Brunei's Refusal To Join Malaysia: Understanding The Reasons

Brunei's decision to not join Malaysia was influenced by several factors, including economic, political, and historical considerations. The country's vast petroleum reserves played a significant role, as Brunei would have had to hand over the rights to those resources to the Malaysian government if they joined the Federation. Additionally, the Sultan of Brunei's position of power would have been diminished as he would have been last in the cycle to become the Malaysian head of state. There was also widespread anti-Federation sentiment within Brunei, with the Brunei People's Party favouring a North Borneo Federation instead. The Brunei Revolt in 1962, an armed uprising against the monarchy and the proposed inclusion in Malaysia, further solidified the Sultan's decision to maintain Brunei's independence.

Brunei's Sultan would have less power as part of Malaysia

Brunei's Sultan would have had less power as part of Malaysia. In 1963, Brunei declined to join the federation of states that became Malaysia, marking a pivotal turning point in the country's history. The Sultan of Brunei would have had to hand over the rights to the country's vast petroleum reserves to the Malaysian government, which would have diminished his power. Additionally, the Sultan would have had to wait 30-40 years to become the Malaysian head of state, as the position is an elected monarchy based on seniority. The Sultan's power would have been further reduced by the democratic system of government that Malaysia intended to implement in Brunei. The Sultan's refusal to join the Federation of Malaysia stemmed from his desire to retain his authority and influence in the region.

Brunei would have to hand over its petroleum reserves to Malaysia

Brunei's economy is heavily reliant on its oil and gas exports, which have dominated the country for the past 90 years. In fact, the energy sector is the main contributor to the country's growth, with 64.7% of the country's GDP in 2022. Brunei is the third-largest oil producer in Southeast Asia, producing an average of 180,000 barrels per day.

Brunei Shell Petroleum (BSP) is the largest oil producer in the country and contributes to around 90% of Brunei's oil and gas revenues. The company is a joint venture between the Brunei government and the Royal Dutch/Shell group of companies, and it also operates the country's only refinery.

If Brunei had joined Malaysia, it would have had to hand over control of its petroleum reserves to the Malaysian government. This would mean that the revenue generated from these reserves would have been distributed throughout the entire country, rather than solely benefiting Brunei. This was one of the main economic reasons why Brunei chose to remain independent.

In addition to economic factors, the Sultan of Brunei also played a role in the decision. As the Malaysian head of state is an elected monarch, the Sultan of Brunei would have had to wait 30-40 years to become the head of state, as he would come last in the cycle due to the seniority of the other royal families.

The Brunei revolt of 1962 also influenced the Sultan's decision. This insurrection by opponents of the monarchy and the proposed inclusion of Brunei in the Federation of Malaysia led to attacks on the oil town of Seria, police stations, and government facilities. The revolt was quickly suppressed, but it caused the Sultan to reconsider the potential risks and consequences of joining the Federation.

In summary, Brunei's vast petroleum reserves and the Sultan's position were key factors in the decision to remain independent and not join Malaysia. The potential loss of control over their oil and gas reserves, along with the Sultan's reduced power, made it more advantageous for Brunei to maintain its independence.

There was widespread anti-Federation sentiment within Brunei

Firstly, Brunei's vast petroleum reserves played a crucial role in shaping public opinion. If Brunei joined the Federation, they would have to surrender control of these reserves to the Malaysian government, potentially compromising their economic interests.

Secondly, the Sultan of Brunei, who held significant power as the nation's monarch, would have had reduced influence in a unified Malaysia. He would have had to wait 30-40 years for his turn to serve as the Malaysian head of state, and even then, his power would be limited compared to the authority he wielded in Brunei.

Additionally, historical factors contributed to the anti-Federation sentiment in Brunei. The nation had a complex colonial history, having been a British protectorate since 1888, and there were concerns about the potential loss of sovereignty and autonomy if they joined the Federation.

Cultural differences between the Borneo states and the Malayan peninsula also played a role in shaping public opinion. The people of Brunei had a strong sense of national pride and did not want to be subjected to political domination by the peninsula. They witnessed the disappearance of Sultanates in the Malay Peninsula due to the formation of the Federation of Malaya, and they wanted to preserve their unique identity and system of governance.

The Brunei People's Party, which initially favoured joining Malaysia, proposed the formation of a North Borneo Federation that would unite the three crown colonies of northern Borneo. This proposal aimed to create a stronger sultanate that could resist domination by Malaya or Singapore and maintain its distinct cultural and historical character.

Overall, the people of Brunei were wary of losing their economic advantages, political autonomy, and cultural identity by joining the Federation. They had witnessed the challenges faced by other states within Malaysia, such as Sabah and Sarawak, which struggled to retain privileges and resources for their state governments. As a result, there was a strong and widespread sentiment against joining the Federation, which ultimately influenced the Sultan's decision to maintain Brunei's independence.

The Sultan of Brunei would be the last to ascend as the Malaysian head of state

Brunei's decision to not join the Federation of Malaysia was influenced by several factors, two of which pertained to the position of the Sultan of Brunei in the Malaysian political system. Firstly, the Sultan of Brunei, as the sole monarch of his country, held absolute power. However, if Brunei joined the federation, the Sultan would have to share power with the other royal families in Malaysia. The Malaysian head of state, the Yang di-Pertuan Agong, is an elected position, with the role rotating between the nine royal families every five years.

At the time of Malaysia's independence, the Sultan of Brunei would have been last in the cycle to become the Yang di-Pertuan Agong, meaning he would have to wait 30 to 40 years (9 royal families x 5-year term = 45 years) before ascending to the position. This would have resulted in a significant reduction in the power held by the Sultan of Brunei, as he would have to wait several decades before becoming the head of state.

Additionally, as part of the federation, Brunei would have had to hand over the rights to its vast petroleum reserves to the Malaysian government. This would have negatively impacted Brunei's economy, as the distribution of oil profits would have to be shared with the rest of Malaysia.

The combination of these factors, along with other political, historical, and cultural differences, led to the decision for Brunei to remain independent and not join the Federation of Malaysia.

Brunei wanted to preserve its sovereignty

Brunei's decision to remain independent was largely influenced by its desire to preserve its sovereignty and the power of its monarch, the Sultan of Brunei. The Sultan would have had to wait 30-40 years to become the head of state in Malaysia, and even then, his power would have been diminished compared to the absolute monarchy he held in Brunei.

The Sultan's refusal to join the Federation of Malaysia was also influenced by economic factors. Brunei's vast petroleum reserves provided the Sultanate with significant income, and joining the Federation would have meant handing over the rights to these reserves to the Malaysian government. Keeping its economic autonomy allowed Brunei to maintain control over its natural resources and the wealth they generated.

Additionally, there was widespread anti-Federation sentiment within Brunei, with locals opposing the idea of being subjected to political domination by the Malayan peninsula. This sentiment was strengthened by external opposition from neighbouring countries like Indonesia and the Philippines, who did not support the unification of North Borneo and Sarawak with the new federation.

The Brunei People's Party, which favoured joining Malaysia, saw unification as a way to create a strong sultanate that could resist domination by Malaya or Singapore. However, the Sultan and the people of Brunei were apprehensive about losing their sovereignty and the advantages they enjoyed as a separate state.

The British, who were keen on creating a counterbalance to Chinese power in the region, also played a role in these events. They continued to pressure the Sultan to join the Federation, even proposing to bring Brunei closer to Malaysia by employing Malaysian officers in the Bruneian administration. However, the Sultan refused, choosing to recruit officers from Britain instead.

Ultimately, Brunei's refusal to join Malaysia was a pivotal turning point in its history, allowing it to retain its territorial integrity and sovereignty.

Frequently asked questions