Austria: Italy's Complicated Ally-Rival

Austria and Italy have had a complex relationship, with both nations influencing each other since the Middle Ages. While Italy has had a long-standing influence on Austrian culture, architecture, and cuisine, Austria has also exerted significant influence over the Italian states, particularly in the north. This dynamic has led to a history of conflict and cooperation between the two countries, with Italy and Austria fighting multiple wars as both enemies and allies.

During the late Middle Ages and the early modern period, Austria and Italy found themselves on opposing sides in several wars, including the Uskok War of 1615–1618. However, they also formed alliances, such as during the wars against the Ottoman Empire, where Austria allied with several Italian states. The complex web of rivalries and alliances continued into the 18th century, with Austria expanding into Italy and ruling various parts of the country. This period saw numerous territorial changes, with different Italian regions falling under Austrian rule or being exchanged through treaties.

In the 19th century, Italian nationalism clashed with Austrian interests, leading to the three Wars of Italian Independence between 1848 and 1866, which ultimately resulted in an Italian victory. Despite this, the two countries continued to have complex relations, with Austria-Hungary and Italy forming the Triple Alliance with Germany in 1882. However, tensions and suspicions remained, and Italy eventually sided with the Triple Entente during World War I, fighting against Austria-Hungary.

Austria and Italy's involvement in World War I

When World War I broke out in July 1914, Italy was officially neutral, despite being a member of the Triple Alliance with Germany and Austria-Hungary since 1882. However, there was strong public sentiment in Italy for joining the war against Austria-Hungary, which was considered Italy's historical enemy. Italy's primary goal was to annex territory along the frontier shared by the two countries, which would "liberate" Italian-speaking populations from the Austro-Hungarian Empire and unite them with their cultural homeland.

During the pre-war years, Italy began to align itself with the Entente powers, particularly France and Great Britain, seeking military and economic support for its expansionist goals. On April 26, 1915, Italy negotiated the secret Pact of London, in which Britain and France promised to support Italy's annexation of the frontier lands in exchange for Italy entering the war on the side of the Entente.

On May 3, 1915, Italy officially resigned from the Triple Alliance, and on May 23, it declared war on Austria-Hungary, joining World War I on the side of the Allies. The Italian front opened up a new, challenging theatre of war, with a 600-kilometer front along Italy's border with Austria-Hungary, most of it mountainous terrain. The Italian army, which initially boasted less than 300,000 men, grew to over 5 million through mobilisation by the war's end in November 1918. The fighting was intense and resulted in heavy losses for both sides, with 11 battles fought along the Isonzo River alone by late 1917.

Italy's decision to join the war against Austria-Hungary was a significant development, given the two countries' shared history. Since the Middle Ages, Austria had exerted considerable influence over the Italian states, particularly in the north. However, Italian nationalism clashed with Austrian interests, leading to three Wars of Italian Independence between 1848 and 1866, which ultimately resulted in Italian victories and the expulsion of Austria from Italy. Despite this, Austria continued to hold Italian-inhabited lands, fuelling ongoing tensions and nationalism within Italy.

By the end of World War I, Italy emerged victorious over Austria-Hungary and gained territories, including Trento and Trieste, as well as the predominantly German-speaking region of South Tyrol, which was annexed to Italy.

Austria-Hungary's annexation of Bosnia and Herzegovina

The annexation of Bosnia and Herzegovina by Austria-Hungary was a significant event in European history that had far-reaching consequences, including the outbreak of World War I. The annexation took place on October 6, 1908, when the Dual Monarchy of Austria-Hungary announced its claim over these two provinces in the Balkan region, formerly under Ottoman Empire control.

The roots of this annexation can be traced back to the Congress of Berlin in 1878, when the great powers of Europe awarded Austria-Hungary the right to occupy Bosnia and Herzegovina, with legal title remaining under Turkish control. This decision was a delicate compromise, as both Austria and Hungary desired these provinces for themselves, and the largely Slavic population held nationalist ambitions. Additionally, Serbia, a neighbouring Slavic country, sought to annex these provinces to further its pan-Slavic ambitions.

In 1908, a rebellion by the Young Turks against the Ottoman government presented an opportunity for Austria-Hungary to assert its dominance in the Balkans. Baron Aloys von Aerenthal, the foreign minister of Austria-Hungary, seized this chance, knowing that their rival, Russia, was weakened after a defeat in the Russo-Japanese War and internal revolution in 1905. On October 6, 1908, Austria-Hungary announced its annexation, upsetting the fragile balance of power in the region and enraging Serbia and pan-Slavic nationalists.

The annexation had significant implications for Austria-Hungary's relations with its neighbours, especially Serbia, Italy, and Russia. It permanently damaged relations with Serbia, leading to war in 1914. Italy, a former ally of Austria-Hungary in the Triple Alliance, was also displeased and eventually broke its alliance in 1915. Russia, despite its weakened state, viewed Austria-Hungary's actions as aggressive and threatening, further escalating tensions in the region.

The crisis surrounding the annexation of Bosnia and Herzegovina ultimately contributed to the outbreak of World War I. Austria-Hungary's actions upset the balance of power in the Balkans and heightened tensions with Serbia, leading to a crisis that brought Europe to the brink of war. The support of Germany for Austria-Hungary, even in the event of aggression, further solidified the battle lines that would soon erupt into a devastating global conflict.

Italy's colonial ambitions in North Africa

In 1881, Italy lost its North African ambitions to France with the French conquest of Tunisia, referred to as the "Slap of Tunis" by the Italian press. This fuelled Italian nationalism and furthered their colonial ambitions. Italy then turned its attention to Libya and the Dodecanese Islands, which it gained control of following the Italo-Turkish War.

In the lead-up to World War I, Italy was a partner in the Triple Alliance with Germany and Austria-Hungary, formed in 1882. However, Italy was reluctant to commit to the alliance due to its conflict of interest with Austria-Hungary in the Balkans and its desire to expand its colonial empire in North Africa. In 1902, Italy secretly extended a guarantee of neutrality to France, and in 1912, it renewed the Triple Alliance with the understanding that it would remain neutral in the event of a war between Austria-Hungary and Russia.

When World War I broke out in 1914, Italy initially declared its neutrality, considering Austria-Hungary the aggressor. However, it eventually entered the war on the side of the Triple Entente, declaring war on Austria-Hungary in May 1915 after securing support for territorial expansion in the Treaty of London. Italy's primary goal was to annex territory along the frontier with Austria-Hungary, "liberating" Italian-speaking populations and uniting them with their cultural homeland.

During World War II, Italy occupied British Somaliland, western Egypt, and other territories in North Africa. However, it lost these conquests to the invading Allied forces by 1943. In 1947, Italy officially relinquished its claims on all its former colonies, including those in North Africa.

The South Tyrol Question

South Tyrol, or Alto Adige in Italian, is a small, mountainous area located in the central Alps. It covers an area of around 7,400 square kilometres and has a population of approximately 500,000. The region is predominantly inhabited by German speakers (around 65%), followed by Italian speakers (27%) and Ladin speakers (4%).

South Tyrol was part of the Austro-Hungarian Empire for 550 years until it was ceded to Italy in 1919 after World War I. This transfer of sovereignty resulted in about 200,000 German and Ladin speakers becoming Italian citizens overnight. During the Fascist era, from 1922 to 1943, Italy attempted to assimilate the South Tyroleans by imposing Italianisation policies. However, the South Tyroleans resisted these efforts and sought to preserve their language and traditions, leading to violent clashes in the 1960s.

The South Tyrolean People's Party advocated for greater provincial autonomy, and in the mid-1950s, German-speaking militants carried out bomb attacks against symbols of Italian state authority. This unrest culminated in a revised statute in 1972, which devolved most powers to the provinces and established power-sharing between the linguistic groups in South Tyrol. This statute granted South Tyrol geographical and cultural autonomy from Italy, marking a significant step towards the 'regional state' established in 2010.

In recent years, the Austrian government has proposed offering dual citizenship to the German- and Ladin-speaking populations of South Tyrol, excluding Italian speakers. This proposal has caused tension with Italy, and there is currently no consensus on a solution.

Overall, the South Tyrol Question represents a complex and evolving dynamic between Austria and Italy, shaped by historical, cultural, and linguistic factors. The region's autonomy and the protection of ethnic minorities have been central to the discourse, contributing to South Tyrol's status as a success story in ethnic minority rights within Europe.

Italy's invasion and annexation of Libya

Prelude to the Invasion

In the late 19th century, Italy had expressed interest in Libya, with these claims being backed by France and Great Britain, who had agreed to the occupation of Tunisia and Cyprus, respectively. In 1902, Italy and France signed a secret treaty that allowed both countries to intervene freely in Tripolitania and Morocco. However, Italy did little to act on this opportunity, and knowledge of Libya's resources remained scarce.

Italian politicians began expressing interest in invading Libya as early as 1908, and the Italian press soon began a massive lobbying campaign in favour of an invasion. Libya was depicted as rich in minerals and water, defended by only 4,000 Ottoman troops, and with a population considered hostile to the Ottoman Empire but friendly to the Italians.

In 1910, Italian diplomacy suspected that Libya would escape Italy's sphere of influence, which would threaten the country's plans as a "great power" and potentially lead to the decline of the monarchy and Italy's liberal system. Italy had obtained the consent of the Great Powers to incorporate Libya into its colonial possessions through a series of pacts and diplomatic formulas.

The Invasion

In the summer of 1911, preparations for the invasion were carried out, and Prime Minister Giovanni Giolitti began to probe the reactions of other European major powers to a possible invasion. On the night of September 26-27, an ultimatum was presented to the Ottoman government, to which they replied with the proposal of handing over control of Libya without war, maintaining formal suzerainty. This proposal was similar to the situation in Egypt, which was under formal Ottoman suzerainty but was controlled by the United Kingdom. Giolitti refused, and war was declared on September 29, 1911.

The Italian army faced some opposition to the war, including from Benito Mussolini, who was then a socialist. Despite this, Italy attacked Tripoli on October 3, 1911, claiming to liberate the Ottoman wilayats from the Sublime Porte's rule. The first disembarkment of troops occurred on October 10 under the command of General Carlo Caneva, and soon Tripoli, Benghazi, Derna, and Tobruk were occupied.

Aftermath of the Invasion

The Italo-Turkish War resulted in the establishment of two colonies: Italian Tripolitania and Italian Cyrenaica, which were later unified into the colony of Italian Libya in 1934. In 1937, this colony was divided into four provinces, and in 1939, the coastal provinces became part of metropolitan Italy as the Fourth Shore.

The invasion of Libya was a costly enterprise for Italy, causing economic imbalance at home. It also showcased the lobbying power of an active and powerful minority, as seen with the advent of fascism after World War I.

Italian control over Libya remained ineffective until the late 1920s, when forces under Generals Badoglio and Graziani waged punitive pacification campaigns that turned into acts of terrible repression. Resistance petered out after the execution of rebel leader Omar Mukhtar in 1931.

Impact on International Relations

Italy's invasion of Libya had implications for its relations with other European powers, particularly those within the Triple Alliance, which included Germany, Austria-Hungary, and Italy. The occupation of the Dodecanese islands in the Aegean Sea during the conflict raised the ire of the Austro-Hungarian Empire, which feared that it would fuel irredentism in nations like Serbia and Greece and cause further instability in the Balkans.

Additionally, Italy's invasion and annexation of Libya brought it into conflict with the German-backed Ottoman Empire, contributing to mutual suspicions and reinforcement of the frontier between Italy and Austria-Hungary. It also influenced Italy's eventual entry into World War I, as the country sought support for territorial expansion against Austria-Hungary.

Frequently asked questions