Exploring The Complexities: Jewish Travel To Afghanistan

Afghanistan has a long history of Jewish settlement, dating back at least 2,500 years. However, due to decades of warfare, antisemitism, and religious persecution, there are no Jews left in the country today. The last remaining Jews, Zebulon Simintov and his distant cousin Tova Moradi, left Afghanistan in September and October 2021, respectively, after the Taliban re-established the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan. While it is possible for Jews to visit Afghanistan, the country's current political and social climate means that it is not a safe destination for Jewish people.

The history of Jews in Afghanistan

Afghanistan's Jewish history may date back 2,500 years to the destruction of the Temple and the Babylonian exile. The country has been remarkably tolerant towards Jews for over a thousand years, with major cities such as Herat and Kabul serving as safe havens for Jews fleeing persecution in other lands.

The recorded story of the Afghan Jews starts in the 900s CE, two centuries after the country was converted to Islam. However, it is believed that Jews settled in Balkh shortly after the collapse of the Kingdom of Judah in 587 BCE. Existing records of a Jewish presence in Afghanistan date back to the 7th century CE, although ancient Iranian tradition holds that there was a Jewish presence as early as the time of Israel and Judah.

At its height in the 1000s and 1100s, the Jewish population of Afghanistan is estimated to have reached between 40,000 and 80,000 members. Many were traders in leather and karakul (sheep pelt) and often travelled long distances between Afghanistan, Iran, India, and Central Asia. They carved their prayers in Hebrew and Aramaic on mountain rocks as they moved between the routes of the Silk Road.

The Jewish population was decimated by the Mongol invasion of 1222. There was a brief revival in the 1500s when Jews once again became prominent in trade between Afghanistan, India, and the Persian Gulf region. However, as trade routes declined and sea routes became more popular, most Afghan Jews became impoverished.

In the 19th century, the situation for Afghan Jews worsened. In 1839, thousands of Persian Jews fled to Afghanistan after Muslim authorities began forcibly converting them. This brought the Jewish population back up to 40,000. However, in 1870, Afghan Muslim authorities enacted harsh anti-Jewish measures, triggering a mass exodus to neighbouring countries.

In 1927, the Jewish population had dwindled to 5,000. The community experienced a brief revival under the rule of King Nadir Shah (1929-1933), who reversed anti-Jewish decrees and gave Jews equal rights as citizens. However, disaster struck when the king was assassinated in 1933, and Nazi propaganda filtered into the country, causing more pogroms and the ghettoization of Jews in Herat and Kabul.

The vast majority of the Jewish population left Afghanistan in the 1960s, with most going to Israel, and some to New York and Europe. Today, over 10,000 Jews of Afghan descent live in Israel, with smaller populations in New York and London.

In 2021, the last remaining Jews in Afghanistan, Zablon Simintov and his distant cousin Tova Moradi, left the country. Simintov was widely believed to be the only Jew still living in Afghanistan from 2005 until his evacuation to Israel in 2021. He lived in and cared for the Kabul synagogue, the only synagogue remaining in the capital city.

The current state of Afghanistan's Jewish community

Afghanistan's Jewish community has a long history, dating back at least 2,500 years. However, due to decades of conflict, antisemitism, and religious persecution, the community has dwindled, and there are currently no Jews living in the country.

In ancient times, Jews settled in Balkh, a Zoroastrian and Buddhist stronghold, after the collapse of the Kingdom of Judah in 587 BCE. Over the centuries, Jewish communities thrived in Afghanistan, with major centres in cities such as Herat and Kabul. Herat was a particularly important location on the Silk Road, with Jewish merchants travelling across the territories of modern-day Afghanistan and beyond. Jewish life in Afghanistan included religious practices, with a synagogue in Kabul, as well as economic activities, with Jews working as merchants, landowners, and moneylenders.

However, the community began to decline in the 20th century due to various factors. Nativist economic policies in the 1940s marginalised Jewish economic activities, and many Jews emigrated to Israel after its creation in 1948. By 1948, the Jewish population had decreased to around 5,000, and by 1969, only about 300 Jews remained. The Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in 1979 further accelerated the exodus, and by 1996, only about 10 Jews were left in the country.

In recent years, the remaining Jews in Afghanistan faced increasing challenges. The Taliban regime, which took power in 1996, imprisoned and abused Zablon Simintov, who was believed to be the last Jew in the country until his evacuation to Israel in 2021. Simintov's cousin, Tova Moradi, was later discovered to be the last Jew in Afghanistan before she too fled to Albania in October 2021.

Today, the majority of Afghan Jews reside in Israel, with smaller communities in the United States and the United Kingdom. Efforts to preserve Jewish sites in Afghanistan, such as synagogues and cemeteries, are ongoing. The history of Afghanistan's Jewish community is a reminder of the country's once diverse and tolerant society.

The reasons for the Jewish exodus from Afghanistan

Afghanistan's Jewish community has a long history, dating back to at least 2,500 years. However, due to various factors, the community has dwindled over time, and by the end of 2004, only two Jews, Zablon Simintov and Isaac Levy, remained in the country. Eventually, both men left Afghanistan, leaving no known Jews in the country. Here are the reasons for the Jewish exodus from Afghanistan:

Persecution and Religious Extremism

Afghanistan has a long history of religious tolerance, and for over a thousand years, the country was remarkably tolerant towards Jews. However, this changed with the rise of religious extremism and political instability in the country. The rise of communism, the Red Army's persecution of religious people, and the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in 1979 led many Jews to flee the country. The Taliban, a hard-line Islamic militant group, also played a significant role in the Jewish exodus. While the Taliban initially tolerated the Jewish community during their rule from 1996 to 2001, they later confiscated the synagogue's Torah scroll and imposed restrictions on the community. The Taliban's extreme interpretation of Islamic law and their crackdown on dissent and independent media further contributed to the exodus.

Economic Factors

Economic hardships and poverty also played a role in the Jewish exodus from Afghanistan. With the decline of the leather and karakul trade, many Afghan Jews sought better economic opportunities in other countries. Additionally, harsh economic laws and restrictions imposed on the Jewish community in the 1930s and 1940s drove many Jews out of the country.

Political Instability and War

Afghanistan has experienced decades of warfare and political instability, which created an atmosphere of fear and uncertainty for the Jewish community. The Soviet-Afghan War, the civil war, and the US-led invasion in 2001 all contributed to the exodus. The constant state of conflict and the lack of stability made it difficult for the Jewish community to thrive, leading many to seek safer and more stable countries to settle in.

Push and Pull Factors

The desire to fulfill Zionist aspirations and the pull of better economic opportunities and a secure home in Israel or Western countries were also significant factors in the Jewish exodus. The establishment of the State of Israel in 1948 and the subsequent Arab-Israeli wars created a sense of uncertainty and instability in the region, prompting many Afghan Jews to emigrate. Additionally, the Israeli government's implementation of policies favoring Jewish immigration, such as the "One Million Plan," encouraged Afghan Jews to leave.

The persecution of Jews in Afghanistan

Afghanistan's Jewish history goes back at least 2,500 years, with some sources claiming it could be as much as 2,700 years. The community was remarkably tolerant towards Jews for over a thousand years, with major cities such as Herat and Kabul acting as safe havens for Jews fleeing persecution in other lands. However, the situation for Afghan Jews began to deteriorate in the late 1800s, with the Muslim authorities enacting harsh anti-Jewish measures that triggered a mass exodus to neighbouring countries.

In the 1930s, the situation worsened further. In 1932, Mohammed Nadir Shah signed a border treaty with the Soviets to prevent asylum seekers from crossing into Afghanistan from Soviet Central Asia. Later that year, Afghanistan began deporting Soviet-origin refugees back to the Soviet Union or to specified territories in China. In 1935, the Jewish Telegraphic Agency reported that "ghetto rules" had been imposed on Afghan Jews, requiring them to wear particular clothes, stay outside markets, and live within certain distances from mosques.

In 1948, there were over 5,000 Jews in Afghanistan, but the vast majority left the country for Israel in the early 1950s. By 1969, only 300 Jews remained in Afghanistan, and most of them left after the Soviet invasion in 1979. Today, there are no Jews left in Afghanistan, with the last remaining Jews having fled the country in 2021.

The future of Afghanistan's Jewish community

Afghanistan's Jewish community has a long history, dating back at least 2,500 years. However, due to various factors such as emigration, warfare, antisemitism, and religious persecution, the community has dwindled over time, and by 2021, there were no Jews reported to be living in the country. So, what does the future hold for Afghanistan's Jewish community?

In recent years, Afghanistan's Jewish community has been reduced to near extinction due to emigration. The majority of Afghan Jews have resettled in Israel, with smaller groups living in the United States, the United Kingdom, and other parts of Europe. This emigration has left Afghanistan without a significant Jewish presence, and it is unclear if or when this situation will change.

However, there is a possibility that Afghan Jews may return to their homeland if conditions improve. Zablon Simintov, who was believed to be the last remaining Jew in Afghanistan before his departure in 2021, expressed his desire to keep Jewish history alive in the country. He stated that he stayed in Afghanistan to preserve the memory of the once-thriving Jewish community. Additionally, Simintov mentioned that his family might return to Afghanistan if peace is restored. This sentiment was echoed by Simintov's distant cousin, Tova Moradi, who left the country shortly after Simintov. She stated that Afghan Jews would come back and invest in rebuilding the country if peace and stability were established.

Lastly, the preservation and restoration of Jewish sites, such as synagogues and cemeteries, could play a role in attracting Afghan Jews back to the country. In Herat, the historic centre of Afghan Jews, there are still some synagogues, a public bath, and a Jewish cemetery. While some of these sites have fallen into disrepair, recent renovations and their inclusion on Herat's list of protected cultural sites offer a glimmer of hope for the future.

In conclusion, the future of Afghanistan's Jewish community remains uncertain. While the community has been reduced to near extinction due to emigration and other factors, there is a possibility that Afghan Jews may return if the country experiences improved security, religious tolerance, and the preservation of their cultural sites. However, for now, Afghanistan's Jewish community exists primarily in the diaspora, with the majority residing in Israel and smaller groups scattered across the United States, the United Kingdom, and Europe.

Frequently asked questions