Racism In Austria And Germany: A Comparative Study

Racism towards Black people is on the rise in Europe, with Germany and Austria showing some of the highest rates of discrimination and harassment. A recent survey of first- and second-generation Black immigrants in 13 EU countries revealed that Germany and Austria had the highest proportion of respondents reporting racial discrimination in the past 12 months, at 64% and 65% respectively. This is a significant increase from previous years, with Austria jumping from 42% to 64% and Germany nearly doubling from 33% to 64%. In terms of discrimination by the police, Austria ranked first, with 53% of men and 24% of women surveyed having been stopped by the police in the previous five years. The study also found that Black people felt the most discriminated against when looking for work in Austria, with 59% of respondents reporting this issue. Given these findings, it is worth examining whether Austria is more racist than Germany and exploring the underlying causes and societal implications of these disturbing trends.

Austria and Germany are the 'most racist' EU states

Austria and Germany have been deemed the 'most racist' EU states, according to a report by the Vienna-based European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights (FRA). The report, titled "Being Black in the EU", surveyed 6,750 Black people in 13 member states, including Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, Poland, Portugal, Spain, and Sweden. The findings revealed that Austria and Germany had the highest rates of discrimination and harassment towards Black people, with around two-thirds of respondents in both countries reporting that they had faced discrimination in the last 12 months.

In Austria, 67% of Black respondents reported experiencing discrimination, a significant increase from 42% in the previous report. Austria also ranked first in discrimination by the police, with 53% of men and 24% of women surveyed having been stopped by the police in the five years before the survey. Additionally, 59% of Black respondents reported facing discrimination when looking for work in Austria, the highest among all 13 countries surveyed.

Germany also saw a sharp rise in racism, with the proportion of Black respondents reporting discrimination in the last 12 months jumping from 33% to 65%. Germany had the highest rate of racist harassment, with 54% of respondents reporting experiencing racist harassment in the past five years. The report also found that one in four Black people in Germany had been stopped by the police in the last five years, with about half feeling it was due to racial profiling.

The FRA report made a series of recommendations for EU member states, including properly enforcing anti-discrimination legislation and considering racial bias as an aggravating factor when setting penalties for crimes. The report's director, Michael O'Flaherty, called the findings "shocking" and emphasized the need for urgent action to address racism and discrimination towards people of African descent in the EU.

Racism is rising in Germany

The European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights (FRA) report, titled "Being Black in the EU", revealed that 65% of Black people in Germany reported facing discrimination in the last 12 months, with similar figures in Austria (67%). This is a stark rise from the 2016 report, when 33% of respondents in Germany and 42% in Austria reported discrimination.

The FRA survey also found that 54% of respondents in Germany reported racist harassment in the past five years, the highest rate among the 13 countries surveyed. This is an alarming trend, with no improvement since the previous survey. The report's director, Michael O'Flaherty, stated that it is "shocking to see no improvement" and that people of African descent face "ever more discrimination" due to the colour of their skin.

The report made several recommendations to EU member states, including properly enforcing anti-discrimination legislation and considering racial bias as an aggravating factor when setting penalties for crimes. These recommendations aim to address the rising racism in Germany and other EU countries, ensuring that people of African descent are protected from discrimination, harassment, and violence.

Austria and Germany have the highest rates of discrimination and harassment

The FRA survey polled 6,750 Black people across 13 EU member states, including Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, Poland, Portugal, Spain, and Sweden. The results showed that Austria and Germany, where far-right parties are gaining support, had some of the worst outcomes.

In Austria, 72% of respondents reported experiencing discrimination due to their skin colour, origin, or religion in the past five years, the second-highest rate after Germany (76%). Austria ranked first in discrimination by the police, with 53% of men and 24% of women surveyed having been stopped by the police in the previous five years.

When it comes to job hunting, Austria was again singled out as the country where Black people felt most discriminated against. A staggering 59% of respondents reported experiencing discrimination when looking for work in Austria. This is particularly concerning given that the survey also found that Black people are overqualified for their jobs, with 35% of respondents with university-level qualifications working in low or medium-skilled occupations.

The FRA report made a series of recommendations for EU member states, including effectively enforcing anti-discrimination laws and considering racial bias as an aggravating factor when setting penalties for crimes. It is clear that Austria and Germany have much work to do to address their high levels of discrimination and harassment towards Black people and create a more inclusive society.

Austria ranks first for police discrimination

Austria has been deemed the most racist country in the EU, alongside Germany, in a report by the Vienna-based Fundamental Rights Agency (FRA). The report, which surveyed 13 member states, found that Austria ranked first for police discrimination, with 53% of men and 24% of women surveyed saying they had been stopped by police in the five years prior. This indicates a concerning trend of racial profiling by law enforcement in the country.

The FRA report highlights that people of African descent continue to face "shocking levels of racism and discrimination" across the EU, with Austria and Germany exhibiting the highest rates. In Austria, 67% of Black people surveyed reported experiencing discrimination in the last 12 months, a significant increase from 42% in the previous report. This is particularly evident in the job market, with 59% of respondents reporting discrimination when looking for work in Austria, the highest across all 13 countries surveyed.

The issue of police discrimination in Austria is a critical concern. The FRA report found that one in four Black people across the EU had been stopped by officers in the last five years, and about half of those surveyed attributed this to racial profiling. In Austria, the numbers are even more stark, with over half of the men surveyed experiencing police stops. This indicates a systemic issue within Austrian law enforcement that disproportionately targets individuals based on their race or ethnicity.

The FRA has called on EU states to address this issue by collecting more accurate data on racist incidents and implementing stricter punishments for racially motivated crimes. It is crucial that Austria takes decisive action to address police discrimination and promote equality and inclusion for people of African descent.

The report's findings underscore the urgent need for reform in Austria's law enforcement practices to ensure the fair and equitable treatment of all individuals, regardless of their race or ethnicity.

Germany has the highest rate of racist harassment

The FRA's report highlighted the pervasive and relentless nature of racism in Germany and Austria, with far-right parties surging in the polls. The study found that 76% of respondents in Germany experienced some form of racial discrimination in the past five years, the highest rate among the 13 countries surveyed. This includes discrimination based on skin colour, origin, or religion. The report also revealed that Germany has the highest rate of racial discrimination among the 13 countries, with 65% of black people reporting that they had faced discrimination in the last 12 months.

The FRA made a series of recommendations to EU member states to address the issue of racist harassment and discrimination. These recommendations include properly enforcing anti-discrimination legislation and considering racial bias as an aggravating factor when setting penalties for crimes. The FRA also called on EU states to collect more accurate data on racist incidents and to impose harsher punishments for racially motivated crimes.

The issue of racist harassment and discrimination in Germany is a serious concern, and the FRA's report highlights the need for urgent action to address these issues. The report found that people of African descent in Germany face discrimination in various aspects of their lives, including employment, housing, and education. For example, one in four respondents in Germany reported being prevented from renting a property due to their racial or ethnic origin. Additionally, young people of African descent in Germany are three times more likely to leave education early compared to the wider population.

The FRA's report provides valuable insights into the experiences of people of African descent in Germany and the ongoing struggle against racism and discrimination. It is clear that much more needs to be done to address these issues and create a more inclusive and equitable society.

Frequently asked questions