Bavarian Cream And Panna Cotta: What's The Difference?

Panna cotta and Bavarian cream are two esteemed desserts that often get confused. Both are creamy, fresh, and served cold, but there are some key differences between the two. Panna cotta is an Italian dessert that translates to cooked cream. It is made with cream, sugar, and gelatin, and is often served with a coulis of berries or a sauce of caramel or chocolate. Bavarian cream, on the other hand, is a French dessert that typically includes eggs and whipped cream in addition to gelatin and sugar. It has a richer, creamier texture and a more decadent flavour profile.

Panna Cotta's origins

Panna cotta, meaning 'cooked cream' in Italian, is a dessert that originated in Italy. More specifically, it is often cited as a traditional dessert of the northern Italian region of Piedmont.

The name panna cotta is not mentioned in Italian cookbooks before the 1960s. However, one unverified story says that it was invented by a Hungarian woman in the Langhe in the early 19th century. Another source suggests that it may have come from a French recipe called 'fromage bavarois' by Marie-Antoine Carême, which is similar to panna cotta but includes whipped cream.

Panna cotta is made from cream, sugar, and gelatin, and is served cold. It is said to be incredibly easy to prepare and became fashionable in the United States in the 1990s due to the influence of Italian Americans in culinary culture.

Bavarian Cream's origins

The origins of Bavarian Cream are somewhat unclear. While it is known as a French dessert, consisting of an egg-based custard with gelatin or isinglass, mixed with whipped cream and set in a mould, it is unclear whether it was actually conceived in France or Germany.

Many sources credit the creation of Bavarian Cream to the French chef Marie-Antoine Carême. However, others claim that it was first made in Switzerland or Germany. It is believed that the dessert was named in the early 19th century for Bavaria, or perhaps for a visiting Bavarian dignitary, given its origins during the 17th and 18th centuries when French chefs cooked for the Bavarian royalty, the Wittelsbach princes.

The dessert first appeared in cookbooks in the United States during the 1880s and gained popularity in the 1930s. In comparison, its counterpart, Panna Cotta, only gained popularity in the US in the 1990s.

Bavarian Cream, or Bavarois, is often confused with Panna Cotta due to their similar appearance and creamy, fresh textures. However, the former typically includes eggs and whipped cream, in addition to gelatin, resulting in a fluffier, richer taste.

Texture and consistency

When it comes to texture and consistency, both desserts offer a sensory delight, but each has its own distinct personality. Bavarian Cream beckons with a velvety allure, its texture akin to silk caressing the tongue. It showcases a remarkable amalgamation of creamy custard and aerated whipped cream. In contrast, Panna Cotta entices with its silky-smooth elegance, gracefully waltzing on the palate. Its gelatin-based structure creates a gentle wobble, a tactile journey that epitomises indulgence.

The juxtaposition of these two desserts highlights their textural craftsmanship. Bavarian Cream's luxurious creaminess against Panna Cotta's ethereal glide showcases the pinnacle of dessert artistry. The addition of whipped cream and eggs in Bavarian Cream contributes to its richer, fluffier, and creamier texture, resulting in a more indulgent taste experience. On the other hand, Panna Cotta, with its simpler structure of cream, sugar, and gelatin, delivers a lighter and silkier sensation on the palate.

Both desserts require no baking and can be prepared in advance, making them convenient options for dinner parties or special occasions. However, it is worth noting that due to the presence of egg yolks in Bavarian Cream, Panna Cotta may be a more suitable choice for vegetarian guests.

In summary, while both desserts share a creamy foundation, their textures and consistencies differ significantly. Bavarian Cream offers a decadent and velvety experience, while Panna Cotta delights with its airy, wobbly, and silky-smooth texture.

Ingredients and flavour profile

Panna cotta and Bavarian cream share a creamy foundation, but their ingredients and flavour profiles differ.

Panna cotta is an Italian dessert with a name that translates to "cooked cream". It is made with cream, sugar, and gelatin, and sometimes milk. The cream may be infused with coffee, vanilla, or other flavourings. Its texture is silky-smooth and wobbly, and it is often served with a coulis of berries or a sauce of caramel or chocolate.

Bavarian cream, on the other hand, is a French dessert with a richer flavour profile. In addition to custard, gelatin, and whipped cream, it contains egg yolks, milk, and sugar. The eggs and gelatin act as setting agents, giving it a velvety, creamy texture. The classic recipe embodies the richness of cream, the subtle sweetness of sugar, and the sophistication of vanilla. Bavarian cream is often served in lavish, moulded forms, adorned with luscious fruit or drizzles of coulis.

Cooking technique and setting agents

When it comes to cooking techniques and setting agents, the processes for Bavarian cream and panna cotta differ.

Bavarian Cream

Bavarian cream is a custard-based dessert. It involves a delicate tempering process to create a velvety base, followed by the meticulous folding in of whipped cream. The setting agents are egg yolks and gelatin. The recipe starts by soaking gelatin sheets in cold water. The sugar, egg yolk, and vanilla are then whisked together in a large bowl until slightly fluffy. Milk is brought to a simmer in a saucepan, and this warm milk mixture is slowly poured into the egg yolk mixture while whisking vigorously. This tempers the egg yolks. The combined mixture is then poured back into the saucepan and cooked over medium heat until it reaches 82°C/180°F. It is important not to let the mixture boil or exceed this temperature, or the egg will curdle. The custard mixture is then removed from the heat and the excess water is squeezed from the gelatin sheets before they are stirred into the hot cream. The custard is then placed in a shallow bowl or container and covered with plastic wrap to prevent a skin from forming on top. It is left to sit for about an hour until it reaches room temperature. Meanwhile, the heavy cream is whipped until it forms stiff peaks. The whipped cream is then gently folded into the custard in portions.

Panna Cotta

In contrast, panna cotta is made with a simpler technique. The cream and milk are gently heated to activate the gelatin. Panna cotta's setting agent is gelatin alone. To make panna cotta, the cream, sugar, vanilla, and gelatin are added to a medium-sized pot and heated on the stove, whisking regularly. When the ingredients reach a boil, the pot is removed from the heat and the gelatin is prepared according to the pack instructions. The gelatin is then added to the cream mixture and whisked. The mixture is then allowed to cool to room temperature to prevent separation. It is then transferred to serving bowls and covered with plastic wrap before being refrigerated for at least four hours, or preferably overnight.

Comparison

The cooking methods and setting agents for Bavarian cream and panna cotta are distinct and contribute to the unique textures of each dessert. Bavarian cream's custard base and combination of egg yolks and gelatin result in a luxurious, creamy texture. On the other hand, panna cotta's sole use of gelatin creates a wobbly, silky-smooth texture.

Frequently asked questions