Camp Stew Vs. Brunswick Stew: What's The Difference?

Camp stew and Brunswick stew are similar dishes with subtle differences. Brunswick stew is a tomato-based stew that usually contains chicken, rabbit, or squirrel, along with vegetables like lima beans, corn, okra, and potatoes. It can also be made with pork, which is more common in Georgia, while chicken is more common in Virginia. On the other hand, camp stew, also known as Alabama camp stew, is often made with canned meat, diced tomatoes, beans, corn, and onion. It is typically thicker than Brunswick stew and may include potatoes, Worcestershire sauce, and hot sauce. Both dishes are comforting and hearty, with Brunswick stew being more versatile and adaptable to different tastes and preferences.

Camp stew is made with canned goods, making it ideal for camping

Camp stew and Brunswick stew are very similar, and the names are sometimes used interchangeably. However, there is a key difference: camp stew is usually made with canned goods, whereas Brunswick stew is typically made with fresh ingredients.

Camp stew is ideal for camping because it can be made with canned goods, which are sturdy, rodent-proof, and easy to pack. Canned goods are also safe to place directly in a campfire, making camp stew a convenient option for those cooking over an open fire. The recipe is simple: combine canned meat, diced tomatoes, beans, corn, and onion in a stockpot and let the flavours simmer together for about an hour.

Camp stew is a hearty and delicious dish that is said to be one of the most flavourful stews ever. It is a popular dish in Alabama and is often served at family gatherings and around campfires. The recipe is flexible, and cooks can add their own twist by including different types of canned meat and beans, or adding vegetables like potatoes, carrots, and celery.

While Brunswick stew can also be made while camping, the traditional recipe calls for fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. This includes small game meats like squirrel or rabbit, or chicken, along with vegetables like lima beans, corn, okra, and tomatoes. The stew is usually cooked over a slow fire, sometimes in a large iron pot suspended over a wood fire.

In summary, camp stew is made with canned goods, which makes it convenient for camping trips, whereas Brunswick stew is typically made with fresh ingredients and cooked over a slow fire. Both stews are hearty and flavourful, with camp stew being a more convenient option for campers due to its use of easily packed and non-perishable canned goods.

Brunswick stew is cooked in a cast-iron cauldron

Brunswick stew is a tomato-based dish that typically includes local vegetables like beans, corn, and okra, as well as meat. It is often cooked and served in a cast-iron cauldron, a tradition that adds to the stew's unique character and history. Here are some insights into why Brunswick stew is cooked in a cast-iron cauldron:

• Tradition and History: The use of a cast-iron cauldron for cooking Brunswick stew is deeply rooted in tradition. The stew originated in the American South, where it was often prepared in large quantities for community gatherings, fundraisers, and family meals. The cauldron, hung over an open fire or placed on a stove, became synonymous with this hearty dish.
• Large Capacity: Brunswick stew is often made in large batches to feed a crowd. The cast-iron cauldron's capacity allows for cooking substantial amounts of stew at once, making it a practical choice for feeding a large number of people.
• Even Heat Distribution: Cast iron is known for its excellent heat retention and distribution. The cauldron's thick walls ensure that the heat is distributed evenly throughout the stew, allowing all the ingredients to cook uniformly and preventing hot spots that could burn certain areas.
• Durability: Cast iron is renowned for its durability and longevity. The cauldron's sturdy construction means it can withstand the high temperatures and prolonged cooking times that Brunswick stew often requires, making it a reliable choice for this traditional dish.
• Outdoor Cooking: Brunswick stew has a strong association with outdoor cooking and community events. The cast-iron cauldron is well-suited for this purpose as it can be placed directly over a fire or used with a portable stove, making it ideal for cooking outdoors.
• Flavor Development: Cooking Brunswick stew in a cast-iron cauldron can enhance its flavor. The cauldron's surface interacts with the ingredients, imparting a unique flavor that is often described as "earthy" or "rustic." This adds to the overall character and depth of the dish.

Preparing Brunswick stew in a cast-iron cauldron is not just a practical choice but also a nod to the dish's rich history and traditions. It transforms the cooking process into a communal experience, bringing people together to enjoy a hearty meal with a distinct Southern flavor.

Brunswick stew is a Southern dish, often served in BBQ restaurants

Brunswick stew is a Southern speciality, often served in BBQ restaurants. It is a tomato-based stew, usually made with chicken or pork, and a variety of vegetables, including corn, butter beans, and okra. It is thought to originate from either Virginia or Georgia, with both states claiming it as their own. The dish is said to have been created by a camp chef on a hunting expedition, and it remains a popular camping meal today.

The exact ingredients of Brunswick stew can vary, but it typically includes some combination of meat, vegetables, and a tomato base. While it can be made with chicken or pork, the traditional recipe called for small game meat such as squirrel, rabbit, or opossum. The stew is often served with cornbread on the side, and some recipes include barbecue sauce for added flavour.

Brunswick stew is considered a Southern dish and can be found on menus in BBQ restaurants across the region. It is particularly popular in Georgia and Virginia, where it is a source of state pride. The dish has a long and controversial history, with both states claiming it as their own. The Virginia General Assembly and the Georgia House of Representatives have even passed resolutions declaring their state as the birthplace of the stew.

The origins of the dish are disputed, with some claiming it was first made in Brunswick County, Virginia, and others saying it originated in the city of Brunswick, Georgia. It may even have older roots, with some suggesting it came from the city of Braunschweig in Germany, which was historically known as "Brunswick" in British English. This theory is supported by the fact that both Brunswick County and the city of Brunswick are named after the German Duchy of Brunswick-Lüneburg.

Brunswick stew is a popular dish for camping and outdoor cooking, as it can be made in a large cast-iron cauldron over a fire. It is a hearty and filling meal, perfect for cold weather, and can be easily adapted to include whatever ingredients are available. Whether enjoyed at a restaurant or cooked at home, Brunswick stew is a delicious and iconic Southern dish.

Camp stew is a speciality in Alabama

Alabama camp stew, also known as Brunswick stew outside of the state, is a speciality in Alabama. It is a thick red stew made from a combination of beef, pork, or chicken, slowly simmered with tomatoes, potatoes, and onions, and perhaps corn and lima beans. The recipe is flexible, and some variations include potatoes, carrots, parsnips, celery, frozen peas, or green beans.

Camp stew is believed to have originated in Alabama before spreading to Georgia, where it is known as Brunswick stew. In July 1883, a correspondent from Wisconsin's Watertown Republican attended a Southern barbecue in Montgomery, Alabama, and mentioned "a genuine southern barbecue" that included "a large kettle of the heads, tail, feet, liver, heart, tongue, &c. of the animals," which was referred to as camp stew. This is quite different from Virginia's version of Brunswick stew, which is typically made with chicken and is believed to have originated as a hunting meal.

Camp stew is a winter staple in Alabama and can be served as a side dish or the main course. It is often cooked outdoors over a campfire or in a Dutch oven. The dish is usually made with canned goods, making it convenient for camping trips. However, some purists insist on using fresh, locally sourced ingredients.

Over time, camp stew recipes have evolved, and the more ignoble parts of the pig, such as the head, are no longer commonly used. Today, it is typical to use fresh pork or a small pig's head in camp stew. The dish is often served alongside cornbread, jalapeño cornbread muffins, Dutch oven bread, buttermilk biscuits, or homemade dinner rolls.

Camp stew is a beloved tradition in Alabama, and it is often associated with family gatherings, campfires, and fond memories of home cooking.

Brunswick stew is usually made with chicken or pork

Brunswick stew is a tomato-based stew that usually contains beans, vegetables, and meat. While the exact origin of the dish is disputed, it is believed to have originated in the United States in either Virginia or Georgia and is named after those states' respective Brunswick County and city of Brunswick.

Over time, the types of meat used in Brunswick stew have evolved. Traditionally, the stew was made with small game meats such as squirrel, rabbit, or opossum. However, today, it is more commonly made with chicken or pork, reflecting a shift towards more easily accessible and familiar proteins.

In Virginia, chicken and rabbit are the more popular choices, while in Georgia, pork is the preferred option. This variation in meat choices has led to different styles of Brunswick stew, with each region putting its own twist on the dish.

Brunswick stew is a versatile dish that can be adapted to use a variety of meats. Some recipes call for using only chicken or pork, while others suggest a combination of the two. Additionally, beef is sometimes used as an additional protein, further adding to the customizability of the stew.

The use of chicken and pork in Brunswick stew provides a hearty and flavorful base that can be enhanced with various vegetables and seasonings. The meat is typically shredded or chopped and combined with ingredients like lima beans, corn, potatoes, onions, and barbecue sauce to create a rich and satisfying dish.

Frequently asked questions