Brunei's Death Penalty For Homosexuality: A Dark Reality

In 2019, Brunei introduced Islamic criminal laws that punished gay sex and adultery by stoning offenders to death. The laws triggered an international outcry from countries, rights groups, and celebrities. The laws also cover a range of other crimes, including punishment for theft by amputation. Brunei's small LGBTQ+ community has expressed shock and fear at the medieval punishments, with many seeking asylum in other countries. The laws have been condemned by the United Nations, foreign governments, and celebrities, with calls for a boycott of luxury hotels owned by the country's leader. While it is unclear whether the death penalty will be carried out, the laws signal a rising intolerance and further marginalization of the LGBTQ+ community in Brunei.

The death penalty by stoning for gay sex in Brunei is a breach of human rights

The law, which is part of Brunei's Sharia Penal Code, punishes gay sex and adultery with death by stoning. This form of capital punishment is considered a brutal and archaic method of execution, amounting to torture. The introduction of stoning as a death sentence sets a new low bar for human rights in Southeast Asia, a region where same-sex relations are still a crime in many countries.

The death penalty by stoning for gay sex in Brunei violates several key premises of international human rights standards. Firstly, the death penalty itself is a controversial punishment that is contrary to established human rights standards. There is strong evidence that the death penalty is not an effective deterrent, and the possibility of an innocent person being wrongly killed is always present. Secondly, legislating torture as a means of capital punishment enshrines state impunity and signals a skewed justice system. Thirdly, by punishing sexual behaviour, the state encroaches on the private lives and behaviours of individuals, imposing its ideals of love, relationships, and marriage. The law fails to recognise concepts such as individual autonomy and consent, and infringes on citizens' rights to privacy and freedom of religion.

The impact of this law has been significant, with members of the LGBTQ+ community in Brunei expressing shock, fear, and dismay. Many have chosen to go further underground or seek asylum in other countries, as they no longer feel safe in their own country. The law has also had a chilling effect on the community, with people becoming paranoid and nervous about talking to each other, for fear of being discovered and punished.

The international community has a responsibility to speak out against such violations of human rights. Celebrities and human rights organisations have led the way in condemning the law and calling for action, including boycotts of Brunei-owned businesses. However, it is crucial that governments and international organisations also continue to apply pressure and use their diplomatic influence to urge Brunei to revoke these draconian laws and uphold the human rights of its citizens.

The law has caused Brunei's LGBT community to go into hiding or seek asylum

Brunei's LGBT community has been forced further underground or to seek asylum in other countries following the implementation of strict new Islamic laws that make anal sex and adultery punishable by stoning to death. The new measures, which came into force in April 2019, have sparked international condemnation from human rights groups, foreign governments, and celebrities.

The LGBT community in Brunei has expressed shock and fear at the "medieval punishments", with many individuals choosing to go into hiding or stop using dating apps and social media to connect with others in the community. Some have left the country, seeking asylum in nations such as Canada. The new laws have created a climate of fear, with individuals afraid of being discovered and punished under the harsh new penal code.

The laws stipulate that individuals accused of certain acts will be convicted if they confess or if there were witnesses present, with four Muslim witnesses required for acts of anal sex or adultery to be prosecuted. This high burden of proof has led to some speculation that the laws may not be widely enforced. However, the mere presence of the laws has had a chilling effect on the LGBT community in Brunei, causing them to further conceal their identities and avoid any actions that could draw attention.

The impact of the new penal code is already being felt in the country, with reports of LGBT individuals deleting dating apps and avoiding online communication out of fear of being targeted. The community, which was already underground due to the previous illegality of homosexuality, has become even more isolated and cautious. The new laws have also affected the relationships and social connections within the community, with people choosing to stop talking to each other or meet in person to avoid being discovered.

The introduction of these laws has caused a sense of fear and powerlessness among Bruneian citizens, who are unable to stop the implementation of Sharia law in their country. The LGBT community, in particular, faces the difficult choice between staying and risking persecution or leaving their homes and support systems to seek safety elsewhere.

The law also applies to non-Muslims and children, violating freedom of religion

Brunei's new penal code, which includes the death penalty for gay sex, has been met with international condemnation for violating freedom of religion and belief. The law applies to both Muslims and non-Muslims, with non-Muslims also facing the punishment of stoning to death for adultery. This means that non-Muslim citizens and foreigners can be put to death for their beliefs and sexual orientation, which goes against the principle of freedom of religion.

The law also applies to children who have reached puberty, with Muslim children as young as 18 years old being targeted. Those who "persuade, tell or encourage" Muslim minors to accept religions other than Islam are liable to a fine or jail time. This provision further violates freedom of religion by restricting the ability of individuals to choose and practice their own beliefs, regardless of their age.

The United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, Michelle Bachelet, urged Brunei's government to halt the implementation of the new penal code, stating that "any religion-based legislation must not violate human rights, including the rights of those belonging to the majority religion as well as of religious minorities and non-believers." She emphasised that religion-based laws should not supersede the fundamental human rights of individuals, regardless of their religious affiliation.

The new law has sparked outrage and protests from celebrities and human rights groups, who have called for a boycott of luxury hotels linked to Brunei. The international community has also responded, with countries such as the United States, the United Kingdom, Germany, and France urging Brunei to halt its plans. The backlash highlights the global support for freedom of religion and the protection of human rights, even in the face of strict religious laws.

While Brunei has since backtracked on enforcing the death penalty for gay sex, the existence of such laws and their potential for future implementation remain a concern for human rights advocates and the international community, who continue to call for their removal. The laws' infringement on freedom of religion and belief underscores the ongoing struggle for the protection and promotion of human rights worldwide, particularly in the context of religious law.

The international community has condemned the law and called for boycotts

The international community has widely condemned Brunei's law imposing the death penalty for gay sex, with countries, rights groups, and celebrities calling for boycotts and other actions to pressure the country to repeal the law.

The United Nations led the international criticism, with the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, Michelle Bachelet, urging Brunei's government to "stop the entry into force of this Draconian new penal code." The UN called the legislation cruel, inhuman, and degrading and said it marked a serious setback for human rights protection. The UN also warned that the laws contravened international human rights standards set out in the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which Brunei ratified in 2006.

In addition to the UN, countries such as the United States, the United Kingdom, Germany, and France urged Brunei to halt its plans. The State Department deputy spokesman, Robert Palladino, stated that the United States "strongly opposes violence, criminalization, and discrimination targeting vulnerable groups, including... lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and intersex persons."

Celebrities, including George Clooney, Elton John, and Ellen DeGeneres, also used their platforms to speak out against the law. Clooney and John joined rights groups in calling for a boycott of hotels owned by the Sultan of Brunei, and Clooney wrote an op-ed in Deadline Hollywood, asking, "Are we really going to help fund the murder of innocent citizens?" DeGeneres added that people need to "rise up" and "do something now." As a result of the boycott calls, companies like JPMorgan and Deutsche Bank told their staff to avoid using Brunei-owned hotels.

Rights groups, such as Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International, also condemned the law and called for action. Phil Robertson, the deputy Asia director for Human Rights Watch, called the penal code "barbaric to the core," and Rachel Chhoa-Howard, a Brunei researcher at Amnesty International, described the laws as "vicious" and asked the international community to condemn them.

The law may be a way for the Bruneian government to strengthen its power

Brunei's implementation of the death penalty for gay sex has been viewed as a way for the Bruneian government to strengthen its power. The country's economy has been declining, and the introduction of stricter laws may be an attempt to maintain control and appeal to more conservative and religious citizens.

The laws were enacted by Sultan Hassanal Bolkiah, who has ruled the country as an absolute monarchy since 1967. The Sultan is one of the wealthiest people in the world, and the country's oil-dependent economy has been suffering in recent years. The new laws may be an attempt to shore up support among conservatives and appeal to potential investors and tourists from the Muslim world. Matthew Woolfe, founder of the human rights group The Brunei Project, stated that the laws could be linked to the country's economic decline and could be a way for the government to "strengthen its hold on power."

The laws have been widely condemned by the international community, including the United Nations, foreign governments, celebrities, and human rights groups. Despite this, the Bruneian government has shown no signs of reversing its decision. The high burden of proof required to prosecute someone under these laws means that they are unlikely to be carried out, but they still contribute to a climate of fear and marginalization for the LGBTQ community in Brunei.

The laws also have a significant impact on the lives and freedoms of Bruneian citizens, particularly women, girls, and LGBTQ individuals. The government's encroachment into private life and the regulation of individual moral affairs give the police unprecedented reach into families and homes. The laws also fail to recognize concepts such as individual autonomy and consent, with compulsory heterosexuality being the imposed norm.

The international community has called for diplomatic pressure and action to be taken against Brunei, with some celebrities even calling for boycotts of the luxury hotels owned by the country's leader. However, the Bruneian government has remained unapologetic and committed to its decision, claiming that the laws are intended to "educate, respect, and protect the legitimate rights of all individuals."

Frequently asked questions