South Tyrol: Italian Or Austrian? A Complex Cultural Identity

South Tyrol is an autonomous province in northern Italy. However, the region has a complex history that has seen its borders and culture shift between Italian and Austrian/Germanic influence.

The area now known as South Tyrol was inhabited by the Alpine population of the Raeti as far back as 15 BC when it was conquered by the Romans. Since then, it has been ruled by the Ostrogoths, the Lombards, the Bavarians, the Bishops of Brixen and Trento, the Prince-Bishopric of Trent, the Austrian Empire, the Kingdom of Italy, and finally, modern Italy.

South Tyrol was part of the Austro-Hungarian County of Tyrol until 1918 when it was annexed by Italy following Italy's victory against the Central Powers in World War I. During World War II, South Tyrol was briefly annexed by Nazi Germany before being restored to Italy in 1945.

Today, South Tyrol enjoys a high degree of autonomy and has strong relations with the Austrian state of Tyrol. While it is primarily Italian-speaking, German and Ladin are also recognised as official languages in the province.

South Tyrol's complex history

South Tyrol has a complex history, with its current status as an autonomous Italian province being the result of centuries of territorial disputes and shifting borders.

The region was first conquered by the Romans in 15 BC, with the northern and eastern parts incorporated into the provinces of Raetia and Noricum, and the southern part becoming part of Roman Italy. After changing hands several times over the centuries, South Tyrol became part of the Austro-Hungarian County of Tyrol until 1918. During World War I, the Allies promised the area to Italy in the Treaty of London in 1915, as an incentive to join the war on their side. Italy declared war against the Central Powers in 1915 and occupied South Tyrol in 1918. The area was formally annexed to the Kingdom of Italy in 1919, with the Treaty of Saint-Germain signed in 1919 ceding the territory to Italy.

The rise of Italian Fascism under Benito Mussolini led to the suppression of the German language and culture in South Tyrol, with German schools being closed and immigration from other Italian regions being encouraged. During World War II, South Tyrol was occupied by Nazi Germany and became part of the Operation Zone of the Alpine Foothills. After the war, the Allies decided that South Tyrol would remain a part of Italy, but with the condition that the German-speaking population be granted a significant level of self-government. This led to the creation of the Trentino-Alto Adige/Tiroler Etschland region, with German recognised as an official language alongside Italian.

However, the arrival of new Italian-speaking immigrants and dissatisfaction with the lack of self-governance led to tensions and terrorist acts by South Tyrolean liberation groups. This period of unrest, known as the South Tyrolean Question, became an international issue and was taken up by the United Nations in 1960. A new Austro-Italian treaty was signed in 1971, granting South Tyrol greater autonomy within Italy and stipulating that Austria would not interfere in its internal affairs. The separatist tensions eased with this new agreement, and South Tyrol has since enjoyed a high degree of autonomy and strong relations with the Austrian state of Tyrol.

The Ladin language

The precise extension of the Ladin language area is a subject of scholarly debate. While a narrower perspective includes only the dialects of the valleys around the Sella group, wider definitions comprise the dialects of adjacent valleys in the Province of Belluno and even dialects spoken in the northwestern Trentino.

Ladin is recognised as a minority language in 54 Italian municipalities. In the 2011 census, 20,548 inhabitants of South Tyrol declared Ladin as their native language. It is the third official language in some eastern municipalities of South Tyrol, along with German and Italian. Ladin is taught in schools and used in public offices, both in written and spoken forms.

The Italianisation policy

South Tyrol, an autonomous Italian province, was inhabited by a large German-speaking majority before its annexation in 1919. The Italianization programme, which aimed to assimilate the native populations, was particularly aggressive in South Tyrol. The fascist regime appointed Achille Starace and Ettore Tolomei to drive the Italianization programme. Tolomei's "program in 23 points" was adopted, and it included:

• The exclusive use of Italian in public offices and official capacities.
• Closure of most German schools.
• Incentives for immigrants from other Italian regions to settle in South Tyrol.
• Prohibition of the name "Südtirol" and "Deutsch-Südtirol".
• Italianization of German place names, public inscriptions, road names, and surnames.
• Removal of the Walther von der Vogelweide monument from Walther Square in Bolzano.
• Establishment of Italian nursery, primary, and secondary schools.
• Strict control of foreign university diplomas.
• Expansion of rail junctions to facilitate the Italianization of Alto Adige.
• Increase in military garrisons in Alto Adige.

The Italianization programme was especially forceful in schools, aiming to destroy the German school system. By 1928, Italian had become the only language of instruction in 760 South Tyrolean classes, affecting over 30,000 pupils. German teachers were dismissed or transferred to the south, and degrees from Austrian or German universities were only considered valid with an additional year at an Italian university. Religious instruction in Italian was made mandatory for Italianized schools, and Italian became mandatory for the last five classes in state schools.

In response, the German-speaking population established "Katakombenschulen" or "catacomb schools", clandestine home schools outside the Italianized standard educational system. German schoolbooks were smuggled across the border, and secret seminars for teacher instruction were organized throughout the province. Fascist countermeasures included searches, confiscations, imprisonments, and deportations.

The Italianization programme also extended to the German-language press, which was subjected to censorship and harassment by the authorities. In 1926, the fascist authorities began publishing their own German-language newspaper, the Alpenzeitung, and other German-language papers were forced to follow a strictly pro-regime editorial policy.

South Tyrol's autonomy

South Tyrol is an autonomous province in northern Italy, with a high degree of self-government. It is the wealthiest Italian province and one of the wealthiest in the European Union. The province has a population of about 534,000 inhabitants as of 2021, with its capital and largest city being Bolzano.

The South Tyrolean autonomy model is considered one of the most successful power-sharing arrangements in the world, thanks to its far-reaching autonomous powers and its implementation mechanisms. The model is designed to regulate the balance of power between the language groups with various measures, such as language equality, reserved positions, and proportionality in public service employment and public funding.

The province has a considerable level of self-government, with exclusive legislative and executive powers and a fiscal regime that allows it to retain 90% of revenue while remaining a net contributor to the national budget. The extensive self-government provided by the institutional framework has been advanced as a model for settling interethnic disputes and protecting linguistic minorities.

The South Tyrolean autonomy has a long history, dating back to the beginning of the 20th century when South Tyrol was part of the Austro-Hungarian Empire. In 1919, it was annexed by Italy following the Treaty of Saint-Germain-en-Laye. During the Fascist rule in Italy, South Tyrol underwent an intensive 'Italianisation' process, which included the prohibition of German language schools. After World War II, the 'Gruber-De Gasperi Agreement' between Italy and Austria guaranteed autonomous legislative and executive powers and regulations to safeguard the German minority.

The Second Autonomy Statute, enacted in 1972, transferred most of the legislative and administrative powers from the Autonomous Region Trentino-Alto Adige/South Tyrol to the Autonomous Province of Bolzano/Bozen. This statute is still in place today and forms the basis of South Tyrol's autonomy. The statute has constitutional rank, and its provisions cannot be interfered with or changed by ordinary law. It has been implemented through enactment decrees, bilateral negotiations with the state, special procedures, and cooperation mechanisms.

South Tyrol's strategic importance

South Tyrol has always been of great strategic importance due to its location between the Germanic north and the Italian south. It serves as a vital link between these two regions, with two important Alpine passes, Brenner and Reschen, connecting them. The region has been a significant trade route since ancient times, with the Via Claudia Augusta, a vital Roman road, crossing through it.

South Tyrol is home to over 800 castles and palaces, bearing witness to its historical significance. The region was ruled by the Habsburg Empire for over 550 years until the end of World War I, when it was annexed by Italy. This shift in sovereignty significantly influenced the culture of South Tyrol, resulting in a unique blend of German and Italian influences in its language, cuisine, and people's personalities.

South Tyrol is an autonomous province within Italy, enjoying a high degree of self-governance. It has its own legislative and executive powers, allowing it to make decisions independently from the central government in Rome. The region is the wealthiest province in Italy and one of the wealthiest in the European Union, with a strong economy and low unemployment rates.

The region is known for its mechanical engineering companies, with some global market leaders in sectors such as cable cars, wind energy, and snow-making technology. South Tyrol is also a major producer of agricultural products like apples and renowned for its wine.

South Tyrol is a vital transit point for freight transport between southern Germany and Northern Italy. The region is well-connected by road and rail, with important highways and railways passing through it, such as the Autostrada del Brennero and the Brenner Railway.

In summary, South Tyrol's strategic importance lies in its geographical location, historical background, autonomous governance, strong economy, and role as a key transit hub.

Frequently asked questions