Austria's Ultimatum: Germany's Unavoidable Path To War

On July 23, 1914, Austria-Hungary, with the full support of its allies in Berlin, issued an ultimatum to Serbia, demanding an inquiry into the assassination of Austrian Archduke Franz Ferdinand and his wife by a Serbian nationalist. This ultimatum, designed to be rejected, pushed Serbia to suppress anti-Austrian propaganda and eliminate terrorist organizations. Germany, working to contain the effects of the ultimatum, denied prior knowledge of it. However, the coordination between Berlin and Vienna was evident, and the ultimatum set off a chain of events that led to World War I, with Germany and Austria-Hungary aligned against Serbia and its allies, Russia, France, and Britain. Later, in 1938, Germany issued ultimatums to Austria, leading to the annexation of Austria, known as the Anschluss, violating international treaties and marking the first act of territorial expansion by Nazi Germany.

Germany's involvement in the ultimatum's creation

Germany was heavily involved in the creation of the ultimatum, which was presented by the Austrian government to Belgrade on 23 July 1914. The ultimatum was issued to Serbia, nearly a month after the assassination of Austrian Archduke Franz Ferdinand and his wife by a young Serbian nationalist. Acting with the full support of its allies in Berlin, Austria-Hungary, in coordination with the German foreign office, pursued a hard-line policy towards Serbia. Their plan was to force a military conflict that would end quickly and decisively with a crushing Austrian victory before Serbia's ally, Russia, had time to react.

The German government was keen to start a war, and the ultimatum was designed to be unacceptable to Serbia. Germany's ambassador to Russia, Friedrich von Pourtalès, told the Russian Foreign Minister, Sergey Sazonov, to reject a summit in London proposed by the British Foreign Secretary, Sir Edward Grey, stating that the proposed conference was "too unwieldy". Pourtalès reported to Germany that Sazonov was "more conciliatory" and willing to satisfy Austrian demands. Germany also worked diplomatically to contain the effects of the ultimatum, but none of the other great powers believed that Austria-Hungary was acting alone.

On 24 July, the German State Secretary for Foreign Affairs, Arthur Zimmermann, sent a dispatch to all German ambassadors (except for Austria-Hungary) telling them to inform their host governments that Germany had no advance knowledge of the ultimatum. Jagow, the German Undersecretary of State, claimed that Germany "exercised no influence of any kind with regard to the contents of the note [the Austrian ultimatum]". However, Germany's involvement in the ultimatum's creation is evident.

After Serbia's response to the ultimatum, which conceded to most of the demands, the Austrian foreign minister's refusal to negotiate made it clear that Vienna was not interested in a diplomatic solution. Germany's Chancellor, Bethmann Hollweg, sent telegrams urgently demanding an "immediate" answer to his 'pledge plan' and the plan for "direct conversations" between Austria-Hungary and Russia. He also expressed severe disapproval of Austria-Hungary.

Germany's diplomatic response to the ultimatum

However, it was widely believed that Germany had played a role in formulating the ultimatum. Winston Churchill wrote that the "Austrian ultimatum to Serbia [was] the most insolent document of its kind ever devised", and that it was designed to be rejected. Indeed, the terms of the ultimatum were extremely harsh and included demands such as the suppression of anti-Austrian propaganda and the rooting out of terrorist organizations in Serbia. It was suspected that Germany and Austria-Hungary were coordinating their actions, with the goal of forcing a military conflict with Serbia and, by extension, its powerful ally Russia.

Despite Germany's attempts to distance itself from the ultimatum, the German government did not counsel Vienna to retract or moderate its demands. Instead, Germany seemed more concerned with preventing other European powers from intervening. For example, when Grey, the British Foreign Secretary, suggested mediation between Italy, France, Germany, and Britain to stop an Austro-Serbian war, Jagow, the German ambassador to Britain, waited until after the ultimatum expired to pass on the offer. Additionally, the German ambassador to Russia, Pourtalès, advised Russia to negotiate directly with Austria-Hungary rather than accept Grey's offer of a summit in London.

As the crisis unfolded, Germany continued to coordinate its actions with Austria-Hungary. On 28 July, Bethmann Hollweg, the German Chancellor, sent the Kaiser's 'pledge plan' to Vienna, instructing the German ambassador to express himself "emphatically" to the Austrian government. Germany also began planning for potential military action, with Moltke advising the German Foreign Ministry to draft an ultimatum to justify an invasion of Belgium. These actions suggest that Germany was actively supporting Austria-Hungary and preparing for the possibility of a wider European war.

The ultimatum's role in Germany's invasion of Belgium

The Austrian ultimatum to Serbia on July 23, 1914, was a significant event that ultimately contributed to Germany's invasion of Belgium. Here is an examination of the role of the ultimatum in that invasion:

The Austrian Ultimatum

On July 23, 1914, nearly a month after the assassination of Austrian Archduke Franz Ferdinand and his wife by a Serbian nationalist, Austria-Hungary, with the full support of its allies in Berlin, delivered an ultimatum to the Serbian foreign ministry. This ultimatum was designed to be deliberately unacceptable, with Vienna making demands that were incredibly harsh and challenging to Serbian sovereignty. Serbia was given 48 hours to respond.

German Involvement

Germany played a crucial role in the formulation and delivery of the ultimatum. They coordinated their plan with the Austrian foreign office, intending to force a military conflict that would end quickly with an Austrian victory before Serbia's ally, Russia, could react. Germany also worked diplomatically to contain the effects of the ultimatum, trying to ensure that other great powers did not intervene.

Serbian Response

Serbia's response to the ultimatum was unexpected. Within the 48-hour deadline, Serbia accepted most of the demands but rejected a few key points, including the participation of Austrian officials in investigations on Serbian territory. This response put Vienna in a difficult position, as they had anticipated Serbian defiance and now appeared uninterested in a diplomatic solution.

Escalation to War

The Austrian ultimatum and Serbian response set off a chain of diplomatic manoeuvrings and attempts at mediation by other European powers, particularly Britain. However, these efforts ultimately failed. Austria-Hungary declared war on Serbia, and the conflict quickly escalated with Germany's involvement, leading to the invasion of Belgium.

Invasion of Belgium

Germany's invasion of Belgium was influenced by the broader context of the escalating conflict. Moltke advised Jagow that Germany should draft an ultimatum to justify an invasion of Belgium. This advice came amid concerns about Germany's lack of military action against Russia. The invasion of Belgium was thus a strategic move in the widening European war that had its roots in the Austrian ultimatum to Serbia.

Germany's reaction to Serbia's response

On 23 July 1914, nearly a month after the assassination of Austrian Archduke Franz Ferdinand and his wife by a Serbian nationalist, Austria-Hungary delivered an ultimatum to Serbia. The ultimatum was formulated with six concrete demands, including an inquiry into the assassination, the suppression of anti-Austrian propaganda, and the elimination of terrorist organisations within Serbia. The Serbian government was given 48 hours to respond.

While the world awaited Serbia's response, Germany worked diplomatically to contain the effects of the ultimatum. Germany's ambassador to Russia, Zimmermann, sent a dispatch to all German ambassadors (except Austria-Hungary) stating that Germany had no prior knowledge of the ultimatum. Simultaneously, Germany urged Austria-Hungary to proceed without delay, aware that any hesitation could invite foreign interference.

Serbia's answer, delivered by Prime Minister Nicola Pasic just before the deadline on 25 July, accepted most of the demands but rejected Austria-Hungary's participation in internal inquiries, citing constitutional violations. This response gained Serbia some international support, but Vienna remained unmoved. Germany's ambassador to Russia, Pourtalès, reported that Russia was willing to see Serbia accept almost all of the demands and favoured direct talks with Austria-Hungary.

Overall, Germany's reaction to Serbia's response to the Austrian ultimatum was influenced by their diplomatic manoeuvring and strategic interests in the region. While they worked to contain the immediate fallout, their actions also contributed to the escalating tensions that ultimately led to the outbreak of World War I.

The ultimatum's impact on Germany's expansionary policies

The Austrian ultimatum to Serbia on 23 July 1914, which led to the July Crisis, had a significant impact on Germany's expansionary policies. The ultimatum, delivered by Baron Giesl von Gieslingen, the Austro-Hungarian ambassador to Serbia, was issued with the full support of Germany and was intended to force a military conflict with Serbia. Germany's involvement in drafting and encouraging the ultimatum demonstrated its expansionist ambitions and its willingness to use aggressive tactics to achieve them.

Germany's support for Austria-Hungary in the ultimatum revealed its desire for territorial expansion and its disregard for diplomatic solutions. The ultimatum demanded that Serbia accept an Austro-Hungarian inquiry into the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand, suppress anti-Austrian propaganda, and take action against terrorist organizations. While Serbia's response conceded to most demands, Austria-Hungary nonetheless declared war shortly afterward. This sequence of events highlighted Germany's role in orchestrating the crisis and its alignment with Austria-Hungary against Serbia.

The impact of the ultimatum on Germany's expansionary policies became more apparent in the years leading up to World War II. Germany, under Nazi rule, pursued a policy of territorial aggression, starting with the annexation of Austria in March 1938, known as the Anschluss. This act violated the Treaty of Versailles and the Treaty of Saint-Germain, which expressly forbade the unification of Austria and Germany. By this action, Hitler continued his expansionist agenda, taking advantage of the appeasement policies of other European powers.

The Anschluss transformed Austria overnight, leading to the persecution of the country's Jewish population and the enthusiastic participation of Austrians in the Nazification process. This demonstrated the far-reaching consequences of Germany's expansionist policies, which built upon the foundations laid by the Austrian ultimatum years earlier. The ultimatum had set a precedent for aggressive actions and the pursuit of territorial gains, emboldening Hitler to continue his expansionist agenda unchecked.

In conclusion, the Austrian ultimatum of 1914 had a significant impact on Germany's expansionary policies. It revealed Germany's aggressive tactics, expansionist ambitions, and alignment with Austria-Hungary. The consequences of the ultimatum extended beyond the July Crisis, influencing Hitler's policies leading up to World War II. The ultimatum's legacy was evident in the annexation of Austria and the subsequent pursuit of further territorial gains by Nazi Germany.

Frequently asked questions