New Brunswick's Debt: A Provincial Concern

New Brunswick's debt, displayed on DebtClock.ca as the province's Net Debt, is a growing concern for the Canadian province. With a projected increase of $183.3 million during the 2023-24 fiscal year, New Brunswick's debt situation is limiting its ability to respond to economic crises such as the COVID-19 pandemic. The province's heavy debt load and limited fiscal capacity have sparked calls for increased spending to support economic recovery, but this approach is not without its challenges. New Brunswick's debt-to-GDP ratio is below that of several other provinces, and it is one of the few provinces expecting to run surpluses in the medium term. However, the surplus is narrowing, and the province's ability to maintain this trajectory depends on strong economic growth.

New Brunswick's net debt to increase by $183.3 million in 2023-24

New Brunswick's net debt is expected to increase by $183.3 million during the 2023-24 fiscal year. This is despite the province's healthy fiscal position, with a FY 2023/24 surplus of about 0.5% of GDP, and a debt-to-GDP ratio lower than several other provinces. New Brunswick is projected to run small surpluses over the next few years, although this relies on strong economic growth being maintained.

The increase in net debt is due to robust program spending growth, which is outpacing revenue gains. The budget includes a significant increase in spending on Education and Early Childhood Development, with a 12% bump in funding. There is also increased funding for "Social Development" and healthcare, with $30 million allocated for wage increases in the health and long-term care sector.

Despite the increase in net debt, New Brunswick's fiscal situation remains healthy compared to other provinces. The province's debt ratio is projected to drop to 25.6% by FY 2026/27, and its low debt burden places it in a favourable position compared to other parts of Canada. New Brunswick's prudent financial management has also allowed for tax relief for the third year in a row, with reductions in personal income taxes across almost all income levels.

The province's success in managing its debt and finances is due to its disciplined approach to spending. New Brunswick has avoided the temptation to borrow money and spend excessively, which has paid off in the long run. The government has been restrained with its spending, with per-person spending only growing by $447 between 2017/18 and 2023/24, in contrast to other provinces that have increased spending by much larger amounts.

New Brunswick's debt sustainability

New Brunswick's finances are currently considered unsustainable, with a ""fiscal gap" of 0.6% of the provincial economy. This means that the government must either increase revenue or cut spending by this amount to achieve long-term sustainability. The pandemic and economic downturn, along with increased government spending, a shrinking economy, and lower projected government revenues, have contributed to the province's large budget deficit and rising debt.

According to the Parliamentary Budget Officer (PBO), a government's policies are sustainable if they result in a province's debt-to-GDP ratio declining or staying flat over time. If the ratio continues to grow, finances are considered unsustainable. In the case of New Brunswick, the debt-to-GDP ratio has been impacted by the pandemic, with the province facing a budget deficit once again.

Before the pandemic, the province had different fiscal prospects. The 2019-20 budget, for instance, expected a third consecutive operating surplus and the first reduction to net debt in over a decade. However, circumstances have changed significantly, and New Brunswick now faces challenges in restoring sustainability to its finances.

To address the debt-to-GDP ratio, the provincial government should consider reducing its size, as lower spending will slow debt accumulation. A smaller government can also have positive effects on economic growth, enhancing revenue generation. This is crucial, as New Brunswick has experienced lower growth than the national average, hindering its ability to balance its budget and generate revenue.

If New Brunswick fails to restore sustainability to its finances, future generations will bear the burden of today's debt accumulation through interest payments on government debt. These interest payments are estimated to cost $655 million this year and will continue to grow if the province's debt is not addressed. Therefore, developing a long-term plan to restore fiscal sustainability is essential to mitigate the impact on future generations.

The impact of COVID-19 on New Brunswick's debt

New Brunswick's finances have been impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic, with the province facing a large budget deficit and rising debt. The pandemic and the resulting economic downturn, increased government spending, shrinking economy, and lower government revenues have all contributed to this. While New Brunswick has had a relatively low number of COVID-19 cases and has shown spending restraint compared to other provinces, the long-term fiscal challenges are a significant concern.

According to the Parliamentary Budget Officer (PBO), a government's finances are considered unsustainable if its debt-to-GDP ratio is on track to keep growing. Unfortunately, New Brunswick's finances fall into this category, with a "fiscal gap" equal to 0.6% of the provincial economy. This means that the government will need to either raise revenue or cut spending to achieve long-term sustainability. The PBO's report highlights that New Brunswick's finances were already in a precarious state before the pandemic, with a net debt of $13.9 billion as of March 31, 2019, the largest debt load among the Maritime provinces.

The COVID-19 pandemic has limited New Brunswick's ability to respond to the economic crisis. The province's heavy debt load and limited fiscal capacity have restricted its ability to spend its way out of the pandemic-caused economic woes. This situation has led to calls for the province to borrow and spend more to match the recovery efforts of other provinces and support households and businesses affected by the pandemic. However, there are concerns that this approach could create more problems in the long run. New Brunswick's government has offered targeted assistance during the pandemic but has been reluctant to spend more freely, considering the long-term implications of adding to the province's debt problem.

Despite the challenges, New Brunswick has demonstrated fiscal responsibility during the pandemic. It was the only province in Canada to avoid borrowing money and incurring deeper debt during the COVID-19 crisis. The province has maintained spending restraint, ensuring that spending remains roughly in line with government revenues. As a result, New Brunswick has recorded a balanced budget and tax reductions, with a projected surplus of $40 million in 2023. This disciplined approach to managing public finances has put the province in a relatively strong financial position compared to its peers.

New Brunswick's debt compared to other provinces

New Brunswick's debt has been a growing concern since the 2008 financial crisis. The province's debt had been increasing for 12 straight years between 2007 and 2019, eventually doubling in size to $14 billion. In 2016, the debt reached 41% of the province's annual economic output, the worst in Atlantic Canada and the second-highest among all provinces after Quebec.

However, New Brunswick's government has since made significant strides in reducing its debt. By March 2023, the province's debt had declined to $11.6 billion, a reduction of $2.3 billion (16%) in three years. This is the largest reduction in debt by a Canadian provincial government in 40 years, barring Alberta's achievement of eliminating its debt entirely over seven years in the 1990s.

The success of New Brunswick's debt reduction efforts has sparked a debate on whether to save or increase spending on struggling public services. Critics argue that the money could be used to fund areas such as housing and healthcare. Nevertheless, the downward trajectory of the province's debt levels has impressed financial analysts, leading to an upgrade in New Brunswick's credit rating.

When compared to other provinces, New Brunswick's debt situation has stood out. A Moncton economist, Richard Saillant, compared the increase in net debt per capita between 2014-15 and 2017-18 for four provinces: Quebec, Prince Edward Island, Nova Scotia, and New Brunswick. While the other three provinces showed a decrease or stability in their debt per capita, New Brunswick experienced an increase of about $1,200 net debt per capita during this period. This increase contributed to a growing financial burden on future generations, according to Saillant.

In summary, while New Brunswick has made remarkable progress in reducing its debt in recent years, it has faced challenges when compared to other provinces. The province's debt levels and trajectory have been a cause for concern, with economists warning of an unsustainable path if changes are not made.

The role of the government in managing New Brunswick's debt

The government of New Brunswick faces a challenging task in managing the province's debt and restoring fiscal sustainability. According to the Parliamentary Budget Officer (PBO), a government's finances are deemed sustainable if their debt-to-GDP ratio decreases or remains stable over time. Conversely, if the debt grows faster than the economy, finances are considered unsustainable.

Unfortunately, New Brunswick's finances have been assessed as unsustainable, with a "fiscal gap" of 0.6% of the provincial economy. This means that the government must make difficult choices to achieve long-term sustainability, either by raising revenues or cutting spending. The pandemic and economic downturn have contributed to the province's financial challenges, with increased government spending and lower projected revenues.

To address the fiscal gap, the New Brunswick government may consider reducing the size of the provincial government, as this could help slow down debt accumulation and have less adverse effect on economic growth. Additionally, the government should focus on enhancing revenue generation, as economic growth is expected to remain low in the coming years, impacting the province's ability to balance its budget.

The consequences of failing to restore fiscal sustainability are significant. Future generations of New Brunswickers will bear the burden of today's debt accumulation through interest payments on government debt. These interest payments will consume resources that could otherwise be invested in critical areas such as healthcare, education, and tax relief. Therefore, it is imperative for the provincial government to develop a comprehensive long-term plan to manage its debt and ensure a sustainable future for its residents.

Frequently asked questions