Bearly Bavaria: Are They Here?

Bears have been a common symbol associated with Germany for hundreds of years. They can be found on the flag and coat of arms of Berlin, as well as various heraldic signs and symbols in Bavaria. In addition, Germany's dense forests and mountainous regions provide the perfect habitat for bears. However, despite their strong association with the country, bears have been extinct in Germany for over 150 years. The last wild bear was killed in 1835 in the Bavarian Alps near Ruhpolding. But in recent years, there have been sightings of bears in Germany, sparking discussions about the potential reintroduction of these majestic creatures into the country's wilds.

The last wild bear in Bavaria was spotted in 1835

The return of the wild bear to Bavaria in 2006 captivated the nation, but it also highlighted the delicate balance between conservation and human safety. This bear, named Bruno, wandered into Germany from Austria, covering a remarkable distance of 250 kilometres. While some celebrated the return of this rare animal, others viewed it as a potential threat. Bruno's behaviour around human settlements and his proximity to livestock led to concerns. He was deemed a "problem bear" by Bavarian minister-president Edmund Stoiber.

Conservationists and nature groups made attempts to capture Bruno alive, but these efforts proved futile. The situation escalated, and hunters tracked down and shot the bear. The life of this wild creature ended in tragedy, and his remains were preserved and displayed in a museum.

The brief return of the wild bear to Bavaria ignited a discussion about the possibility of their reintroduction to the German wilds. While some expressed concerns about the potential dangers posed by bears, others argued that successful coexistence between humans and bears was achievable, as evident in other parts of Europe and North America. The Federal Agency for Nature Conservation acknowledged the likelihood of brown bears returning to Germany due to neighbouring populations in northern Italy and Slovenia.

The story of the last wild bear in Bavaria and the subsequent appearance of Bruno highlight the complex dynamics between wildlife conservation and human-wildlife conflicts. It serves as a reminder of the delicate balance needed to protect both the interests of people and the survival of these magnificent creatures.

Bears have been a common symbol associated with Germany for hundreds of years

Berlin, the country's capital, is perhaps the most well-known example of the bear symbol in Germany. The city's coat of arms features a black bear on a white shield, and the bear has been used as a charge in the Berlin coat of arms since 1709. The bear also appears on the flag of Berlin and on various heraldic signs and symbols throughout the city. The earliest evidence of the bear as a symbol of Berlin is a heraldic seal from 1280, nearly two decades before the twin towns of Cölln and Berlin were united, forming the city we know today.

The bear symbol in Berlin may have originated as a reference to Albrecht the Bear, the founder of the Margraviate of Brandenburg in 1157. As the grandfather of the founders of Cölln and Berlin, it seems fitting that the city would adopt his nickname as its symbol. Another theory suggests that the bear was chosen as a canting or singing arm because the German word for bear, "Bär", sounds phonetically similar to the first syllable of Berlin.

In addition to Berlin, bears have also been associated with the region of Bavaria in Germany. While bears have been extinct in the country for over 150 years, they were once commonplace in the forests and mountains of Bavaria. The last wild bear in Germany was spotted in Bavaria in 1835 and was subsequently killed by hunters. In 2006, a young male brown bear named Bruno wandered into Bavaria from Austria, marking the first bear sighting in Germany in over a century. Unfortunately, Bruno was deemed a nuisance and a potential threat, and he met the same fate as his predecessor in 1835.

Despite their absence from the German wilds, bears continue to hold cultural significance in Germany. They have long been a symbol of strength and a favoured symbol of warriors in Germanic culture. The association with strength and power may be why bears were often hunted and considered a sign of strength for those who could take one down.

In 2006, a bear called Bruno wandered into Germany from Austria

The bear, weighing about 600 pounds, was first sighted in the municipality of Ettal, in Bavaria, on the night of May 19, 2006. He was initially welcomed by animal conservationists and nature groups, who celebrated the return of the rare animal. However, Bruno soon became a nuisance, destroying beehives, killing sheep, and even walking through a Bavarian village, taking a rest in front of the police station. He earned the nickname "Problem Bear" for his troublesome behaviour.

The Bavarian government considered Bruno a threat, and hunters were tasked with tracking him down. Bruno managed to elude his hunters for a while, with the search costing over 125,000 euros. Despite attempts to capture him alive, he was eventually shot and killed in Rotwand in Bavaria early on June 26, 2006. His remains were preserved and put on display at the Museum of Man and Nature in Munich.

Bruno's arrival in Germany sparked a debate about the potential return of bears to the country. Wildlife experts and conservationists argued that it was time to prepare for the return of more bears, while farmers and livestock owners expressed concerns about the potential threat to their livelihoods. The European Union is supporting a program in Austria, Italy, and Slovenia that aims to expand the bear population in the Alps. Despite the controversy surrounding Bruno's presence, his story captured the imagination of many, with some even considering him a hero.

Bruno was deemed a ''problem bear' and was shot and killed

Brown bears were once a common sight in the forests and mountains of Bavaria. But in May 2006, Germany was captivated by news of the first wild bear sighting in over 170 years. The bear, named Bruno by the German press, had wandered into Germany from Austria, and was initially welcomed as a symbol of successful conservation efforts. However, this excitement was short-lived.

Bruno, officially known as JJ1, soon gained a reputation as a "problem bear". He ventured into villages, ransacked honey farms, and killed dozens of sheep and other livestock. These behaviours, common among predators, were interpreted as a sign that Bruno enjoyed killing. His proximity to human settlements and his loss of fear of humans led government officials to deem him a potential threat to people. Bavaria's environment minister, Werner Schnappauf, described Bruno as "out of control" and declared that hunters were free to shoot him.

Despite public objection and attempts to capture Bruno alive, which cost over 125,000 euros, the shoot to kill order remained in place. In the early morning of 26 June 2006, Bruno was shot and killed by an unnamed hunter at Rotwand Mountain in southern Bavaria. His remains were stuffed and put on display at the Museum of Man and Nature in Munich.

Bruno's sad fate sparked discussions about the potential reintroduction of bears into German wilds. While some argued for stronger conservation efforts, others pointed to the challenges and risks associated with bears' proximity to human settlements and livestock. Bruno's story highlighted the complexities of human-wildlife interactions and the ongoing efforts to find a balance between conservation and public safety.

Conservationists believe that bears could return to Germany

Bears have been a common symbol associated with Germany for hundreds of years. The country's dense forests and woodland areas, as well as its sweeping mountainous regions, are perfect habitats for bears. In fact, the bear is so symbolic of Germany that it can be found on the flag and coat of arms of Berlin, and on various heraldic signs and symbols in Bavaria.

Despite this, bears have been extinct in Germany for over 150 years. The last wild bear was killed in 1835 in western Bavaria, and since then, there have been no sightings of bears in the wilds—until 2006. In May 2006, a young male brown bear nicknamed Bruno wandered over 250 kilometres from northern Italy to Bavaria, becoming the first wild bear sighted in Germany for 170 years. Unfortunately, Bruno was deemed a nuisance and a threat, and despite attempts to capture him alive, he was shot and killed by hunters.

In October 2019, another bear was sighted in Bavaria, having also come from northern Italy via Austria. While this bear has not been spotted again, its presence has raised the question of whether bears could be successfully reintroduced to the German wilds. Conservationists believe that bears could indeed return to Germany, particularly given the presence of bear populations in neighbouring countries like Austria, Italy, and Slovenia. The Federal Agency for Nature Conservation has stated that there is a high probability that brown bears will return to Germany, and some bears have already been sighted in the Bayerischer Wald, a national park in the southwest of the country.

However, experts agree that strong conservation efforts will be needed to properly reintroduce bears into Germany. This includes implementing measures to protect livestock and inform local populations about how to deal with bears. Additionally, it is important to consider the potential dangers posed by bears and take steps to mitigate these risks. Nevertheless, with the successful reintroduction of wolves, eagles, and lynxes into German forests, there is hope that bears may also be able to flourish once again in Germany's wilds.

Frequently asked questions