Austria's Edict Of Tolerance: A Historical Perspective

The Edict of Tolerance, also known as the Edict of Toleration, was a decree issued by Emperor Joseph II of Austria on 13 October 1781, with an additional edict for the Jewish population issued on 2 January 1782. The Edict of Tolerance was part of a series of comprehensive reforms by Joseph II, known as Josephinism, aimed at remodelling Austria into an ideal Enlightened state. The edict granted religious freedom to non-Catholic Christians, including Lutherans, Calvinists, and the Eastern Orthodox, allowing them to practice their faith openly and marking a significant shift towards religious tolerance during the Age of Enlightenment.

The 1781 Patent of Toleration

The Patent of Toleration was a significant step towards religious tolerance, reflecting the Age of Enlightenment's ideals of reason, individual liberty, and the separation of church and state. It granted religious freedom to non-Catholic Christians, including Lutherans, Calvinists, and the Eastern Orthodox, allowing them to practice their faith openly. This marked the first time after the Counter-Reformation that the practice of non-Catholic religions was guaranteed in Austria.

While the Patent extended religious freedom, worship was still heavily regulated. For example, wedding ceremonies remained under the jurisdiction of the Catholic Church, and the construction of churches by minority faiths was constrained. These regulations on church buildings were not abolished until after the revolutions of 1848. The Patent also addressed mixed-faith marriages, stating that if the father was Catholic, the children had to be raised Catholic, while if the mother was Catholic, only the daughters had to be raised in that faith.

The 1782 Edict of Tolerance

The Edict of Tolerance extended religious freedom to the Jewish population. This was a significant milestone, as it was the first step towards Jewish emancipation in Europe. However, it did not grant full citizenship to Jews in the Austrian Empire. The Edict allowed Jewish children to attend schools and universities, and adults to pursue various occupations, such as merchants or factory owners. Jews could also learn trades but were not allowed to become master craftsmen.

The Edict of 1782 eliminated some previous restrictions on Jews, such as forcing them to wear gold stars or pay a special tax. However, it also imposed new requirements. For example, Jews were required to use the national language of the country instead of Hebrew or Yiddish, and their immigration into Austria was severely restricted. Official documents and textbooks could not be printed in Hebrew. The Edict also abolished the autonomy of Jewish communities, requiring them to adopt stable German names and be subject to military conscription.

The impact on religious minorities

The Edict of Tolerance, issued by Emperor Joseph II of Austria in 1781, had a significant impact on religious minorities in the country. This decree, also known as the Patent of Toleration, granted religious freedom to non-Catholic Christians, including Lutherans, Calvinists, and Serbian Orthodox believers. It allowed them to practice their faith openly, build churches, and educate their children according to their beliefs. The edict also removed civil disabilities that these religious minorities had previously faced in Austrian domains.

One of the most notable effects of the Edict of Tolerance was the empowerment of previously marginalized religious groups, particularly Protestant and Orthodox Christians. They gained increased freedoms, such as the ability to establish places of worship and access education that aligned with their religious beliefs. This marked a significant shift towards religious tolerance during the Age of Enlightenment, reflecting the ideals of individual liberty and the separation of church and state.

The impact of the edict extended beyond religious practices. Religious minorities now had the right to hold public office and engage in trade, industry, and commerce. They were also admitted to universities, which further enhanced their opportunities for social and economic advancement. These changes enabled greater participation and integration of religious minorities into civic life, reducing some of the previous social and economic barriers they faced.

However, it is important to note that the edict did not grant complete equality to all religious minorities. While it improved their legal status, certain restrictions remained in place. For example, congregations were limited to no more than 100 people in a private home, and there were specific regulations regarding the construction of churches. Additionally, the edict faced scrutiny and opposition from conservative elements within the Catholic Church, who resisted the reduction of the Church's influence on state affairs.

The impact of the Edict of Tolerance on the Jewish population in Austria is also worth highlighting. While they gained some freedoms, such as the elimination of discriminatory restrictions and the ability to attend schools and universities, they still faced significant limitations. Immigration of new Jews into Austria was severely restricted, and they were not allowed to become master craftsmen. Additionally, the edict mandated that Jewish languages, such as Hebrew and Yiddish, be replaced by the national language, impacting their cultural expression.

The long-term significance

The 1782 Edict of Tolerance, issued by Emperor Joseph II of Austria, was a significant step towards religious tolerance and pluralism in Europe. It extended the freedoms granted by the 1781 Patent of Toleration to the Jewish population, allowing them to pursue all branches of commerce and attend schools and universities. This edict, along with the previous one, reflected the ideals of the Age of Enlightenment, promoting reason, individual liberty, and the separation of church and state.

The Edict of Tolerance was part of Joseph II's comprehensive reforms of the Austrian Empire, known as Josephinism, which aimed to remodel Austria into an ideal Enlightened state. These reforms included the Patent of Toleration, which granted religious freedom to non-Catholic Christians, and the Edict of Tolerance, which extended these freedoms to the Jewish population. The edicts allowed recognised religions to hold congregations of up to 100 people in private homes and build churches under specific conditions.

The Edict of Tolerance had a significant impact on the Jewish community in Austria, who had previously been treated harshly. While it did not grant full citizenship, it was a milestone in Jewish emancipation in Europe, creating new economic and educational opportunities for the Jewish population. It eliminated some previous restrictions on Jews, such as wearing gold stars or paying specific taxes, and allowed them to attend schools and universities. However, it also imposed new requirements, such as the abolition of Hebrew and Yiddish in favour of the national language.

The Edict of Tolerance, along with the Patent of Toleration, faced significant opposition from the Catholic Church and conservative factions within the empire. Despite this resistance, these edicts represented a shift towards secular governance and the reduction of the influence of the Catholic Church on state affairs. However, after Joseph II's death in 1790, his policies were reversed, highlighting the challenges of implementing Enlightenment ideals in a deeply religious society.

The limits of the Edict

The Edict of Tolerance, issued by Emperor Joseph II of Austria in 1782, was a significant step towards religious freedom and tolerance. However, it had certain limitations that restricted its impact on Jewish and non-Catholic communities.

While the Edict granted religious freedom to non-Catholic Christians, including Lutherans, Calvinists, and the Eastern Orthodox, their worship was heavily regulated. They were only permitted to hold private religious exercises in clandestine churches, and their places of worship could not resemble traditional church buildings. Wedding ceremonies, for instance, were reserved for the Catholic Church. Furthermore, if a Catholic man had children with a non-Catholic woman, all the children were to be raised Catholic. In contrast, if a Catholic woman married a non-Catholic man, only the daughters were raised Catholic, while the sons could follow their father's faith.

The Edict of Tolerance for Jews in 1782 extended their freedom to pursue various occupations and attend schools. However, they still faced several restrictions. Jews were required to send their children to German-language primary schools or Christian schools, and while they could attend state secondary schools, they were not allowed to become master craftsmen. The Edict aimed to reduce their involvement in finance, petty trade, and other economic activities deemed undesirable. Additionally, Jews had no right to public worship or printing presses, and their immigration into Austria was severely restricted.

Frequently asked questions