The Great Afghan Exodus: Understanding The Annual Flight From Afghanistan

Afghanistan has been suffering from insecurity and conflict for the past 50 years, which has led to a mass exodus of its citizens. Since 2001, 5.9 million Afghans have either been displaced internally or fled the country, primarily to Pakistan and Iran. By 2000, over 6 million Afghan refugees were residing in Iran and Pakistan. In 2023, Pakistan and Iran decided to deport more refugees. As of October 2020, there were 780,000 registered Afghan refugees in Iran, and in 2021, the number of Afghans in Pakistan was 1,438,432. The continuous wars in Afghanistan, political and religious persecution, and poverty have created a diasporic population of over 8.2 million Afghans across 103 countries.

The US withdrawal from Afghanistan in 2021

The decision to withdraw US troops from Afghanistan was made by President Joe Biden, who set an initial deadline of September 11, 2021—the 20th anniversary of 9/11—for the full withdrawal. This deadline was later moved up to August 31, 2021. The withdrawal was negotiated by former President Donald Trump with the Taliban in 2020, with the Taliban agreeing to sever ties with Al-Qaida and stop attacks on US forces in exchange.

The evacuation of US citizens and vulnerable Afghans was chaotic and dangerous, with thousands of people swarming Kabul's airport desperate to flee Taliban rule. US troops had to be deployed to secure the airport perimeter and protect the evacuation process. The evacuation was also deadly, with 13 US service members and dozens of Afghans killed in an attack by the militant group ISIS-K outside the airport on August 26, 2021.

The US withdrawal left many Afghans who had helped US forces and those who felt at risk from the Taliban behind. It also raised fears that Afghanistan could once again become a safe haven for terrorists, as was the case with al-Qaida leader Ayman al-Zawahiri, who was discovered in Kabul and killed in a US drone strike in July 2021.

The Taliban's swift takeover of Afghanistan drew comparisons to the fall of Saigon in 1975 and raised questions about the capability of Western democracies to build lasting institutions in countries like Afghanistan. It also sparked a refugee crisis, with Afghans fleeing the country in fear of Taliban rule.

The US withdrawal from Afghanistan was a controversial decision that divided Americans. While 54% supported the decision to withdraw, 42% believed it was the wrong choice. The handling of the situation by the Biden administration was also widely criticized, with large majorities expressing negative views.

The Taliban's return to power

The Taliban's harsh interpretation of Islamic law has resulted in severe restrictions on women's rights and freedoms. Most women have been banned from working, girls have been prohibited from attending secondary school, and all women have been banned from attending and teaching at universities. Women are also no longer allowed to travel long distances without a male chaperone and have been ordered to cover their faces in public. The Taliban has re-established its Ministry for the Propagation of Virtue and Prevention of Vice, which enforces prohibitions on behaviour deemed un-Islamic.

The Taliban's rule has also had a catastrophic impact on Afghanistan's economy, which has effectively collapsed. Malnutrition rates have soared, and hundreds of thousands of jobs have been lost. The banking sector has been paralysed by sanctions, and Afghanistan has been unable to engage with the international financial system. The value of its currency has plummeted, raising the cost of imports and exacerbating inflation.

The healthcare system is also in a state of crisis, with limited access to basic healthcare services and high rates of child malnutrition. The Taliban's crackdown on free speech and political activity has further exacerbated the situation, with journalists and activists detained, beaten, and intimidated.

The future for Afghans living under Taliban rule remains highly uncertain. While the end of the war has brought some relief, millions are struggling to survive, and there is a constant threat of violence and human rights abuses. The international community's response to the Taliban's return to power has been largely ineffective, with aid conditionality failing to influence the group's behaviour. As a result, Afghanistan faces a dire economic and humanitarian crisis, with no end in sight to the suffering of its people.

Afghan refugees and asylum seekers

Afghanistan has been suffering from insecurity and conflict for the past 50 years, which has led to an increase in internal displacement. Afghan refugees are citizens of Afghanistan who were forced to flee from their country as a result of continuous wars, political or religious persecution, and violence. Since 2001, 5.9 million Afghans have either been displaced internally or fled the country, primarily to Pakistan and Iran. Afghan refugees represent one of the world's largest protracted refugee populations. There are more than 8 million Afghans who have been forced to flee their homes, creating a diasporic population of over 8.2 million Afghans across 103 countries.

Iranian officials, for example, deport thousands of undocumented Afghans without allowing them to demonstrate a legal right to remain in Iran or lodge an asylum application. Pakistan currently hosts more than 1.5 million registered Afghan refugees and another million unregistered Afghans. In 2016 alone, up to 365,000 refugees were forcibly returned to Afghanistan from Pakistan, in what Human Rights Watch described as "the world's largest unlawful mass forced return of refugees in recent times".

Some countries that were part of the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) established special programs to allow thousands of Afghans to resettle in North America or Europe. As stateless refugees or asylum seekers, they are protected by the well-established non-refoulement principle and the U.N. Convention Against Torture. They receive maximum government benefits and protections in countries such as Australia, Canada, Germany, the United Kingdom, and the United States.

In 2021, the Canadian government announced it would resettle 40,000 vulnerable Afghans, including women, girls, members of the LGBTQ+ community, human rights workers, and journalists. By August 2022, Canada had resettled 17,375 Afghan refugees. In the same year, the US admitted more than 10,000 Afghan refugees from the United Arab Emirates, which became a temporary host on behalf of other nations. Throughout the course of Operation Allies Welcome, the United States issued humanitarian parole status to more than 76,000 evacuated Afghan nationals.

The impact of US military presence

The US military presence in Afghanistan lasted for nearly 20 years, from 2001 to 2021. The US invasion of Afghanistan was justified by the need to prevent the country from becoming a safe haven for international terrorists and to take revenge for the September 11th terrorist attacks. The US-led coalition aimed to create the conditions for the Afghan government to exercise its authority throughout the country and build the capacity of the Afghan national security forces.

The impact of the US military presence in Afghanistan has been significant. Firstly, the US military presence contributed to the displacement of Afghan nationals. The war led to both internal and external displacement, with many Afghans fleeing to neighbouring countries such as Pakistan and Iran. The US-led coalition's actions also caused civilian casualties and fuelled the insurgency. Additionally, the US military presence resulted in the Taliban's resurgence and their eventual return to power in 2021.

Secondly, the US military presence had a complex effect on Afghanistan's social and economic development. On the one hand, the US provided financial support for Afghanistan's security forces and development projects. However, the efforts were hampered by inadequate funding, waste, and confusion over responsibilities. The US presence also led to social and economic disruptions, with sluggish reconstruction efforts, widespread corruption, and civilian casualties causing anti-American and anti-Western sentiment among Afghans.

Thirdly, the US military presence had a significant impact on Afghanistan's political landscape. The US supported the establishment of a powerful central government under Hamid Karzai, which was beset by corruption and internal divisions. The US-led coalition's presence also influenced the peace process, with the Taliban refusing to participate in negotiations until all foreign forces had withdrawn.

Finally, the US military presence had regional implications, particularly in Pakistan. The presence of US forces in Afghanistan contributed to tensions between the two countries, with Pakistan being accused of harbouring Taliban militants and providing safe havens. The relationship between the US and Pakistan was further strained by the US drone strikes targeting insurgent leaders in Pakistan.

The future of Afghan refugees

Afghan refugees are one of the world's largest protracted refugee populations. The country has been mired in conflict since the 1970s, with violence being the major factor in involuntary population movements among Afghans. The continuous wars, political and religious persecution, and poverty have resulted in a diasporic population of over 8.2 million Afghans across 103 countries.

Host Country Challenges

Afghan refugees have primarily sought refuge in neighbouring Pakistan and Iran, with smaller numbers going to India, Turkey, and countries in Europe and North America. While these countries have provided temporary refuge, there are challenges.

In Pakistan, Afghan refugees have faced racial discrimination, harassment, and mistreatment by authorities. They have limited rights, restricted access to education, and are vulnerable to deportation. Iran has also deported thousands of undocumented Afghans without allowing them to seek asylum.

Inadequate International Support

The international community has been criticized for showing indifference towards Afghan refugees, with Europe, Iran, and Pakistan forcibly returning large numbers. The forced returns add to instability in Afghanistan, as the country lacks the capacity to absorb these returnees.

Insecurity and Conflict in Afghanistan

The ongoing conflict and instability in Afghanistan pose significant challenges for the return of refugees. The Taliban's rule, widespread insecurity, weak rule of law, corruption, and underdevelopment make it unsafe for refugees to return. The country also faces a humanitarian crisis, with limited access to healthcare, malnutrition, and a lack of essential services.

Education and Skills Development

Education and skills development are crucial for the future of Afghan refugees, especially the younger generation. However, lack of educational facilities, poverty, and parental indifference have resulted in low enrolment rates among Afghan refugee children. This lack of education can lead to crime and militancy, impacting both host countries and Afghanistan itself.

Need for Sustainable Solutions

The preferred solution is voluntary repatriation, but the current conditions in Afghanistan do not support sustainable returns. The international community needs to ensure security and provide development assistance, particularly in health, education, and employment.

Bilateral Relations and Regional Cooperation

The issue of Afghan refugees has impacted relations between Afghanistan and its neighbours, especially Pakistan. There is a need for a people-centric approach and improved bilateral ties to address the refugee crisis effectively. Regional economic cooperation, such as through the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC), can also play a role in promoting stability and development in the region.

In conclusion, the future of Afghan refugees depends on a range of factors, including the stability of Afghanistan, international support, access to education and skills development, and regional cooperation. While there are challenges, creative solutions are emerging, and the international community must work together to ensure the protection and well-being of this vulnerable population.

Frequently asked questions