Roatan: A Belizean Paradise Or Misplaced Identity?

Roatan and Belize are two Central American destinations that are often compared by travellers. Roatan is an island 30 miles off the north coast of Honduras, while Belize is a country located between Guatemala and Mexico. Both are popular for their beaches, diving spots, and water activities. However, they offer distinct experiences and have their own unique attractions.

Roatan and Belize can be visited together

Belize is an eco-tourist paradise, offering a diverse range of ecosystems, including dense jungles, secluded beaches, and the second-largest barrier reef in the world. Popular attractions include the Cockscomb Basin Wildlife Sanctuary & Jaguar Preserve, where you can find an array of wildlife, and the former capital, Belize City, which boasts beautiful Victorian buildings and a rich history.

Roatan, on the other hand, is known for its snorkelling and diving opportunities, with easy access to coral reefs and dive sites. The island also offers other activities such as ziplining, island culture tours, and exploring smaller settlements like Punta Gorda and Garifuna village.

When planning a trip to both locations, it's important to consider your interests and budget. Belize City, for example, is more expensive than Roatan, with an average daily cost of $88 per person, compared to $38 in Roatan. However, flights from the United States to Belize are quite frequent and convenient, with several airlines offering direct flights from major cities.

By combining a visit to Roatan and Belize, travellers can experience the best of both worlds, enjoying the natural beauty, cultural attractions, and adventure activities that each destination has to offer.

Roatan is part of Honduras

Roatan is an island in the Caribbean, located about 40 miles off the northern coast of Honduras. It is the largest of the Bay Islands of Honduras and is situated between the islands of Utila and Guanaja. Roatan is a popular tourist destination, known for its beautiful beaches, coral reefs, and scuba diving spots.

The island has a rich history, dating back to indigenous groups such as the Pech or Paya, who are believed to have arrived on the island around 600 AD. Christopher Columbus visited the neighbouring island of Guanaja on his fourth voyage in the early 1500s, and soon after, Europeans began raiding Roatan for slaves. The island became a resting stop for ships coming and going from Central America, attracting an array of settlers, traders, pirates, and military forces. Both the British and Spanish claimed the Bay Islands during their struggle for control of the Caribbean.

In the 19th century, the British formally claimed the Bay Islands and established settlements on Roatan. However, in the 1860s, the territory was ceded back to Honduras, and the islands became a department of Honduras. Today, Roatan is a Honduran municipality, with Coxen Hole as its capital. The island has two municipalities: José Santos Guardiola in the east and Roatan, including the Cayos Cochinos, in the west.

Roatan's culture is diverse, influenced by its history as a resting spot for ships and its time as a British colony. English is the first language of native islanders, with Spanish as the second, although Spanish usage has increased due to the influx of mainland Hondurans in recent decades. The island's culinary scene reflects its diverse influences, with a mix of cuisines from southern Mexico, Central America, the US Gulf Coast, and beyond.

Roatan has a tropical climate, with temperatures ranging from 70F to 80F throughout the year. The island experiences two main seasons: the Rainy Season, which occurs from October to January, and the Dry Season. The annual humidity is estimated at 77%, and the average year-round temperature is 80° F, making it a popular destination for sun-seekers and water sports enthusiasts.

With its stunning beaches, diverse culture, and array of water activities, Roatan continues to be a sought-after destination for travellers seeking a unique blend of history, natural beauty, and tropical charm.

Belize has beaches, but they're not great

Belize's beaches are rare and unique, and it's worth knowing their locations in advance so you don't arrive thinking every spot on the water will be a sun-soaked paradise. The Placencia Peninsula is home to the longest stretch of beach in mainland Belize, but even here, the waters aren't Caribbean turquoise. Instead, they are clear and refreshing.

Another popular beach destination in Belize is Secret Beach on Ambergris Caye. While it is certainly no longer a secret, it is a fun and accessible spot with calm, clear, and shallow waters that are great for snorkelling and other water activities. However, it can be a little rocky, and stingrays hide in the seagrass, so waterproof footwear is recommended.

Hopkins Village Beach, located in the eastern Garífuna village of Hopkins, is another quiet beach destination in Belize. This uninterrupted, 5-mile beach is lined with coconut trees, locals' homes, colourful guesthouses, and local eateries. However, the waters here are not crystal clear, but rather murky compared to the barrier reef.

Overall, while Belize does have some spectacular beaches, they are not your typical Caribbean white-sand paradises. The country offers a unique and diverse mix of coastline, from white sandy stretches to rocky shores, and the beach experience is often enhanced by the vibrant culture, food, and wildlife that Belize has to offer.

Roatan has better beaches than Belize

Roatan and Belize are two distinct destinations, each with its own unique appeal, but if you're seeking breathtaking beaches, Roatan might be the better choice. Here's why:

Beach Accessibility

Belize boasts a magnificent coastline along the Caribbean Sea and numerous offshore islands. However, many of its beaches are secluded and can only be reached by boat or plane. In contrast, Roatan offers more accessible beaches, with some of the best spots, like West Bay and Camp Bay, reachable by taxi or a short boat ride.

Beach Variety

Belize's beaches offer a diverse experience, ranging from golden and white sandy shores to rocky coastlines. While this variety is intriguing, Roatan's beaches are known for their pristine beauty, with soft, white sands and crystal-clear waters.

Snorkeling and Diving

Both destinations cater to snorkeling enthusiasts, but Roatan takes it a notch higher. Its beaches provide easy access to some of the most vibrant coral reefs and marine life in the region. The snorkeling and diving spots are just off the beach, eliminating the need for lengthy boat rides. Little French Key, West Bay, and Camp Bay are renowned for their exceptional snorkeling experiences.

Beach Amenities and Activities

Roatan's beaches offer a range of amenities and activities to suit different preferences. Beach clubs, bars, and restaurants are readily available for those seeking a lively atmosphere. For a more relaxed experience, there are secluded spots like Little French Key, which offers paddle boarding, kayaking, and snorkeling. Mayan Key, another popular beach, provides a romantic setting for couples.

Wildlife and Nature

Roatan and Belize both offer opportunities to explore wildlife and nature. Belize's Cockscomb Basin Wildlife Sanctuary is home to a diverse array of wildlife, including jaguars, ocelots, and monkeys. Roatan, on the other hand, allows you to witness an array of marine life, including rays, turtles, and even dolphins, without venturing far from the beach.

In conclusion, while Belize has its own allure, Roatan stands out for beachgoers seeking a combination of natural beauty, accessibility, and a variety of activities. Its beaches cater to families, couples, and adventure seekers alike, making it a prime choice for an unforgettable beach vacation.

Roatan has good snorkelling

Roatan is a popular destination for snorkelling, with its fringing barrier reef, rich marine life and clear waters. It is considered one of the top snorkelling destinations in the Caribbean. The island boasts stunning and pristine snorkelling spots, with sightings of queen angelfish, sea turtles and displays of soft coral in crystal-clear water.

Roatan is the biggest of the Bay Islands, a small Honduran archipelago located about 30 miles off the mainland coast. The island is almost 50 miles long and 5 miles wide, with a northwest coast bordered by a breathtaking coral reef, which offers world-class snorkelling experiences, especially in West Bay. The West End and West Bay area, in the west of the island, is the hotspot for snorkelling in Roatan. West Bay reef is healthy and easily accessible from the beach, making it a great location for beginners and families with young children. The southern end of the bay is where the reef is closest to the shore. Swim along the rocks on the left and then out to the reef drop-off, where you will find colourful corals, parrotfish, blue tang, surgeonfish, queen angelfish and butterflyfish.

Half Moon Bay in the village of West End is another top snorkelling spot, known for its wide variety of marine life. You can explore the iron shore on both sides of the bay and the West End Reef, located about 700 feet from the beach. The southern side is calmer and offers easier access to the reef. As you swim out, you can view seahorses and octopi on the right side of the bay and squid and starfish on the left. As you near the reef, you’ll be able to spot sea fans, sea whips and hundreds of fish, such as hogfish, butterflyfish and filefish.

Starfish Alley, located between West Bay and West End, is known for its abundance of cushion sea stars. They are found near the beach, in less than 3 feet of water.

The French Key reef is located within the French Cay Marine Park on the south coast of Roatan. You’ll need to pay a fee of around $30 per person to access this site, but it offers crystal-clear waters, a healthy reef and bountiful aquatic life. The resorts on the private islands of Little French Key and Big French Key, as well as the Fantasy Island Beach Resort, offer snorkelling tours that include gear rentals, boat transportation and stops at the area’s best snorkel spots.

With a healthy reef, diverse sea life and minimal boat traffic, Sandy Bay on the northern side of the island is packed with fantastic places to snorkel. Spooky Channel and Anthony’s Key are two of the area’s top snorkel sites. Spooky Channel is a cut in the reef that offers the chance to see vibrant corals, large groupers and parrotfish. This site is best for strong swimmers with prior snorkelling experience due to the depth, distance from shore and potential currents.

Roatan offers year-round snorkelling, with the best conditions between February and August. The temperatures are fairly consistent all year round, with an average of 78°F (25.5°C) in winter and 84°F (28.8°C) in summer. The sea is warm all year round, with temperatures of 82-84°F (28-29°C), so there is no need to pack a wetsuit. However, sun protection is important as it is easy to get sunburnt.

Frequently asked questions