Austrian Economics: Conservative Or Classical Liberal?

The Austrian School of Economics has been branded as a radical laissez-faire wing within the economics profession, with some commentators even deeming it more right-wing than Milton Friedman. The school, founded in 1871 by Carl Menger, a Viennese economist, is characterised by its strict adherence to methodological individualism, the concept that social phenomena are primarily the result of individual motivations, actions, and self-interest. This school of thought has influenced many contemporary economists and stands in contrast to other schools of economic thought, such as the neoclassical and German historical schools. While the label Austrian may no longer hold substantive meaning, the ideas and influence of this school persist in the economic theories of today.

The Austrian School of Economics is heterodox and advocates for methodological individualism

The Austrian School's roots can be traced back to 1871 and the work of Carl Menger, Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk, and Friedrich von Wieser in Vienna, Austria-Hungary. Menger's book, "Principles of Economics," published that year, is considered the founding text of the school. In it, Menger argued for the universality of economic laws and the importance of individual choices and subjective preferences in shaping economic outcomes. This put the Austrian School at odds with the dominant German Historical School, which focused on detailed historical examination rather than universal principles.

The Austrian School's commitment to methodological individualism has led to several key insights and propositions that set it apart from other economic schools of thought. Firstly, they argue that prices are determined by subjective factors, such as an individual's preference to buy or not buy a particular good, rather than objective costs of production or equilibrium between supply and demand. Secondly, they emphasize the heterogeneity of capital goods, arguing that they cannot be treated as homogeneous and perfectly substitutable in economic models. Thirdly, they believe that interest rates are determined by individuals' time preferences rather than the supply and demand of capital.

The Austrian School's approach to economics has had a significant influence on the field, with many of its early concepts being absorbed into mainstream economics. However, it has also faced criticism and rejection from mainstream economists due to its rejection of model-building and mathematical and statistical methods. Despite this, the Austrian School continues to have a dedicated following, with universities, institutes, and think tanks promoting its ideas and contributions to economic thought.

It originated in Vienna in 1871 with the work of Carl Menger and others

The Austrian School of Economics was founded in 1871 in Vienna, Austria-Hungary, with the publication of Carl Menger's book, 'Principles of Economics'. Menger's work, along with that of his contemporaries, Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk and Friedrich von Wieser, is considered the foundation of the Austrian School.

Menger's book was one of the first modern treatises to advance the theory of marginal utility, which states that the economic value of goods and services is subjective in nature, and that with an increase in the number of goods, their subjective value for an individual decreases. This theory became one of the pillars of the marginalist revolution in economic analysis. Menger argued that economic analysis is universally applicable and that individual choices, determined by subjective preferences and the margin on which decisions are made, are the essential building blocks of a universally valid economic theory.

The Austrian School was methodologically opposed to the Historical School, which dominated economic thinking in German-language countries at the time. The Historical School argued that economic science could not generate universal principles and that research should focus on detailed historical examination. This dispute between the two schools became known as the 'Methodenstreit' or methodology quarrel.

Menger's work was particularly opposed by Gustav Schmoller, a leader of the Historical School, who gave the derogatory name 'Austrian School' to the work of Menger and his followers, due to their faculty positions at the University of Vienna. Despite the negative connotations intended by Schmoller, the label endured and was eventually adopted by Menger and his adherents themselves.

The Austrian School owes its name and origin to this dispute with the German Historical School, and the University of Vienna played a central role in its early development.

It is often considered a radical laissez-faire wing within the economics profession

The Austrian School of Economics has long been branded as a radical laissez-faire wing within the economics profession. In fact, it is considered much more "right-wing" than Milton Friedman, the profession's most recognised advocate of the free market. The Austrian School is a heterodox school of economic thought that advocates strict adherence to methodological individualism, the concept that social phenomena result primarily from the motivations and actions of individuals along with their self-interest. Austrian-school theorists hold that economic theory should be exclusively derived from basic principles of human action.

The Austrian School was founded in 1871 with the publication of Carl Menger's Principles of Economics. Menger, along with William Stanley Jevons and Leon Walras, developed the marginalist revolution in economic analysis. Menger dedicated Principles of Economics to his German colleague William Roscher, the leading figure in the German Historical School, which dominated economic thinking in German-language countries. In his book, Menger argued that economic analysis is universally applicable and that the appropriate unit of analysis is man and his choices. These choices, he wrote, are determined by individual subjective preferences and the margin on which decisions are made. The logic of choice, he believed, is the essential building block to the development of a universally valid economic theory.

The Austrian School uses the logic of a priori thinking to discover economic laws of universal application, whereas other mainstream schools of economics make use of data and mathematical models. The Austrian School holds that prices are determined by subjective factors like an individual's preference to buy or not to buy a particular good, whereas the classical school of economics holds that objective costs of production determine the price, and the neoclassical school holds that prices are determined by the equilibrium of demand and supply. The Austrian School rejects both the classical and neoclassical views, saying that costs of production are also determined by subjective factors based on the value of alternative uses of scarce resources, and the equilibrium of demand and supply is also determined by subjective individual preferences.

The Austrian School views the market mechanism as a process and not an outcome of a design. People create markets with their intention to better their lives, not by any conscious decision. So, if you leave a bunch of amateurs on a deserted island, sooner or later, their interactions would lead to the creation of a market mechanism. The Austrian School believes it is possible to discover the truth simply by thinking aloud. Interestingly, this group does have unique insights into some of the most important economic issues of our times.

It uses a priori thinking and logic to discover economic laws of universal application

The Austrian School of Economics uses a priori thinking and logic to discover economic laws of universal application. This means that they believe it is possible to discover economic truths simply by thinking aloud and conducting "thought experiments", rather than relying on data and mathematical models like mainstream schools of economics. This approach is known as methodological individualism, which holds that economic theory should be derived exclusively from basic principles of human action.

The Austrian School argues that economic analysis is universally applicable and that the appropriate unit of analysis is an individual and their choices. These choices are determined by subjective factors, such as individual preferences, values, and expectations. By understanding the logic of choice, they believe it is possible to develop a universally valid economic theory.

This sets the Austrian School apart from other economic schools, such as the German Historical School, which rejects the universal application of economic theorems and focuses on detailed historical examination instead. The Austrian School also differs from the classical school of economics, which holds that objective costs of production determine prices, and the neoclassical school, which argues that prices are determined by the equilibrium of demand and supply.

The Austrian School's approach to economic analysis has led to valuable insights into various economic issues, including the laws of supply and demand, the cause of inflation, the theory of money creation, and the operation of foreign exchange rates. Their unique perspective has earned them a permanent place in the complex world of economic theory.

Overall, the Austrian School's use of a priori thinking and logic allows them to discover economic laws that they believe are universally applicable, providing a foundation for their economic theories and insights.

It emphasises the role of the market mechanism as a process, not an outcome of design

The Austrian School of Economics is a heterodox school of economic thought that advocates strict adherence to methodological individualism, the concept that social phenomena result primarily from the motivations and actions of individuals along with their self-interest. Austrian School economists believe that economic theory should be exclusively derived from basic principles of human action.

The Austrian School views the market mechanism as a process and not an outcome of design. People create markets with their intention to better their lives, not by any conscious decision. So, if you leave a bunch of amateurs on a deserted island, sooner or later, their interactions would lead to the creation of a market mechanism.

The Austrian School uses the logic of a priori thinking to discover economic laws of universal application, whereas other mainstream schools of economics make use of data and mathematical models. The Austrian School holds that prices are determined by subjective factors like an individual's preference to buy or not to buy a particular good, whereas the classical school of economics holds that objective costs of production determine the price and the neoclassical school holds that prices are determined by the equilibrium of demand and supply.

The Austrian School's approach to understanding economic phenomena is based on individual purposes and plans, with the primary task of making economic phenomena intelligible by basing them on individual purposes and plans. This is in contrast to other schools of economic thought, which have focused on aggregate variables, equilibrium analysis, and societal groups rather than individuals.

Frequently asked questions