South Tyrol's Future: Austria Or Italy?

South Tyrol, an autonomous Italian province, was part of the Austro-Hungarian County of Tyrol until 1918. It was annexed by Italy following World War I and has since been the subject of calls for secession and reunification with Austria. The region has a complex history, with a majority German-speaking, Austrian-oriented population that has experienced cultural assimilation and language suppression under Fascist Italy. While some South Tyroleans feel a strong connection to Austria and support the idea of reunification, others value the benefits of their autonomous status within Italy. The question of South Tyrol's future remains a topic of debate among locals, politicians, and international observers.

The South Tyrolean independence movement

South Tyrol, an autonomous Italian province, was part of the Austro-Hungarian County of Tyrol until 1918. It was annexed by Italy following Italy's defeat of the Central Powers in World War I. Since then, there have been calls for South Tyrol's secession from Italy and reunification with Austria.

The South Tyrolean Freedom (STF) party, a regionalist, separatist, and national-conservative political party, is at the forefront of the South Tyrolean independence movement. The party seeks to represent the German-speaking population of South Tyrol, who view their incorporation into Italy as a historical injustice. The STF proposes the secession of South Tyrol from Italy and its reunification with the State of Tyrol within Austria, advocating for the right to self-determination through a referendum.

The history of South Tyrol has been marked by a struggle over the rights of German-speaking people, who form a minority in Italy but a large majority in South Tyrol. Following its annexation, the Fascist regime attempted to assimilate South Tyrol into Italy, banning the German language from public offices, schools, and health establishments, and imposing the Italian name "Alto-Adige" on the province.

In response to these injustices, the German-speaking population of South Tyrol has long sought a return to Austria. The Südtiroler Volkspartei (SVP), or South Tyrolian People's Party, established after World War II, has been a major proponent of secessionism. However, Italian nationalists have opposed this movement, arguing that German-speakers wishing to join Austria should leave the territory.

Despite the challenges, the South Tyrolean independence movement has gained significant support. Polls conducted in 2013 revealed that 46% of South Tyrol's population would favour secession from Italy. The movement has been further fuelled by events such as the Scottish vote on independence from the UK, which has demonstrated the strength of European democracies to withstand democratic paths to secession.

The complex history and cultural associations of South Tyrol with neighbouring Austria continue to shape the political landscape of the region. While legal and practical obstacles make secession challenging, the movement persists as a reflection of the region's unique identity and aspirations for self-determination.

The South Tyrolean Liberation Committee

The history of the South Tyrolean Liberation Committee can be divided into two stages. In the first phase, from 1956 to 1961, the activists focused on symbolic targets, such as relics of the fascist regime, and tried to avoid causing physical harm to people. On 12 June 1961, the BAS organised the bombing of 37 electricity pylons supplying power to the industrial zone of Bolzano, later known as the Night of Fire (Feuernacht).

After the imprisonment of almost all leading members, the organisation entered a second, more violent phase. This phase was characterised by an increasing infiltration of Austrian and German neo-Nazis and intensified secret service activities, which culminated in several assassinations and ambushes on Italian security forces. The most notorious attack during this period was the 1967 attack on a security patrol at Cima Vallona, in which four Italian soldiers were killed.

With the progression of negotiations concerning South Tyrolean autonomy in the late 1960s, the activities of the BAS slowed down. The South Tyrolean Liberation Committee ceased to exist after a series of arrests in 1981.

Today, South Tyrol is a peaceful and wealthy Italian province, enjoying a high degree of autonomy and strong relations with the Austrian state of Tyrol. However, given the region's historical and cultural ties to Austria, calls for secession and reunification with Austria persist among some locals and political groups.

The region's complex history

South Tyrol, an autonomous Italian province, was part of the Austro-Hungarian County of Tyrol until 1918. It was annexed by Italy after World War I, but its complex history dates back much further.

In 15 BC, the region was conquered by Roman commanders and incorporated into the provinces of Raetia and Noricum. After the fall of the Roman Empire, the region changed hands several times, eventually becoming part of the Ostrogothic Kingdom of Italy in the 5th and 6th centuries. Over the following centuries, it was influenced by the Kingdom of the Franks, the Lombards, and the German stem duchy of Bavaria.

In the 11th century, Emperor Conrad II established the Prince-bishopric of Trent, securing control of the region. The territory was further consolidated under the Counts of Tyrol, who gained independence from Bavaria in 1180. From the 13th century, they held much of their territory directly from the Holy Roman Emperor and were elevated to Princes of the Holy Roman Empire in 1504.

After the Napoleonic Wars, the Austrian Empire was forced to cede the northern part of Tyrol to Bavaria in the Peace of Pressburg. Tyrol remained split between Bavaria and Napoleonic Italy until 1814, when it was returned to Austria by the Congress of Vienna.

The rise of nationalism in Europe after the Napoleonic Era had a significant impact on South Tyrol. The struggle for Italian unification was largely waged against the Austrian Empire, which controlled many ethnically Italian areas. This period, known as Italian irredentism, led to increasing tensions between Italy and Austria.

During World War I, Italy joined the Allied Powers and declared war on the Central Powers, including Austria-Hungary. The Treaty of London, signed in secret, promised Italy territorial gains in Austrian crown lands, including South Tyrol. Despite petitions from South Tyrolean officials and assurances from US President Woodrow Wilson, South Tyrol fell under Italian military administration after the war with the signing of the Treaty of Saint-Germain-en-Laye in 1919.

Under Benito Mussolini's Fascist regime, South Tyrol experienced a strong push for cultural assimilation, with the Italianization policy aiming to eliminate the German language in speech, education, and everyday use. During World War II, Italy and Nazi Germany formed the Axis Powers, and the South Tyrol Option Agreement led to the resettlement of a significant portion of the South Tyrolean population to German-controlled territories.

After World War II, South Tyrol was granted a certain level of self-government, and in 1972, it was designated as an autonomous province within Italy, allowing for greater self-governance. This status was further solidified by an agreement between the Austrian and Italian governments in 1992, which granted South Tyrol extensive privileges, including retaining 90% of its tax revenues.

Today, South Tyrol enjoys a high degree of autonomy and strong relations with the Austrian state of Tyrol, particularly after Austria's entry into the European Union, which led to a common currency and the de facto disappearance of borders. However, calls for secession and reunification with Austria persist, fueled by the region's historical and cultural ties to Austria.

The linguistic divide

South Tyrol is characterised by its three native language groups: German, Italian, and Ladin. The region became part of Italy after the breakup of Austria-Hungary in 1919, and the Italianisation of South Tyrol significantly altered the local demographics.

In the 2024 census, 57.6% of the population used German as their first language, 22.6% spoke Italian, 3.7% spoke Ladin, and 16.1% spoke another language in addition to Italian and German. Of the 116 South Tyrolean municipalities, 102 have a German-speaking majority, eight have a Ladin-speaking majority, and six have an Italian-speaking majority.

The Second Autonomy Statute, implemented in 1972, gives legal, administrative, and financial independence to the province. It also introduced a system of proportionality between the three ethnolinguistic groups, with public administration positions, welfare resources, and funding for cultural activities divided between them.

Under this system, individuals must submit a declaration of linguistic affiliation to the Court. This has been criticised for contributing to divisions between ethnolinguistic groups and failing to foster social cohesion. The declaration does not account for individuals who speak multiple languages or none of the three official languages. This has particularly impacted migrants, who make up almost 10% of the population.

The division between language groups is embedded in the way of life in the region. Schools, for instance, are divided into three different systems. This has made it difficult for migrants like Mariam, a 42-year-old Moroccan woman, to integrate and interact in society. She and other migrants have expressed a desire for a bilingual or multilingual system that fosters social cohesion.

Despite these criticisms, the Second Autonomy Statute has been credited with successfully regulating conflict and promoting tolerance between South Tyrol's ethnolinguistic groups.

The economic implications

South Tyrol, a wealthy Italian province, has been part of Italy for almost 100 years. However, some South Tyroleans feel more Austrian than Italian. The region was annexed by Italy following World War I and has been the subject of reunification talks with Austria.

South Tyrol's return to Austria would have significant economic implications for both the region and the countries involved. Currently, South Tyrol enjoys a high degree of autonomy within Italy, retaining almost 90% of its tax revenues while still receiving a substantial amount of state services. This financial arrangement has contributed to South Tyrol's status as the wealthiest Italian province.

If South Tyrol were to return to Austria, the region's economic situation would likely change. As part of Austria, South Tyrol would be subject to the same tax laws as the other Austrian states, potentially resulting in a reduction in the region's tax revenues. Additionally, South Tyrol may no longer receive the same level of state services and investments from Italy, which could impact its economic development.

On the other hand, a return to Austria could also bring economic benefits to South Tyrol. The region has strong cultural and historical ties with Austria, particularly with the state of Tyrol, and joining Austria could strengthen economic cooperation and cross-border trade. A common currency and the de facto disappearance of borders between the two regions could facilitate trade and economic integration.

The impact of South Tyrol's return on the economies of Italy and Austria would also be noteworthy. For Italy, losing South Tyrol would mean a reduction in tax revenues and a potential decrease in economic activity in the surrounding regions. Italy's financial crisis could be exacerbated by the loss of South Tyrol's economic contributions.

For Austria, integrating South Tyrol into its economy could bring both challenges and opportunities. On the one hand, Austria would gain a wealthy region with a highly skilled workforce, contributing to its economic growth. On the other hand, Austria would need to invest in South Tyrol's infrastructure and public services, ensuring a smooth transition and maintaining the region's economic prosperity.

In conclusion, South Tyrol's return to Austria would have complex economic implications. While South Tyrol may benefit from strengthened economic ties with Austria, it would also face changes in its tax structure and relations with Italy. The impact on Italy and Austria's economies would also be significant, affecting tax revenues, economic activity, and cross-border relations.

Frequently asked questions