Austrian School: Classical Economics Evolution Or Revolution?

The Austrian School of Economics is a heterodox school of economic thought that emerged in 1871 in Vienna with the publication of Carl Menger's Principles of Economics. It is founded on the belief that economic theory should be derived from basic principles of human action and individual choices, with a focus on methodological individualism. This school of thought emphasizes thought experiments and a priori thinking to discover universal economic laws, rather than relying heavily on data and mathematical models like other mainstream schools. While it shares similarities with classical economics, particularly in its roots and advocacy for free-market principles, the Austrian School diverges in its rejection of certain classical ideas, such as the belief that money is neutral.

The Austrian School's focus on methodological individualism

The Austrian School of Economics is a heterodox school of economic thought that advocates strict adherence to methodological individualism. This concept suggests that social phenomena arise primarily from the motivations, actions, and self-interest of individuals. Austrian theorists maintain that economic theory should be derived exclusively from the fundamental principles governing human behaviour.

The Austrian School, founded in 1871 by Carl Menger, Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk, Friedrich von Wieser, and others, stands in methodological opposition to the Historical School, a dispute known as the Methodenstreit, or methodology quarrel. The Austrian School owes its name to this quarrel, as it was first used by Gustav von Schmoller, a leader of the Historical School, in an attempt to characterise the Austrian School as outcast and provincial.

Methodological individualism, a core tenet of the Austrian School, asserts that economic phenomena are caused by the subjective choices of individuals, encompassing factors such as individual knowledge, time, expectation, and other subjective factors. This approach, termed "praxeology" by Ludwig von Mises, involves deducing a priori theoretical economic truths through thought experiments, independent of empirical observation or statistical analysis.

Austrian economists believe that economic systems are not purposefully designed but are rather the unintended by-products of self-interested individual actions. Consequently, they argue that government intervention is often harmful since it is impossible to know the preferences and utilities of every individual. This perspective aligns with classical economists' belief that government intervention is, at best, neutral.

However, Austrian School economists diverge from classical economists on the role of money, asserting that money is not neutral. They propose that economic analysis should focus on individual people making choices based on their preferences, or "human behaviour." This approach often involves exploring the unintended consequences of individual choices, which have lasting impacts on economic activity.

The Austrian School's emphasis on methodological individualism and its unique approach to economic theory have made it a distinct and influential force in the complex world of economic thought.

The Austrian School's rejection of mathematical modelling and econometrics

The Austrian School of Economics is a heterodox school of economic thought that is characterised by its rejection of mathematical modelling and econometrics. Instead, it advocates for strict adherence to methodological individualism, which posits that social phenomena are primarily the result of individual motivations, actions, and self-interest. This school of thought originated in Vienna in 1871 with the work of Carl Menger, among others, and is also known as the ""Vienna School" or "Psychological School".

The Austrian School stands apart from other economic theories due to its belief that broad economic trends are the sum of smaller individual decisions and actions. This is in contrast to theories such as the Chicago School, which utilise historical abstracts and broad statistical aggregates to make predictions. Austrian economists emphasise the processes of cause-and-effect in real-world economics, the implications of time and uncertainty, the role of the entrepreneur, and the use of prices and information to coordinate economic activity.

A key example of this is their theory of marginal utility, which states that the economic value of goods and services is subjective and diminishes with the increase in the number of goods. This theory, developed by Menger, formed one of the pillars of the marginalist revolution. Later, Ludwig von Mises applied this theory to money in his "Theory of Money and Credit", suggesting that the marginal utility of money can help determine how much money is too much.

Another illustration of the Austrian School's approach is their view on interest rates. They reject the classical view, which states that interest rates are determined by the supply and demand of capital. Instead, they argue that interest rates are determined by the subjective decisions of individuals to spend money now or in the future, reflecting their time preference.

While the Austrian School rejects traditional mathematical modelling, some Austrian economists have incorporated models and mathematics into their analyses. For instance, Austrian economist Steven Horwitz argued that Austrian methodology is consistent with macroeconomics and can be expressed in terms of microeconomic foundations. Similarly, Roger Garrison writes that Austrian macroeconomic theory can be effectively expressed using diagrammatic models.

In conclusion, the Austrian School's rejection of mathematical modelling and econometrics is rooted in their commitment to methodological individualism and their belief in deriving economic theory from basic principles of human action. They utilise a priori thinking and thought experiments to discover economic truths, offering unique insights into important economic issues. While some Austrian economists have incorporated mathematical elements, the school's overall rejection of traditional modelling sets it apart from mainstream economic theories.

The Austrian School's belief in the subjectivity of economic value

The Austrian School of Economics, founded by Carl Menger in 1871, is a heterodox school of economic thought that advocates strict adherence to methodological individualism. This means that Austrian economists believe that economic theory should be derived from the basic principles of human action, with a focus on individual choices and preferences. This is in contrast to other schools of economic thought, which tend to focus on aggregate variables, equilibrium analysis, and societal groups rather than individuals.

One of the key tenets of the Austrian School is the subjective theory of value, which states that the economic value of goods and services is subjective in nature. In other words, the value of a good or service is not inherent but is determined by the individual's perception and how much satisfaction they derive from it. This means that the same good or service can have different values for different individuals. For example, a diamond ring might be incredibly valuable to someone planning a proposal but hold little value for someone who prioritizes experiences over material possessions.

Menger's explanation of the subjective theory of value in his book "Principles of Economics" forms the basis of the Austrian School's belief in the subjectivity of economic value. He argued that the economic values of goods and services are subjective, and that with an increase in the number of goods, their subjective value for an individual diminishes. This concept is known as diminishing marginal utility.

The subjective theory of value was further developed by later Austrian economists such as Ludwig von Mises and Friedrich Hayek. Mises, in his book "Theory of Money and Credit" (1912), applied the marginal utility concept to money, arguing that increasing the money supply ultimately decreases its value due to diminishing marginal utility. Hayek, on the other hand, won the 1974 Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences for his contributions to "the theory of money and economic fluctuations".

The Austrian School's belief in the non-neutrality of money

The Austrian School of Economics is a heterodox school of economic thought that advocates strict adherence to methodological individualism, the concept that social phenomena result primarily from the motivations and actions of individuals along with their self-interest. Austrian School theorists hold that economic theory should be exclusively derived from basic principles of human action.

The Austrian School's position on the non-neutrality of money can be traced back to the work of Ludwig von Mises, who applied the theory of marginal utility to money in his book, "The Theory of Money and Credit" (1912). Mises argued that the value of money is subjective and dependent on individuals' preferences and expectations. He also introduced the concept of time preference, which suggests that individuals' decisions to save or spend money are based on their preferences for consumption in the immediate or distant future.

According to the Austrian School, increases in the money supply can lead to an increase in prices, but not simultaneously across all goods and services. This can result in a disparity in relative prices, affecting individuals' purchasing power and potentially leading to a recession. They believe that government manipulation of the money supply and credit can cause economic fluctuations and misallocation of resources, known as "malinvestment".

Furthermore, the Austrian School emphasizes the role of banks in the creation of credit and the impact of interest rates on economic activity. They argue that artificially low-interest rates can lead to unsustainable investment decisions and contribute to economic booms and busts.

Overall, the Austrian School's belief in the non-neutrality of money highlights their focus on the subjective nature of economic values and the impact of individual choices on the economy. They argue that changes in the money supply can have far-reaching consequences beyond just prices and wages, affecting production, consumption, and the overall economic structure.

The Austrian School's view of the market as a spontaneous order

The Austrian School of Economics, founded in 1871 by Carl Menger with his book "Principles of Economics", views the market as a spontaneous order. This perspective is rooted in their belief that economic phenomena emerge from the choices and actions of individuals, rather than being designed or predetermined.

According to Austrian economists, markets are not deliberately constructed but are a result of people's inherent drive to improve their lives. This aligns with their commitment to methodological individualism, which asserts that social phenomena, including economic systems, arise primarily from the motivations, actions, and self-interest of individuals.

Additionally, the Austrian School's perspective on the market as a spontaneous order influences their stance on government intervention. They argue that because markets are not designed, government intervention is usually harmful as it disrupts the natural order that arises from individual choices.

Frequently asked questions