task force was formed to shut down this source of funds.

In addition, the Taliban received support from Pakistan, which provided a safe haven for the group's leaders and militants. Pakistan's former President Pervez Musharraf admitted that the Taliban was receiving cross-border aid, and that the problem in Afghanistan was due to support from Pakistan.

The Taliban's resurgence resulted in increased violence and civilian casualties, and posed a significant challenge to the US-led coalition forces and the Afghan government.

The Taliban's decentralised network

The Taliban is a decentralised network of fighters and low-level commanders who are empowered to recruit and find resources locally while the senior leadership remains sheltered in neighbouring Pakistan.

The Taliban was founded in the early 1990s and ruled most of Afghanistan from 1996 until October 2001. The group's founding nucleus was composed of peasant farmers and men studying Islam in Afghan and Pakistani religious schools. The Taliban found a foothold in southern Afghanistan and, by 1994, had moved their way through the south, capturing several provinces from various armed factions who had been fighting a civil war after the Soviet-backed Afghan government fell in 1992.

The Taliban's first move was to institute a strict interpretation of Islamic law, which often resulted in merciless policies on the treatment of women, political opponents, and religious minorities. The Taliban also provided a safe haven for al-Qaeda, giving them a base to freely recruit, train, and deploy terrorists to other countries.

In 2001, the Taliban was ousted from power by a US-led campaign against al-Qaeda. However, the group survived and, in 2005, began to enjoy a resurgence, showing greater coordination and resilience among its fighters. The Taliban's decentralised network of fighters allowed them to continue their insurgency campaign against the Afghan government and US-led coalition forces. This campaign combined guerrilla warfare with terrorist tactics and resulted in the Taliban retaking control of Afghanistan in 2021.

The Taliban's ideology and rule

The Taliban is an Afghan militant movement with an ideology that combines elements of Pashtun nationalism and Deobandi Islamic fundamentalism. The group's name means "students" in Pashto, reflecting its origins in the mid-1990s as a force of Afghan religious students and scholars seeking to confront crime and corruption.

The Taliban's ideology is heavily influenced by Deobandi Islamic fundamentalism, which emerged in colonial India in the 19th century as a response to British rule. Deobandi Islam, or Deobandism, is a rigid and pristine interpretation of Islam, insisting on a return to the practices of the seventh century and a global jihad to protect Muslims worldwide. This ideology was spread by Muslim clerics Maulana Muhammad Qasim Nanautawi and Maulana Rashid Muhammad Gangohi, who established the first Deobandi school in the north Indian state of present-day Uttar Pradesh.

The Taliban's interpretation of Deobandi Islam is also influenced by Wahhabism, a conservative form of Islam from Saudi Arabia that believes in a literal interpretation of the Quran. The Taliban's strict religious ideology combines this with a conservative Pashtun social code (Pashtunwali) to create a brutally repressive regime.

The Taliban's rule in Afghanistan, both historically and following their return to power in 2021, has been characterised by their harsh enforcement of their interpretation of Islamic Sharia law. This has resulted in brutal treatment of Afghans, including massacres, denial of food supplies, and destruction of cultural monuments. The group has also committed a cultural genocide by destroying historical and cultural texts, artifacts, and sculptures.

During their rule, the Taliban has imposed strict restrictions on women, banning them from education and most employment, and requiring them to wear head-to-toe coverings and be accompanied by a male guardian when travelling. They have also restricted modern education, banned entertainment and recreational activities, and forbidden the practice of other religions.

The Taliban's relationship with Pakistan

Pakistan's Inter-Services Intelligence Directorate (ISI) has long supported the Taliban, but the exact nature of the relationship is complex and difficult to summarise.

The Taliban's founder, Mullah Omar, was trained by the ISI during the war against the Soviets in the 1980s. After the Soviets retreated from Afghanistan, Omar was one of many warlords fighting for control of the country. The Pakistani army gave him support for the drive on Kabul in 1996, which gave the Taliban control of most of the country. Pakistan provided experts, advisers, oil, and supply routes for the Taliban.

However, the relationship is not without its tensions. The Taliban is virulently anti-Shiite, which increases sectarian tension in Pakistan, which has a much larger Shiite population than Afghanistan.

The Pakistani government has repeatedly denied that it provides military support to the Taliban, but the country's military leaders are the country's de facto rulers and have a great deal of influence over the Taliban. Pakistan's military leaders would have likely preferred a peaceful end to the conflict in Afghanistan, but only on the condition that the Taliban held decisive influence in any future Afghan government.

The Pakistani military has longstanding ties to the Taliban and has provided the group with financial resources, training, weapons, logistical support, and safe havens in Pakistani territory. The Taliban can freely move men and resources into Afghanistan, use Pakistani hospitals to treat their wounded fighters, and communicate with their operational commanders in Afghanistan. They have even used Pakistani passports to travel abroad.

The head of the ISI-backed Haqqani network, Sirajuddin Haqqani, was appointed to be one of the two deputy leaders of the Taliban in 2015, further enhancing the agency's sway over the Taliban.

In summary, the Taliban's relationship with Pakistan is complex and multifaceted. While Pakistan has provided significant support to the Taliban, including training, weapons, and safe havens, the relationship is not without tensions, and the Taliban's recent gains in Afghanistan may create serious blowback for Pakistan, including increased sectarian violence and a more unstable region.

Frequently asked questions