Belarusians Fleeing To Poland: Understanding The Exodus

Thousands of migrants from countries like Iraq, Syria, and Libya have been attempting to cross into Poland from Belarus. Many of these migrants are fleeing dangerous conditions in the Middle East and Africa and are trying to enter the EU. Previously, people have largely tried to enter the EU through Greece and Italy, which are shorter and more direct routes. The sudden surge in migrants from Belarus has sparked accusations from Poland and the EU that Belarus, and its ally Russia, are intentionally allowing people to travel to Minsk and providing them with transport to the Polish border to destabilize Europe.

People are fleeing dangerous conditions in the Middle East

In 2021, Poland experienced a migration crisis as thousands of migrants from the Middle East and Africa attempted to cross its border with Belarus. Many of these migrants were fleeing dangerous conditions in their home countries.

The Middle East has been plagued by conflict, persecution, human rights violations, and instability, causing people to flee in search of safety and better lives. The ongoing conflict in Syria, for example, has resulted in the largest displacement crisis globally, with 13.8 million people forcibly uprooted within and beyond its borders as of June 2024. The conflict has led to widespread destruction, displacement, public health emergencies, and a devastating earthquake in 2023. Syrian refugees have sought asylum in over 137 countries, with Turkey, Lebanon, Jordan, Iraq, and Egypt being the top destinations.

Afghanistan is another country facing long-term refugee situations, with Iran and Pakistan hosting millions of Afghan refugees. Recurring drought, political instability, and prolonged conflict have contributed to severe food insecurity and forced people to leave their homes.

Additionally, the Israel-Palestine conflict has had profound ramifications across the region and worldwide. The conflict's deep roots lie in Israel's forced displacement and dispossession of Palestinians, military occupation, apartheid, and illegal blockade of the Gaza Strip. The violence has resulted in the killing and displacement of thousands of civilians, with Israeli forces committing war crimes and Hamas deliberately targeting civilians in Israel.

The impact of these long-standing conflicts in the Middle East has blighted the lives of millions, including internally displaced people, refugees, migrants, and ethnic minorities. They face a range of challenges, such as a lack of access to basic rights like food, water, housing, healthcare, and security. Indiscriminate attacks, infrastructure destruction, forced displacement, and abusive rule by security forces and armed groups continue with impunity.

Economic crises, sharp cost-of-living increases, and natural and climate change-linked disasters have further exacerbated the situation. Regional governments have failed to adequately respond to these challenges, affecting the fundamental human rights of their citizens. As a result, people are left with no choice but to flee in search of safer and better living conditions.

As people from the Middle East attempted to cross the Polish border, they faced harsh responses from Polish authorities, who imposed a state of emergency and prevented aid organizations from providing much-needed assistance. Clashes erupted between migrants and Polish police, with people trying to enter Poland by cutting border fences or battering them with logs.

The situation at the Poland-Belarus border highlights the desperation of those fleeing dangerous conditions in the Middle East and the complex political and humanitarian challenges faced by European countries in addressing the migration crisis.

Polish officials are preventing aid from reaching migrants

The situation at the Poland-Belarus border has been described as a "migration crisis" or "humanitarian crisis", with thousands of migrants, including women and young children, gathering on the Belarusian side of the border trying to enter Poland. Many of these migrants are fleeing dangerous conditions in Middle Eastern and African countries, such as Iraq, Syria, Afghanistan, and the Democratic Republic of the Congo. They have been encouraged to fly to Minsk by the Belarusian dictator, Alexander Lukashenko, who is accused of intentionally sparking the crisis to retaliate against sanctions and criticism.

In response to the influx of migrants, Poland has adopted a hardline approach, with Polish officials vowing to prevent anyone from crossing the border. They have imposed a state of emergency and passed laws that allow for the immediate expulsion of migrants who cross the border illegally, without examining their asylum applications. This has been criticised by human rights groups as a violation of international law, which states that anyone seeking international protection must be given access to the asylum process, even if they have crossed a border illegally.

The Polish government's actions have prevented aid organisations from providing much-needed assistance to migrants stranded on the Belarusian side of the border. This has resulted in dangerous conditions, with temperatures dipping below freezing and at least eight people dying of exposure in the area. The situation has been further exacerbated by the Belarusian government's refusal to allow migrants back into their territory.

To address the influx of migrants, the Polish government has also announced the establishment of 49 Foreigners' Integration Centres (CICs) across the country. These centres will provide standardised services, including language courses, legal assistance, and psychological care, to help newly arrived migrants integrate into Polish society. However, this initiative has been met with mixed reactions, with some criticising it as a form of "replacement migration" and a potential threat to the safety and cultural homogeneity of Poland.

Belarus is accused of intentionally sparking the crisis

Background

The crisis at the Belarus-Poland border began in the summer of 2021, when Belarusian authorities started facilitating the transit of asylum seekers from the Middle East and neighbouring countries to the country's border with Poland. This was in retaliation for sanctions imposed by the EU earlier that year.

Accusations against Belarus

Poland, the EU, NATO, and others blame Belarus for intentionally sparking the crisis. They accuse the country of luring vulnerable people into a political game by allowing them to travel to Minsk and providing transport to the Polish border. European leaders believe that Belarus's president, Alexander Lukashenko, is motivated by revenge for sanctions and criticism of his brutal crackdown on the Belarusian opposition.

Consequences of the Crisis

The consequences of the crisis have been dire, with thousands of people stranded at the border without adequate food, water, shelter, or medical care. As of November 2021, at least 13 people have died, mostly due to exposure to freezing temperatures. People have also reported injuries from attempting to cross the border, including cuts from barbed wire fences. The situation has been further exacerbated by the refusal of both Belarus and Poland to allow humanitarian organizations access to the border region to provide aid.

Calls for Action

The international community has called on Belarus to stop all abuses against migrants, including violence, detention, and denying them access to humanitarian aid. There have also been calls for Belarus to respect the right to freedom of movement and allow migrants to return to Minsk or their home countries if they wish. Additionally, Belarus should launch investigations into abuses committed by its border guards and hold those responsible accountable.

Polish authorities have responded with violence and illegal denial of asylum

Polish authorities have taken a hardline stance in response to the influx of migrants at the Belarus border, imposing a state of emergency that has prevented aid from reaching those in need and resulted in illegal denial of asylum. This crisis has seen Polish officials vowing to prevent anyone from crossing the border, with newly passed laws allowing police to ignore asylum requests and forcibly expel migrants back into Belarus. This response has been characterised as harsh and violent, with police deploying chemical sprays to push back those attempting to enter.

The Polish government's actions have been widely criticised by human rights organisations, who argue that the denial of asylum is unlawful and inhumane. Amnesty International has been particularly vocal, stating that the proposals "endanger the rights of people seeking safety" and "penalise people who may have been subject to violence and trafficking". They further emphasise the inconsistency of these actions with EU law and the EU's Pact on Migration and Asylum, which upholds the right to asylum as protected by the EU Charter on Fundamental Rights.

The Polish government, led by Prime Minister Donald Tusk, has defended its decision to suspend the right to asylum, citing national security concerns and accusing Belarus and Russia of orchestrating the mass transfer of migrants to destabilise the West. Tusk has referred to this as a "hybrid war" and argued that the suspension is necessary to protect Poland's borders. He has also pointed to Finland's similar actions in response to migration pressure from Russia.

However, critics argue that Poland is playing politics with human rights and using the situation as a political tool to gain favour with voters. They highlight the incompatibility of the suspension with international law and EU rules, as well as the potential for it to cause a humanitarian crisis. The European Commission has acknowledged the challenge posed by Belarus and Russia but maintains that member countries must uphold their legal obligations, including the right to apply for international protection.

The situation has caused dismay among human rights groups and created tensions within Tusk's governing coalition. It remains to be seen whether Poland will face consequences for its denial of asylum and if the suspension of asylum applications will be upheld in the long term.

The EU is balancing humanitarian values with political considerations

The situation at the Belarus-Poland border is a complex issue that tests the EU's commitment to its humanitarian values and political considerations. On the one hand, the EU upholds the right to asylum and the humane treatment of migrants and refugees as fundamental principles. On the other hand, the EU must also navigate its difficult relationship with Poland and address the ongoing political disputes with Belarus.

The crisis at the border began in the summer of 2021 when Belarusian authorities, in retaliation for EU sanctions, started facilitating the transit of migrants to its borders with Poland, Lithuania, and Latvia. Local travel agents in the Middle East encouraged people to travel to Minsk, promising easy entry into the EU. As a result, thousands of people, mainly from Iraq, Syria, and Afghanistan, found themselves stranded at the Belarus-Poland border, facing harsh conditions and unable to seek asylum.

The EU is faced with the challenge of upholding its humanitarian values and ensuring the protection of those seeking asylum. The situation on the ground is dire, with limited access to food, water, shelter, and medical care. People are spending days or weeks in the open without basic humanitarian services, leading to deaths, hypothermia, and other illnesses. Both Belarus and Poland have been accused of human rights violations and preventing humanitarian organizations from providing aid.

The EU's political considerations come into play with its difficult relationship with Poland and the ongoing dispute with Belarus. Poland has adopted a hardline response to the crisis, imposing a state of emergency and passing controversial amendments that allow authorities to dismiss asylum applications. The EU Commission, humanitarian agencies, and members of the European Parliament have criticized these actions. Additionally, Poland's plans to build a wall along its border with Belarus further undermine the right to seek asylum.

The EU must balance its commitment to humanitarian values with its political considerations. On the one hand, the EU needs to hold Poland accountable for its response to the crisis and ensure that Poland respects its obligations under EU and international law. On the other hand, the EU must also address the actions of Belarus, which has been accused of luring vulnerable people into a political game and putting lives at risk. The EU has imposed sanctions on Belarus and is working to dissuade the country from continuing these actions.

The situation at the Belarus-Poland border is a test for the EU, requiring a delicate balance between upholding humanitarian values and navigating complex political considerations. The EU must work towards a swift resolution that prioritizes the humane treatment of migrants and refugees while also addressing the underlying political issues.

Frequently asked questions