Germany's Military Presence In Afghanistan: A Complex Engagement

Germany has had troops in Afghanistan since 2001, when it joined the US-led war on terror. German soldiers are expressly told that their mission is not a combat one but rather a short intervention to stabilise the country. However, Germany is still taking part in a NATO-led mission to train the Afghan National Defence forces, with up to 1,300 soldiers deployed to Afghanistan. The German government has extended the Afghanistan mission several times, with the last extension lasting until January 2022. The German chancellor Angela Merkel has welcomed the US's decision to prolong its troops' engagement in Afghanistan.

Germany's military presence in Afghanistan dates back 18 years

Germany's military presence in Afghanistan dates back to 2002, when the country joined the US-led war on terror following the September 11 attacks. Over the years, Germany has deployed around 150,000 troops to Afghanistan, making it one of the largest contributors of troops to the conflict. The German military presence in Afghanistan has primarily focused on training and supporting the Afghan National Defence Forces, rather than direct combat operations. However, German troops have faced attacks and casualties during their nearly 20-year mission in the country.

In the early stages of the mission, German soldiers were told that their deployment was a short intervention aimed at stabilizing the country. However, the mission lasted for almost two decades and cost the lives of 59 German soldiers, with many more wounded in action. The conflict in Afghanistan has also taken a toll on the mental health of German troops, with a rise in cases of post-traumatic stress disorder among those who have served in the country.

Germany's involvement in Afghanistan has been a controversial issue domestically, with some lawmakers calling for an exit plan and questioning the justification for the continued presence of German troops. In recent years, Germany has begun to wind down its military presence in Afghanistan, with the last German troops departing the country in 2021. The withdrawal came amid a deteriorating security situation and concerns about the future of Afghanistan as international forces completed their withdrawal.

Despite the end of the military mission, Germany remains engaged in Afghanistan through diplomatic efforts and humanitarian aid. In 2021, German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock warned of a looming humanitarian catastrophe in Afghanistan and pledged to speed up the evacuation of vulnerable Afghans. Germany has also provided financial support and development assistance to Afghanistan over the years, with the Afghan intervention costing German taxpayers billions of euros.

The German government extended the Afghanistan mission for the last time in 2020

In 2020, the German government extended its military presence in Afghanistan for the last time. The German Parliament voted to continue the Afghanistan mission, which had been ongoing for nearly two decades at that point. The decision to extend the mission was made despite uncertainty over the future of the US military presence in the country, with opposition lawmakers calling for an exit plan.

The German government's decision to extend the Afghanistan mission was based on its commitment to NATO and its responsibility to promote human rights and the rule of law in Afghanistan. Foreign Minister Heiko Maas emphasised the progress made in the country over the previous two decades, including improvements in democratic institutions, living standards, and educational opportunities. He argued that the presence of German and NATO forces was vital to ensuring that these gains were not lost.

The extension of the mission was not without controversy, however. By 2020, the Afghanistan mission had become the bloodiest deployment of the Bundeswehr in Germany's postwar history. As of October 3, 2019, 59 German soldiers and three policemen had died in Afghanistan, with 39 of those deaths being hostile. In addition, 245 German soldiers and four police officers had been injured due to hostile activity. The high number of casualties caused concern in Germany, as it was the highest of all deployments abroad since World War II.

The financial cost of the mission was also significant. By the end of 2018, the Afghan intervention had cost German taxpayers around €16.4 billion, with the use of the Bundeswehr alone accounting for €12 billion.

Despite these concerns, the German Parliament approved the extension of the mission until January 2022, with up to 1,300 soldiers deployed to Afghanistan. However, this would be the final extension, and in June 2021, Germany completed its withdrawal from Afghanistan, bringing an end to its longest, most expensive, and bloodiest military mission since WWII.

The US withdrawal from Afghanistan could put peace and progress in danger

Firstly, the US withdrawal from Afghanistan endangered the fragile peace in the country. The Taliban, a fundamentalist regime that had provided sanctuary to al-Qaeda, quickly regained control of Afghanistan following the US withdrawal. This posed a significant threat to the security and stability of the region, as the Taliban had a history of supporting terrorist organizations and promoting extremist ideologies.

Secondly, the US withdrawal disrupted the progress made in Afghanistan over the past two decades. Since the US-led invasion in 2001, Afghanistan had made significant strides in establishing democratic institutions, improving living standards, and promoting human rights, particularly for women and girls. However, with the Taliban back in power, there are concerns that these gains could be lost. The Taliban have a history of oppressing women and denying them access to education and employment.

Additionally, the US withdrawal created a power vacuum in Afghanistan, leading to a security crisis. With the Afghan government and security forces weakened, there is a risk of the country descending into civil war or becoming a haven for terrorist organizations. The US military presence had played a crucial role in maintaining stability and countering terrorist groups.

Furthermore, the US withdrawal had a detrimental impact on the Afghan economy and development initiatives. Afghanistan is heavily reliant on international aid and support for its economic stability. The withdrawal of US troops and the subsequent collapse of the Afghan government disrupted development programs and put the country's future at risk.

Finally, the US withdrawal led to a refugee crisis, as thousands of Afghans fled the country out of fear of persecution and violence under Taliban rule. This crisis not only affected Afghanistan but also neighboring countries and the wider international community.

In conclusion, the US withdrawal from Afghanistan had far-reaching consequences and put the fragile peace and progress in the country in danger. It remains to be seen if Afghanistan can recover from this setback and find a path towards stability and prosperity without the presence of US troops.

The German military mission in Afghanistan was the bloodiest deployment of the Bundeswehr in Germany's postwar history

Germany's military mission in Afghanistan was the bloodiest deployment of the Bundeswehr in Germany's postwar history. The German parliament first approved sending the military to Afghanistan in December 2001, and the first troops arrived in Kabul in January 2002. Over the years, 59 German troops died in Afghan missions, with 35 of them killed in combat or as a result of militant attacks. This made the Afghanistan mission Germany's deadliest military mission since World War 2.

The German soldiers were expressly told that their mission was not a combat one but rather a short intervention aimed at stabilizing a war-torn, isolated country in which al-Qaida founder and September 11 attacks mastermind Osama bin Laden was hiding. However, the mission turned out to be very different. German soldiers died in suicide attacks and in combat—mainly in the Kunduz province in northern Afghanistan. Likewise, many Afghan civilians were killed there, including once when a German colonel ordered an airstrike on the Taliban in September 2009.

The German government has warned that a premature withdrawal of NATO troops could jeopardize peace talks with the Taliban. In 2020, the German Parliament extended the Afghanistan mission for the last time. The German military said that the last troops were on their way home via Tbilisi, Georgia, and that Brig. Gen. Ansgar Meyer, the last commander of the German contingent, was on board an Airbus A400M aircraft bringing them home.

The German military mission in Afghanistan has been costly, with the Afghan intervention costing German taxpayers around €16.4 billion by the end of 2018. The use of the Bundeswehr alone accounted for €12 billion.

The US withdrawal from Afghanistan could give the Taliban a tactical advantage

Germany has had troops in Afghanistan as part of a NATO-led mission to train the Afghan National Defense Forces. In 2020, the German Parliament extended the Afghanistan mission for the last time, with up to 1,300 soldiers deployed to Afghanistan until January 2022.

The US withdrawal from Afghanistan has been a highly debated topic, with some arguing that it could give the Taliban a tactical advantage. This is because the US military presence in Afghanistan has been a crucial factor in countering the Taliban's influence and preventing the country from becoming a safe haven for terrorist groups. With the US troops gone, there are concerns that the Taliban will gain more power and that Afghanistan could once again become a base for terrorist organizations.

The Taliban has already made significant gains in recent years, and the withdrawal of US troops could further embolden them. Additionally, the Afghan government and security forces have struggled to maintain stability and effectively counter the Taliban's advances. Without the support of US and NATO forces, it is uncertain whether the Afghan government will be able to hold off the Taliban's advances.

The US withdrawal could also have a negative impact on the counterterrorism efforts in the region. The US military presence in Afghanistan has provided valuable intelligence and surveillance capabilities that have been crucial in tracking and targeting terrorist groups. With the US troops gone, it will be much harder to gather information and carry out counterterrorism operations.

Furthermore, the withdrawal of US troops could lead to a deterioration of security and political stability in Afghanistan. This could create a power vacuum that the Taliban could exploit to gain more control over the country. Additionally, the US withdrawal could lead to a collapse of the Afghan economy, which has been heavily dependent on foreign funding and support.

The impact of the US withdrawal on the region remains to be seen, but there are concerns that it could lead to a resurgence of the Taliban and a decrease in security and stability in Afghanistan. It is crucial that the international community remains engaged in Afghanistan and continues to support the country's development and security to prevent it from becoming a safe haven for terrorist organizations.

Frequently asked questions