The Sound Of Energy: Bahrain's Turbine Noise Levels

The Bahrain World Trade Center is a 240-metre-high, 50-floor, twin-tower complex located in Manama, Bahrain. It is the first skyscraper in the world to integrate wind turbines into its design. The structure features three 29-metre-diameter wind turbines suspended between the two towers, which are expected to provide 11% to 15% of the complex's total power consumption. While the innovative design has been lauded for its sustainability, there have been concerns about the noise and vibration caused by the turbines, with some reports suggesting that the offices below are unusable when the turbines are in operation. So, how loud are the turbines in Bahrain?

The turbines are loud and cause vibrations, making the office space unusable

The Bahrain World Trade Center is a 240-metre-high, 50-floor, twin-tower complex located in Manama, Bahrain. It is the first skyscraper in the world to integrate wind turbines into its design. The building features three 29-metre-diameter wind turbines suspended between the two towers, which are expected to provide 11% to 15% of the towers' total power consumption.

While the wind turbines have been praised for their innovative design and contribution to sustainability, there have been concerns about the noise and vibrations they produce. Some people have reported that the turbines cause a low, irritating hum and vibrations that make it difficult to work in the offices below. In fact, one commenter stated that the office space was unusable due to the noise and vibrations, and as a result, the turbines are now locked in position and do not turn.

The issue of noise and vibrations from the turbines seems to be a common problem, with similar issues reported in other buildings with integrated wind turbines, such as the Strata Tower in London. The turbines in the Bahrain World Trade Center may not have been adequately designed to address this issue, as some people have reported that the building vibrates when all three turbines are turned on together. To mitigate this problem, the building management usually only runs one or two turbines at a time.

The designers of the building may have prioritised the integration of wind turbines and the potential for renewable energy over the comfort and usability of the office space. This suggests that more careful consideration of the potential impact on occupants is needed when designing and constructing similar buildings in the future. While the use of wind turbines in skyscrapers is a commendable step towards sustainability, it is important to ensure that the spaces remain usable and comfortable for those who work there.

The turbines are expected to operate 50% of the time on an average day

The Bahrain World Trade Center (BWTC) in Manama, Bahrain, is a 240-metre-high (787 ft), 50-floor, twin-tower complex. It is the first skyscraper in the world to integrate wind turbines into its design. The building features three 225 kW wind turbines, each measuring 29 metres (95 ft) in diameter, with a combined wind power capacity of 675 kW. These turbines are expected to operate 50% of the time on an average day.

The turbines are located on three sky bridges that link the two towers. The towers themselves are sail-shaped, designed to funnel wind through the gap between them and provide accelerated wind passing through the turbines. This innovative design was confirmed by wind tunnel tests, which showed that the buildings create an S-shaped flow, ensuring any wind coming within a 45-degree angle to either side of the central axis will create a wind stream that remains perpendicular to the turbines. This optimisation of wind flow significantly increases the potential for electricity generation.

The wind turbines in the BWTC are expected to provide 11% to 15% of the towers' total power consumption, or approximately 1.1 to 1.3 GWh per year. This amount of energy is equivalent to providing lighting for about 300 homes, 258 hospitals, 17 industrial plants, and 33 car engines.

The BWTC has received recognition for its sustainability, winning awards such as the 2006 LEAF Award for Best Use of Technology within a Large Scheme and the Arab Construction World for Sustainable Design Award. The building's design and integration of wind turbines showcase a commitment to environmental sustainability and a move towards more sustainable design in desert climates.

The turbines are designed to generate between 11% and 15% of the centre's energy needs

The Bahrain World Trade Center (BWTC) is a 240-metre-high, 50-floor, twin-tower complex in Manama, Bahrain. It is the first skyscraper in the world to integrate wind turbines into its design. The structure features three 29-metre-diameter wind turbines suspended between the two towers on sky bridges. These turbines are expected to generate between 11% and 15% of the centre's energy needs, which is equivalent to approximately 1.1 to 1.3 GWh per year. This amount of energy can provide lighting for about 300 homes, 258 hospitals, 17 industrial plants, and 33 car engines.

The unique design of the BWTC maximises wind power to achieve this level of energy generation. The towers are sail-shaped, acting as airfoils that channel wind through the gap between them. This funnel shape accelerates the wind passing through the turbines, increasing their potential to generate electricity. Additionally, wind tunnel tests showed that the buildings create an S-shaped flow, ensuring that any wind within a 45-degree angle to either side of the central axis will create a perpendicular wind stream, further optimising energy production.

The BWTC is a testament to innovative design and sustainability. It has received multiple awards, including the 2006 LEAF Award for Best Use of Technology within a Large Scheme and the Arab Construction World for Sustainable Design Award. The integration of wind turbines in an oil-rich country like Bahrain is a notable step towards reducing demand on fossil fuel energy reserves and promoting sustainable design in desert climates.

While the BWTC is a pioneering example of wind energy integration, it has faced some challenges. One issue is the noise and vibration created by the turbines, which can make the office spaces below challenging to work in. To mitigate this, the turbines are often operated individually or turned off entirely during periods of high wind speed. Additionally, the building's design could have been optimised further for energy generation. Prof.dr.ir. Bert Blocken from Eindhoven University of Technology noted that if the towers were built in the opposite direction, they could have produced up to 15% more energy per year.

The turbines are fixed horizontal-axis, and can only operate with wind from a limited azimuth range

The Bahrain World Trade Center is a 240-metre-high, 50-floor, twin-tower complex located in Manama, Bahrain. It is the first skyscraper in the world to integrate wind turbines into its design. The building features three 225 kW wind turbines, each measuring 29 metres in diameter, for a total wind power capacity of 675 kW. These turbines are fixed horizontal-axis, meaning that the rotational axis of the rotor is parallel to the wind direction. This type of turbine is much more widely used than vertical-axis turbines, even though it requires a mechanism for orienting the blades. Horizontal-axis turbines are characterised by a higher aerodynamic yield and can start autonomously. They are also less expensive and less exposed to mechanical stress.

The turbines in the Bahrain World Trade Center are fixed in a north-facing direction, as this is the direction from which air from the Persian Gulf blows in. The sail-shaped buildings on either side of the turbines are designed to funnel wind through the gap between them, providing accelerated wind passing through the turbines. This means that the turbines can only operate with wind from a limited azimuth range, specifically a 45-degree angle to either side of the central axis. Wind tunnel tests confirmed that the buildings create an S-shaped flow, ensuring that wind within this range creates a wind stream that remains perpendicular to the turbines, maximising their potential to generate electricity.

The turbines are expected to operate 50% of the time on an average day and provide 11% to 15% of the towers' total power consumption, or approximately 1.1 to 1.3 GWh a year. This is equivalent to providing lighting for about 300 homes, 258 hospitals, 17 industrial plants, and 33 car engines.

The turbines are controlled by a wind turbine control system (WTCS)

The Bahrain World Trade Center is a 240-metre-high (787 ft), 50-floor, twin-tower complex located in Manama, Bahrain. It is the first skyscraper in the world to integrate wind turbines into its design. The three 225 kW wind turbines, totalling 675 kW of wind power capacity, are controlled by a wind turbine control system (WTCS).

The WTCS plays a critical role in optimising the performance of the wind turbines and ensuring their safe and efficient operation. It consists of advanced hardware and software components that work together to regulate the turbines' behaviour. The system takes into account various factors, such as wind speed, direction, and turbulence, to adjust the turbines' operation accordingly.

One of the key functions of the WTCS is to maximise the power generation of the turbines. By using computational fluid dynamics and wind tunnel tests, engineers were able to determine the ideal shape of the towers to funnel wind through the gap between them. The WTCS then uses this design advantage to control the turbines' speed and orientation, maximising their exposure to the funnelled wind.

Additionally, the WTCS is responsible for monitoring the turbines' performance and detecting any potential issues or anomalies. It can adjust the turbines' operation to maintain optimal performance and minimise downtime. This includes implementing control strategies to address issues such as vibration, noise, and excessive wind speeds, which have been noted as concerns by some occupants of the building.

The WTCS also plays a vital role in ensuring the safety of the wind turbines. It can detect and respond to adverse conditions, such as high winds or mechanical issues, by activating safety protocols. This may include slowing down or stopping the turbines to prevent damage or potential hazards. Overall, the WTCS is an essential component of the Bahrain World Trade Center's wind turbine system, enabling efficient power generation while maintaining the safety and comfort of those within the building.

Frequently asked questions