East Brunswick's Best Pizza: A Slice Of Heaven

East Brunswick, New Jersey, is a pizza lover's paradise, offering a variety of mouth-watering options to satisfy any craving. From classic New York-style and Sicilian pies to unique creations like the popular Grandma Pizza, the pizzerias in this town will not disappoint. Whether you're a thin-crust enthusiast or a deep-dish devotee, East Brunswick has something to tantalize your taste buds.

When it comes to the best pizza in East Brunswick, NJ, several pizzerias stand out. One notable mention is Giddy's Pizzeria, known for its lively atmosphere and delicious thin-crust pies. Their extensive menu offers something for everyone, including seafood dishes and kid-friendly options. Michelangelo's Pizza is another local favourite, serving the community for over 15 years with exceptional food and service. Their thin-crust Neapolitan pizzas, loaded with fresh, high-quality ingredients, are a must-try.

For those seeking a more traditional experience, Stefano's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria and Mancini Brooklyn Pizza deliver authentic Italian flavours. If you're craving something unique, Mi Bella Puebla Pizzeria & Mexican Cuisine offers a fusion of Mexican and Italian cuisine, while The Original Thin Crust Pizza Company, featured on NJ's official Pizza Trail, serves up super-thin crust pies.

With so many amazing pizzerias to choose from, East Brunswick is a destination for pizza enthusiasts looking to indulge in a slice of heaven.

Best delivery pizza

If you're looking for the best pizza delivery in East Brunswick, New Jersey, look no further than Michelangelo's Pizza. Voted the Best Thin-crust Pizza in the East Village NY City Festival in 2003, this pizzeria has been serving the local community and the South River area for over 15 years. Their menu features homemade creations prepared by skilled chefs using fresh and high-quality ingredients.

Try their Special Neapolitan Pizza, a tantalizing combination of mushrooms, pepperoni, peppers, and sausage. If you're feeling adventurous, opt for the Meat Lover's Neapolitan Pizza, loaded with five different meat toppings. Michelangelo's also offers a variety of slices, perfect for those who can't decide on just one topping. Don't forget to add a chef salad to your order, topped with provolone, ham, and turkey.

Another excellent option for pizza delivery in East Brunswick is Giddy's Pizzeria. With a lively atmosphere and colourful walls, Giddy's serves up delicious thin and crispy crusts with just the right amount of garlic. Their fresh ingredients and perfectly melted cheese will keep you coming back for more. Indulge in their dessert pizza for something unique – sweet dough topped with creamy Nutella and crunchy hazelnuts.

For a more extensive range of options, Mancini Pizza is a great choice. They offer online ordering and are open 7 days a week for your convenience. Mancini's uses fresh ingredients and provides friendly service, ensuring a brilliant dining experience.

If you're willing to travel a little further, you can find Pappagallos Pizzeria Restaurant in Highland Park, about 5 miles away. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, Pappagallos offers delicious pizza with fresh ingredients, a perfect ratio of sauces to cheese, and a friendly staff.

So, whether you're a thin-crust enthusiast or a cheese and pepperoni traditionalist, these pizza spots in and around East Brunswick, New Jersey, have got you covered for your next pizza delivery craving.

Best takeout pizza

If you're looking for the best takeout pizza in East Brunswick, New Jersey, look no further than Giddy's Pizzeria. With its extensive menu, Giddy's offers almost everything you'd expect from a pizzeria. Their Margherita Pizza, topped with basil pesto, parmesan, fresh garlic, and mozzarella on a thin Sicilian crust, is a standout option. The pizzeria also serves deep-dish, Sicilian, and Grandma-style pizzas if you're looking for a more traditional East Brunswick pizza experience.

Another great option for takeout pizza is Mancini Brooklyn Pizza, which serves delicious pizza and has received praise for its friendly staff and outstanding service.

For those who enjoy thin-crust pizza, East Brunswick's The Original Thin Crust Pizza Company is a must-visit, having been featured on NJ's official pizza trail. Owner Matt Verney serves up a super-thin crust with a spin on a 60-year-old family recipe.

Other notable mentions for the best takeout pizza in East Brunswick include Brothers Pizzeria, Maria's Pizza & Subs, and Stefano's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria.

Best pizza near East Brunswick

East Brunswick, New Jersey, is a great place to visit for pizza lovers. The town offers a variety of pizza styles, including New York-style, Sicilian, New Jersey-style, Grandma, and deep-dish pizzas. The most popular type of pizza in East Brunswick is Grandma Pizza, which originated in the town in 1979 when Brothers Pizza was opened by Italian immigrants. This style of pizza features a thin crust topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, and it is baked in a regular oven instead of a traditional pizza oven.

If you're looking for the best pizza near East Brunswick, there are several options to consider:

J&J Restaurant & Pizzeria in South River

The town of South River is just two miles from East Brunswick, and J&J Restaurant & Pizzeria is known for its unique pizza offerings. One of their standout pies is the Caesar Salad Pizza, topped with grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, croutons, and Caesar dressing. If you're a meat lover, the J&J Famous Special Pizza is loaded with meat and veggie toppings.

Rustoni's Pizza in Sayreville

Located about four miles northeast of East Brunswick in Sayreville, Rustoni's Pizza offers a variety of gourmet pan pizzas with interesting toppings. Their chicken toppings come in a range of flavors, including BBQ sauce, lemon and wine sauce, ranch dressing, and buffalo sauce.

Mancini Brooklyn Pizza in East Brunswick

Mancini Brooklyn Pizza is a popular spot for both locals and visitors. They use fresh ingredients and offer friendly service. While they serve more than just pizza, their pizzas are delicious and have received positive reviews from customers.

Giddy's Pizzeria in East Brunswick

Giddy's Pizzeria, located in East Brunswick, offers a wide range of menu options, including seafood dishes and kid-friendly choices. Their pizzas are highly regarded, especially their Margherita Pizza, which features a thin Sicilian crust topped with basil pesto, parmesan, fresh garlic, and mozzarella. They also offer a local favorite, the Grandma Pizza, as well as deep-dish pizza.

The Original Thin Crust Pizza Company in East Brunswick

Featured on NJ's official Pizza Trail, The Original Thin Crust Pizza Company is a must-visit destination for thin-crust pizza lovers. Owner Matt Verney uses a 60-year-old family recipe to create super-thin crust pizzas that are hard to find elsewhere.

Whether you're a resident of East Brunswick or just visiting, these pizzerias are sure to satisfy your pizza cravings!

Best Sicilian pizza

When it comes to Sicilian pizza, East Brunswick has a lot to offer. The town is known for its delicious New York-style, Sicilian, New Jersey-style, Grandma, and deep-dish pizzas. While Grandma Pizza is the most popular in many pizzerias, there are several places that offer mouth-watering Sicilian pizza.

One option is Giddy's Pizzeria, which offers a Margherita Pizza on a thin Sicilian crust. The crust is topped with basil pesto, parmesan, fresh garlic, and mozzarella. The pizzeria has been serving mouth-watering pizza since 2014 and offers an extensive menu, including seafood dishes and a kid's menu.

Another option is Franks Pizza & Italian Restaurant, which offers a wide variety of pizzas, including several Sicilian options. Their Plain Cheese Sicilian Pizza and Extra Cheese Sicilian Pizza are classic choices, but they also offer more unique options like the Mushrooms Sicilian Pizza, Pepperoni Sicilian Pizza, and Meatball Sicilian Pizza. The restaurant has been a local favourite for many years and also offers a range of other Italian dishes.

For a more unique take on Sicilian pizza, you can try Mancini Pizza. They offer a variety of unique and delicious pizzas, pasta, salads, and wraps. While they don't specify a Sicilian pizza, their focus on fresh ingredients and unique flavours makes them worth considering.

Finally, Stefano's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is another great choice for Sicilian pizza. They offer a cosy atmosphere and a variety of Italian dishes, including pizza and appetisers. While they don't specify a Sicilian pizza on their menu, they do offer a New York-style pizza with plentiful toppings, which may include a Sicilian option.

So, while there are several contenders for the best Sicilian pizza in East Brunswick, the final decision comes down to personal preference for crust thickness, toppings, and overall dining experience.

Best pizzeria atmosphere

When it comes to the best pizzeria atmosphere in East Brunswick, NJ, there are several contenders that offer a warm and inviting ambiance. Here's a detailed look at some of the top spots:

Giddy's Pizzeria

Giddy's Pizzeria stands out for its lively atmosphere. The walls are painted bright colours, and the pizzeria always has great music playing in the background. Their extensive menu offers something for everyone, including classic pizza options and unique creations like the Margherita Pizza on a thin Sicilian crust, topped with basil pesto, parmesan, fresh garlic, and mozzarella.

Mancini Brooklyn Pizza

Mancini Brooklyn Pizza provides a friendly and inviting atmosphere. They use fresh ingredients and offer high-quality food and services. Customers rave about the brilliant pizza and the friendly kitchen staff, making it a popular spot for both lunch and dinner.

The Original Thin Crust Pizza Company

Featured on NJ's official Pizza Trail, this pizzeria is a must-visit for thin-crust pizza lovers. The dining atmosphere is true to its name, serving up super-thin crust pizzas made from a 60-year-old family recipe. Owner Matt Verney puts his own spin on the traditional recipe, creating a unique dining experience.

Stefano's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Stefano's offers a relaxed yet slightly nicer atmosphere than your average pizza shop. They serve a variety of pizza styles, including the popular Grandma Pizza, a thin-crust pizza with a pungent garlic taste, topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese. Stefano's is a great choice for those seeking a casual dining experience with delicious food.

Michelangelo's Pizza

Michelangelo's Pizza is an East Brunswick favourite, serving the community for over 15 years. They offer exceptional service and food, with skilled chefs preparing homemade creations using fresh and high-quality ingredients. Their thin-crust pizza was even voted the best in the East Village NY City Festival in 2003.

These pizzerias in East Brunswick, NJ, excel in creating a welcoming and enjoyable atmosphere for their customers, ensuring that their dining experience goes beyond just the taste of the pizza. Each pizzeria has its unique charm, contributing to the overall appeal of the town's pizza scene.

Frequently asked questions