Barbuda's Reconstruction: A Slow And Steady Revival

In 2017, Hurricane Irma devastated the island of Barbuda, forcing almost all of its 2,000 residents to evacuate. The storm caused extensive damage to the island's landscape and infrastructure, with 95% of properties damaged or demolished. Since then, the island has been struggling to rebuild, facing challenges due to limited financial resources and tensions with the central government in Antigua over development priorities. While there have been some efforts to support the recovery, such as a 5 million euro agreement with the European Union for housing reconstruction, the process has been slow, and the island still lacks essential services like a fully functioning hospital or bank. The future of Barbuda remains uncertain, with concerns about the potential loss of cultural heritage and traditional ways of life due to the focus on tourist ventures and exploitation by wealthy elites.

Hurricane Irma's impact on Barbuda

Hurricane Irma hit Barbuda in early September 2017, causing extensive damage to the island's landscape and infrastructure. The Category 5 storm battered the island with winds of up to 185 mph, resulting in the death of a two-year-old child and an estimated 90% of properties damaged. The prime minister ordered an evacuation to Antigua, and while Hurricane Jose passed without incident, the recovery process was challenging and slow.

The evacuation mandate was prolonged for six weeks due to health concerns, and even when residents were allowed to return, many opted to remain in Antigua, especially those with children, as schools in Barbuda did not restart until early 2018. The rebuilding process has been slow, with issues regarding insurance and tenancy slowing down the process. Additionally, the complicated relationship between Antigua and Barbuda, marked by tensions and differing development paths, has further complicated recovery efforts.

The focus on tourist ventures by multinational developers and the Antiguan government has threatened to erode the unique culture, identity, and traditional land relations in Barbuda. The rush to develop large-scale tourism infrastructure, such as a new airport, has bypassed environmental and cultural assessments, destroying prime hunting and farming areas and threatening the coral reefs surrounding the island. The Barbudan way of life, including traditions like horse racing, hunting, and beach festivities, is at risk of becoming a memory of the past.

The rebuilding process has been slow and piecemeal, with government workers often facing payment issues. Basic infrastructure, such as a fully functioning hospital or bank, is still lacking on the island. While some Barbudans have returned and are working to rebuild their community, many have chosen to stay in Antigua or abroad, finding jobs and building new lives. The future of Barbuda remains uncertain, with locals questioning if the island will ever return to normal and if its cherished lifestyle can be preserved.

The role of international aid in Barbuda's recovery

In September 2017, Hurricane Irma devastated the island of Barbuda, causing widespread destruction to its landscape and infrastructure. The small Caribbean island was evacuated for the first time in its history, and the trauma of the hurricane took its toll on the local community. In the aftermath of the storm, international aid played a crucial role in helping Barbuda rebuild and recover.

One notable example of international aid in Barbuda's recovery was the US$2 million Chinese-aid funded Post-Disaster Roof Restoration project. This initiative aimed to repair 250 house roofs, and it exceeded its target by providing roofing materials for a total of 302 homes and essential facilities. The project was completed in six months, and it allowed hundreds of people to return home to the island. The Chinese Government worked in collaboration with the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) and the National Office of Disaster Services (NODS) to implement this project, which strengthened the resilience of the island against future hurricanes.

Another instance of international aid was the support provided by humanitarian organisations such as Samaritan's Purse, the Red Cross, and the UN. These organisations assisted in the rebuilding of homes and the cleanup of debris, despite facing bureaucratic obstructions. The Red Cross also played a crucial role in providing estimates of the number of people who had returned to the island, which helped to assess the progress of the recovery efforts.

While international funding has been essential in Barbuda's recovery, there are concerns about the potential negative impacts of disaster capitalism. Multinational developers and the central government in Antigua have been accused of exploiting the vulnerability of the island to promote tourist ventures rather than focusing on local recovery. This has led to tensions between Antigua and Barbuda, as the Barbudan governing council prioritises selective development projects that align with their cultural values and environmental sustainability.

Despite these challenges, international aid has played a significant role in helping Barbuda rebuild after Hurricane Irma. The combination of financial assistance, humanitarian efforts, and technical expertise has contributed to the island's recovery and resilience. However, it is essential to strike a balance between economic development and preserving the unique cultural and environmental heritage of Barbuda.

The future of Barbuda's tourism industry

Barbuda's tourism industry is facing a challenging road to recovery in the aftermath of Hurricane Irma, which devastated the island in 2017. The category 5 storm caused extensive damage to the island's infrastructure and landscape, leading to a mass evacuation of its residents. The rebuilding process has been slow, with Prime Minister Gaston Browne stating that it will take "years to fully recover Barbuda".

One of the main challenges hindering the island's recovery is the lack of financial resources. Despite receiving some international aid and donations, the funding has fallen short of the estimated hundreds of millions needed for rebuilding. This lack of funding has resulted in only a partial reconstruction of damaged properties, with over 600 out of 1,200 properties still needing to be rebuilt.

To strike a balance between tourism development and cultural preservation, it is crucial to involve the Barbudan community in the decision-making process. Traditional governing practices, which involve bringing development projects to the Barbuda Council for a vote, should be respected. Additionally, sustainable tourism practices should consider the concept of sustainability from the perspective of the local Barbudan people, rather than solely focusing on the end product.

In conclusion, the future of Barbuda's tourism industry depends on a sensitive and community-driven approach to development. While tourism can bring economic benefits, it is essential to preserve the local culture, identity, and natural attractions that make Barbuda unique. By involving the Barbudan community and respecting their traditional practices, a sustainable and culturally sensitive tourism industry can be fostered, ensuring that the island remains a desirable destination for independent travellers seeking a natural and peaceful experience.

The preservation of Barbuda's cultural heritage

Barbuda is an island that is part of the nation of Antigua and Barbuda. In 2017, Hurricane Irma caused extensive damage to the island's landscape and infrastructure. Since the hurricane, Barbuda has relied on the larger Antiguan government and international funding for its recovery. However, the recovery process has been culturally insensitive and politically driven, threatening the preservation of Barbuda's cultural heritage.

Tangible Heritage

Tangible heritage refers to physical structures and artefacts such as historic buildings, museums, monuments, documents, and other artefacts. Barbuda is unique in the Caribbean due to its relatively pristine landscape, extensive forests, beaches, and coral reefs that have not been transformed by large-scale tourism or sugar plantations.

After Hurricane Irma, UNESCO commissioned a preliminary impact assessment to evaluate the damage to tangible heritage sites in Barbuda. While some historical buildings were structurally affected and may not be salvageable, other structures survived the hurricane intact. The Barbuda Museum, housed at the Interpretation Centre, survived unscathed, but the Children's Museum was destroyed and requires complete rebuilding. Additionally, the sites housing archaeological collections were damaged, and the collections remain at risk without safe storage.

Intangible Heritage

Intangible heritage refers to traditional practices and rituals such as artistry, festivities, and religious rituals. In Barbuda, traditions like horse racing, hunting, camping, living in caves, beach festivities, traditional healing, and the construction of traditional houses are endangered due to the impact of the hurricane and the focus on tourist ventures in the recovery process. The Annual Barbuda Caribana Festival, a five-day celebration including talent and calypso competitions, a food fair, dancing, and horse racing, had to be cancelled due to the damage caused by the hurricane.

Communal Land Ownership

Communal land ownership, passed down through generations, is central to Barbudan identity. The Barbuda Land Act of 2007 codified this communal ownership, stating that "all land in Barbuda is owned in common by the people of Barbuda". However, there have been efforts to dismantle this Act and open up the island to privatisation and development. Barbudans are fighting to reinstate the Act and preserve their traditional land relations.

Local Resistance and Grassroots Movements

Local resistance movements, such as Barbuda Silent No More, are actively working to preserve Barbudan identity and culture. They are fighting against elite economic interests that threaten to take over the land and exploit the island for tourism ventures. However, it remains uncertain how much power these grassroots movements will have against the wealthy investors and the central government in Antigua.

The Role of the Diaspora

The Barbudan diaspora has provided resilience and support during the recovery process. They have assisted with cleanup efforts and rebuilding homes, working alongside humanitarian organisations such as the Red Cross and the UN.

The importance of land ownership in Barbuda's rebuilding process

Land ownership in Barbuda is a complex issue with a long history. Communal land ownership, passed down through generations, is central to Barbudan identity. Since the end of slavery, the land on Barbuda has been held in common by all Barbudans, with residents having the right to occupy residential land, graze animals, and use land for commercial purposes. This customary collective land ownership evolved in response to Barbudans' post-emancipation resistance to efforts to relocate them to neighbouring Antigua.

The Barbuda Land Act of 2007 codified this arrangement, stating that "all land in Barbuda is owned in common by the people of Barbuda". The Act also required major developments over $5.4 million to be approved by a majority vote of the elected Barbuda Council. This allowed the Barbudan governing council to be selective about which development projects were allowed on the island, setting it apart from the larger Antiguan government's focus on large-scale tourism.

However, in 2016, the value of major developments that did not require popular approval was increased to $40 million, opening up more possibilities for development. This led to concerns that wealthy developers would exploit the island's natural resources and cultural heritage in the name of "development" and "sustainable tourism".

In 2017, Hurricane Irma devastated Barbuda, destroying nearly every structure and leaving the majority of the population homeless. As pledges of reconstruction aid poured in, Prime Minister Gaston Browne announced the end of collective land ownership, claiming that private, freehold land ownership was necessary to secure financing for rebuilding efforts. Barbudans disputed this notion, arguing that the 2007 law already allowed for foreign real estate investment through leases.

The dispute over land ownership in Barbuda intensified, with the government amending the Barbuda Land Act to allow for private ownership and opening the door for foreign investment. Activists and Barbuda's sole elected lawmaker, Trevor Walker, warned that the traditional way of life in Barbuda would be extinguished if wealthy developers were allowed to profit from these changes. They argued that the government's plans for privatisation would disenfranchise Barbudans and threaten their cultural heritage and traditional land relations.

The issue of land ownership is crucial in Barbuda's rebuilding process as it determines the direction of the island's development. While some argue that private land ownership will bring economic growth and sustainability, others fear that it will lead to the exploitation of the island and its resources, threatening the Barbudan way of life. The rebuilding process must consider the importance of land ownership in maintaining the unique identity and culture of Barbuda, while also ensuring that the island has the necessary resources and financing for a sustainable future.

Frequently asked questions