Democrats' Complex Relationship With The Afghanistan War: Support For Troops, But Not The Conflict

The war in Afghanistan has been a contentious issue for both Democratic and Republican administrations. While the war has been ongoing for almost two decades, public opinion polls show that Americans remain supportive of maintaining the US military presence in the country. This support is reflected in the actions of Democratic lawmakers, who have generally advocated for a continued commitment to the mission in Afghanistan, even as they faced opposition from the Bush Administration and Congressional Republicans.

However, there are nuances within the Democratic Party regarding the war. While some Democrats have pushed for a reduction of troops or a complete withdrawal, others have emphasised the need to keep a small presence in the country. This position is often justified by concerns about the potential for terrorist groups to regain a foothold in Afghanistan if US troops were to leave. Nonetheless, the Democratic Party has become increasingly liberal on domestic issues, and a significant number of congressional Democrats have called for an end to prolonged wars in the Middle East.

Democrats have advocated for a refocused commitment to Afghanistan, the central front in the fight against al Qaeda

At nearly every turn, Democratic efforts to right the course in Afghanistan have been thwarted by the Bush Administration and Congressional Republicans. Despite this, Senate Democrats have pushed for a greater focus on Afghanistan since 2002, with Senator Biden, Ranking Member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, calling for a strengthening of resolve in the fight in Afghanistan. Since then, Senate Democrats have continued to pressure the Bush Administration to refocus counter-terrorism efforts on Afghanistan and Pakistan.

Democrats have advocated for a strategy to address the complex security and development challenges facing Afghanistan, calling for a comprehensive plan to eliminate terrorist safe havens in Pakistan and Afghanistan. They have also pushed for a new approach to relations with Pakistan to promote long-term strategic engagement, introducing bipartisan legislation to build a more effective strategic relationship with the Pakistani government and its people.

Senate Democrats have provided increased funding for reconstruction initiatives key to stabilizing Afghanistan and countering the terrorist threat. They have also led efforts to provide troops on the battlefield in Afghanistan with the equipment, training, and resources they need to fulfill their mission.

In summary, Democrats have consistently advocated for a refocused commitment to Afghanistan as the central front in the fight against al Qaeda, despite opposition from Republicans and the White House. They have pushed for a strategy that addresses security and development challenges, increased funding for reconstruction, and enhanced support for troops, all while navigating political obstacles and working towards stabilizing the region.

A 2019 poll found that 38% of Democrats favoured maintaining current troop levels in Afghanistan

The results of this poll are surprising given the current partisan polarization in the United States on nearly every issue. For example, on the issue of the U.S. withdrawal from northern Syria, 66% of Democrats opposed the move, while only 23% of Republicans did. This represents a 43-point difference in attitudes between the two parties. In contrast, when it comes to Afghanistan, there is little polarization between Democrats and Republicans.

The lack of deep polarization on Afghan issues may be due to the relative consistency across Republican and Democratic administrations in their handling of the war, as well as the almost universal congressional support for the war when it was initiated after the 9/11 attacks. Additionally, the results of the poll suggest that Americans are hesitant to deploy U.S. troops into other conflicts, but they remain comparatively supportive of maintaining the U.S. military presence in Afghanistan.

Despite the poll results, many Democratic presidential candidates in 2020 expressed a desire to withdraw troops from Afghanistan. For example, Elizabeth Warren and Cory Booker promised a full exit, while other candidates such as Bernie Sanders and Joe Biden also expressed a desire to pull back troops. However, some Democrats, such as Representative Jason Crow, have worked with Republican lawmakers to restrict Trump's planned withdrawal of troops from Afghanistan.

Some Democrats have supported Trump's decision to withdraw troops from Afghanistan

While many Democrats have criticized the Biden administration's handling of the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan, some have supported Trump's decision to withdraw troops from the country. In fact, a Pew Research Center survey conducted in August 2021 found that a majority of U.S. adults (54%) supported the decision to withdraw troops from Afghanistan, and this sentiment was particularly strong among Democrats, with 70% supporting the decision.

Some Democratic presidential candidates in 2020, such as Pete Buttigieg, Elizabeth Warren, and Joe Biden, proposed a unilateral, non-negotiated withdrawal from Afghanistan. They argued for ending the "`endless war`" and bringing troops home, even if it meant doing so without a peace agreement with the Taliban. This stance was criticized by some who warned of potential negative consequences, including a resurgence of extremist groups and a rollback of advances made in areas such as democracy, press freedom, and human rights. Despite these concerns, Democratic candidates felt that the potential benefits of ending the war outweighed these risks.

Additionally, some progressive Democrats in Congress, such as Ro Khanna and Matt Gaetz, worked together to oppose efforts to restrict Trump's planned withdrawal of troops from Afghanistan. They voted against an amendment that would have prohibited the reduction of U.S. troops in Afghanistan below 8,000 without certain conditions being met, demonstrating their support for a more rapid withdrawal.

While there were differing views within the Democratic Party regarding the specifics of the withdrawal, there was a general consensus that the U.S. military presence in Afghanistan needed to end, even if it meant accepting some level of risk or negative consequences.

Some Democrats have opposed Trump's decision to withdraw troops from Afghanistan

Some Democrats opposed Trump's decision to withdraw troops from Afghanistan. In July 2020, the House Armed Services Committee voted in favour of an amendment to the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) that prohibited the reduction of U.S. troops in Afghanistan below 8,000 without meeting certain conditions. The amendment was jointly proposed by Democratic Congressman Jason Crow and Republican Congresswoman Liz Cheney, and passed with a significant majority of Democratic votes.

The Crow/Cheney amendment imposed conditions stating that, for troop reductions from Afghanistan to be allowed, the Defense Department must certify that leaving Afghanistan would not increase the risk of new terrorist safe havens or negatively affect counter-terrorism efforts against the Islamic State, al Qaeda, and associated forces.

The amendment asserted that a rapid military drawdown and lack of U.S. commitment to Afghanistan would undermine diplomatic efforts for peace, and that the current agreement with the Taliban did not provide appropriate protections for vulnerable populations or create conditions for the rejection of violence and prevention of terrorist safe havens.

In addition to the amendment, some Democrats also expressed concerns about the potential negative consequences of withdrawing troops from Afghanistan. These concerns included the risk of the Taliban retaking control, the potential loss of gains made for Afghan women's rights, and the possibility of Afghanistan once again becoming a base for terrorist attacks against the U.S.

Some Democrats have called for a full exit of troops from Afghanistan

In 2020, the House Armed Services Committee voted in favor of an amendment prohibiting the reduction of U.S. troops in Afghanistan below 8,000 without meeting certain conditions. However, this amendment was sponsored by Democratic Congressman Jason Crow of Colorado and Congresswoman Liz Cheney of Wyoming, indicating that not all Democrats supported a full exit of troops.

By 2021, most congressional Democrats were backing President Joe Biden's decision to withdraw U.S. troops from Afghanistan, though many expressed concerns about the potential negative consequences, such as the Taliban retaking control and the loss of gains made for women's rights. Some Democrats, like Senator Jeanne Shaheen of New Hampshire, opposed Biden's withdrawal plan, predicting a "civil war or a Taliban takeover."

Overall, while there have been differing opinions among Democrats, a significant number have called for a full exit of troops from Afghanistan, citing the need to end endless wars and bring troops home.

Frequently asked questions