Whatsapp's Role In Warfare: Secure Communication For Soldiers In Afghanistan

In Afghanistan, WhatsApp has become the second most popular way for Afghans to communicate with each other and with the outside world, after Facebook. Both Afghan soldiers and Taliban fighters regularly use WhatsApp to communicate on and off the battlefield. For instance, when Taliban fighters surrounded the district centre of Bala Murghab in western Afghanistan, an Afghan commander used WhatsApp to coordinate bombing runs with American air support. However, American officials have criticised the use of WhatsApp by soldiers in Afghanistan, citing security concerns.

Taliban fighters also use WhatsApp

The Taliban's use of WhatsApp has been a problem for the app's owner, Meta (formerly Facebook), which is bound by US sanctions that have been in place for over two decades against the militant group. Meta has been engaged in an uphill battle to block Taliban-affiliated accounts. A Meta spokesperson said that WhatsApp identifies users associated with the Taliban by scanning group names, descriptions, and group profile photos, and then blocking offending accounts. However, it remains unclear what proof Meta officials require that a WhatsApp account is associated with a Taliban user before blocking them.

The Taliban's use of WhatsApp has also raised concerns about the security of the app. American officials say that despite WhatsApp's advertised "end-to-end" encryption, it is a security risk. The American military has asked the Pentagon to develop a more secure alternative. However, Afghan military officials say that WhatsApp has unique benefits in the fight against the Taliban, who rely on the app to update their superiors and check in with their fighters.

The Taliban's sophisticated use of social media has come as a surprise to many. The group has used social media platforms to build political momentum and, now that they are in power in Afghanistan, to make a public case that they are ready to lead a modern nation state. The Taliban's tactics show a high degree of skill, and analysts believe that at least one public relations firm is advising the group on how to push key themes and amplify messages across platforms. The Taliban's ability to operate within the rules of social media companies has also left these companies vulnerable to political crosscurrents, as they face questions about why former US President Donald Trump has been banned from Twitter while various Taliban figures have not.

WhatsApp's security concerns

WhatsApp is one of the world's most popular messaging apps, with over two billion users worldwide. The app offers end-to-end encryption, which is designed to protect the privacy of its users. However, there are still several security concerns associated with the app. Here are some of the key issues:

Malware Exploits

WhatsApp has been vulnerable to various malware exploits in recent years. In 2019, a vulnerability was found in the app that allowed hackers to install malware on users' devices. More recently, in 2022, a similar vulnerability was patched, which could have allowed hackers to infect users' devices with malware via video calls. In addition, a new type of malware known as "Agent Smith" spread to over 25 million mobile phones, creating significant WhatsApp security concerns. This malware secretly replaced popular apps like WhatsApp on people's phones without their knowledge, bombarding users with ads and potentially stealing sensitive information.

Phishing Scams

WhatsApp is often used for phishing attacks, where criminals send links to potential victims that could infect their devices with malware. Attackers often pretend to be trusted contacts or even hijack the accounts of friends or family members to trick users into clicking these links. Once a user clicks, their device connects to a server that installs malware. One common scam involves sending a message asking for a six-digit verification code, which is then used to gain access to the victim's account.

Privacy Concerns

WhatsApp is owned by Meta, the parent company of Facebook and Instagram. As a result, there are concerns about the sharing of user data between these platforms. In 2021, WhatsApp's privacy policy was changed to allow more user data to be shared with Meta, raising concerns about potential data monetization and privacy invasion. Additionally, WhatsApp collects and shares information about how users interact with the service, including their phone numbers, financial transaction information, and usage habits. This data sharing undermines the privacy that end-to-end encryption aims to provide.

Unencrypted Backups

While WhatsApp messages are end-to-end encrypted during transmission, the backups stored on iCloud or Google Drive may not be encrypted. These backup files contain decrypted versions of messages, potentially undermining the app's encryption. Unless users enable end-to-end encrypted backups in their settings, their messages could be vulnerable to interception if someone gains access to their cloud storage accounts.

Security Risks for Military and Government Personnel

The use of WhatsApp by military and government officials has raised security concerns, especially when dealing with sensitive information. In the case of soldiers in Afghanistan, the use of WhatsApp could potentially expose critical information to enemy combatants, putting lives at risk. Additionally, the app's metadata collection, which includes information about conversations, connections, and geolocation, could pose a national security risk if exploited by adversaries.

Scams and Misinformation

WhatsApp, like other social media platforms, has been implicated in the spread of misinformation and fake news. In India and Brazil, WhatsApp was used to spread fabricated messages about child abductions and political misinformation, respectively, leading to real-world violence. The platform has implemented forwarding limits and removed the forwarding shortcut button to mitigate the spread of misinformation. However, it remains a challenge to combat the sharing of false information entirely.

WhatsApp's benefits in the fight against the Taliban

WhatsApp has become an essential tool for both the Afghan government and military, as well as the Taliban. While American officials have expressed concerns over the security risks of the app, Afghan military officials have highlighted several benefits of using WhatsApp in the fight against the Taliban.

WhatsApp has become the second most popular way for Afghans to communicate with each other and with the outside world, after Facebook. The app is now used by the highest echelons of the Afghan government and military, as well as by Taliban fighters. Afghan military officials argue that the benefits of WhatsApp in their fight against the Taliban outweigh the potential security risks.

WhatsApp groups have become virtual operation centres, allowing ministers and commanders to make urgent decisions and send instructions from anywhere, without having to be physically present in a secure operation centre. This flexibility has become crucial in a battle that is focused on making small, quick tactical gains—a district here, a village there.

WhatsApp has also been used by the Taliban to spread propaganda and gain favour among Afghan citizens. The Taliban have used the app to communicate directly with Afghan citizens, telling them they are in control and providing numbers to call in case of problems. This has allowed the Taliban to take their fight directly to the hearts and minds of the Afghan people, bypassing American soldiers and using free American internet infrastructure to their advantage.

In summary, WhatsApp has provided several benefits to the Afghan government and military in their fight against the Taliban, including increased flexibility in decision-making and communication, as well as a way to connect with citizens. However, it is important to note that the Taliban have also leveraged the app to their advantage, using it to spread their message and coordinate their activities.

US military's use of WhatsApp

The use of WhatsApp by the US military in Afghanistan has been a cause for concern for American officials, who have noted that the app's "`end-to-end` encryption poses a security risk. This is especially true in light of the recent decision to withdraw troops from the region, where sensitive information needs to be kept confidential.

WhatsApp has become a popular means of communication in Afghanistan, including among the Taliban. Both Afghan soldiers and Taliban fighters regularly use the app to communicate on and off the battlefield. For instance, in 2019, when Taliban fighters surrounded the district center of Bala Murghab, an Afghan commander used WhatsApp to coordinate bombing runs with American air support.

The app's widespread use in Afghanistan has led to its adoption by the Afghan government and military, including for military communications. This has resulted in the US military's use of WhatsApp, albeit on rare occasions. Usually, WhatsApp groups are used for communication among Afghan security leaders and their ground commanders. However, in some instances, US military commanders have been added to these groups.

The US military's use of WhatsApp puts operations at risk of interference, as information can be inadvertently leaked to hostile adversaries. As a result, the American military has asked the Pentagon to develop a more secure alternative. In contrast, Afghan military officials argue that WhatsApp provides unique benefits in the fight against the Taliban, who also rely on the app. They believe that the advantages of the app outweigh the potential security risks.

WhatsApp's voice message feature

WhatsApp has become a popular method of communication in Afghanistan, not only for civilians but also for military personnel. Both Afghan soldiers and Taliban fighters regularly use WhatsApp to communicate on and off the battlefield. For instance, during a battle in Bala Murghab, Afghan troops used WhatsApp to coordinate bombing runs with American air support when cloud cover made visual communication impossible.

WhatsApp has recently introduced a new feature called 'Fast Playback' for voice messages, which allows users to speed up voice messages to listen to them more efficiently. There are three playback speed options: 1x (default), 1.5x, and 2x. This feature is available on both Android and iOS devices and can be used without changing the pitch of the speaker's voice.

While WhatsApp's voice message feature has proven valuable in certain situations, there are security concerns. American officials have highlighted that, despite WhatsApp's "end-to-end" encryption, it poses a security risk. The app's widespread use in the military community has led to fears of interference and the potential leakage of critical information to hostile adversaries. As a result, the American military has requested that the Pentagon develop a more secure alternative for military communications.

Frequently asked questions