The Evolution Of Afghanistan's Economic Structure: Command Economy In Focus

Afghanistan's economy is not a command economy, but it is also not a free-market economy. Instead, it is a mixture of both systems, with some aspects leaning more towards a command economy.

In a command economy, the government decides how resources are used and what goods and services are produced. Afghanistan's economy has historically been influenced by political and social factors, such as war and political instability, which have deterred business investors. The country has a long history of government control, with a focus on generating revenue for military capabilities. Afghanistan's economy is largely driven by agriculture, with an emphasis on food production and exports, and it is rich in natural resources, including minerals and precious stones.

While Afghanistan has some characteristics of a command economy, it also has aspects of a market economy, where individuals make decisions about resource allocation and the production of goods and services.

Afghanistan's economy is largely based on agriculture

Agriculture is crucial for the national economy, accounting for about a quarter of Afghanistan's GDP. The country's agriculturally-dependent population constitutes 60% of the total population, with farming being the main livelihood for over half of Afghan households. However, productivity in the agricultural sector remains relatively low, and a third of the population faces food insecurity. The semi-arid region is highly vulnerable to climate change, and arable agriculture is typically small farms heavily dependent on irrigation and water availability. Despite these challenges, Afghanistan has the potential to increase its output of cereals, fruits, nuts, and vegetables and develop supply chains for higher-value-added products.

The country's livestock sector is also significant, with sheep farming being extremely valuable. Wool and highly prized Karakul skins are the major sheep product exports. Additionally, animal husbandry produces meat and dairy products for local consumption, and skins and wool are important for domestic carpet weaving.

Afghanistan's economy continues to improve due to various factors, including the expansion of its agriculture sector. The country has the potential to enhance its agricultural output and create more sustainable and inclusive jobs with the right mix of policies and investments.

The country's GDP is low

Afghanistan's GDP is low for a variety of reasons, including war, political instability, and a lack of foreign investment. The country's GDP is projected to fall further in the coming years, which will likely lead to increased poverty and unemployment.

Afghanistan's GDP is currently ranked as the 155th largest in the world in terms of nominal gross domestic product (GDP) and 137th in terms of purchasing power parity (PPP). The country's GDP stands at $6.81 billion as of 2024, with a GDP per capita of $200. The GDP is projected to fall to $5.79 billion with a GDP per capita of $142 in 2025.

The low GDP is due in large part to the country's history of war and political instability, which has deterred business investors. The continuous war and internal strife have disrupted trade and transport, led to a loss of labor and capital, and prevented efforts to rebuild the nation. Additionally, Afghanistan has faced challenges in accessing the international banking system and has lost access to offshore foreign exchange reserves due to frozen central bank assets.

Another factor contributing to the low GDP is the country's reliance on agriculture, which is vulnerable to droughts, floods, and other natural disasters. While agriculture is the main source of income for the country, it accounts for less than a third of GDP due to insufficient irrigation, drought, and lack of market access.

Afghanistan also has a high unemployment rate of over 23%, with an estimated 79% of Afghans dependent on agriculture and related industries for their livelihoods. The country's population has increased by over 50% between 2001 and 2014, while its GDP grew eightfold during the same period. This has put a strain on resources and contributed to the low GDP per capita.

Furthermore, Afghanistan has struggled to attract foreign investment due to political instability and a challenging business environment. The country has sought foreign investment to improve its economy, but the recent return of the Taliban to power has led to a further decline in investment confidence and the loss of international development aid.

The low GDP in Afghanistan has had significant impacts on the country's population, with about half of the population living below the poverty line. The proportion of households that do not have enough income to meet basic food needs has increased, and the economic stagnation is expected to deepen poverty and unemployment further.

Overall, the combination of political instability, reliance on agriculture, high unemployment, and lack of foreign investment has contributed to Afghanistan's low GDP. The country faces significant challenges in improving its economic outlook and reducing poverty and unemployment.

Afghanistan has a high unemployment rate

The unemployment rate in Afghanistan increased by 1.3 percentage points (+9.22%) in 2023, reaching 15.38%—the highest it has been in the observed period. In 2021, the unemployment rate was 13.3%, with a maximum rate of 12.4% and a minimum of 6.7%. The average unemployment rate between 1991 and 2022 was 8.77%, with a minimum of 7.91% in 2012 and a maximum of 14.1% in 2022.

The high unemployment rate in Afghanistan is due to several factors. Firstly, the country has a history of political instability and war, which has deterred business investors. Secondly, the Taliban takeover in 2021 led to significant job losses, particularly in the agriculture, civil service, and construction sectors. The Taliban's restrictions on women's participation in the workplace have also disproportionately affected women, with their employment levels decreasing by an estimated 16% in the third quarter of 2021. Additionally, the freezing of Afghanistan's assets and the lack of international donor support have severely impacted foreign aid, trade, and investment, causing cash shortages and restrictions on bank withdrawals that have hurt businesses, workers, and households.

The unemployment rate in Afghanistan has serious economic and social implications. It contributes to the country's poverty, with about half of the population living below the poverty line. It also threatens to worsen child labour levels, as children may be forced to work to support their families. Overall, Afghanistan's economic outlook remains uncertain, with the threat of stagnation looming until at least 2025.

The country has a large amount of natural resources

Afghanistan is believed to be sitting on one of the richest troves of minerals in the world. The country has an abundance of natural resources, including extensive deposits of barites, chromite, coal, copper, gold, gemstone, iron ore, lead, lithium, marble, natural gas, petroleum, salt, sulfur, talc, uranium, and zinc. It is estimated that Afghanistan has over one trillion dollars in untapped mineral deposits, with some estimates placing the figure at three trillion dollars.

Afghanistan's mineral wealth includes:

• Copper: Afghanistan may hold 60 million metric tons of copper, with the Mes Aynak copper mine in Logar province estimated to hold 11 million tons of copper, worth over $100 billion.
• Iron ore: Afghanistan has an estimated 2.2 billion tons of iron ore, worth over $350 billion.
• Rare earth elements: Afghanistan is estimated to have 1.4 million tons of rare earth elements, which are essential for modern technology and military equipment. These include lanthanum, cerium, neodymium, and aluminium.
• Lithium: Afghanistan has been called the "Saudi Arabia of lithium" due to its potential vast deposits. Lithium is highly sought-after for its use in batteries for electric vehicles and electronics.
• Gold: Gold resources are more modest, with an estimated 2,700 kg, worth almost $170 million.
• Other metals: Afghanistan also has deposits of aluminium, tin, lead, and zinc.
• Oil and natural gas: With hydrocarbon-rich neighbours, Afghanistan has an estimated 1.6 billion barrels of crude oil, 16 trillion cubic feet of natural gas, and 500 million barrels of natural gas liquids.
• Gemstones: Afghanistan has historically been a major source of lapis lazuli, a semi-precious stone mined in the country for thousands of years. Other gemstones include rubies, emeralds, sapphires, turquoise, and garnets.

The country's mineral wealth presents a significant opportunity for economic growth and development. However, there are also challenges, including poor security, weak legislation, corruption, and a lack of infrastructure, which have hindered the development of the mining sector and discouraged potential investors.

The economy is dependent on foreign aid

Afghanistan's economy is heavily dependent on foreign aid. In recent years, the country has received aid amounting to 43% of its GDP. The loss of this aid has had a devastating impact on the country, causing a sharp contraction in the economy and widespread disruptions to public services.

Afghanistan's economy is largely based on agriculture, with an estimated 79% of Afghans dependent on agriculture and related agribusinesses for their livelihoods. The country's main exports include agricultural products such as fruits, nuts, and hand-woven carpets, as well as opium.

The influx of foreign aid has had a significant impact on Afghanistan's economy. It has contributed to improvements in GDP growth, life expectancy, poverty reduction, child and maternal health, education, and infrastructure. However, these improvements are relatively modest compared to the amount of aid poured into the country.

The sudden loss of foreign aid has resulted in a massive liquidity crisis and a dysfunctional banking sector. The country's central bank, Da Afghanistan Bank, has been unable to access its foreign reserves, which were frozen by the US and other countries. This has led to a shortage of currency and restrictions on banking transactions, further crippling the economy.

The loss of aid has also disrupted the flow of imports, causing shortages of essential goods such as food, fuel, and medical supplies. The humanitarian crisis in Afghanistan has been exacerbated by a severe drought, with almost half the population facing food insecurity.

The dependence on foreign aid has also had political consequences. With a significant portion of government funding coming from aid, the loss of this support has left the country vulnerable to economic and political instability.

To address the humanitarian crisis and support long-term economic development, Afghanistan needs to reduce its dependence on foreign aid and promote private sector growth, particularly in the agricultural and extractive sectors. Strategic investments in infrastructure, research, and market access are necessary to enhance agricultural productivity and create jobs.

Additionally, efforts to improve governance, reduce corruption, and create a conducive business environment are crucial for attracting foreign investment and promoting sustainable economic growth.

Frequently asked questions