Belize's Unemployment Mystery

Unemployment in Belize has been a persistent issue, with estimates from recent years placing the unemployment rate at around 8-10%. While the country has a high ratio of land to population, indicating that unemployment should not be an issue, the problem is predominantly concentrated in urban areas. The situation is further complicated by the presence of subsistence farmers and Mayan hill villagers, who may be considered self-employed or unemployed depending on the definition applied. The urban unemployed population in Belize is characterised by a lack of education and skills, rendering them unemployable by industrialised nation standards. Government policies influenced by international organisations like the IMF and World Bank have been criticised for their ineffectiveness in addressing the unemployment problem.

Unemployed vs self-employed in rural areas

Belize has a relatively high unemployment rate, estimated at 9% in 2017, which decreased by 0.5% in 2023. This figure does not include the economically inactive, such as the long-term unemployed, children, or retirees.

In rural areas, the self-employed are those who operate a trade, business, or profession, either individually or as a partner. This includes professionals, proprietors, taxi drivers, street vendors, tour operators, and technicians, among others. The self-employed are not subject to the general direction and control of the recipient of their service. They must be between the ages of 18 and 60, be a resident of Belize, and not be employed by another entity.

The self-employed in rural areas of Belize enjoy certain freedoms, such as choosing their weekly income, which is then used to calculate their contribution payments. They must, however, adhere to certain requirements, such as registering in person, providing a valid Social Security Number, and possessing a valid social security card.

On the other hand, the unemployed in rural areas may face challenges in finding employment opportunities. The high unemployment rate suggests that a significant portion of the economically active population is without work but actively seeking employment. This situation may lead to competition for available jobs and potentially contribute to underemployment, where individuals are employed but desire more work or better opportunities.

The contrast between the unemployed and self-employed in rural areas of Belize highlights the potential benefits of self-employment. By starting their own ventures, individuals can take control of their financial situation, avoid competition for a limited number of jobs, and potentially improve their economic situation. However, it is important to note that self-employment also comes with its own set of challenges, such as the need to consistently find clients or customers and the lack of traditional employment benefits.

Impact of education on unemployment

While I was able to find some information on the unemployment rate in Belize, I could not find specific details on the impact of education on unemployment in the country. However, here is some information on Belize's unemployment rate.

Belize's unemployment rate was 3% in April 2024, according to the Statistical Institute of Belize. This is a decrease from the previous year, when the rate was reported to be between 8% and 9%. The unemployment rate in Belize seems to have decreased by 0.5% since 2023, but the two years prior recorded significantly higher rates than previous years.

Government policies and intervention

The Belizean government has implemented various policies and interventions to address the issue of unemployment in the country. While the unemployment rate in Belize has shown a downward trend in recent years, the problem persists, especially in urban areas. The government's approach has been influenced by their training and education in industrialized nations, as well as recommendations from organizations like the IMF and World Bank. However, some critics argue that these approaches are misguiding and not suitable for the unique context of Belize.

One of the main interventions has been the creation of employment through foreign investment and low-cost labour. However, this approach has largely failed to make a significant impact on the unemployment situation. Belize has also tried experimenting with government interventions, but these have not yielded the desired results, especially when compared to the success of similar initiatives in neighbouring countries like Jamaica and Barbados.

The key to tackling unemployment in Belize, according to some experts, lies in rapid technological progress and innovative, imaginative policies. They suggest that Belize should focus on developing a technological society by providing rural communities with telephones, computer technology, and free internet access. Additionally, there is a need for technological training and education among the general populace to meet the demands of the future job market.

One potential industry that Belize could explore is aircraft manufacturing and servicing, utilizing the information readily available in their electronic library. Another option is to focus on computer science and programming, specifically targeting the Spanish-speaking markets in South America. Data entry is another field that could provide opportunities for Belizeans, given the availability of free internet access in the country.

Education reforms are also necessary to align with the changing job market. For instance, computer software training should be prioritized, and typing should be introduced as a mandatory course from elementary school onwards. By embracing innovative solutions and adapting to the dynamic global economy, Belize can overcome the challenges of unemployment and pave the way for a brighter future for its citizens.

Foreign investment and labour costs

Belize has the smallest economy in Central America, with a GDP of US$1.3 billion in 2021, a 12.5% expansion over the previous year. The country's economy is largely based on tourism, with the sector contributing significantly to its growth. However, the COVID-19 pandemic caused a collapse in the tourism industry, leading to a spike in unemployment.

The Belizean government encourages Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) to relieve fiscal pressure and transform the economy. While the government is interested in attracting FDI, certain bureaucratic and regulatory requirements, such as the Exchange Control Act, impede investment and growth. Additionally, the small population, high cost of doing business, high public debt, bureaucratic delays, insufficient infrastructure, and corruption constitute investment challenges.

Belize has no restrictions on foreign ownership or control of companies, but foreign investments must be registered with the Central Bank of Belize. The government has taken steps to improve the ease of doing business through trade license, stamp duty, exchange control, and land reforms.

The financial system in Belize is characterised as stable but fragile, with high costs of finance and lending rates constraining economic growth. The country's banking sector has experienced a loss of correspondent banking relationships, resulting in fewer services offered at higher costs.

To promote FDI, the government offers various incentive packages and has identified priority sectors such as agriculture, agro-processing, tourism, renewable energy, and business process outsourcing. The Belize Trade and Investment Development Service (BELTRAIDE) is the country's investment and export promotion agency, providing advisory services to foreign investors.

While there are no restrictions on foreign ownership, certain investment incentives show a preference for Belizean-owned companies, such as the requirement for majority local ownership to obtain a tour operator license. Foreign investors undertaking large capital investments must adhere to environmental laws and regulations and may be required to prepare an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA).

The labour force in Belize is largely unskilled, and employers often rely on temporary workers, including migrant workers from neighbouring Central American countries, to fill jobs in the agricultural sector. The minimum wage in Belize is BZ $3.30 (US $1.65) per hour, and employers are flexible in offering salary increases based on the cost of living and prevailing practices.

Overall, Belize's small and vulnerable economy, combined with bureaucratic challenges and high costs of doing business, may contribute to unemployment in the country.

Technological progress and education

Belize has made significant progress in this area, with a recent decrease in the unemployment rate by 0.5 percentage points, according to the World Bank. This indicates a positive direction, although the previous two years saw a higher unemployment rate.

The country's economic institutions and policies play a crucial role in maintaining low involuntary unemployment and sustaining real wage increases. Additionally, co-insurance measures against job losses resulting from both creative destruction and competition from other economies have been implemented in successful economies, ensuring that technological advancements and the exchange of goods and services are welcomed by most citizens.

Education is another vital aspect. The more educated the population is, the better equipped they are to adapt to new technologies and find employment. Belize conducts labour force surveys twice a year, in April and September, to gather data on the working-age population. These surveys help track employment and unemployment rates, providing insights for policy interventions.

Furthermore, the country's investment in education is evident through initiatives such as the National Strategy for the Development of Statistics and the publication of Education Statistics by the Statistical Institute of Belize. These efforts contribute to enhancing the skills and employability of Belize's citizens.

Overall, Belize's progress in technological advancement and education has the potential to positively impact unemployment rates and promote economic growth.

Frequently asked questions