Bolivia: A Country Plagued By Poverty And Instability

Bolivia is a country plagued by political instability, corruption, poverty, and crime. Since gaining independence from Spain in 1825, Bolivia has experienced frequent government overthrows, with the constitution being rewritten over 200 times. This has resulted in poor governance and underdevelopment, making Bolivia the poorest nation in South America. Despite its abundant natural resources, Bolivia struggles with inequality and a lack of human development, hindering its economic, social, and political progress. The country also faces issues with education, access to clean water and sanitation, and low productivity in rural areas. Additionally, Bolivia has a reputation for petty and violent crimes, scams, and drug-related issues, making it a potentially unsafe destination for travelers.

Political instability and violent protests

The early 2000s were a particularly turbulent time, with the resignation of President Hugo Banzer in 2001, followed by four controversial presidents within the next five years. This period of political impermanence was largely due to the discovery of natural gas in Bolivia and the government's plans to export the reserves. This sparked violent discourse between the Bolivian population and the government, with protests against plans to export the country's newly discovered natural gas reserves to large Northern Hemisphere markets. The period between 2003 and 2005 was characterised by political instability, racial tensions, and violent protests.

The political and social tension in Bolivia poses a serious risk to personal safety and has led to frequent anti-government protests and civil unrest. Even during periods of relative stability, protests and demonstrations are common in Bolivia. While these gatherings are usually peaceful, they can quickly turn violent, and foreigners are advised to avoid large crowds, especially during times of civil unrest.

The country's long history of political instability has been fuelled by widespread poverty, which has hindered the country's development and governance. Almost 40% of Bolivians live in extreme poverty, and the country's human development index ranks 104th out of 174 countries and territories. The government has recognised the need to address poverty and has implemented various programs to alleviate it. Despite some progress, Bolivia remains the poorest nation in South America, with a real GDP lower than it was a generation ago and most of the population still living below the poverty line.

In addition to political instability and violent protests, Bolivia faces other challenges such as insufficient education, lack of access to clean water and sanitation, and low productivity in rural areas. These issues contribute to the country's overall instability and hinder its progress.

Poor infrastructure and underdevelopment

Bolivia's infrastructure is in a state of disrepair, with a lack of basic infrastructure such as water management systems and roads, which is a significant contributor to the country's poor development. The country's railway system, which was once a fine example of engineering, has fallen into a state of disrepair, with most Bolivian railroads in need of repair and upgrade. The Bolivian government has recognised the issues with its infrastructure and has made highway construction and maintenance a priority in recent years.

The country's rural areas are the most affected by the lack of infrastructure, with inadequate access to clean water and sanitation. This has led to a high risk of disease and illness, with diarrhoea being one of the most common and serious consequences. The lack of infrastructure also inhibits farmers' profits, as transportation is expensive and challenging.

The insufficient infrastructure in Bolivia is also evident in the education system, particularly in rural areas. Public school education is of extremely poor quality, and private education is often too expensive for most families. This creates a cycle where poor families stay poor, unable to escape poverty without access to quality education.

The country also faces challenges with its power and communication infrastructure. Bolivia's electric power generating capacity is limited, and the state-owned long-distance telephone company, ENTEL, has faced controversy and privatisation. However, communication has rapidly adapted to new technology, with the continued rapid growth of cellular phone use.

Inequality and poverty

Bolivia is the poorest nation in South America, with almost 40% of Bolivians living in extreme poverty. The country is plagued by inequality and inadequate development, which hinders its economic, social, and political progress.

Political Instability

Bolivia has a history of political instability, with over 200 governments since gaining independence from Spain in 1825. The early 2000s saw another period of turmoil, with the resignation of President Hugo Banzer in 2001, followed by four controversial presidents within five years. This instability was partly due to the discovery of natural gas reserves and the government's plans to export them, which caused violent discourse between the government and the Bolivian people.

Insufficient Education

Public school education in Bolivia, especially in rural areas, is of extremely poor quality, and private education is unaffordable for most. This creates a cycle where poor families stay poor, while wealthy families progress. Without a good education, it is incredibly difficult to escape poverty.

Lack of Clean Water and Sanitation

In rural areas, many people lack access to clean, natural, or potable water and are forced to drink contaminated water, which puts them at significant risk of disease. Diarrhea, resulting from drinking contaminated water, is responsible for over one-third of deaths among Bolivian children under five. While access to clean water has improved since the 1990s, these improvements are concentrated in urban areas, where sanitation needs are less dire.

Low Productivity in Rural Areas

Over 80% of Bolivia's rural population lives below the poverty line. This is largely due to the low productivity of small-scale farming, frequent water shortages, and a lack of infrastructure such as water management systems and roads. The absence of roads makes transportation expensive, further inhibiting farmers' profits.

Inequality

Bolivia has a diverse society, with approximately 35 different ethnic groups. However, the majority indigenous population remains highly marginalized and continues to live in extreme poverty. In 2001, the mean income per capita in indigenous households was about 300 Bolivian Bolivianos per month, compared to 480 Bolivian Bolivianos for non-indigenous households. This gap is partly due to the difference in sources of income, with non-agricultural wages being higher than agricultural self-employment income. Additionally, indigenous peoples have significantly less access to social services, and higher dropout rates result in a persistent education gap between indigenous and non-indigenous Bolivians.

Corruption in government and police

Corruption in Bolivia is a major problem that is considered an accepted part of life. Citizens perceive the judiciary, police, and public administration as the country's most corrupt sectors.

Government Corruption

Government bureaucracy is viewed as inefficient and bloated, with hiring and promotion decisions driven by political connections rather than merit. Officials often treat public financial data as their personal property and fail to provide transparency around it. Bolivia scored 13 out of 100 on the Open Budget Index in 2010, the worst performance in Latin America.

Rampant corruption within the government and elite perpetuates poverty and hinders advancement. Local governments have been implicated in illicit enrichment schemes, and there is a perception that the government's anti-corruption efforts are insincere.

Police Corruption and Narcotics Trafficking

Police corruption is a significant issue in Bolivia, exacerbated by low wages and inadequate training. The police force is considered the third most corrupt institution in the country, and corruption is seen as the primary obstacle to effective crime-fighting. Drug trafficking further exacerbates police corruption, with narcotics police and secret police involved in cocaine trafficking since the late 1950s. Many officers have ties to organised crime, particularly drug traffickers, and are appointed to senior positions due to their political connections.

The complexity of Bolivian tax law and the lack of adequate inspection controls also provide opportunities for corruption. Companies consider corruption a major obstacle when doing business in the country, and bribery is often expected when dealing with the justice system and public services sector.

Drug-related crime and trafficking

Bolivia's history of political instability, corruption, and poverty has created an environment where drug trafficking can thrive. The country has a long history of corruption, with a culture of impunity and a weak rule of law. This has allowed drug trafficking organizations to operate with relative ease, often with the complicity of government officials, law enforcement, and the judiciary. According to a senior Bolivian police source, some of the more sophisticated criminal clans in Bolivia can produce up to 1000 kilograms of coca base, which is then transported to Brazilian organized crime syndicates or bought by Colombians for further processing into cocaine.

The Bolivian government has made efforts to combat drug trafficking, particularly in controlling coca crops. However, the resources deployed against drug trafficking are often outmatched by the potential profits in the drug trade. Additionally, the departure of the DEA, the Bureau of International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs (INL), and USAID from the country has left a void in strategic intelligence and counter-narcotics aid.

The issue of drug-related crime and trafficking is not limited to Bolivia's borders. Bolivian drug trafficking organizations have established a permanent presence in Paraguay and Brazil to secure supplies of cocaine and its derivatives. There are also indications that Colombian "oficinas de cobro" ("collection offices"), criminal structures used to monitor and regulate cocaine trafficking, have been set up in Bolivia. These oficinas collect payments from traffickers and hire assassins to carry out murders when necessary.

The longer Bolivia remains a drug production and transshipment nation, the more likely it is that its organized crime groups will evolve into sophisticated transnational organizations. Without a significant investment in the fight against drug trafficking and transnational organized crime, the prognosis for Bolivia is pessimistic.

Frequently asked questions