The Troubled Legacy: Evaluating The Economic Impact Of America's Longest War

The US economy has been impacted in both positive and negative ways by the war in Afghanistan. On the one hand, the war has contributed to significant economic setbacks in the US through lost opportunities for investment in public infrastructure and services, and higher borrowing rates. The hundreds of billions of dollars invested in military assets could have been spent on improving public infrastructure such as roads and water systems. War spending has also contributed to higher interest rates for borrowers. On the other hand, some argue that war spending has helped rejuvenate the economy, reducing unemployment rates. The total cost of the war is estimated at $2.3 trillion, with the benefit, according to some, being the avoidance of another 9/11-style attack.

The US spent $2 trillion on the war in Afghanistan

The US spent approximately $2 trillion on the war in Afghanistan. This figure includes not only the costs of military equipment and training but also interest payments on borrowed funds, veterans' care, and other increased Pentagon expenses. The war in Afghanistan has contributed to significant economic setbacks in the US, including lost opportunities for investment in public infrastructure and higher borrowing rates.

The biggest chunk of the $2 trillion spent in Afghanistan went to the Overseas Contingency Operations budget for the Department of Defense, consuming nearly $1 trillion. The second-largest expense was the estimated $530 billion in interest payments on borrowed funds to finance the war. The US also appropriated over $144 billion for Afghan reconstruction, much of which went to private contractors and NGOs tasked with implementing programmes to build Afghanistan's security forces, improve governance, and combat illicit drugs.

Despite the enormous investment, Afghanistan still has one of the smallest formal economies in the world. President Ashraf Ghani stated that 90% of the population was living on less than $2 per day. The illicit economy, meanwhile, has thrived. Afghanistan is now the leading global supplier of opium and heroin.

The war in Afghanistan has had a devastating impact on the country's economy, with ordinary citizens suffering from severe poverty and a dependent economy. The US occupation created this dependent economy by providing just enough aid for survival, and much of the aid was funnelled through warlords rather than reaching the people directly.

In terms of the benefits of the war, the avoided cost of another terrorist attack on US soil could be considered. The direct impact of the 9/11 attacks on the US economy was estimated at a 0.5% hit to GDP, which would be over $100 billion in today's terms. However, the expense of the wars in Afghanistan, Iraq, and Syria far exceeds this figure, totalling more than $5 trillion.

The US government's decision to withdraw from Afghanistan was based in part on the recognition that the economic and human costs of the war were not yielding commensurate results. The fall of the Afghan government and the rapid takeover by the Taliban underscored the failure of the US investment to create sustainable security and stability in the country.

The US economy suffered due to lost opportunities for investment in public infrastructure

The US economy has suffered due to lost opportunities for investment in public infrastructure. The money spent on the war in Afghanistan could have been invested in education, healthcare, or green energy, creating at least 1.4 million more jobs. Instead, the money was spent on military assets such as ships and aircraft, which have little positive impact on the wider US economy.

The hundreds of billions of dollars spent on military assets during the first decade of the war in Afghanistan could have been used to improve core public economic infrastructure, such as roads and water systems. This would have had a more significant impact on the US economy and improved the lives of US citizens.

The war spending has also contributed to higher interest rates for borrowers, as it has been financed entirely by debt. This has led to a higher ratio of national debt to Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and subsequent rising long-term interest rates. As a result, borrowers such as new homeowners are facing higher interest rates on their loans.

The opportunity cost of the war in Afghanistan is significant, and the US economy has undoubtedly suffered due to the lost opportunities for investment in public infrastructure and services. The money spent on the war could have been used to create jobs, improve infrastructure, and reduce the national debt, all of which would have had a positive impact on the US economy.

The war led to higher interest rates charged to borrowers

The US war in Afghanistan has had a significant economic impact, with costs estimated at $2.3 trillion by the Congressional Budget Office and Brown University. This spending has been financed entirely by debt, which has contributed to a higher ratio of national debt to Gross Domestic Product (GDP). As a result, borrowers such as new homeowners now face higher long-term interest rates charged by banks and other creditors.

The war in Afghanistan has contributed to higher borrowing rates for Americans, including those taking out loans for homes or other large purchases. This is due to the increased national debt incurred by the US government to fund the war efforts. The war has been expensive, with the US government spending billions of dollars on military assets, such as ships and aircraft, as well as reconstruction and aid in Afghanistan. This has resulted in a higher ratio of national debt to GDP, which has subsequently led to rising long-term interest rates.

The impact of war spending on interest rates is a significant cost of the post-9/11 wars. The hundreds of billions of dollars invested in military assets could have been used to improve public infrastructure, such as roads and water systems, or to invest in sectors like clean energy, public education, and healthcare, which create more jobs. Instead, the money borrowed to fund the war has contributed to higher interest rates for borrowers.

The war in Afghanistan has not only contributed to higher interest rates but has also had other economic impacts. The opportunity cost of war spending means that there are fewer investments in public infrastructure and services. Additionally, the war has led to increased geopolitical uncertainty, impacting markets and asset prices. The war has also contributed to a falling dollar, which, along with rising energy prices, has strained the budgets of US companies and consumers.

The war in Afghanistan has had far-reaching economic consequences, including higher interest rates for borrowers. The increased national debt and opportunity costs of war spending have impacted Americans' borrowing rates and affected investments in public infrastructure and services. The war has also contributed to geopolitical uncertainty and market volatility, further impacting the economy.

The US economy is now less dependent on war spending

The US has spent $2.26 trillion on the war in Afghanistan since 2001, according to the Costs of War Project at Brown University. This figure includes the Overseas Contingency Operations budget for the Department of Defense, interest payments on borrowed funds, and appropriations for Afghan reconstruction. However, despite this significant expenditure, the US economy's dependence on war spending is relatively modest compared to historical levels.

During World War II, defense spending rose to 37.8% of US gross domestic product (GDP). In comparison, the combined US defense budget and war spending today account for about 6.2% of GDP. This indicates a decreasing reliance on war spending as a proportion of overall economic activity.

The impact of war spending on the economy is a subject of debate among economists. Some argue that massive defense spending during World War II helped rejuvenate the US economy, reducing unemployment rates. Others, like economist Joseph E. Stiglitz, contend that increased military spending negatively affects the living standards of citizens and can push a country towards recession.

The war in Afghanistan has had collateral economic consequences beyond direct expenditures. For example, the conflict has contributed to volatility in global oil markets and increased international debt. However, the overall economic impact of the war on the US is complex and remains a subject of discussion among experts.

As the war in Afghanistan has ended, the US economy is no longer directly dependent on war spending related to that specific conflict. The US federal government can now allocate resources differently, potentially investing more in areas such as education, healthcare, or green energy, which some argue would have created more jobs than war spending.

While the US economy has been influenced by war spending, it is important to recognize that the economy is a complex system with numerous factors at play. The country's economic health is influenced by a variety of domestic and global factors beyond military expenditures.

The war in Afghanistan has negatively impacted the Afghan economy

The war has resulted in severe poverty, with the majority of the population unable to meet their basic food and non-food needs. The proportion of households that did not have enough income to meet basic food needs more than doubled from 16% to 36% between 2021 and 2022. The interim Taliban administration's policies, including restrictions on women, have further exacerbated the country's instability and hindered economic growth.

The war has also led to a brain drain, with tens of thousands of highly skilled Afghans fleeing the country. The banking sector is dysfunctional due to constraints on international transfers and concerns about liquidity and solvency. The country's export growth is weakening, and structural deficiencies in the private sector are expected to impede any significant economic progress.

The war has also resulted in increased economic inequality, with warlords and political elites profiting from corruption and the drug trade while the majority of the population has struggled to survive. The ordinary citizens of Afghanistan have dealt with severe poverty and impoverishment, with little to no economic benefit from the war.

Overall, the war in Afghanistan has had a devastating impact on the country's economy, leading to increased poverty, unemployment, inequality, and a weakened private sector. The country is now facing a dire humanitarian crisis, with a lack of access to basic needs such as food, education, and healthcare.

Frequently asked questions