Belarus: Navigating High Ambiguity Tolerance In Society

Belarusians are traditionally thought to be tolerant, but this is not entirely accurate. While Belarusians are known for their respect for other nations and their cultures, they are not very high on international rankings of tolerance. This is attributed to the influence of the Soviet era, when anything different or foreign was considered an enemy.

Belarusians value peace above everything else. They are patient, fatalistic, and conformist, perhaps due to the harsh and risky agricultural practices they historically engaged in. They are also individualistic and collectivist at the same time, perhaps due to their history of living in marshy, wooded landscapes where families had to rely on themselves but also help each other.

Belarusians are not very expressive and are comfortable with ambiguity. They are not quick to judge and are slow to take action, preferring to observe and think things through. They are also averse to risk and are slow to trust.

Belarusians are generally tolerant of other cultures and beliefs

Peace as the Highest Value

Belarusians in the 21st century value peace above everything else. This is reflected in their toasts, hymns, and everyday conversations. They have a long history of fighting in wars despite not initiating them, which may explain their strong aversion to conflict.

Respect for Other Nations and Cultures

Unlike many nations, Belarusians have never felt a sense of superiority over others or believed that they had to impose their way of living on other nations. They have also never rushed to extremes and rarely migrated until the 20th century. Instead, they focused on their families, friends, and local communities. This mentality is often blamed for the vagueness and ambivalence of Belarusian national identity, but it is also credited for the existence of a distinct Belarusian culture despite influences from neighbouring countries like Poland and Russia.

Belarusians have historically respected other nations and their cultures. During the time of the Great Duchy of Lithuania, Belarusians, Lithuanians, Ukrainians, Jews, and Tatars lived together peacefully despite their different religious views, traditions, and languages. This tradition of tolerance continues today, and Belarus is a rare place where antisemitism has never been an issue.

Indifference to National, Social, and Political Causes

Belarusians tend to be indifferent to national, social, and political causes, which may be seen as a lack of engagement or a form of passive resistance. This indifference has allowed them to preserve their culture despite outside influences. It has also made them less likely to stand out or attract attention, which was a survival strategy during Soviet times when standing out often meant suffering or even death.

Collectivism and Individualism

Belarusian society exhibits a mix of collectivist and individualist values. On the one hand, families tended to settle far from each other due to the marshy and wooded landscape, so each family had to rely on itself for survival. On the other hand, it was important to be "like everyone else" and to help each other when possible. This dynamic continues today, with Belarusians reporting a preference for collectivist values while also being introverted and uncomfortable with teamwork.

Patience and Fatalism

Belarusians are known for their patience, which may be due to the harsh and risky agricultural practices that characterised their early history. They had to work hard and be patient to survive, and their success depended on factors beyond their control, like the weather. This led to a fatalistic approach to life, where they learned to accept things as they were rather than trying to change them.

Traditionality and Conformism

In the conditions of harsh and risky agriculture, novelty was unwelcome and seen as too risky. Instead, it was safer to repeat the practices of previous generations. This practical conformism extended to behaviour patterns, values, and beliefs, and it helped preserve Belarusian traditions despite outside influences like Christianity and communism.

While Belarusians are generally tolerant of other cultures and beliefs, their society is not without its issues. They rank low on international rankings of tolerance, which is attributed to the influence of Soviet times when anything foreign or different was considered an enemy. There is also a lack of engagement with national, social, and political causes, which can be seen as indifference but may also be a form of passive resistance.

Belarusians value peace above all else

Belarusians have fought in many wars, but these were not of their initiation. Their mentality is heavily integrated with the indifference to national, social, and political causes. They are more concerned with the well-being of their family and friends. This mentality is often blamed for the vagueness and ambivalence of the Belarusian national identity. However, it is also credited for the existence of a Belarusian national identity: by separating themselves from whatever was happening beyond their village, they made it impossible for Poles and Russians to overwhelm and take over their culture.

Belarusians have historically respected other nations and their cultures. During the times of the Great Duchy of Lithuania, Belarusians, Lithuanians, Ukrainians, Jews, and Tatars lived together in peace, sharing different religious views, traditions, and languages. Belarus is a rare place where antisemitism was never an issue.

Belarusians are patient and fatalistic, perhaps due to the harsh and risky agriculture they practiced, which required work and patience, and where loads depended on the weather. They are also traditional and conformist. In such conditions, labour required repeating what had been done for generations before, rather than learning and experimenting. This attitude extrapolated to how Belarusians valued patterns of behaviour, beliefs, and values.

Unlike members of low-ambiguity-tolerant cultures, Belarusians do not feel threatened by unknown situations. Uncertainty is a normal part of life, and they accept it as it comes. They are comfortable with ambiguity and will accept and feel comfortable with unclear or unknown questions. They will not avoid talking to people from other countries due to a fear of making mistakes.

However, Belarusians are not high on the international rankings of tolerance. This is attributed to the influence of the Soviet times, where everything different and foreign was considered an enemy.

Belarusians are patient and fatalistic

Belarusians are known for their patience and fatalism, two qualities that are deeply rooted in the country's history and culture. Here are some paragraphs that explore this aspect of the Belarusian national character:

Belarusians have endured a long history of war, foreign rule, and political upheaval. This has instilled in them a strong sense of patience and resilience. They have learned to "suffer through" difficult times, often with a stoic attitude. This is reflected in the many anecdotes and proverbs that emphasise the Belarusian capacity for endurance.

The country's geography and agricultural traditions have also shaped the national character. The Belarusian landscape, with its marshes and woods, required hard work and patience from those who settled there. Survival depended on steady, repetitive labour, rather than experimentation. This practical conformism extended to other aspects of life, including social norms and values, which were expected to remain unchanged.

The unpredictable nature of life in Belarus, due to political and economic instability, has also contributed to a fatalistic outlook. Belarusians often view the future as uncertain and beyond their control, leading them to focus on the present and what is immediately around them. This attitude is reflected in the saying, "All is fine as long as we're not at war."

The Belarusian experience of living under different rulers and regimes has also influenced their tolerance for ambiguity. They have learned to adapt to changing circumstances and to accept things as they are, rather than striving for idealistic goals. This pragmatism is reflected in their indifference to national, social, and political causes.

However, this tolerance for ambiguity has its limits. Belarusians have a strong sense of national identity and pride in their culture, which can make them resistant to outside influence. They value their independence and are cautious of anything that might threaten their way of life, including political or economic reforms. This resistance to change can be seen as a form of fatalism, an acceptance of their fate.

In conclusion, the Belarusian character is shaped by a unique blend of patience, resilience, and fatalism. These qualities have helped them survive and adapt to the challenges they have faced throughout their history. While they may appear indifferent or passive to outsiders, Belarusians possess a quiet strength and determination that has preserved their national identity and culture.

Belarusians are conformists

Conformity is a key aspect of the Belarusian national character. In the past, the Belarusian people have been described as conformists, with a strong sense of traditionalism and a preference for repeating established behaviours rather than experimenting with new ones. This traditionalism and conformism are deeply ingrained in the Belarusian mentality and have contributed to the survival of Belarusian culture.

Belarusians' conformism can be traced back to the conditions under which they lived and worked. The landscape was marshy and wooded, and the agricultural practices were harsh and risky. In such an environment, novelty was unwelcome and too risky. Instead, survival depended on steadily repeating the behaviours and practices of previous generations. This conformism extended beyond labour and influenced how Belarusians valued patterns of behaviour, beliefs, and values.

Today, Belarusians continue to connect the two worlds of collectivism and individualism. They report preferring collectivistic values but often act as introverts, unable or unwilling to work in a team. This may be a result of the Belarusian landscape, which was marshy and wooded, causing families to settle far from each other and rely mostly on themselves for survival.

Another factor contributing to Belarusians' conformism is their respect for other nations and cultures. Throughout history, Belarus has been home to people of different religions, traditions, and languages, and this diversity was never considered a problem. Belarus is also a rare place where antisemitism was never prevalent.

However, Belarusians' conformism has also had negative consequences. During Soviet times, the premise of being like one's neighbour turned into a damaging behaviour of not standing out. Those who attracted too much attention or stood out did not survive. This mentality continues to influence Belarusians today, who are often introverts and unwilling to take risks or experiment with new ideas.

Belarusians are pessimistic

Belarusians are often described as a pessimistic people. This is partly due to the harsh reality they have lived through, including the many wars they have fought in. Many researchers of Belarusian ethnicity and folklore point to the abundance of dramatic, hopeless songs in their culture.

This pessimism is also reflected in the fact that Belarusians value peace above everything else. The risk of war is a greater concern than a poor standard of living or the form of government. This belief can be seen in common toasts for peaceful times and in the lyrics of the Belarusian hymn.

Belarusians' pessimism is also reflected in their attitude towards indulgence. They generally feel that indulging themselves is inherently wrong. It is more culturally appropriate to complain and show the outside world how abused they are. This attitude may be traced back to centuries of harsh labour.

Belarusians' pessimism also extends to their view of the future. They are known for their patience and ability to "suffer through" anything. This may be due to the harsh and risky agricultural conditions they faced historically, where every novelty was unwelcome and too risky to try. As a result, they tend to be traditional and conformist, repeating the behaviours, values, and beliefs of previous generations rather than experimenting with new ideas.

Finally, Belarusians' pessimism is reflected in their view of themselves and their place in the world. They lack a feeling of national superiority and do not feel destined to save the world or bring a different way of living to other nations. They are indifferent to national, social, and political causes, and this attitude has been blamed for the vagueness and ambivalence of Belarusian national identity.

Frequently asked questions